StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Cigarettes and Smokers Regarding The Economy - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Cigarettes and Smokers Regarding The Economy" describes that cigarette is a legal good but its harmful effects surpass the pleasure it gives. If the supply and demand for cigarettes were both unitary elastic, then the burden of tax would have been shared equally by the producer and the consumer…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
Cigarettes and Smokers Regarding The Economy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Cigarettes and Smokers Regarding The Economy"

?Q1. Externalities occur when there are differences between marginal private costs/benefits and marginal social costs/benefits. If there is a negative externality attached to any good then that means that the cost to society (MSB) is greater than the cost (MPC) the consumer is paying for it (http://www.economics.fundamentalfinance.com) .The price that a consumer pays for a packet of cigarettes is the private cost that he incurs but in the case of cigarettes private cost is exceeded by social cost for reasons such as passive smokers are at a greater health hazard than active ones, smoking results in ulcers and different kinds of cancer such as lung cancer, mouth cancer etc. In the figure below, the triangle E1EF represents the welfare loss to the society. Q2. The elasticity of demand for cigarettes is inelastic for adults which mean that demand is not that responsive to a change in price (Kamin). How much the incidence or burden of sales tax is borne by consumers and how much is borne by producers depends on elasticity of demand and supply. An important concept to bear in mind is that sales tax is a tax on a transaction as opposed to a tax on a person. For instance if a packet of cigarettes currently costs $2.50 and there is a sales tax of $1 on it, then the producer will not be willing to sell it at any price less than $3.50. The diagram below shows how the tax burden will be distributed: As can be seen from the graph above, the decrease in consumer surplus is a lot greater than the decrease in producer surplus as the elasticity of demand for cigarettes is inelastic and the supply is elastic. The consumer bears greater burden of the tax. There is also a dead weight loss (area represented by the triangle) as the difference between Qt and Q* represents the goods unsold because of the imposition of tax. The benefit of selling these goods is not large enough to cover the tax burden so the sale of these goods does not take place. Dead weight loss is of benefit to neither the producer nor the consumer. However if the supply and demand for cigarettes were both unitary elastic, then the burden of tax would have been shared equally by the producer and the consumer. The diagram below shows the equal reduction in consumer and producer surpluses: Q3. A price floor is a form of government intervention to prevent decreases in price. Governments use a price floor to discourage the consumption of some goods for example cigarettes. Smoking is the leading cause of cancer in Australia hence the Cancer Council of Australia requested the government to abolish duty free tobacco sales and to set a price floor in order to stop the sale of cheap cigarettes that pose a serious threat to public health. The diagram below shows what a price floor looks like. P0 is the equilibrium price where the quantity demanded (q d ) equals the quantity supplied (q s ). However at the price P*, q s is greater than q d indicating a surplus in the market at the price floor and a loss in sales revenue. Q4. If the suppliers earn positive economic profits, then this will attract new entrants into the perfectly competitive market because of free entry and exit (College). Also because the cigarettes are identical, new entrants do not have to worry about advertising. The overall industry output will increase which will cause a rightward shift in the industry’s supply curve (from S to S1). This will apply a downward pressure on price as the quantity supplied is greater than the quantity demanded and there is a surplus (Q1-Q3) in the market. The price will drop till the point where an individual supplier is only able to earn normal profit (the point where average revenue equals average cost). Hence the opportunities of positive economic profits are diminished in the long run. If the government’s antismoking campaign proves to be successful, then that means people become more aware of the hazards of smoking. This can lead to a fall in the demand for cigarettes because demand in a perfectly competitive market is infinitely elastic. People who are casual smokers might even quit completely as they do not have addiction issues. The industry’s demand curve will shift rightwards from D1 to D2, resulting in a change in price from P1 to P2 and in equilibrium quantity from Q1 to Q2. The individual firm’s sales revenue is measured by “prices times’ quantity (P x Q)”. It is clear from the diagram (Bamford 166)below that the area P1Q1 is greater than the area P2Q2, indicating a fall in the individual firm’s revenue, though the firm is still able to earn a positive economic profit. Q5. Cigarette is a legal good but its harmful effects surpass the pleasure it gives. Take Ukraine for example, which has 16.5 million smokers and there are 115,000 deaths per year because of tobacco related diseases and the male life expectancy is also very low (Samina Shariff 1). As per the theory of Pigouvian taxation: “taxes on a product should be set equal to the externalities the product’s use imposes on others and should not depend on effects on oneself (which are assumed to be internalized in consumption decisions)” (Koszegi). Imposing higher sales taxes on cigarettes is a consequence of higher externalities posed by cigarettes to the society and this policy also is in synchronization with the theory of Pigouvian taxation. In the Ukraine example, if the sales tax was increased to 70%, tobacco related deaths between 249,000 and 994,000 could be avoided (Shariff 1). Cigarettes taxes are most effective in reducing consumption of the young population or more precisely children and teenagers who get pocket money and are not financially independent (Chaloupka). People who try cigarettes for thrill will be put off greatly by a significant amount of sales tax. But for hard-core consumers of cigarettes, quitting is not easy at all as they experience withdrawal symptoms if they try to quit. They will be willing to forgo their consumption of other products but cigarette. Foregoing the consumption of other products does not curb the need for them. Therefore, hard-core smokers tend to resort to shop lifting because after spending on cigarettes they are left with very less money. The sellers of other products will incur losses because hardcore smokers are willing to sacrifice products like biscuits, sweets, chocolates or magazines for cigarettes. Sometimes when the government announces a rise in sales tax on cigarettes, it takes time for the tax to come into effect. In the mean while smokers buy cigarettes in bulk so that they do not have to pay the higher price for a packet of cigarettes. So this bulk buying should be taken into account before the government imposes sales tax. Some economists are of the view that a sales tax on cigarette will be more effective in the long run than in the short run because smokers readily adjust to price in the short run. If the price is permanently increased from let’s say $2.5 to $5.0 for a packet of cigarettes then the long run impact will be double the short run one and a lot of people will be able to overcome the habit altogether. Imposing a sales tax on cigarettes is just not enough. The revenue generated from sales tax should be invested in Health Programs dedicated to discouraging smoking. Also filtered cigarettes should be taxed less than the unfiltered ones. However the difference in the tax rates for the two should not be very large. Besides this taxation policy, there should be a ban on cigarette advertising and it should be made mandatory that the hazards of smoking be mentioned on a packet of cigarettes. With no advertising, the attractive packaging also lures consumers. The government should come up with a generic packaging design that is less appealing to consumers. It should be obligatory on retailers to sell cigarettes to people who have attained the age of majority (18 years old). Government sponsored campus drives at different schools and universities should be held in which lectures on negative effects of smoking should be conducted. Student volunteers can also be hired by the government to spread awareness. There should be tariffs imposed on the cheap cigarettes imported from other countries. Sales taxation alone cannot deter consumers from smoking. Like other economic policies, taxation should be carried out with above mentioned measures to ensure good health of all. Works Cited Bamford, Colin. AS Level and A Level Economic. Cambridge University Press, 2002. Chaloupka, F J. tobaccocontrol.bmj.com. College, Geoff Riley of Eton. http://wwwtutor2u.net. September 2006. . http://www.economics.fundamentalfinance.com. . Kamin, David. www.swarthmore.edu. 2002. . Koszegi, Jonathan Gruber and Botond. "A Modern Economic view of Tobacco Taxation." 2008. Samina Shariff, Anna Gillmore and Hana Zaubova Ross. "Economics of Tobacco Taxation in Ukraine." 2009. Shariff, Samina. "Economics of Tobacco Taxation in Ukraine." 2009. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Cigarettes and Smokers Regarding The Economy Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1391342-economics
(Cigarettes and Smokers Regarding The Economy Essay)
https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1391342-economics.
“Cigarettes and Smokers Regarding The Economy Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1391342-economics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Cigarettes and Smokers Regarding The Economy

