StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Rewrite of Gone With The Wind: A Fair Use - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper titled "Rewrite of Gone With The Wind: A Fair Use" states that copyright issues still present challenges in society, particularly in an American society where the law allows for certain exemptions concerning infringement of it. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful
Rewrite of Gone With The Wind: A Fair Use
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Rewrite of Gone With The Wind: A Fair Use"

?Ali Alkhalfan Ms. Roberts English 105 18 November Rewrite of Gone With The Wind: A Fair Use Writing back of literary works is an invaluable practice to the society because it examines another author’s ideas, message and presentation in a different perspective. In addition, writing back also exposes some issues that may have been left untouched by the original author, yet they are of great significance to the society. According to Lessig, the society encourages and allowsthe rewrites to flourish because of the immense importance that they hold (124). Thus, copyright law though protects originality and creativity of the authors, gives room for rewrites by providing exemptions under which they are not entitled to infringement.However, this has also created a room for copyright conflicts and other related issues. Numerous copyright issues have dominated the debate scene prompting the question as to what should be considered fair use and what should not. One notable copyright battle was between Gone With The Wind (GWTW) and The Wind DoneGone (TWDG). In this case, the author, Randall rewrote the GWTW by retelling the story through a slave’s perspective. This encompasses writing back to society and power, which has a rich contribution to the society. Nevertheless, the conflict here was whether TWDG violated copyright laws by copying GWTW. Through evaluation of free speech, fair use, parody and satire, it is clear that TWDG did not cause infringement of copyright laws. The infringement law allows rewrites based satire and parody. As a result, there was no infringement in the case of GWTW and TWDG since the rewrite was based on satire. Nevertheless, when solving the conflict, other concepts such as free speech and its application also came up. Thus, it is essential to understand how fair use, parody and satire, and free speech apply in rewrite cases. In the case, SunTrust Bank v Houghton Mufflin, SunTrust Bank aimed at stopping Houghton from publishing TWDG on the grounds that it infringed the novel GWTW. However, the 11th Circuit found that TWDG was not guilty of infringement, and thus, allowed for the publication of the rewrite. The Supreme Court made this decision citing the sufficient transformative nature of TWDG, which warrants as fair use. This marked the beginning of a long-term battle on TWDG’s infringement of copyright laws with regard to the rewrite of GWTW. Nevertheless, what arose from this case is that fair use sets the legal framework that accommodates both commercial and creative decisions. In analyzing a literary work or any other thing for fair use, there are four factors that play a key role in the determination of fair use. According to Netanel in Making Sense of Fair Use, these are provisions of Section 107 of the United States Copyright Act (Making Sense of fair Use 715). The first factor deals with character and purpose of the uses, for example, it considers whether the use is for nonprofit educational or for commercial nature purposes. The second factor provides for the nature of the work copyrighted. The third factor looks at the work copyrighted as a whole and determines the substantiality and amount of the portion used with respect to the entire work. Finally, the fourth factor provided for by the US Copyright Act under Section 107 looks at the impact of the rewrite on the potential market, and how the copyrighted work is valued. Beebe notes that the four factors are a test that must be applied in every case to determine fair use, and there is no bright line rule that can determine the issue of fair use (558). The major goal of fair use is to provide a flexible approach of determining and making a decision as to whether fair use applies in a particular case. The major concern is whether the use of the original work that is copyright protected is fair or not. In addition, the fair use doctrine does not base its arguments on equity, but is rather a creature of the common law courts. Furthermore, in the application of fair use, the secondary user’s motives are generally irrelevant as the main concern is the characterization of the overall use as unfair or fair. In principle, the four factors mentioned above must be given weight in the analysis of fair use, but in practice only two have emerged as the most crucial in determining fair use.These two, according to Beebe, are the first and the fourth conditions, which provide different perspectives to fair use (558). For instance, the first condition provides for a transformative use approach to fair use while the fourth one deals with the market failure approach to the doctrine of fair use. Using this to evaluate fair use in the rewrite of GWTW, it is clear that there is enough transformation to fulfill the first condition of fair use.For example, Randall borrows settings, characters, and plot twists from GWTW, but he does not merely copy them, he transforms them into another creative piece. The story is uniquely told from a slave’s perspective, and scenes are inverted to transform the piece from the original copyright work. Similarly, the rewrite also passes the test for market; thus, the rewrite of GWTW qualifies as fair use. Hence, according to the fair use evaluation, TWDG did not infringe copyright law. Another issue that provides for exemption in infringement of a copyrighted work is free speech. Free speech is one of the values of the First Amendment, and such, it is a crucial subject that must be taken into account in making a decision about infringement. This is because everyone in the society has the right to express themselves, as long as this expression does not present harm to other individuals. Several factors make up free speech,as Bollinger notes, “There are three justifications put forward for free speech: the search for truth, autonomy and democracy” (465). The basis for the search for the truth argument is that if speech is truly free then the truth can be discovered in an unrestrained discourse. Similarly, the autonomy argument ties free speech to personal liberty. This means that copyright law has to take into account the provision of free speech, and this could be done by creating an infringement exemption on the basis of free speech. Free speech is a powerful consideration in copyrighted works because it allows for social criticism, which helps in making a broader point about the society. This makes the determination of fair use in a rewrite even more complex than it already is with parody and satire. Thampapillai suggests that application of free speech in rewrite issues can be evaluated in two