StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Fiedlers Original Model of Leadership - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper "Fiedler’s Original Model of Leadership" will discuss Fiedler’s original Model of Leadership and then compare this with his later development of Cognitive Resource Theory. Fiedler’s original Model of Leadership is known as the Fiedler Contingency Model of Leadership…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.2% of users find it useful
Fiedlers Original Model of Leadership
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Fiedlers Original Model of Leadership"

To determine the leader’s leadership style, Fiedler created the Least Preferred Coworker (LPC) questionnaire to measure whether a leader is task-oriented or relationship oriented.  The LPC questionnaire has 16 opposing adjectives such as pleasant-unpleasant, efficient-inefficient, open-guarded, and supportive-hostile.  Respondents were then asked to rate their coworkers on a scale of one to eight for each of the 16 contrasting questions.  If the respondent scored in favorable terms with his or her co-worker, it is then said that the respondent is relationship oriented.  In contrast, when the respondent scored unfavorably towards his or her coworker in the LPC, it is then said that the respondent is task-oriented based on Fiedler’s original Contingency Model (Utecht, 1976).

Fiedler’s Contingency Model was then reconceptualized which brought about his Cognitive Resource Theory of Leadership.  This leadership model determines the influence of the leader’s cognitive capacity and experience’s reaction to stress.  The hypothesis of Fiedler’s Cognitive Resource Theory of Leadership are as follows (Vecchio);

  1. If a leader is under stress, the leader's intellectual abilities will be diverted from the task. As a result, measures of leader intelligence and competence will not correlate with group performance when the leader is under stress.
  2. The intellectual abilities of directive leaders will correlate more highly with group performance than will the intellectual abilities of nondirective leaders.
  3. The correlation between leader intelligence and group performance will be higher when the group is supportive of the leader than when the group is not supportive (as a consequence of the need for the group to implement a leader's directions).
  4. If a leader is nondirective and the group supports the leader, the intellectual abilities of the group's members will be correlated with the group's performance.
  5. A leader's intellectual abilities will be correlated with a group's performance to the degree that the task is intellectually demanding (i.e., necessitates the use of intellectual abilities).
  6. When under stress, a leader's job-relevant experience (rather than intellectual ability) will correlate with group performance (141).
  7. A leader's directive behavior is a function of relationship- versus task motivation (i.e., the Least Preferred Coworker construct), and situational control influences

  8. What type of leader characteristic (more intelligent vs. more experienced) is most suited for high-stress incidents? What type of leader (more intelligent vs. more experienced) is best suited for low-stress planned incidents? When giving your answers provide a detailed example of a police leadership position that would fit the leadership style of more intelligent and more experienced. 

In a study conducted by Vecchio (1990) titled “ “where he tested the relationship of a leader's cognitive ability or intelligence performance in a real-life scenario, he concluded that “the nature of the relationship of the leader to group performance, if there is one, continues to be elusive.    These results indicate that the relationships suggested by cognitive resource theory do not appear to be sufficiently strong or reliable that they can be easily teased out of group performance data”.  Interestingly, the subjects were also uniformed personnel of “forty-eight four-person groups … created from a larger set of Air Force enlisted personnel. These airmen were classmates (i.e., in smaller units of 8 to 12 airmen per class) at an air base in the Midwest” which is very close to a police leadership position, the subjects, being in the armed service also. 

            Being such, we can conclude that in a highly stressful incident, experience is more suited for leadership than cognitive intelligence because it cannot be established by a formal that intelligence is more effective in a highly stressful scenario.  In addition, common sense dictates that in a highly stressful situation, people tend to act more on their instincts than a mental process whose ponderous nature can take some time to decide which could be inimical in a police leadership where rapid response is critical. Further, instinct is not developed by cognition or study but by a collection of experiences of how people will react to a given situation.


  1. Next, in your own words, define, discuss, and provide a scenario in a CJ organization of Transactional Leadership, Transformational Leadership, and Visionary Leadership. 