The Possible Benefit from Tobacco

In order to understand the implications of the increased taxation, the   paper will discuss the importance of cigarette taxes to the economy of the United States and discuss the purpose of taxation as a social policy.... In order to have a clear understanding of the importance of cigarette taxes, it is appropriate to give a historical background of the object- cigarettes.... However, when America started trading with other colonies after the American Revolution, tobacco in the form of cigarettes became popular....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Health, Economic and Legal Implications of Smoking Tobacco

In addition, suggested solutions to the smoking menace will be highlighted This research paper aims highlighting the effects of tobacco smoking on health and the economy while illustrating measures taken to curb the ever increasing prevalence of smoking.... The study adopted a mixed method of research, which incorporated qualitative and quantitative research approaches while relying on direct sources of data to investigate the detrimental effects of tobacco smoking on health and the economy....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Health Economics: Plain Packaging of Cigarettes

In the paper “Health Economics: Plain Packaging of Cigarettes” the author analyses attempts of several counties to reduce the number of smokers.... The plain packaging of cigarettes is another attempt to reduce the number of smokers.... The removal of the branding removes the attractiveness of the product and therefore discourages the smokers to consume the product.... The branding for the cigarettes needs to be removed from the pack of cigarettes....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Electronic Cigarettes

smokers are increasingly turning to e-cigarettes to get their nicotine fix.... Even though some state government have already imposed restrictions, there are other significant concerns such as whether the e-cigarette can make smokers quit smoking and the clarity of the side effects of the products as claimed by various public health group bodies, the Federal and State governments and the public (Popova & Ling, 2013).... In the paper “Electronic cigarettes” the author analyzes new regulations on electronic cigarettes proposed by the Food and Drug Administration thus heightening debate over smoking....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Cigarette Tax: Distribution of Tax Burden or the Incidence of Taxation

nbsp;… Though the taxation on cigarettes seems to cause some monetary loss and decline in the benefit of smokers in the United States the truth is that it is beneficial for the economy as a whole.... In this topic, we would concentrate on a special case: the tax imposed by the Federal Government on the cigarettes and its impact on the consumers and producers.... To offset the external diseconomies created by smokers.... Here smokers create negative externality....
20 Pages (5000 words) Term Paper

Should Tobacco Companies Be Held Responsible for Smoking-related Illnesses and Deaths

Later on April 14, 1994, in a historic hearing regarding the regulation of tobacco products, Fuentes states that seven CEOs of the nation's largest tobacco companies appeared before Congress in a Senate hearing to testify on the addictive properties of nicotine.... Owing to the story, there was heightened fear in many Americans as to the potential risk that cigarettes posed....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Cigarettes as a Cause of Fire

nbsp;… Instead of thinking about banning the cigarettes altogether or emphasizing upon degrading the quality of cigarettes so as to reduce their vulnerability to cause fire, smokers should be requested to ensure that the conditions in which they smoke are free of all such factors that might in any way assist a burning cigarette bud to cause a fire.... The case study "cigarettes as a Cause of Fire" points out that cigarettes have largely been referred to as a fundamental source of fire in many fire breakout incidents that have occurred at various places in the world so far, where their identification as the causal factor was altogether unjust....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Why Smoking Should Be Banned in Public Places

So much so that they choose to smoke despite warnings regarding its negative effects, physical signs of smoking that have taken its toll on the body, and rules against smoking.... There are many health-related concerns regarding smoking in general, but more so when done in a public place where there are more people affected by the smoke.... One of the concerns regarding smoking as a whole is that for the smokers, direct contact with tobacco smoke either causes or promotes lung cancer....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us