StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Market Abuse Directive - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Topic: Market Abuse Directive (2003/6/EC) Institution Affiliation: Date: Financial markets are an important component of any given economy. For the European financial markets, the fundamental role that the financial markets play cannot be ignored…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
Market Abuse Directive
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Market Abuse Directive"

Topic: Market Abuse Directive (2003/6/EC) Affiliation: Financial markets are an important component of any given economy. For the European financial markets, the fundamental role that the financial markets play cannot be ignored. However, operational and performance challenges have been evident over the years as a result of market abuse. Market abuse is an activity or an action that aims at making some stakeholders in the financial markets worse off and other better off by manipulating the functions of the financial markets.

In most cases, investors have been directly or indirectly disadvantaged through market abuse (Ferran, 2004, pg. 127). There are various ways in which market abuse results. The first form of an activity that results in market abuse is insider trading. Information unavailable to the public is used by few individuals in financial markets dealings, taking advantage of the larger public investors. In some other instances, the financial instruments price setting mechanism has been distorted or false and misleading information released to the public , the motive being to benefit just a few in these markets (Mantysaari, 2009, pg. 122). The Market Abuse Directive (MAD) was formulated and implemented to counter such activities and promote fairness and integrity in the European financial markets.

When integrity is upheld, investors are confident in carrying out their business. The directive therefore is purposed to combat market abuse (Seredydska, 2011, pg. 227).However, MAD has been termed to be ineffective and inefficient in meeting its primary objective, necessitating a need for dire reforms. The need to urgently reform the MAD springs from a number of observed activities that the directive has failed to address. Reforming the directive would require that the directive becomes more effective in meeting its primary objective, combating market abuse.

The MAD is not integrated into the micro and macroeconomic sector of the European member states. It is not applicable to the determinants of money demand and supply, including but not, limited to public debt management, monetary policy and the exchange rates (Mantysaari, 2009, pg. 380). The micro macroeconomic components are crucial in the light of financial markets business. In order to determine the economic direction of a given union, Central Banks of all member states should actively be involved in order to direct and control activities in the markets that are likely to affect the economy positively or negatively.

The MAD however, ignores the role of the European system of Central Banks (Katharina, 2004, pg. 141). As a result, the primary decisions made by these Central Banks are not integral to the activities that the directive seeks to address. It is important that the directive integrates important components of the entire economy in order to achieve the desired results effectively. Lack of an all-round treatment of constituent controlling units of the financial markets hinders the achievement of the directive due to conflict of interest between the Central Banks and the MAD directors.

Individual member country Central Banks have also been left out in the monitoring undertaken by the directive. In order to incorporate all necessary aspects into the MAD, dire reforms are necessary and urgent. Critical analysis of the MAD has found further deficiencies, mounting on more pressure for reforms to the MAD. The directive has failed to achieve its stated objectives due to the directive’s limited scope. It is necessary to create an extensive scope of the directive. Specifically, prohibitions that concern insider dealing and market manipulation are not adequate (Seredydska, 2011, pg. 227). Loopholes to these prohibitions have been evident, making it possible for market abuse to occur, with failure of administrative law to justify such prohibitions due to the evident loopholes.

Market abuse practitioners have in several instances justified their activities under the provisions of the directive. This shows that the directive at some instances fails to meet its purpose. On the same note, the extent to which one financial instrument affects the value of another financial instrument has not been fully met. The regulatory role of the MAD in the market therefore fails, thus the need for reforms. MAD and the use of e-technology are not fully matched. Relevant authorities that monitor market abuse are limited by e-privacy rules when seeking access to telephone and data traffic records for supervisory purposes (Katharina, 2004, pg. 97). This has been a major source of the directive’s failure.

It is therefore necessary to amend and reform the MAD statute provisions in such a way that the MAD provides a clear outline of how authorities access the required data and information in regulating and controlling market abuse in the financial markets. Disclosure of inside information is another concern when it comes to the ineffectiveness and failure of the MAD. Such information should not be released to the public without prior consideration of its effects. The delay of disclosure provided by the MAD currently is ambiguous.

It lacks clarity, making it prone to manipulation and further being used to the public’s disadvantage. Disclosure delay, criteria for the delay and applicable laws should be clear and integrated into the entire justice system (Ferran, 2004, pg. 134). The idea is to safeguard the public from misleading information that ends up benefiting a few at the expense of investors in the financial markets. Evidence of failure, ineffectiveness and inefficiency of MAD cannot be disputed. The European Commission (EC) should be on the fore front in addressing the concern of urgently reforming the MAD as a result of failure to achieve its stated objectives.

