StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Anthropology: Females and Males as Representative of Nature and Culture - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Anthropology: Females and Males as Representative of Nature and Culture" discusses an analysis of women within biological and cultural perspectives, on the foundation of which she has endorsed the relationship between woman and man, and between woman and nature…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.2% of users find it useful
Anthropology: Females and Males as Representative of Nature and Culture
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Anthropology: Females and Males as Representative of Nature and Culture"

?ANTHROPOLOGY ESSAY QUESTION Renowned anthropologist theorist and researcher Sherry B. Ortner (1974) has made a critical and in-depth analysis of women within biological and cultural perspective, on the foundation of which she has endorsed the relationship between woman and man on the one hand, and between woman and nature on the other. Ortner declares inferiority of women at social scale as the outcome of her biological and physical composition, which not only deprives her of respect equivalent to men, but also are assigned quite different duties, obligations and responsibilities in the light of their innate physical qualities. Hence, it is nature to assign divergent responsibilities to both the genders on the basis of their mental and physical characteristics. Ortner also finds females closer to nature than males because of their tendencies, inclinations and apparent traits. The theory has been topic of discussion since it was first presented in 1972. Though the present paper also views males closer to nature in many aspects, yet it partially agrees with the notion that females have same connection with males as the nature maintains with the cultural attributes prevailing within a society. Ortner declares division of labour as the outcome of biological features of humans. In other words, nature of man’s work, activities, attitude, behaviour and career selection are directly dependent of his innate aptitude, physical strength, mental capabilities and gender. Consequently, man’s abilities to dominate over others also seek roots in his natural competence and inborn gifted faculties. Ortner vehemently supports the very belief that gender discrimination has been in vogue in every culture of the globe since man set his foot on the very face of earth. He argues that though high claims are made, by different societies and so called civilised nations, regarding the existence of equality in social status between man and woman, yet practically woman seldom enjoys the same magnitude of freedom and position that is attributed to man within a social establishment. Hence, every human society is male dominated one in the real sense, where female stratum is always in an inferior position, and is suppressed, subjugated and discouraged in one way or the other by males. As a result, demarcation of privileges, social status and respect could easily be found in all human societies without discrimination since the known history of the world at large. “Patriarchal structured societies”, according to Hammack, “have flourished around the world, and their dominance is evident throughout history. These societies have prospered in every measurable way: population growth, economic surplus, military might, and even technological advancement, while at the same time creating a social system that commodified their females’ reproductive capacity.” (2007, p. 2) Hence, women have been the prey to inequality, injustice and gender discrimination at the hands of the males since ever. Somehow, the inequality has direct connection with their biological structure. “Gender is” Lorber states, “so much the routine ground of everyday activities that questioning its taken-for-granted assumptions and presuppositions is like wondering about whether the sun will come up. Gender is so pervasive that in our society we assume it is bred into our genes.” (1994, p.1) Thus, women’s activities and assigned responsibilities are actually dependent of their gender and physical strength as well. Though the human rights activists and torch-bearers of freedom of thought and action aptly argue in favour of several rights and privileges have been bestowed upon women, yet they absolutely neglect the very reality that the females had to make long and exhaustive struggle to win even the right to cast vote in twentieth century; the advantage the male stratum had already been enjoying for the last many centuries. It has aptly been observed that women are discouraged and exploited at work places, and they get low wage rate in comparison to men. “The differential occupational distribution of men and women explains the majority of the gender gap in wages.” (Peterson and Morgan 1995, p.331) Similarly, it is only the women belonging to modern societies of the globe which have been granted so called equal rights; otherwise, an overwhelming majority of the Asian and African women are still looked down upon even in this era of tremendous technological advancements. “In Indian culture”, Veer submits, “the widows used to be burnt alive along with the dead body of their husbands. Though such kind of brutality does not prevail in the contemporary India, yet the brides are still burnt alive provided they have not brought heavy and precious dowry luggage along with them at the eve of their marriage. The physical torture, mental molestation and sexual harassment are the most frequently committed crimes in India against women.” (2004, p.139) Consequently, the country is still lagging far behind from the advanced nations of the globe in respect of gender equality, even she has experienced incredible achievements in the fields of defence strategies, IT, science, medicine and sports etc. Similarly, women are considered to be mere sex object in majority countries of Africa and the Middle East as well. Moreover, women are also victim of harassment and domestic violence even in the USA and Europe, which have given birth to feminist movement in these states during 19th and 20th centuries. “The women belonging to western societies are also fearful of sexual harassment at their work place, markets and public places. Similarly, they are prey to domestic torture, sexual exploitation and violence at the hands of male members of their family at large.” (Madriz, 1996, p.433) Somehow, it is not mere male domination that has paved the way towards the ultimate subordination of women in a social establishment. On the contrary, it is their innate characteristics that play pivotal role in their inferior status in society. The same notion has been supported by Ortner in his