StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Mixed Communities and Their Efficacy - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Mixed Communities and Their Efficacy" analyzes that due to the trend of “growing economic segregation and economic deprivation”, governments and urban planners have developed housing plans to prevent the further marginalisation of the lower-income classes…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Mixed Communities and Their Efficacy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Mixed Communities and Their Efficacy"

Mixed Communities: Reduced Housing Units in Higher Income Residential Areas Public Housing policy has developed through time. Originally, governments made improvements upon uninhabitable residential areas by full demolition and subsequent renovation of those slums.1 But as sociologists have concluded, in order to conquer socioeconomic disparities, all income brackets must be interconnected in order to attain a unified social fabric and develop attractive communities.2 Within mixed communities this cohesion is possible. The purpose of mixed communities is to improve the quality of life of low-income families and combat the disadvantages often incurred by them in concentrated low-income areas. Due to the trend of "growing economic segregation and economic deprivation"3 governments and urban planners have developed housing plans in order to prevent further marginalisation of the lower-income classes. The segregation of these people is a concern, as residents in low-income concentrations have higher levels of unemployment, their job networks are limited, and their neighbourhoods are plagued by poor healthcare and schools.4 Mixed communities are created in a variety of ways, through the evolution of older housing areas, as a by-production of mainstream housing development, by the overall masterplanning of new areas, and by intentionally altering existing areas whose origins were social renting'.5 THEMES: SATISFACTION, HEALTH, INTEGRATION OF NEIGHBOURHOOD SATISFACTION When discussing mixed communities and their efficacy in the improvement of living standards of low-income families, key issues that social scientists review are related to community satisfaction. Mixed neighbourhoods ideally will be agreeable to both subsidised low-income families and the higher income families that pay full market price. It has been shown throughout the literature that despite the labelling of 'mixed community', the prime factor in desirability of housing is the housing unit itself, including design, spaciousness, cleanliness, and location. HEALTH Low-income households are particularly benefited in relocation to mixed housing communities because of the improved cleanliness, safety, and general wellbeing of the neighbourhood. Oftentimes, residential areas of low-income concentrations do not have fully functional amenities, are neglected in service standards and resource allocation.67 In fact, in a study using data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NAHNES), Kumanyika and Grier (2006) linked childhood obesity prevalence to low-income housing.8 There is an absence of higher-end amenities and services, like hospitals and clinics. Lack of recreational opportunities for both children and adults, are characteristic of low-income areas. INTEGRATION Contrary to desired outcomes of mixed communities, little evidence has shown that low-income persons in better-off areas climb the social ladder in terms of job opportunities or increased salary.9 However, due to the disconnect from their previous residential areas, it can be said that poverty, unemployment, and drop-outs, are less likely to be perpetuated.1011 In a 2005 study conducted by the Brookings Institution in Washington D.C. on England communities, researchers found a favourable ambience between neighbours of different income brackets in mixed communities. One tenant said, "I personally would not think that anybody was very different whether they are renting their house off the council or buying, and I really don't know why there is this great big emphasis."12 But before it be concluded that mixed communities interact so well as to improve social networks, it should be clarified that in two separate research studies,13 mixed communities interacted well and were civil, but "mostly co-existed as neighbours rather than friends"14. That is to say, they were polite to each other, but did not mix in the same social circles. DEBATES A certain difficulty for mixed communities and housing developments is the lack of flexibility of these areas during interaction with the larger municipal setting, which is to say the real estate market. Planned neighbourhoods should be cohesive with open-sector neighbourhoods dependent upon fluctuations of the housing market. The logic of this is that the more rigid the guidelines of mixed communities, the more susceptible they will be to failure. The obverse of a people's housing policy is one where the decisions are made unilaterally by public sector institutions. Essentially this is a monopoly approach in which the planning, design and execution of housing programs take place without reference to consumer demand. The result is that housing services are produced which do not satisfy the needs of the clients. (Frankenhoff)15 For this reason, the University of Westminster set research students and Development faculty to the task of reviewing their own and others' case studies, in order to define key factors in the success of mixed neighbourhoods.16 After all, attractiveness is key to residents' satisfaction. One of the areas the Westminster students defined for the creation of successful communities was the existence of 'a full range of housing types and sizes.' Other researchers have alluded to this as well, like Berube (2005), and Desmond17 (2001). An issue concerning public housing developments is their 'non-place' in the real estate market. In 1998, the Joseph Rowntree Housing Trust attempted a creative solution to one of their neighbourhood's increasingly un-mixed population. The problem was that more and more houses within the 'mixed community' were being inhabited by low-income families, thereby making in less attractive to other future buyers. In order to prevent this housing community to turn into a ghetto, the trust opened up a number of homes to the open market for sale or shared ownership.18 A related debate is whether mixed communities harm the wellbeing and hinder the progress of more affluent households in those areas. Contrary to fears, it has been proven that housing developers may maintain as much confidence in mixed communities as in others: "There was no evidence that mixed communities lowered the prices of houses or put off potential purchasers."19 PERSPECTIVES One perspective of mixed-community opponents is that residents from low-income areas 'do not care' about the standards of their environment. They will not provide the necessary up-keep on their houses and the neighbourhood will be injured by the inclusion of low-income families as their homes become the block's eyesores. In fact, in a set of interviews conducted by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, it was found that the perceived 'lack of up-keep' of low-income people was a product of living and working in problem environments.20 The following is an illustration of how "Sometimes even the most motivated and responsible residents" are worn down: I used to be out cleaning I used to go out and lift up (rubbish) and I thought 'What the hell am I doing I'm far too old for this'. I don't touch it now.21 The same study found that low-income families regarded their homes in much the same way as others, and there was no perceivable difference between the two types of dwellers. OMISSIONS In survey of the literature, I was unable to find any research related to ratio of housing types within mixed communities. Among other motivations, mixed communities are designed for the social integration of all income levels, meaning that low-incomes and high-incomes will equally reside within neighbourhoods. However, I wonder if there is a limit on the number of low-income families that may be placed within a mixed community before it hinders the community. Also, it was difficult to impossible to find statistics on the allocation of government funds for these neighbourhoods, and who these resources are controlled by. Secondly, the research projects and case studies conducted within mixed communities have excluded one very important investigation. To support this statement, let us recall that low-income residents in new neighbourhoods find satisfaction with their new housing mainly because of improved cleanliness, facilities, and services. In higher income areas, there are more clinics, stores, pharmacies, etc. In lower income areas, there is no foreseeable profit for investors, and they do not want to invest there. What would happen in this scenario: What if service sites, particularly concerning healthcare and recreation, like parks, were implanted in areas of low-income concentration Then, would the findings like those of Kumanyika and Grier be different Thirdly, what happens with the problem environments that still exist Mixed communities are better-off communities with the sporadic inclusion of subsidized families. What happens with the areas of concentrated worse-off families Although urban planners have gone away from the 'demolish' then construct slap-dash 'brick and mortar' approach,22 opting for social inclusion of families, there still exist those areas of unhealthy, uninhabitable housing complexes that cause people to give up hope, saying "It will stay a dump no matter what we do" and "There's that much rubbish we just tend to walk past it"23. Research has been conducted on the inefficacy of municipalities to deal with slum areas. But more experimental work should be conducted in order to improve the situation for those yet excluded. As Berube (2005) pointed out in his study funded by the Brookings Institution, "It may be more important-and more realistic-for policy to prevent detrimental non-mix than to pursue some idealised mix across the whole of the country."24 A related issue is income. Families are subsidised in order to meet the standards of better living neighbourhoods. To solve the problem at its cause would be to increase the minimum wage earned by workers so that they would fiscally afford better housing. In time, slums, or areas of concentrated low-income families -- areas subject to adverse health and school environments, not to mention social exclusion - would be abandoned as all residents attained a better quality of life by that increased annual income. Notes Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Mixed communities Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words”, n.d.)
Mixed communities Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1510171-mixed-communities
(Mixed Communities Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words)
Mixed Communities Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1510171-mixed-communities.
“Mixed Communities Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1510171-mixed-communities.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Mixed Communities and Their Efficacy

