StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Effective Motivational Techniques: Private versus Public Organizations - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
 The paper aims to proffer pertinent issues relative to comparative motivational techniques deemed effective in private versus public organizations in the United States. The discourse would initially present a general overview of contemporary motivational practices in the workplace setting…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
Effective Motivational Techniques: Private versus Public Organizations
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Effective Motivational Techniques: Private versus Public Organizations"

 Effective Motivational Techniques: Private versus Public Organizations Abstract The paper aims to proffer pertinent issues relative to comparative motivational techniques deemed effective in private versus public organizations in the United States. Using secondary sources of information through a review of related literature, the discourse would initially present a general overview of contemporary motivational practices in the workplace setting, prior to delving into the dominant motivational techniques and programs considered effective in private and public organizations. The highlight of the findings would reveal which motivational programs and incentive schemes are most crucial in enhancing employee performance and increasing productivity on a comparative basis. A concluding portion would summarize relevant details from the discourse. Effective Motivational Techniques: Private versus Public Organizations One of the most closely monitored and evolving concepts in organizational behavior is motivation. Diverse professionals and business practitioners have conducted various studies that revealed the crucial impact that motivational programs have spurred towards the achievement of organizational goals. Factors that have been proven to enhance employee performance and productivity have been scrutinized, ranging from remarkable cash benefits and non-monetary incentive schemes, or a combination of both. However, since contemporary organizations have evolved and were delineated in terms of structure, purpose and roles, public and private organizations for instance, could not possibly apply the same set of motivational programs deemed to be effective in their respective workplace settings. In this regard, the paper aims to proffer pertinent issues relative to comparative motivational techniques deemed effective in private versus public organizations in the United States. Using secondary sources of information through a review of related literature, the discourse would initially present a general overview of contemporary motivational practices in the workplace setting delving into the dominant motivational techniques and programs considered effective in private and public organizations. The highlights of the findings would reveal which motivational programs and incentive schemes or validated guidelines are most crucial in enhancing employee performance and increasing productivity on a comparative basis. A concluding portion would summarize relevant details from the discourse. Contemporary Motivational Techniques Contemporary organizations have evolved into more sophisticated and complex institutions due to the influence of various external and internal factors that affect their operations. Various workplace trends have necessitated the need to adapt and adjust to new development ranging from “globalisation of the economy, mergers, privatisation, speedy advancement in information communication technology (ICT), environmental sustainability, aging workforce, and increasing wealth separation” [Tawnd]. The transformation was marked and evidently validated by Thomas (2009) who acknowledged having reviewed motivation in the workplace setting for more than 30 years. Thomas (2009) averred that “the proportion of American workers who say that their work is meaningful, allows them discretion, and makes use of their abilities has more than doubled… (Current breed of employees) raised during an era of rapid technological change and instant access to data, respond best to work that is more meaningful, allows them to learn cutting-edge skills, and lets them find their own ways of accomplishing tasks” (p. 1). However, as noted by Boyne (2002), “critics of New Public Management argue that differences between public and private organizations are so great that business practices should not be transferred to the public sector” (p. 97). Concurrently, private organizations do not expect public organizational practices to be deemed applicable in their workplace setting, particularly with regards to motivational programs, performance evaluation, and other managerial functions. The differences between private and public organizations were clearly summed, to wit: “1. The public sector is made up of agencies and institutions owned and operated by the government, while the private sector is made up of small businesses, corporations, as well as profit and non-profit organizations. 2. The public sector is not profit-driven, while this is the case with the private sector. 3. The end beneficiary of the services offered by the public sector is the general public, while it is the general consuming public who take advantage of the goods and services offered for profit by the private sector businesses” [Dif12] Identified as the force or drive that influences people to be directed towards an identified goal (Martires and Fule, 2004; Ud din and Inamullah, 2008), motivation is considered a crucial element that must be incorporated in organizational practices to sustain and support operational growth. Adeyemi (2010) has specifically revealed that “intrinsic motivation is needed in order to arouse a worker's passion or commitment to the job he/she does. It is also important to stress that shared vision, leadership, team work, training, increased capability, and goal accomplishment are inseparable and powerful motivators that can be encouraged and embedded to create a high performance culture” [Ade10]. In the public sector, a study conducted by Wright (2003) cited and reveal several researches by diverse authors disclosed that “public sector employees have been found to place a lower value on financial rewards and a higher value on helping others or public service than their private sector counterparts” (p. 4). However, the same research indicated the need to further validate the contentions given insufficient and contradictory support from other public organizations [Wri03]. In one study written by Kalala (2009), he cited Perry, et al. (2006) as indicating that “according to numerous studies conducted among public employees, the results indicated that among those surveyed, financial rewards was not the most motivating factor” (Perry, Mesch, & Paarlberg, Motivating employees in a new governance era: the performance paradigm revisited, 2006; cited by Kalala, 2009, p. 1). Wright’s (2003) findings revealed that extrinsic rewards do not provide enough motivating influences to public organization employees to focus on the suggestion that “public sector employees are more motivated by the intrinsic rewards associated with altruistic and service related opportunities but that these rewards reduce the importance of extrinsic rewards in public organizations” (Perry & Wise, 1990; cited in Wright, 2003, p. 20). A closer evaluation of related literatures indicate that employees from both private and public organizations, despite their serving significantly different organizational structure and type, value intrinsic rewards more than extrinsic incentives. To clarify, Vallerand (2004) distinguished intrinsic from extrinsic rewards by through the following definitions, to wit: “Intrinsic motivation refers to engaging in an activity for itself and for the pleasure and satisfaction derived from participation…When extrinsically motivate, individuals do not engage in the activity out of pleasure but rather do so to derive some kind of rewards that are external to the activity itself” (p. 429). Since intrinsic rewards were revealed to be more motivating for both private and public personnel and these information is easily determined and solicited from authoritative and academic sources, then, how come “despite the frequent review of workers' salaries and allowances over the years, it is amazing to learn that a good number of employees are getting dissatisfied with their jobs and work condition (Oshiomole, 1992; cited in Adeyemi, 2010, p. 1)? The response would hereby determine what factors or guidelines assist in effectively applying motivational techniques to achieve the purpose these programs are supposed to attain. Guidelines to Effective Motivational Programs After having identified that intrinsic rewards, which are outcomes that come from the performance of the work itself (such as satisfaction felt directly by an employee after a job well done and are mainly under the employee’s own control), are the main motivators for both private and public organizations’ personnel, the review of previous research has enabled one to gather and collate findings that would assist contemporary organizations in applying the most effective motivational schemes. According to Adeyemi (2010), “what really matters in boosting employee productivity or output is not the kind of motivation that is employed but the extent to which the employee is being truly motivated by any chosen method” (p. 1). This implies that a well-designed and innovative motivation program needs to consider the specific needs and drives of its subordinates to be truly effective. There are types and classification of workers, depending on their roles and responsibilities in the organization that need to be incorporated and evaluated in the incentive programs. Kalala (2009) has emphasized that “public administration employees can be motivated using different techniques other than financial-based rewards such as on-job challenges, provision of work autonomy as well as providing performance feedbacks to motivate professional workers. To effectively motivate low level workers, dependent workers, techniques such as pay increase, permanent employment status after certain time on the job and opportunities for professional development” (p. 1). The rationale for not focusing on financial-based rewards for public organization employees is that the compensation of these employees depend on the budget allocated by the government. Unlike in private organizations, financial rewards and bonuses could be effectively linked to exemplary performance, especially when the performance accords the organization with vast opportunities for financial gain. Further, as disclosed by Kalala (2009), “public officers find it difficult to use job promotions to reward workers due to bureaucracy and cronyism that is inherent in public organizations. Additionally, managers and supervisors in public administration positions find it difficult to financially reward best performers due to public ethics act and other existing legislations whose provisions restrict financial rewards” (p. 1). Managers in public organizations therefore resort to providing intrinsic rewards in the form of recognition, achieving a sense of fulfillment for a acknowledging work well done, and providing the employees with self-direction and the opportunity for self-management. In the study conducted by Thomas (2009), he identified four intrinsic rewards in contemporary workplace setting as: (1) sense of meaningfulness; (2) sense of choice; (3) sense of competence; and (4) sense of progress” (p. 1). A sense of meaningfulness is given due recognition as the employee identifies the value of the purpose being pursued. The sense of choice is considered a reward to employees where managers have established trust and confidence for delegating crucial tasks, as needed. A sense of competence is arrived at through experience and expertise in one’s line of work. Finally, a sense of progress is clearly measured through the identification of goals and the strategies employed to achieve them. Summary and Conclusion The comparative analysis of motivation in public and private organizations revealed no significant differences in terms of application of motivational programs as employees from both organizational types indicated preference for intrinsic over extrinsic rewards.The constraints and restricted ability of public organization managers to provide financial rewards justify the use of alternative non-monetary incentives to assist in enhancing job performance and satisfaction. As emphasized by Thomas (2009), “the intrinsic rewards seem to create a strong, win/win form of motivation for both an organization and its employees—and one which suits the times. This type of motivation is focused on the shared desire that employees’ work makes an effective contribution to meaningful purposes” (p. 1). The implication of this finding is that despite significant differences between public and private organizations, the underlying factors that drive and engage employees to work towards the achievement of organizational goals remain universal in nature. When pay and other monetary incentives have served the basic physiologigal and security needs of the workers, personnel look for more motivating factors that would satify higher order needs. As job responsibilities and tasks encourage more creativity and innovativeness from employees to accomplished defined objectives, both public and private managers recognize the need to design and implement motivational schemes that respond to the changing expectations and trends of current times. References Tawnd: , (Tawo, Arikpo, & Ojuah, n.d., p. 17), Dif12: , (Difference Between Public and Private Sectors, 2012, p. 1), Ade10: , (Adeyemi, 2010, p. 1), Wri03: , (Wright, 2003), Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Effective Motivational Techniques: Private versus Public Organizations Research Paper”, n.d.)
Effective Motivational Techniques: Private versus Public Organizations Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1440813-effective-motivational-techniques-in-the-workplace
(Effective Motivational Techniques: Private Versus Public Organizations Research Paper)
Effective Motivational Techniques: Private Versus Public Organizations Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/business/1440813-effective-motivational-techniques-in-the-workplace.
“Effective Motivational Techniques: Private Versus Public Organizations Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1440813-effective-motivational-techniques-in-the-workplace.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Effective Motivational Techniques: Private versus Public Organizations