thesis under examination. Ortner is of the opinion that since Nature has created man and woman in quite divergent way, the mode of women’s thinking, vision, exposure, feelings and sentiments is entirely different from men. Being kind, sympathetic, sacrificing and compassionate at heart, women appear to be very close to nature in all manners. Women are not only physically soft and tender, but also they are far more kind and compassionate towards others in comparison with males at large. They do not surrender sentiments and emotions even at the eve of most unfavourable state of affairs. On the contrary, males always apply intellect and wit in trivial matters, and hence display indifference, coldness and rationality while solving their problems and combating with the knotty issues in general. Moreover, women’s biological composition and physical texture also turns them closer to nature, which men are deprived of to a great extent. “Many of the ovarian secretions function for the benefit of the egg, promoting its maturation and adapting the uterus to its requirements; in respect to the organism as a whole, they make for disequilibrium rather than for regulation-the woman is adapted to the needs of the egg rather than to her own requirements.” (Ortner, 1974, p. 24) However, the connection and resemblance of men with nature cannot be refuted altogether. On the other hand, they have also been blessed with some distinguished traits that seek their attribution to Nature. For instance, men are tough, stout, strong and steel-nerved, and hence are source of shelter, protection and financial support to women. In the same way, they are, like Nature, the source of encouragement and are benefactor of their families. They traditionally take responsibility of working from dawn to dusk outside their home far from the sight of the family, just to provide a better standard of living to their families. They also maintain the capability of concealing their personal pains and agonies from women in order to save them from emotional collapse and distress, and hence do not share their sorrows with women. On the other hand, women announce their trivial problems and disclose each and everything regarding their liking and disliking, which is actually the cultural characteristic rather than the trait of Nature. Somehow, women’s unabated love, warm affection, sense of responsibility and meekness make them the true representative of Nature, which is always loving and beneficent to humans and other creatures of the universe. Women have happily accepted all domestic responsibilities, where they do not get involved into domestic chores, including cooking, baking, child-rearing, cleansing and washing, but also provide physical and sexual comforts to the husbands. Hence, they absorb their worries and tensions by offering them the pleasures and satisfaction related to their hunger and sexual lust. Women serve as the delicate sex and weak stratum of society, which not make up nearly half of the total population of every society, but also render their valuable services in domestic chores and professional activities on the one hand, and make hard efforts in the business ventures, promotion of art and culture, and struggle through the political platforms for human rights and eradication of gender discrimination on the other. Women are the true representative of nature with all its delicacy, beauty and mirth. Similarly, men appear to be the representative of cultural norms, values, traditions, conventions and customs. However, researches reveal the very fact that women are more successful in domestic responsibilities and the feminine professions including counselling, teaching and nursing than they are in politics, marketing and engineering. Since women in western countries are comparatively more involved in professional life, they are undergoing more serious imbalances while designing their work-life schedule. Wollstonecraft (1993) argues that would men be truly content with rational fellowship instead of slavish obedience. “With rational fellowship women would be more observant daughters, more affectionate sisters, more faithful wives and reasonable mothers, better citizens.” (Quoted in Falco, 1997, p. 969) To conclude, it becomes crystal clear that man’s achievements, accomplishments, career selection and growth in personal and professional life seek support and inspiration from his innate characteristics, which determine his way of action for the future years to come. The same is particularly applied to gender, where men and women are born to render entirely different services and performances. It is therefore a large majority of the individuals working in military forces, engineering department, administration and politics belongs to male stratum; while nursing, cooking and child-rearing are generally considered the subjects of female interests. It is therefore Ortner appears to be justified in her claim that females and males are representative of nature and culture respectively. Bibliography 1. Hammack Jacqueline K. (2007) Women in Ancient Mesopotamia: the Mothers of Female Subordination Jackson State University Department of History HIST-447 pp.2-6 Retrieved from http://jkhammack.com/5-9body&cvrpg.pdf 2. Lorber, Judith (1994) Night to his Day: The Social Construction of Gender Yale University Press p. 1 Retrieved from http://meac.org/Resources/ed_services/SG_WEB/SeeingGender/PDFs/SocialConstructionOfGender.pdf 3. Madriz, E. (1996). The perception of risk in the workplace: A test of routine activity theory. Journal of Criminal Justice, 24, 407-412. 4. Ortner, Sherry B. (1974). Is female to male as nature is to culture? In M. Z. Rosaldo and L. Lamphere (eds), Woman, culture, and society. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, pp. 68-87. http://www.uio.no/studier/emner/sv/sai/SOSANT1600/v11/Ortner_Is_female_to_male.pdf 5. Peterson, Trond, and Morgan, Laurie A. (1995) Separate and Unequal: Occupation-Establishment Sex Segregation and the Gender Wage Gap. American Journal of Sociology 101 pp. 329–33 6. Veer, Udai. (2004) Crime against Women Anmol Publications Private Limited new Delhi p. 139 7. Wollstonecraft Mary (1993/1792) http://truthseekerjournal.com/1994archive/121_2/ts212w.shtml Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Anthropology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/anthropology/1417242-anthropology-essay-question
(Anthropology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/anthropology/1417242-anthropology-essay-question.
“Anthropology Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/anthropology/1417242-anthropology-essay-question.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Anthropology: Females and Males as Representative of Nature and Culture

