StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Evaluating a website as a source for learning history - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Should history websites be boring? This is the question that comes to mind after reading Lisa Richardson’s article. In attempt to be humorous, one can lose the traits of neutrality and objectivity that are crucial to academic work. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
Evaluating a website as a source for learning history
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Evaluating a website as a source for learning history"

Download file to see previous pages

Should history websites be boring? This is the question that comes to mind after reading Lisa Richardson’s article. In attempt to be humorous, one can lose the traits of neutrality and objectivity that are crucial to academic work. The website chosen for analysis is http://opinion.latimes.com/opinionla/2009/10/glenn-beck-hilarity.html and it was visited on the 24th of October 2013. It was particularly interesting because it focuses on one of the most controversial but continual aspects of US history; slavery.

Not only is this piece deficient in terms of historical evidence, it largely focuses on the opinions of a media personality. Therefore, it is an unsuitable website for learning history because it prioritizes political shaming over historical accuracy. Website analysis Instead of dwelling on historical information first, the author starts with someone’s untruths and then uses some historical events to back them. This article mocks media personality, Glenn Beck, by asserting that he was trying to make a spin on a historical issue that was known to all.

According to the author, Glenn Beck alluded to the fact that liberals in the 19th century were slave supporters. She then adds that this was totally unfounded because conservatives were slave-owners. They had much to lose from the abolition of this practice, so they fought against the liberals in order to have their way. From the spin on this topic, one can deduce that the writer’s agenda is to portray conservatives as irrational people. The target audience also consists of liberals who would find an attack against conservatives quite palatable.

This site, which is known as Opinion L.A. belongs to a number of bloggers with liberal leanings. If the writer of the piece was interested in disseminating historical truths, she would have started with facts and then alluded to someone’s rant about the same. Useful information is hard to find and buried in a plethora of attacks, but it still exists. As a historian, one would still find something useful in the site. The story highlights the political disagreements that were sparked by debates on slavery.

It sheds light on why the institution was able to persist for a relatively long time. Consensus on the matter was simply not forthcoming. At least the website mentions the relationships between the state and its constituents especially when it wanted to restrict certain practices. This website thus highlights the nature of controversies that stemmed from political disagreements. It is possible to know these facts because a civil war arose from the differences. However, one would require a thorough knowledge of the events in American history to discovery these hidden truths.

This article is slanted on one side to make it appear as though democrats were the progressive thinkers of their time. A number of persons disagree with this view because they believe that democrats only acquired a progressive incline after the 1960s when it was necessary to do so. Furthermore, the author is bent on labeling historians either as liberal or conservatives. The following statement illustrates one of the assumptions made by the writer: “Conservatives, of course, were slave-owners and liberals were not.

Conservatives in the 19th century believed in the tyranny of state government and liberals did not.  Everyone with a shred of understanding about American history knows that. We had a whole war over it.” (Richardson, 2009) In the matter of slavery, this dichotomy does not work well because several individuals had liberal views but did not support slavery. Conversely religious activists fought for abolition of slave trade even when most of their views were regarded as conservative. It is for this reasons that one would question the comments of the writer.

She seems too intent on painting one side of the political divide as a change agent and the other as a forestaller. It would have been better for the writer to focus on events as they were rather than

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Evaluating a website as a source for learning history Essay”, n.d.)
Evaluating a website as a source for learning history Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/e-commerce/1488974-evaluating-a-website-as-a-source-for-learning-history
(Evaluating a Website As a Source for Learning History Essay)
Evaluating a Website As a Source for Learning History Essay. https://studentshare.org/e-commerce/1488974-evaluating-a-website-as-a-source-for-learning-history.
“Evaluating a Website As a Source for Learning History Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/e-commerce/1488974-evaluating-a-website-as-a-source-for-learning-history.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Evaluating a website as a source for learning history

Company Profile of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc

Particularly, the link for “About Us” gives information regarding the purpose of Wal-Mart and a brief history note is also mentioned.... It is important to have reliable source to answer these questions.... Step 4: Finding Sources First and most reliable source is the official website of Wal-Mart.... Step 2: Sharing My Knowledge In order to get some information, I visited the website of walmartstore.... In this website, a sufficient amount of information is available regarding health and wellness, careers and so on....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Evaluating E-Business Website

The best choice for a company in that uses e-business as a strategy is to make the website as friendly and pleasing to the customers as possible.... Executive summary: This study relates to on to evaluation of E-Business website of the M&M, which falls under of chocolate manufacturing industry.... E-business website is significant aspect for organizations' for deploying technological inventions, and for withstanding competition worldwide....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

The Websites Dynamic Learning Areas

Selznik (1996) identifies seven elements of community: history, identity, mutuality, plurality, autonomy, participation, and integration.... Selznik notes that communities are stronger when their members share history and culture, rather than simply abstract general interests.... The paper 'The Website's Dynamic learning Areas' presents an increasing occurrence of individuals using computers for watching videos, listening to music, grocery shopping, communication and writing blogs....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Internet Interest Levels

Throughout the three sessions, there are teaching methods and learning opportunities presented to appeal to a wide range of learners.... The paper 'Internet Interest Levels' focuses on the elderly of the United States which represents a significant and growing portion of the population....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Patient Guide to WWW

A simultaneously amazing and annoying feature about internet surfing is that anyone can launch a website in a span of few minutes.... Examine the source The website's content shouldn't contain anecdotes and testimonials of the patients as primary health information (Szwarc, 2008) Caretaker or the patient must understand the significance of last three letters “URL” in the website.... The internet user must check to see whether the facts provided by one source are published by any other website for the same diseases....
3 Pages (750 words) Coursework

History of Phishing and Development

This paper “history of Phishing and Development” will present a detailed analysis of using phishing for/in website verification.... This research is aimed at discussing and elaborating the phishing technique, its main implementation areas, disadvantages and its utilization for the website verification.... There are several cases of the identity theft and online frauds using phishing and other hacking techniques, but this paper will concentrate mainly on the positive aspects of the phishing like that its use for the website verification....
20 Pages (5000 words) Research Paper

Analysis of the Sources about Online Learning

The paper contains the annotated bibliography of sources which proves the statement that online learning is more effective in terms of student achievement than traditional classroom learning such as "Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Profession" … The selected journal article includes a case study that has focused the impact of online learning courses on interpersonal interaction behavior of students.... The website has indicated that it publishes two issues (general and special) every year while its scope includes research papers based on empirical and qualitative approaches, case studies illustrating the practice of the e-learning, and opinion articles that encourage the notion of debates related to e-learning....
21 Pages (5250 words) Annotated Bibliography

Reccomendation of 15 Critical Websites: a Comprehensive Study

This website is fantastic because of its ability to save a user's history in an easy drop menu.... nbsp;… Three that model the best traits, and three that while adequate resources, fall short of being regarded as an exemplary educational website.... om/Class Marker is a great website for any individual who wants interactive testing online.... Zito is a great website for busy librarians who are constantly finding new reference sites and search engines....
6 Pages (1500 words) Annotated Bibliography
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us