The Function of HRM in Business Organizations

The veritable tomes which has been written on HRM testifies to its centrality in organisational life and its status as a determinant of organisational success, not to mention the capacity of corporations to successful attain their strategic objectives.... An organisation's human resource, and most definitely its management, plays an integral role in defining a company's potentials and its limitations....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

A Cross-Sectoral Investigation of Strategic Fit vs Flexibility

This dissertation takes a contrary position, arguing that even though there may exist structural differences between public and private sector organisations, the differences are not such as to prevent the successful implementation of private sector management strategies and paradigms in public sector organizations, as would allow for the adoption of Total Quality Management lending to the evolution of an effective and efficient human resource.... The current research "A Cross-Sectoral Investigation of Strategic Fit vs Flexibility" is primarily purposed to examine the management paradigms associated with either in an attempt to determine whether flexibility is transferring to the public sector....
74 Pages (18500 words) Dissertation

Virginia Department of Transportation

This research paper, Virginia Department of Transportation, highlights that Philip Shucet, the newly hired commissioner of Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) is currently assessing the organization's status in line with prolific public outcry.... To complicate matters, VDOT has no system of measuring the successful completion of important projects confirming public scrutiny.... This paper outlines that Shucet is determined to address VDOT's various dilemma to steer the organization into a productive team reversing the low public opinion generated by the past administration....
9 Pages (2250 words) Admission/Application Essay

Distributed Computer System

In addition, the centralized techniques are effectual in attaining the control over a business or corporation's information system.... (2006), in early years of the twenty first century there has been an huge increase in worldwide networking communications in the form of wireless as well as wired broadband connections to the internet such as customary general purpose computer systems,… However, the basic challenge is to use different communications arrangements to offer up to date services that fulfill user requirements reliably....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Extrinsic and Intrinsic Factors among Rank and File Employees in the Hospitality Industry

hellip; The group becomes more effective and successful when their goals are accomplished through employee motivation, satisfaction, and commitment which influence majority of organisational outcomes (Manolopoulos 2008).... To gain insight into the significance of human resources is to understand that such individuals and the company itself should be one and the same....
19 Pages (4750 words) Research Paper

Performance and Guanxi Effect on Job Security to Reduce Turnover Intention in Saudi Arabia

The research tries to show the relationship between Guanxi and turnover intentions of the workers in the Saudi Arabian private employment sector that has been controversial for a long time.... The psychological and physical surroundings where information will be gathered ought to be made private, ensure privacy and general physical solace.... This paper makes a conclusion that to attain the legitimacy of the data collected, the inquiries pollswill be inferred from data accumulated in the writing audit to guarantee they are right illustrative of what private associations thought about with respect to representative turnover....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Proposal

Managing Change in Public Sector

Public managers in organizations are often required to initiate major change or transformation in their agencies.... ublic managers in the organizations are often required to initiate major change or transformation in their agencies (Kee and Davis, 2006).... The author of the "Managing Change in public Sector" paper discusses the issues related to managing change in the public sector and its impact.... nbsp; Hence, today it has become an important task to manage the change in public sector....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

HR Services and Employee Satisfaction in the IT Qatari Industry

The quantitative research study “HR Services and Employee Satisfaction in the IT Qatari Industry” defines rapport between the quality of the provided HR services and employees' engagement due to testing of 100 co-workers from IT institution based in Doha in the State of Qatar....  … Globalization has produced radical changes in the world such that “knowledge and technology have become the dominant social forces shaping society”....
20 Pages (5000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us