StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of Putnams Claim - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Analysis of Putnam’s Claim" focuses on the fact that the author does believe that people still talk of divorce “in an almost pious reverence”, but this the author believes is bound to change since divorce is continuously becoming so common…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
Analysis of Putnams Claim
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of Putnams Claim"

1 Identify Putnam's claim. Where does he it in his essay From your experience, do you agree with him Do you agree that people discuss "divorce" in an almost pious reverence saved only for life threatening illness Putnam claims even though he did go through the same trepidations as any child of divorced parents do; he did not miss out on things that children need the most. This is clearly stated in the first sentence of the fourth paragraph of his essay where he wrote that: "Perhaps one of the most important reasons for my absence of "trauma" (for lack of better word) stemming from my parent's divorce is that I am by no means alone in my trials and tribulation." I do believe that people still talk of divorce "in an almost pious reverence", but this I believe is bound to change since divorce is continuously becoming so common. The time will come when divorce will be talked about openly and sadly will be seen as a normal day-to-day happening in society. 2.) On what ground does Putnam base his claim Find specific evidence he presents to support his claim. Do you find it convincing and supportive Putnam based his claims on the fact that he feels he still can depend on his parents although he gets to spend time with them separately. He has found resolution in his family's situation of which he has quaintly expressed when he wrote that "The safest environment for me was to be with one happy parent at a time, instead of two miserable ones all the time." I find the discussions in his essay convincing and supportive on his claim on what the divorce of his parents has done for him. He was able to present negative implications of the divorce and at the same time presented a clear understanding and acceptance of his living situation "with two houses to call home." 4.) Putnam has several warrants, some of them stated explicitly and some implied. In paragraph 2 he states: "A loving parent will be a successful one even if he or she cannot afford to furnish his or her child with the best clothes or the most sophisticated gourmet delicacies." Do you agree with this warrant On what commonly shared values or beliefs does he base this warrant Are there any aspects of his warrant with which you disagree What backing does Putnam provide to support his warrant Is it sufficient I agree with Putnam's warrant that: "A loving parent will be a successful one even if he or she cannot afford to furnish his or her child with the best clothes or the most sophisticated gourmet delicacies." It is of a commonly shared belief or value that a parent's love and care is enough or sufficient to satisfy a child's happiness and well-being. Material vanity is of no importance when children lack of genuine attention, love and care. His claim is supported by his statement that: "With love as a driving force in a parent's mind, he or she will invariably make the correct decisions." In his opinion, he writes that the decision of his parents to separate after discovering that they no longer loved each other produced a healthy living situation for Putnam when he spends time with a happy parent at each time instead of living together with unhappy parents. 6.) Notice the qualifier Putnam uses in paragraph 3 when he says, "In all truthfulness, there have been some decidedly negative ramifications stemming from our family separation" (emphasis added). What limitations does this qualifying statement put on his argument Does this limitation weaken his argument at all The qualifying statement on paragraph 3 limits his argument because it opens to the whole other side of his claim. This statement stresses on the fact that his parent's divorce had a negative impact in his life. Although it limits his claim, it does not weaken his argument. It only shows of his acceptance and that he is not on denial of what he felt or seen as a child of divorced parents. 7.) Does Putnam acknowledge and address anticipated rebuttals to his argument Can you locate any in his essay What rebuttals can you make in response to his arguments Putnam does acknowledge and address anticipated rebuttals to his argument when he wrote that "As I reread the first section of this essay, I realize that it is perhaps too optimistic and cheerful regarding my life as a child of divorced parents." However I can make no rebuttals in response to his arguments because this essay is of his life and experiences. It only implies that what divorce for him may or may not be the same for others. "Merck pitches another use for Gardasil" http://money.cnn.com/2005/12/16/news/fortune500/merck/index.htm Claim 1 Merck claims that Gardasil, besides being an experimental cervical cancer vaccine can also prevent sexually transmitted viruses that cause symptoms such as external genital lesions in women like vagina and vulvar lesions. This vaccine was tested on female subjects worldwide before it was approved by the FDA and in late-stage tests that were conducted, it showed 100% efficiency in preventing STD viruses that cause 90% of vaginal and vulvar lesions in women. Claim 2 Merck vaccines' president claims that Gradasil is "a major breakthrough in cancer protection" and a great help to the expansion in the vaccine market in the future. For cervical cancer alone, about 3,900 women die annually in the US. Currently, the company is awaiting approvals on two vaccines; Rotateq and Zostavax which are for severe diarrhea in infants and shingles respectively. Claim 3 As Merck faces lawsuits, layoffs and the upcoming patent expiration of its top earner, Zocor, Gardasil will probably be one of the company products that will help them stop the company's downfall. Zocor's patent expiration is due in a year. Merck has resolved to cutting off jobs, closing and selling of some of its plants to replace lost sales with the impending expiration of Zocor's patent. Merck is also facing 9,200 costly lawsuits from those who blame Vioxx, an arthritis pain reliever for heart attacks. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Putnam Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1517222-putnam
(Putnam Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1517222-putnam.
“Putnam Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1517222-putnam.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of Putnams Claim

