StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Supreme Court Case: Roe versus Wade - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
There are numerous controversial cases that have been presided over by the Supreme Court of the United States. One such case is the case that involved Roe and Wade. The case whose ruling has remained subject to debate to-date related to the issue of abortion. Indeed, before the high court ruling, abortion was unconstitutional and therefore was prohibited in the country. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
Supreme Court Case: Roe versus Wade
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Supreme Court Case: Roe versus Wade"

Download file to see previous pages

An overview of the Roe versus Wade Case and Supreme Court decision The Roe v. Wade case was decided in 1973 following a suit filed by Norma McCorvey (under the alias Jane Roe) against Dallas County District Attorney (Henry Wade). The main event that led to the filing of the case was Roe’s third pregnancy against her wishes. Initially, Roe wanted to procure an abortion pretending that she had been raped. This scheme however failed. During this time, Texas had stringent anti-abortion laws only allowing it in the case of incest and rape.

In 1970, the US District Court, Texas, ruled in Roe’s favor citing a number of merits but went short of granting an injunction that would bar the laws on abortion from taking effect. The court’s decision was guided by the 9th amendment and the Griswold versus Connecticut ruling. Roe appealed against the ruling of the district court in the Supreme Court. Justice Harry Blackmun in his guided opinion emphasized that Texas law on abortion was vague. Later in 1973, the court ruled in favor of Roe in a 7-to-2 majority vote.

The court’s decision made it clear that abortion was indeed a fundamental right according to the supreme law of the land. As such, any law that attempts to restrict the procurement of abortion ought to be subjected to strict scrutiny. Furthermore, the court ruled that the right of privacy as encompassed in the 9th amendment is broad enough to consider the decision of a woman in regard to maintaining or terminating her pregnancy (Cornell University Law School, 2011). The court in making this decision declined to consider the 9th Amendment rationale as postulated by the district court.

According to the ruling, the ninth amendment did not obviously establish rights that could be enforceable by the federal government. In this respect, Roe won the court’s favor majorly on the basis of the due process clause of the Constitution (Cornell University Law School, 2011). Constitutional questions raised by the case The main question that the Supreme Court ruling seeks to answer in the Roe V. Wade case relates to the fundamental right of women as enshrined in the Constitution. In particular, the ruling sheds light on the right to privacy and personal liberty.

In so doing, it is established that the woman has the right to decide whether to maintain or terminate her pregnancy. In effect, abortion is no longer legal only when it is carried out to save the mother’s life in case of medical complications as was previously the case in many states. The legality of abortion is based on the consideration of various interests of the woman and the preservation of human life. Evaluation of the decision’s constitutional significance There are several court rulings that relate to abortion in the US.

Prior to 1821, abortion was considered a common law crime. After this year, several states enacted laws that prohibited abortion; only allowing its procurement under special cases. In a case involving Griswold and Connecticut, a Court ruled that birth control law in the state of Connecticut was unconstitutional (Abortionfacts, 2011). In Katz versus the United States, the court held that there exists no such thing as

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Supreme Court Case: Roe versus Wade Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/law/1390707-case-report
(Supreme Court Case: Roe Versus Wade Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1390707-case-report.
“Supreme Court Case: Roe Versus Wade Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1390707-case-report.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Supreme Court Case: Roe versus Wade

U.S. Supreme Court Case Tennessee vs. Garner

supreme court case Tennessee vs.... US supreme court case Tennessee vs.... The basic issue that this case brings to fore is the ascertaining of the constitutionality of the deadly use of force by the law enforcement agencies against an unarmed, fleeing suspect (Findlaw, 2008).... Should the nature or proportion of force used by a police team against an escaping terrorist be same as that used against a harmless teenager, who attempts to escape from the scene of some petty crime This case highlights the human rights of the fleeing suspects and pragmatically checks the unrestrained use of force by t...
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Supreme Court Justice

The study "supreme court Justice" presents a critical analysis of a hereditary legal practice in the supreme court of the USA.... Harlan's family legacy and unique contribution to the history of the supreme court are extraordinary.... Judiciary is the service of two Harlans as associate justices of the supreme court - John Marshall Harlan, and his grandson, John Marshall Harlan II.... John Marshall Harlan was confirmed by the Senate in December 1877 and was the 45th justice of the supreme court....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Supreme court cases

Royal Dutch Petroleum which is expected to be tried during the month of October, in this case it will be decided whether the judges of America have the authority supreme court Cases Currently the supreme court of United s of America has accepted to review around forty cases during its period of 2012 to 2013.... Another major case that has been highlighted and is to be reviewed by the supreme court on tenth of October is Fisher v.... Another major case related to business that is to be reviewed by the supreme court on November 5th is Comcast Corp v....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Positivism and the Separation of Morality

The paper "Positivism and the Separation of Morality" highlight that although the judicial function is strictly restricted to interpreting the existing law, the Positivist theory and Hart's rule of recognition allows flexibility of judicial interpretation within the framework of social rules....
25 Pages (6250 words) Case Study

The Reasons Behind the Business Success of Southwest Airlines

The objective of this case study "The Reasons Behind the Business Success of Southwest Airlines" is to provide a detailed analysis of the business and marketing strategy adopted at Southwest Airlines.... Furthermore, the study will also discuss the strengths of the company's corporate culture....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

Thomas Randolph and His Career

This paper "Thomas Randolph and His Career" focuses on one of the most famous Scottish Kings, and he managed to secure military independence from England.... The legendary victory of the Scottish at the Battle of Bannockburn has become of one of the defining moments in Scottish history.... nbsp;… There are a number of primary sources that may be used in conjunction with a study of Randolph, although these are by necessity limited due to the scarcity of documents in general from this time....
48 Pages (12000 words) Case Study

The Selection and Description of Supreme Court Justices

The paper 'The Selection and Description of supreme court Justices' presents the US supreme court Justice System which is on par in terms of power and influence as the President and the Senate.... The US supreme court is mandated to uphold the Constitution in any issue.... It is thus of extreme importance that a supreme court judge be thoroughly cognizant of the US Constitution and to be able to set aside ideologies whether social, political or cultural....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Roe Versus Wade's Abortion Trial

This case study "roe versus wade's Abortion Trial" analyzes a path-breaking decision to hear a case challenging the constitutional validity of the long-standing state laws that made abortion a crime, unless the abortion was performed because of a life-threatening situation for the mother.... roe versus wade allowed pre-viability for women to terminate their pregnancy and the state had the right to regulate only after viability.... Roe and the attorneys appealed to the supreme court against this injunctive ruling of the U....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us