Transactional leadership is contingent upon making followers obey by means of exchange either by remuneration or by the expectation of rewards (Jamaludin et al., 2011). Transformational leadership is the kind of leadership that produces similar leaders and makes subordinates expect much from themselves and is motivated not by exchange or reward but by a belief towards a common goal and objective (Ismail et al., 2010).  Visionary leadership is the kind of leadership akin to transformational leadership where a leader “articulate, express and share the organizational missions and goals in a simple, easily understood and tangible vision statement. . . [it] develops clarity, focus and flexibility” in an organization (: Dwivedi, 2006).

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Leadership Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/law/1392164-leadership
(Leadership Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1392164-leadership.
“Leadership Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1392164-leadership.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Fiedlers Original Model of Leadership

Business Assignment about leadership as a business strategy

There are different types of leadership styles that can be practiced by the organizational leaders.... From the research it can be comprehended that Alan Mulally and Bill Gates as objects of current research are effective leaders and it is under their leadership that the company has been successful at achieving great heights.... The main objective of the paper is to identify the leadership skills of two different leaders.... The study will try to compare and contrast the leadership skills of these two personalities and to obtain the effectiveness of the leader....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Organizational Behavior

leadership: Based on the concept of Fordism, Henry ford is a true leader.... Field Marshal Slim clearly distinguishes management from leadership.... He indicates that leadership encompasses personality and vision in which case he alludes to, people focus, innovation, personal power and influence.... Achievements: Fords most noted achievement at the commencement of his career is the model T automobile first produced in 1908.... Innovation: the trait of innovation stands out in Fords success for instance, in the model T and subsequent automobiles such as the plastic car....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Effective Leadership

Right from day one, the topic of leadership has amazed and fantasized many experts all over the world (Griffin & Moorhead, pp.... Traits of leadership, characteristics of leaders, what makes a leader, are leaders born or made and there are many other questions, which have been able to catch the attention of researchers and experts for the past many decades (Fulmer & Goldsmith, pp.... This paper attempts to look at different types of leadership and the recent developments in the field of leadership by briefly looking at the literature available on Fred Fielder's Situational Leadership Model....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Motivation and Emotion at Work

The author of the essay under the title "Motivation and Emotion at Work" thoroughly explains that every organization is faced with problems which include leadership problems, economic constraints, low employee motivation, customer complaints, and many others.... leadership is the backbone of the organization.... Barnard (1938) defines leadership as the capability of the superior to influence the behavior of subordinates and convince them to follow a particular strategy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Approach to Managers and Leaders

staffs, it is more formal and scientific than leadership, it is more rational, structured and centralized, and lastly manager gives no major emphasis on change, and tends to focus on intrinsic working. ... He has to take care of executing a task and also define how it is going to be executed with respect to ethics, work culture, and above all sustainability. ...
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The Leadership Challenge of the Gulf of Mexico Oil Spill Crisis

The author of the paper "The leadership Challenge of the Gulf of Mexico Oil Spill Crisis" states that crisis leaders should never take for granted the value of crisis planning and leadership.... This essay argues that crisis leadership is important to all forms of organization.... Inopportunely, among crisis leaders, the perspectives concerning crisis leadership remain anchored in the strategic components of crisis management, instead of on integral leadership theories, styles, models, and approaches....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Organisation Behaviour

The author outlines the role of organizational behavior and leadership theories to analyze different management situations.... Not everybody interested in studying leadership theories has wholeheartedly supported every single aspect of the Fiedler contingency model (Fiedler et al.... n his book 'Improving leadership Effectiveness: The Leader Match Concept, originally published during 1976 Fiedler (alongside co-writers Martin Chemers and Linda Mahar) actually offers a self-paced leadership training program for managers....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Management-Leadership Theories

In the context of this scenario, the company needs to adopt a new style of leadership.... According to the theory, leaders need to develop the following personal attributes to ensure that they manage changes:When taking over new positions, it is necessary that managers restructure their managerial plans to suit their style of leadership (Adetule, 2011 p.... The theory is a model of change for leaders, emphasizing the need for and the process of change to newer and efficient management techniques (Adetule, 2011 p....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us