Reflective log on communication

According to Schon (1983, p.... 23), reflective log is defined as "the capacity to reflect on action so as to engage in a process of continuous learning", which, according to the originator of the term, is "one of the defining characteristics of professional practice".... ... ... ... According to Schon (1983, p....
24 Pages (6000 words) Essay

Salem witch trials

Mary Beth Norton, In the Devil's Snare: The Salem Witchcraft Crisis of 1692 A Book Review Introduction Mary Beth Norton was born in Ann Arbor, Michigan, in 1943.... She received her B.... .... from the University of Michigan in 1964, her M.... .... from Harvard University in 1965, and her Ph.... ....
10 Pages (2500 words) Book Report/Review

Argument of Scientific Realism

Among different scientific realists, Bas van Fraassen and Larry Laudan are scientific realists who have debated against the claim of Hilary Putnam more accurately.... The no-miracle claim by Hilary Putnam further explains the theory on the basis of abduction.... The no-miracle claim could also be understood in terms of a hypothetical situation where an entity 'A' is a fact that is known surprisingly and through premise 'P' the fact 'A' can be elaborated....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Diplomacy in the international system

Academic discourse on the topic has often been framed within the polarised international relations theory paradigms of neo-liberalism versus realism.... ... ... Furthermore, within these models of international relations theory, commentators have also addressed the roles of diplomats in international relations theory and the focus of this paper is to critically evaluate the role of diplomacy in international relations....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Comparison of the Play and the Film: The Crucible

Both the play and the film follow a similar dialogue, but several lines have been cut out of the film because of time constraints that serve to highlight some of the play's themes while reducing others as can be seen through an analysis of the first act.... This movie review "Comparison of the Play and the Film: The Crucible" presents The Crucible, Arthur Miller wrote both play and screenplay for the film....
7 Pages (1750 words) Movie Review

New Zealand Voter Turnout

This paper "New Zealand Voter Turnout " explains the possible causes of voter turnout drop in New Zealand and some of the approaches that can be employed to reverse the trend.... owering levels of civic culture examined the most in this paper as the main factor.... ... ... ... Many people have expressed a remarkable degree of concern over the levels of voter turnout in the established democracies such as New Zealand....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Knowledge about the World

This work called "Knowledge about the World" describes the problem of objective knowledge and existence of human beings in the objective world.... The author outlines the concept of skepticism, Descartes' method, the ways of creation of perfectly-justified theories concerning the reality, the role of intellectual intuition....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Ethics, Metaphysics, Pragmatism, and Their Individual Value

It is argued that effective analysis of metaphysics can ultimately occur in pragmatism when metaphysics is linked to ethics.... "Ethics, Metaphysics, Pragmatism, and Their Individual Value" paper describes three main branches of philosophy: ethics, metaphysics, pragmatism, and their individual value....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us