StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Security versus privacy - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Uyen Ton 14 May 2011 Airplane Security versus Human Privacy Since the devastating terrorist attacks in America on September 11, 2001, the American government and Department of Homeland Security have done everything in their power to assure that citizens and government officials alike do not experience a similar catastrophe as the one on that ill-fated September morning…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
Security versus privacy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Security versus privacy"

Uyen Ton 14 May Airplane Security versus Human Privacy Since the devastating terrorist attacks in America on September 11, 2001, the American government and Department of Homeland Security have done everything in their power to assure that citizens and government officials alike do not experience a similar catastrophe as the one on that ill-fated September morning. Due to other attempted attacks, such as the bombing that was averted on Christmas Day on an airplane over Detroit, Michigan, the Department of Homeland Security has increased security measures in airports throughout the world.

Unfortunately, many of these measures have become controversial, because many people are claiming that the TSA agents cross the boundaries of personal privacy. Though numerous people may not be thrilled with the thorough patdowns or the detailed full-body scanners, they exist to ensure safety by making sure terrorists cannot enter an airplane with weapon or explosives, and should therefore be embraced, not rejected. The thorough patdowns and the full-body scanners may be revealing and invading on the privacy of airline passengers, but their purpose is to guarantee that dangerous materials and equally dangerous people do not make it onto airplanes.

In the attacks on September 11, the suicide bombers found no difficulty in getting on the airplanes fully armed with a variety of weapons, and going through security without being detected. Since then, the goal has been to disable others from getting away with the same thing. This is where the patdowns and body scanners come in to play. After airplane passengers go through the basic metal detector, if there is any further concern, such as the metal detector sensing something stronger than jewelry or coins, they are given the option of receiving the patdown or going through the additional scanner.

If they do not want to receive the patdown or the full body scanner, they will not be allowed onto the airplane. If these measures are implemented, more potential threats can be found and avoided. Passengers are able to benefit from these precautions because they will not only feel safer knowing that others are being pat down, but be safer as well. A temporary breach in privacy is a small price to pay for guaranteed safety not only to those in the airport or on an airplane, but to everyone else in the sky on other airplanes or other such aircraft and on the ground.

While these security measures might be tedious, time-consuming, and as speculated by Jeffrey Rosen in “Nude Awakening: The Dangerous Naked Machines”, be considered to invade on the privacy of individuals (Rosen 1), these are not the purposes that they serve. People have every right to be concerned when a stranger has their hands around their private regions, but these agents are specially trained in how they search passengers. The time it takes to check and make sure that every person is safe when they travel is done out of concern for the well-being of every citizen.

These measures were designed for the sole purpose of making sure that people are safe. Though invading privacy is an issue of concern since it goes against the rights of human beings, the need for safety from enemies and terrorists who are willing to kill anybody is an even bigger matter that needs the most attention as the lives of people are put at risk. It is unfortunate that we have entered a time in America’s history where we cannot trust people who simply want to travel or visit relatives in distant places.

Children and the elderly, though seeming innocent upon presentation, are just as liable to house an explosive or a weapon as a terrorist. As noted by Mohammad Khan in “Racial Profiling Ineffective”, detailed scanning and searching of individuals used to be based on racial profiling with TSA focusing on people who, simply by looking at one’s skin color, could be marked as potential threats (Khan 1). This poses an issue as TSA turns to racism to determine if someone may or may not be a terrorist.

This method is as faulty as simply assuming that children or elderly people are exempt from being involved in a terrorist attack. Instead of focusing on everybody as being potential terrorists, TSA agents used to automatically assume who is or is not capable of being involved in a terrorist plot. Nowadays, patdowns and full-body scans need to be used as often as possible because threats have been known to come in all religions, ethnicities, genders, and ages. Threats must be met and taken care of before innocent bystanders find themselves victims to devious plans.

The patdowns and body scanners are necessary since anybody can be a threat, and just assuming that someone is safe based on gender or skin color is not a guaranteed way to ensure the safety of others. Another great counterargument surrounding the controversial security measures is that the measures being used are not helping to keep people safe. Young children and infants are being thoroughly patted down, but dangerous criminals are still being let onto airplanes with weapons without any trouble, such as the terrorist who attempted the Christmas Day bombing, which Schultz points out in “New Airport Policy: Grin and Bare It (Shultz 1)”.

Due to this, many people feel that their privacy is being compromised without any benefits in regard to safety. Since the thorough patdowns and full-body screenings are often implemented when there is heightened concern about an individual, such as if someone were to set off the basic metal detector or the bomb detector, people are appalled when infants are sent to an agent to receive a full-body patdown. The people who should be getting the most attention, such as those that have criminal backgrounds, are the ones who walk through the airport with ease.