Anthropology Questiuons

The people within the Hofriyat practice Muslim religion and culture and are presented as having strict beliefs.... The culture of the Tiv involved story telling while rituals that they called aan artform.... When the locals insist that she tells them a story, Bohannan gets a little nervous because she fears that Hamlet may not be applicable within this culture as she had argued with her English colleague.... The story presents arguments which help the reader to understand the reason why the Hofriyat people persist on keeping their Pharaonic circumcision culture....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Anthropology of Power and Resistance

For those who seek to make sense of contemporary processes of cultural globalization and transnational culture flows, these theoretical developments raise a rich set of ethnographic possibilities.... The paper "anthropology of Power and Resistance" tells us about the impacts of policy interventions.... The word 'anthropology' is ultimately from the Greek (Anthropos, 'human', plus logos, 'discourse' or 'science').... Central European writers then employed it as a term to cover anatomy and physiology; part of what much later came to be called 'physical' or 'biological anthropology....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Trobrianders of Papua New Guinea

Weiner sought to provide a gender-balanced view of Trobriand culture by highlighting discoveries regarding the importance of woman's work and wealth in Trobriand society.... he reader will know of a culture of matrilineal descent and its importance to them.... In the end, readers will find Weiner's work to be revealing a new perspective of the world learned thru the in-depth contemplation of the Trobriander's culture.... e then set out to make known to the world the Trobriander culture and tried to put across the native's point of view as opposed to the outsider's view....
10 Pages (2500 words) Book Report/Review

Anthropology at Home and Abroad

Social, cultural, and religious anthropology are some of the discipline's fields that concentrate on human nature and all the matters related to mankind, from a cultural, social and biological point of view.... Malinowski and Suad Joseph's studies proved: inclusion in the studied culture helps to better interpret the studied material.... Curiosity is part of human nature.... This basic human nature forced the anthropologists to go out and explore different people....
21 Pages (5250 words) Research Paper

Cannibal Culture: Art, Appropriation and Commodification of Differences

The author examines the book "Cannibal culture" by Deborah Root.... Cannibal power is an integral part of culture and society.... If that had not happened, the inevitable consumption of a culture we have all come to call civilization would have been the reality today in Europe and maybe America.... The anesthetization of the way of life in the west has also been balanced by the consumptive invasion of the Iraqis and the Libyans by our own military (always in defense of our culture)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Advertisement Analysis

Thirdly, adverts are products of an enhanced professional culture emanating from the discipline of advertising and showbiz.... The culture of that time did not allow free interaction between males and females, and therefore, the ad attempted to convey the message that the beer can do the trick for the men in terms of getting attention from the dream girl.... The magazine is equally popular among both males and females e the date when it was first issued....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Gender and Sex Distinctions in Anthropology

These specialists apply the aspects of biological, social, humanities as well as physical sciences that present differences between males and females.... This essay "Gender and Sex Distinctions in anthropology" discusses how the distinctions between gender and sex are used by anthropologists as well as how it has been challenged.... The two have been distinguished in meaning and application in various such as anthropology.... The evolution of anthropology has played role in the present use of the topic, although there are shifts on traditional anthropological concepts of gender and sex....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Judith Butlers Text-Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity

Butler notes that feminists have time and time again made recourse to the implied pre-patriarchal state of culture as a framework upon which to base a new society that is non-oppressive.... In the normative culture, gender is spilt into male and female.... In the paper 'Judith Butler's Text-Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity', a text context analysis is done on the conceptual framework of gender theory, basing the analysis on Judith Butler's text-Gender Trouble: Feminism and the subversion of identity....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us