ways (428). One, free speech can be evaluated on the basis of utilitarian theory whereby the decision/outcome should present maximum benefit. Second, free speech can be approached on the basis of essentiality. This is because societies that values and practice democracy highly values free speech as an essential element in the society. In such societies, free speech may override copyright law whenever necessary. According to Samuelson, Free speech promotes self-expression and liberty especially in a democratic society (2549). Thus, a satirical or parody novel is highly allowed in such a society as it makes a political or social point beneficial to the society. Therefore, rewriting a novel in the form of a satire is an act of speech, and allowing such rewrites to flourish mirrors how valuable free speech is to the society. Randall’s rewrite of GWTW draws favor from free speech because it exposes the slavery that the original novel left out. Furthermore, it explores the issue of the race, which relates with political issues, as well as the role of democracy in the society. The United States Copyright Act allows for exemption on the infringement of the law when it comes to rewrites and this is when the rewrite is based on satire or parody. Parody is a form of literary and social criticism with a socially significant value similar to free speech of the First Amendment. Though a rewrite of literary work in the form of parody exempts it from infringement in all cases, one written in the form of satire may not escape infringement in some circumstances. More compelling is the distinction between parody and satire as in practice they appear the same; thus, their applicability is also the same. In an attempt to distinguish between parody and satire, Netanel states, “Parody's humor, or in any event its comment, necessarily springs fromrecognizable allusion to its object through distorted imitation. Its art lies in thetension between a known original and its parodie twin. When parody takesaim at a particular original work, the parody must be able to 'conjure up' atleast enough of that original to make the object of its critical wit recognizable.”(Copyright’s Paradox 56). A pure satire does not qualify as fair use, but a satire combined with parody is fair use and so is a pure parody. A good example of a combination of parody and satire can be drawn from Randall’s TWDG, which satirizes the South and parodies the novel GWTW by Mitchell. Therefore, the rewrite contains elements of political and socialcriticim directed to the society, which means that it is both a parody and satire. This is one of the reasons that the Circuit Court allowed for the publication of TWDG by arguing that it did not violate the copyright law. Netanel illustrates parody and satire as one of the concepts of understanding fair use since the copyright law provides an exception for these two aspects of rewrite (715). TWDG satires and parodies GWTWbecause it exposes the slavery and other atrocities, which had been left out by Mitchell who romanticized of the antebellum era. In addition, the novel tells the story from the perspective of a slave to get a clear picture of the events and racial issues in the South. Furthermore, the Randall’s TWDG is critical transformation, making it a different tale. For example, the novel stays away from original prose used by Mitchell and acquires a different language through Cynara, which is the vehicle of parody in this rewrite, and as we flip through the pages of her diary, we get a clear insight into the race and slavery portrayed in this novel. Finally, the rewrite portrays whites in a different way from Mitchell, that is, powerful, but stupid. The major goal of the rewrite is to strip the romanticism presented by Mitchell, and generally demystify GWTW. Hence, TWDG achieves both parody and satire, which exempts it from infringement of the copyright law and qualifies it as fair use. Undoubtedly, rewrites play an imperative role in society, and thus they should be allowed to flourish. One of the benefits of rewrites is that they provide various cultural products to choose from, thus, making culture richer. However, not all rewrites are beneficial as some may be mere copying or a case of plagiarism, and such add no value to the society. Therefore, it is important to determine the kind of rewrites acceptable in the society, especially those that exposes the social and political issues in a satirical way. According to the copyright law that protects copyrighted works, parody and satire are some of the exemptions to infringement of copyright law. In addition, free speech also plays a critical role in determining fair use of rewrites as it sometimes because it allows for self-expression, mainly in a democratic society. Evaluating the infringement issue surrounding TWDG shows that it passes the test for fair use; hence, the rewrite does not infringe GWTW. Another aspect that marked settling of the case was that the publisher donated money to a college that Mitchel had attended. Copyright issues still present challenges in the society, particularly in the American society where the law allows for certain exemptions concerning infringement of it. However, the most important thing to remember when determining whether there is fair use in a particular rewrite is the value it adds to the society, as well as ensure that the provisions of free speech are upheld at all levels. This means that in a democratic society, such as America, the right to expression and liberty should count towards determination of infringement cases. Nevertheless, it is also important to ensure that the material released for public audience has some beneficial nature, and allows the societal culture to flourish. In every society, there will always be those who come up with original idea, and those who are only good at making a satire out of and criticizing these ideas. Works Cited Beebe, Barton. "An Empirical Study of US Copyright Fair Use Opinions, 1978-2005." University of Philadelphia Law Review (2008): 582-86.Print. Bollinger, Lee. "Free Speech and Intellectual Values' () 9243S." Yale Law Journal (1983): 438. Print. Lessig, Lawrence. Remix: Making Art and Commerce Thrive in the Hybrid Economy. New York:Penguin, 2008. Print. Netanel, Neil. "Making Sense of Fair Use." Levis and Clark Law Reviews (2011): 715. Print. Netanel,N. Weinstoek.Copyright's Paradox. Oxford: Oxford UP, 2008. Print. Samuelson, Pamela. "Unbundling Fair Uses." Fordham Law Review (2009): 2544-56. Print. Thampapillai, Dilan. "The Novel as a Social Satire: 60 Years Later, the Wind Done Gone and the Limitaions of Fair Use." Deakin Law Review (2012): 427-52.Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Gone With The Wind paper 5 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1490202-gone-with-the-wind-paper
(Gone With The Wind Paper 5 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1490202-gone-with-the-wind-paper.
“Gone With The Wind Paper 5 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1490202-gone-with-the-wind-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Rewrite of Gone With The Wind: A Fair Use