The methods being implemented have been helping to keep people safe, as even infants and elderly people have been found to be harboring bombs and weapons on their person. In the case of infants, many terrorists believe that children, as innocent as they are, would never be accused of being a tool or weapon in a terrorist plot. Because of this, it has to be assumed that, for everyone’s safety, anybody can pose a threat. It is true that people with criminal backgrounds should have more attention put on them since they already have a past of larger, dangerous and illegal actions, but if a TSA agent has reason to believe that a child might have a bomb strapped to them, it is in the best interest of everyone for that child to be searched.

As long as threats exist to our nation, there will need to be methods to avoid them. Balancing aggressive security measures and the need to respect privacy might be easier said than done, but if people learned to cooperate and understand that these measures are being done for their safety, the system can run more smoothly. If people do not like the measures being taken at airports, they can find another method of travel, such as by train or cruise ship, or be more prepared for when they go to the airport by not giving the TSA agents any reason to be suspicious of them, so that they are not stopped with the assumption of carrying weapons.

To make the security check go more smoothly, the passengers should make sure that all forms of metal, such as jewelry or coins, are removed from their person before going through the metal detector. The attack during September 11 left America a more cautious, prepared nation, and it would be in the best interest of everyone if they allowed America to grow back into the secure nation that it once was. A temporary sacrifice of privacy must be made to achieve this, but it will be worth it in the long run.

Works Cited Khan, Mohammad. "Racial Profiling Ineffective." The Daily Evergreen Online. N.p., 14 Jan. 2010. Web. 13 May 2011. . Rosen, Jeffrey. "Nude Awakening: The Dangerous Naked Machines." The New Republic. N.p., 29 Jan. 2010. Web. 13 May 2011. . Schultz, Connie. "New Airport Policy: Grin and Bare It." Creators Syndicate. N.p., n.d. Web. 13 May 2011. .

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Security versus privacy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1421598-security-versus-privacy
(Security Versus Privacy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1421598-security-versus-privacy.
“Security Versus Privacy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1421598-security-versus-privacy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Security versus privacy

Ethics in Computing

Some of the areas that have been changed include entertainment, employment, security, commerce, transportation, and medicine.... The paper "Ethics in Computing" tells us about computing technology.... nbsp;This aspect of technology has been very influential in various spheres of the world and most notably the information and communication spheres of the world....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Closed Circut Television: A Closed Case

The use of CCTV to monitor public activities by law enforcement agencies has triggered many controversial debates about security versus privacy of the people.... In the context of law enforcement surveillance activities, a common conception of privacy stems from criminal cases interpreting the Fourth Amendment of the constitution.... According to the Supreme Court, if the person under surveillance has a reasonable expectation of privacy, the Fourth Amendment applies, and a warrant is generally required to conduct a lawful search....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

LOVE Individual privacy vs. national security

The individual privacy vs.... This implies that compromise of individual privacy and LOVE" Individual privacy vs.... The individual privacy vs.... national security research project will seek to establish whether the imposed anti-terrorism measure will compromise people's freedom and privacy.... This implies that compromise of individual privacy and freedom in pursuit of national security is a global as well as a national issue....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Use of CCTV in Crime Prevention

The trend of increasing crime across the globe, especially in terms of terrorist attacks, has forced law enforcement authorities in all nations, including UK, to resort to the deployment of modern technology to monitor the activities of suspects and to contain crimes.... Closed… uit Television (CCTV) is a part of such technologies used for scrutinising the premises of vital installations such as airports, railway stations, street corners, parking lots, shops and other sensitive premises....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The Use of losed Circuit Television

Besides having high security benefits, introduction of CCTV has nevertheless resulted to infringement of privacy and freedoms of various individuals within the area under surveillance.... This is because privacy is an important aspect and a fundamental human right.... The dilemma in this case here is that, the introduction of Closed Circuit Television (CCTV) has enhanced security and the expense of individuals' freedom and privacy.... Consequently, the installation of CCTV in public places has deteriorated human privacy and freedom....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Privacy versus Security Debate

This study argues that insecurity can be fought without necessarily invading privacy.... The study analyses which side between privacy and security is more important.... hellip; The global debate on the importance of individual privacy and national security continues to trouble governments and citizens alike.... As such, the level of privacy which is adequate for optimal security remains contentious.... privacy versus Security Debate Number privacy versus Security Debate The global debate on the importance of individual privacy and national security continues to trouble governments and citizens alike....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Public Policing Versus Private Security

This essay "Public Policing versus Private Security" compares private security and public police that basically carry out different errands but the essential policing performed by them are mutually supportive, making law enforcement easier and effective.... nbsp;… Regardless of the common goals and duties of both private security and public policing, the latter has a much wider mandate than the former.... The public policing functions on behalf of the government and hence receives more benefits when compared to the private security individuals....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Nature of Surveillance within the Context of Big Data Collection and Privacy Versus Security

As the paper "The Nature of Surveillance within the Context of Big Data Collection and privacy Versus Security" outlines, surveillance has always been mainly used by organizations that concern themselves with law enforcement with the aim of keeping close attention on individuals of interest.... However, the practice of surveillance has been met with its fair share of challenges especially regarding issues concerning security and privacy matters and people understanding the nature of surveillance....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us