StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Claire Berlinskis Polemic Ban the Burqa - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author in the following book review "Claire Berlinski's Polemic Ban the Burqa" mentions that the reader is versed in the opposing opinion with regards to the wearing of the burqa and/or head covering in what the author describes as a “civilized society"…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
Claire Berlinskis Polemic Ban the Burqa
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Claire Berlinskis Polemic Ban the Burqa"

Section/# Rhetorical Analysis of Claire Berlinski’s Polemic “Ban the Burqa” As with most well argued, the particular article in question, Claire Berlinski’s “Ban the Burqa”, first states the arguments to the contrary point of view while appearing to lend a degree of credence to these alternatives. Moreover, the way in which the legality and morality, as well as spirituality, are all intimately related to the subject matter is presented to the reader in the earliest stages of the piece. As a function of this, the reader is well versed in the opposing opinion with regards to the wearing of the burqa and/or head covering in what the author describes as a “civilized society”. However, as one might expect, these alternative views do not appropriately reflect the views of the author herself. Rather, notwithstanding the well-articulated counter arguments and the issue of freedom and legality that they necessarily entail, the author constructs an argument for the complete prohibition at worst and discouragement at best of the burqa within society. As a means of quickly seeking to jar the reader’s attention from the rhetorical strength of those individuals who have come out against legislation banning the veil, Berlinski shifts to the isolated cases of sexual violence that take place in the lawless suburbs of Paris. As a means of distraction this is an effective tactic due to the fact that it instantly congeals the reader’s impression of Islam as naturally given to sexual violence, rape specifically, and depicts the male adherents as little more than sexually deviant thugs who are more than willing to cast aside all decency that a host culture, such as France, may have gifted them as a means of punishing those who dare to show a bit of self expression and freedom of strict Islamic tradition. As a function of shifting the debate from the broad to the specific, the author is able to convince the reader that her specific point of view is the most rational. This rhetorical approach is not unique; however Berlinski applies it masterfully. Right after eviscerating Islamic European culture for being broken, immoral, and unrestrained, Berlinski states, “Yet the burqa must be banned. All forms of veiling must be, if not banned, strongly discouraged and stigmatized” (Berlinski 2). The argument deviates further from the subject matter when Berlinski brings in the topic of gynecological examinations of girls within many of the recent immigrant communities within Europe. Although it is not the function of this author to make a moral judgment with regards to whether or not such a fascination with sexual chastity is right or wrong, it should also not be something that the author herself relies on with regards to making her point with respect to the legitimacy and/or legality of wearing traditional Islamic head coverings in public places. Such a distraction is both unwarranted and unnecessary as it merely draws attention away from the key point which was sought to be relayed to the reader. Though this represents a separate issue that arguably retains a level of moral judgment and religious and societal tie ins, it nonetheless has no bearing to the conversation at hand and is used to further a rhetorically inept analysis of the issue at hand. Finally, the author likens the existence of the burqa to the very smallest in the continuum of Islamic radicalism and its outgrowth, terrorism, which she believes to not only be sweeping Europe and the Middle East but the rest of the world. This serves as clarion call to action on the part of the reader but as has been noted from the prior rhetorical deficiencies that the piece exhibits, it can be inferred that this call to action, however well intentioned it may be, is not grounded in proof or solid analytics. As a way of furthering the reader’s pathos just a bit more on the topic, the author reveals that she believs the head covering is “cancerous” and ultimately an outgrowth o fa disease of radical Islam that is spreading across the glove. Even a cursory analysis of such a proposition is laughable due ot the fact that head covering within the Islamic tradition long predates any exhibition of terrorism or suicide bombing for that matter. Ultimately, what the author has done is set up the burqa and/or the head covering as something of a straw man argument. Within such a construct, the reader can begin to notice the core shortcomings of yet another argument that Berlinski presents. Without the ability to point to rational understanding and verifiable fact, the author is prompted to reach for an untenable position. However, to the author’s credit, there was one particular point of the piece that raised this author’s ire. The author relates how certain individuals among the Islamic leadership around the world view the rape and sexual assault of women who have seemingly “invited” such an occurrence due to the fact that they have no covered themselves appropriately. Said one Islamic cleric, “If you take out uncovered meat and place it outside . . . without cover, and the cats come to eat it . . . whose fault is it, the cats’ or the uncovered meat’s? The uncovered meat is the problem. If she was in her room, in her home, in her hijab, no problem would have occurred” (Berlinski 3). Although this can only tangentially be related to the issue of banning the head scarve and/or burqa, the mere fact alone that such ignorance and sheer stupidity exists within the radicalized portions of the Islamic world is alarming to say the very least and should be fought at each and every turn. The right of women in an era that should show the first reasonable hope of feminism that this world has yet seen to conduct themselves as they wish, dress as they wish, and all other manners of freedoms should not be questioned whatsoever. The logic of the approach is further called into question by the polemic approach that Berlinski makes. Instead of approaching the topic from a reasoned standpoint, panic, fear, and elements of xenophobia are used to motivate the reader to engage with the topic in the way that the author approaches it. This understanding is something that calls the reader to reconsider the other points that Berlinski puts forward. Although many of these points are relevant and worthy of inclusion; seeking to encourage the audience to engage with the topic based on pathos is never a solid foundation for an argument to be predicated on. Nevertheless, the polemic does include elements of both ethos and logos; however, these are somewhat diminished by the over abundance of pathos and the seeming desire of the author to force the reader to adopt her own point of view for fear of what failure to do so might effect. Through Berlinski’s use of logic and evidence, the reader is made aware of the fact that the derivation of understanding that Berlinski provides is not grounded in a broad or pervasive truth nor an appreciation for liberty and the exhibition thereof; rather, it is grounded in a disdain for the Islamic head coverings due to the fact that she views the actions of a small percentage of Islamic practitioners disdainful. Granted, the gang rapes that are being exhibited in the Islamic conclaves of Paris are disgusting and disheartening to say the least, it is nonetheless not a sufficient logical argument to seek to emplace a morally motivated head scarves/covering/burqa ban on the many hundreds of thousands of honest, law-abiding citizens that make up the remainder of Muslim individuals living in parts of Europe or the United States. Work Cited Berlinski, Claire. "Ban the Burqa - Claire Berlinski." National Review Online. N.p., 16 Apr. 2014. Web. 27 June. 2014. . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Claire Berlinskis Polemic Ban the Burqa Book Report/Review - 41, n.d.)
Claire Berlinskis Polemic Ban the Burqa Book Report/Review - 41. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1651199-essay
(Claire Berlinskis Polemic Ban the Burqa Book Report/Review - 41)
Claire Berlinskis Polemic Ban the Burqa Book Report/Review - 41. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1651199-essay.
“Claire Berlinskis Polemic Ban the Burqa Book Report/Review - 41”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1651199-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Claire Berlinskis Polemic Ban the Burqa