The Vienna and Prague Declarations: On the Reformation and Rethinking of Drug Policies

For the second point, I also agree with the implementation and evaluation of a science-based public health approach tailor-fitted to individuals/communities.... Both the Vienna and the Prague Declarations deal with the need to reform the policies regarding the treatment of drug users and the change in the implementation of such policies....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Parenting Program Can Impact Self-Efficacy

The paper "Parenting Program Can Impact Self-efficacy" describes that the research has also contributed to the body of parenting whereby practitioners can know how to address the problem of self-efficacy among parents in order to raise their children in the most effective manner.... The objective of the research was to evaluate the parental self-efficacy encounters for the users of a parenting program and consider the results obtained in the process to the realities on the ground....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Major Factor Influencing Delinquency

In the essay "OP-ED's position" the author describes that he agrees with OP-ED's position that the major factor that influences delinquency is poverty because social disorganization theory suggests that poverty is an important ecological characteristic that can decrease collective efficacy and informal social control.... I agree with OP-ED's position that the major factor that influences delinquency is poverty because social disorganization theory suggests that poverty is an important ecological characteristic that can decrease collective efficacy and informal social control....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Social Origins of Islam

The origin of Islam stems from the ideology of Quran that swept the Arabian Peninsula and introduced new patterns of life, through building on the already existing cultural patterns of the Arabs, so much that it almost eroded the traditional cultures that already existed… Nevertheless, it is not only the Quran ideology that formed the fundamental basis of the rise of the Islamic culture, religion and way of life, but also the blending of the existing pre-Islamic culture with a changing economic lifestyle that introduced trade and This blending was the reinforced by the new form of world view that arose from the Quran ideology and the consequent Islamic theology, resulting in the establishment of Islam not only as a religion, but also as culture and way of life of the Arabs....
8 Pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review

Community Health Promotion and Prevention

On the other hand, contemporary public health nursing involves working in collaborations and The health workers are challenged to take the leadership role of assessing the assets and the needs of communities and populations in order to propose solutions through partnership.... Since these solutions that will have a greater influence on heath and illness patterns of various levels within the communities and the broader population....
4 Pages (1000 words) Coursework

Sociological Perspectives of Crime

This paper ''Sociological Perspectives of Crime'' tells that sociological perspectives of crime have undergone considerable changes over the years as theorists attempt to adjust to the transformations in society.... This essay highlights a number of changes that have informed changes in sociological theories since 2000....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Suicide Prevention Programs

This paper "Suicide Prevention Programs" discusses suicide as one of the leading causes of death of young people in the United States of America.... Some of them do display red-flag behaviors while others do not show they have problems, and this makes the prevention of suicide rather difficult.... hellip; Based on the information obtained through the analysis of available data on suicide, one can draw the conclusion that the problem is acute and very serious in American society as thousands of people choose to end their lives rather than call for help....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Australian: Health, Drugs, and Alcohol

Now, after many decades thanks to the despondency in Aboriginal communities no one needs to lead Aboriginals by the hand to the killer drug, alcohol.... People in mainstream Australian society also drink alcohol but the use of alcohol is not a problem in non-indigenous societies to the same extent as they are in Aboriginal communities.... Alcohol was introduced to Aboriginal communities by Europeans who came to Australia several centuries ago....
9 Pages (2250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us