Coordinated measures that account for the present failures and deficiencies need to be put in place. This can be done at EU level prior to the EC’s decision, especially in the light of short selling (Mantysaari, 2009, pg. 171). References Ferran, E, (2004), Building an EU securities market, London: Cambridge University Press. Seredydska, I, (2011), Insider Dealing and Criminal Law: Dangerous Liaisons, California: Springer. Katharina, P, (2004), Law and governance in an enlarged European Union, London: Hart Publishing.

Mantysaari, P, (2009), The Law of Corporate Finance: General Principles and EU Law: Volume II: Contracts in General, California: Springer.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Market Abuse Directive Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1441277-it-is-sometimes-said-that-the-market-abuse
(Market Abuse Directive Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1441277-it-is-sometimes-said-that-the-market-abuse.
“Market Abuse Directive Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1441277-it-is-sometimes-said-that-the-market-abuse.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Market Abuse Directive

Prospectus Regulation as a Tool for Investors

The Prospectus directive (PD) is required to be reviewed every 5 years by the European Commission (Lannoo, 2007).... A prospectus can be published only with some types of securities that are either offered to the public or are requested for admission on a regulated market (Legislative.... Similarly, after listing of shares on respective bourses, if the competent authority finds infringement of provision, then it can inform the market operator to suspend trading in the stock for 10 working days or even in that matter prohibit public from trading in the securities till further notice....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

The Financial Services and Markets Act 2000

Introduction The Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA) contains the statutory regime for controlling and regulating market abuse within the UK.... Statutory Definitions and Regulations of Insider Dealing The Criminal Justice Act 1993 which implements the EU directive on insider dealing creates two offences of insider dealing.... Grier defines insider dealing as gainful use of “secret information” related to investments that are traded in the open market by “those who are privy to that information and should not be taking advantage” of that information and knowledge....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Problematic Effectiveness of Insider Dealing Sanctions

Some of the problematic effectiveness of sanctions includes the gaps in regulation of commodity derivatives, lack of legal certainty of the Market Abuse Directive, the gaps in regulating new markets, platforms and over the counter instruments in the emerging markets.... The Market Abuse Directive (MAD) faced numerous challenges in curbing insider trading.... EU directive 2003/6/EC24 adopted in 2003 updated the legal framework on insider dealing and market manipulation behavior....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Takeovers Directive as a Piece of Legislation

More specifically, in the UK, a takeover refers to the purchase of a public company whose shares are listed on a stock exchange… The Takeovers directive Is An Ineffective Piece Of Legislation Designed To Create An Unachievable Single Market For Takeover Activity.... For instance, the EU Takeover directive of 2004 was adopted with the...
24 Pages (6000 words) Essay

Dirct and e-Marketing

Without the transparency afforded by building freedom of information and data protection principles into the systems which will deliver online services, it is hard to see why people should trust not to abuse the powers it will need to tie together the data from disparate sources.... If the same 'smart' electronic card will in future be used for financial transactions, to hold medical records, criminal records, driving licence details and to authenticate my dealings with departments, how can a cost6omer be sure the firm will not abuse the technology to track my movements, lifestyle, reading matter and so on This gap in public trust is going to be one of the biggest problems facing the wiring up of public service delivery, and strong FOI and data protection laws are the absolute minimum requirements to bridge the divide....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Directive on Food Supplements

This report "directive on Food Supplements" discusses directive on food supplements, which resulted in the prohibition of the marketing of products not abiding by the Directives of the EC law, The Alliance for Natural Health and Nutri-Link Limited, comprised of organization of manufacturers across Europe.... The directive further stated that effective August 1, 2005, products that did not comply with the directives should be prohibited.... The directive provided in Article 15 also affirmed that 'Member States shall bring into the force of laws' and other aforesaid stipulations needed to abide by the Directive6....
8 Pages (2000 words) Report

Effects of Child Abuse

Findings from this research will help clarifying the misconception that early abuse has minimal impact on long term outcomes.... This paper involves discussion and research to find out if the victims of child-abuse remember their cases when they turn older and if it really impacts their behaviors and life in various ways.... After reviewing numerous articles, journals, books, newspapers or other sources, it would become easier to analyze the extent of influence over one's mind of child abuse from childhood to adulthood....
32 Pages (8000 words) Essay

Stock Exchange and Fair Market Place

Companies issues IPO or… Stock exchanges act as “continuous auction” in the market with sellers and buyers doing transaction at the same level which is known as the floor of the stock exchange.... Stock market always fluctuates and it depends on several factors like profitability and performance of the company, political and social factors, and govt.... Systematic risks are the market risks and can be measured by beta.... Now we need to consider the various types of risks that are associated with investing in the stock market....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us