Proxemic Behavior

It noted that both groups behaved very similarly in polemic terms, but oppositely of what had been observed in earlier studies.... This paper includes an analysis of five articles that touch the topic of proxemic behaviour in this or that way.... This bibliography includes Galvao M....
2 Pages (500 words) Annotated Bibliography

Muslim Women Portrayal

The problems for Muslim women were created such as that why they cover their faces; wear burqa (piece of cloth that covers body) and do not indulge with men.... Movements against Muslim community have been going on since then and a couple of years ago some of the European countries such France has banned burqa wearing.... Heavy fines on Muslim women have been imposed because of wearing burqa (Ferracioli, 2013).... Concise details about burqa ban in France in also elucidated in the paper....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Historiography Of The Dobama Movement In Burma

The Dobama Asiayone Movement was essentially a Burmese Nationalist group that was established by the Burmese leader Ba Thoung back in May 1930 аfter the killing of an approximated 250 Indian dock workers as well as their families by Burmese.... hellip; Brief History of the Dobama Movement in Burma....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Plan of the Media Watch Project:

Mark Hookham, 03 August 2010, Dewsbury Tory peer hits out over attempts to ban the burka, Yorkshire Evening Post, http://www.... During the course of the last few weeks, both the print and electronic media gave coverage to the French Parliament's ban on burqa.... … The following recent articles selected from the Internet shows that the issue of burqa ban in France continues to be debated here in the media, both in the UK and abroad.... Step 1: Choosing the title During the course of the last few weeks, both the print and electronic media gave coverage to the French Parliaments ban on burqa....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Harp of a Burma by Michio Takeyama

The book relates the story of Japanese soldiers in a troupe, especially Private Mizushima who can play the Burmese harp, who were involved in the Second… It focuses on the aftermath of the surrender, with special focus on Mizushima.... The author focuses on the human experience whilst telling the story....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Ban the Burqa By Claire Berlinski

The article, ban the burqa written by Claire Berlinski in the National Review Online magazine have contributed to many controversial… The rhetorical analysis of this article discusses the purpose of the article, its targeted audience, rhetorical strategies used, diction and style as well as about the logical fallacies accompanying it.... It also poses the limitations in the author's ideas and how it Claire's firsthand audience comprised of the magazine's subscribers and the online surfers, who are less inclined to the reality of cultural and religious significance behind the burqa ban....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Burma: Military Rule in the 1990s

This essay "Burma: Military Rule in the 1990's" concentrates on the main achievement and failures of the military rule in Burma in the 1990's.... hellip; The very presence of the SLORC is distasteful to a genuine constitutional making process and Democracy because it has declared itself above the law and has entrenched its power through exercising Martial Law in Burma....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Ban the Burqa Insight

As the paper "ban the burqa Insight" outlines, there are two types of hijab, the Burqa, and the Niqab.... hellip; This thesis will use constructive and well-planned arguments to show that the current arguments and literature calling for a burqa ban is frail and trivial and explain how banning the burqa is an easy resolution to a nation's identity crisis.... It will examine the limited literature addressing the banning of the burqa to advance understanding of the issue and to develop the argument....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us