Guidelines for Writing an Academic Paper

Ineffective arguments that use logical, emotional or ethical fallacies detract the reader for writer's credibility.... Writing papers is probably the one thing that may stick throughout one's life, therefore, a student must excel in the art of writing papers.... The objective of this article is to outline the general principles and best practices of writing an academic paper....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Gone With The Wind

gone with the wind Introduction Copyright issues have come up from time to time given the millions of literary works published in the society.... A good example of copyright issue that raised much debate is the relationship between gone with the wind (GWTW) and The Wind Done Gone (TWDG).... Hence, this research will evaluate the copyright issues surrounding the conflict between GWTW and TWDG with reference to fair use and transformative elements....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Proposal

Gone With The Wind

Furthermore, Dilan evaluates application of fair use with reference to the case of 60 Years Later and the rewrite of gone with the wind.... This brings the issue of fair use as demonstrated by several infringement battles such as in the case of Colting's 60 Years Later novel and Suntrust Bank v Houghton Mifflin.... fair use sets a legal ground that permits commercial and creative decisions regarding rewrites.... This leads to more cultural products making our culture richer, but also poses the big challenge of determining what qualifies as fair use and what does not....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Developing Materials for Reading and Writing Skills

n the other hand, the skill of writing is difficult when compared to reading because writing requires more effort in terms of correctness of grammar, use, or appropriacy of expression, punctuation, spelling, and of comprehension on the reader's part.... Over the decades, there has been a tremendous expansion of reading material in different genres, posing a definitive challenge to any reader in comprehending and decoding the meaning of the written text....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Homeward Bound and Reckless Move

Well there could be any number of reasons right I could have a sexually abusive stepfather, or perhaps my mother is like that crazy, compulsive character on Desperate Housewives, or maybe I have lousy grades, an eating disorder and a drug problem, I could be on the run from the police (You can really use your imagination here).... It was sickly sweet like fruit gone bad, the very air had turned rancid with it....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Re-writing a Creative Writing piece

The porter was on the telephone but he winked at Mohamed, as if they both shared a common secret, and inclined his head in a nod of greeting.... No news from home, but that was usually the case Mohamed.... ... ... He picked up his briefcase and entered the inner courtyard. ... ... nly a few seconds later, Alice arrived, driving her bike confidently along the narrow cobbled lane even as she keeps an eye on the notebooks in her basket....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Writing a Sales Letter to the Client

It would be fair enough for us to disclose a few features regarding our product and its workability to the client.... The author of the paper "Writing a Sales Letter to the Client" has been tasked with writing a sales letter to Eastern Wisconsin University, the biggest client of the new product, the 'Hot Blocks....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

A Tremendous Expansion of Reading Material

Writing is difficult compared to reading because writing requires more effort in terms of correctness of grammar, use, or appropriacy of expression, punctuation, spelling, and comprehension on the reader's part.... The following paper under the title 'A Tremendous Expansion of Reading Material' a tremendous expansion of reading material in different genres, posing a definitive challenge to any reader in comprehending and decoding the meaning of the written text....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us