StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Charges Against Socrates - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "The Charges Against Socrates" focuses on Socrates, one of the most prominent Greek philosophers of the Hellenistic Age. His powers of logical reasoning and the invention of the Socratic Method have left an enduring legacy on Western philosophy.  …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.4% of users find it useful
The Charges Against Socrates
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Charges Against Socrates"

Socrates is one of the most prominent Greek philosophers of the Hellenistic Age.  His powers of logical reasoning and the invention of the Socratic Method have left an enduring legacy on Western philosophy.  The ideas spawned by him were given further life and shape by his bright pupil Plato, who also documented much of what Socrates orated to his audience.    Although he was a prominent member of the Aristocratic class, his lack of deference to authority would ultimately lead to his tragic end.  In this tragedy lies heroism and moral fortitude.  Although deemed guilty by the then prevailing laws of Athens, he stands righteous in spirit.  Even when given the choice between a life in exile or immediate execution, he chose the latter as a matter of adhering to principle.  The following passages will elaborate on this assessment. 

Socrates was brought to trial by the democratic Athenian jury, which had scores to settle with prominent members of the previous regime.  Socrates’ association with the previous regime made him a target of persecution, irrespective of the veracity of the alleged charges.  He was accused of undermining religious and state authority and for also corrupting the minds of young Athenians.  But in reality, Socrates made no deliberate attempts to bring down the religious and state authorities.  Instead, he encouraged his students to adopt a critical approach to moral actions, also suggesting that the Athenian rulers themselves are not exempt from such scrutiny.  Even when sentenced to death by the Athenian court, Socrates did not try to evade his fate, but rather accepted it with equanimity.  Even though he is termed ‘guilty’ by the Athenian court, his rationale for accepting the verdict reveals the moral soundness of his decision, thus, in effect, vindicating his moral righteousness. (Vlastoc, 1991, p.114)

For example, “At 49c-d Socrates elaborates his leading premise to 'one should not wrong any person', adding to this 'not even if one has been wronged by him. At 49e5-7 he states a further premise 'one should do what one has agreed to do, provided that it is not wrong'. He then proposes that it follows from these premises that it would be wrong for him to escape (49e9-50a3)”. (Bostock, 1990, p.2)  By reasoning in this fashion, Socrates puts principles ahead of self-interest.  In this broad sense, he is really not guilty.

Moreover, his concern for law and order among Athenian civilians made him put the public interest ahead of his own.  For example, “if Socrates tries to escape, he will be attempting, for his part, to destroy the Laws, and (thereby) the whole city; for a city could not survive if the verdicts reached by the courts were set aside and rendered powerless by individuals. (50a8-b8).”  (Bostock, 1990, p.2)

Socrates reasons that one should do nothing wrong, further adding that his own life till that point was lived in accord with this premise.  Since disobeying Athenian laws would amount to doing wrong, he argues against his own bodily interest and surrenders to the court.  He thus accepts the death penalty imposed on him as a matter of righteous conduct and lawful behavior.  It is easy to extend this logic and come to the conclusion that Socrates thought that it would always be wrong for any citizen of Athens to disobey any law of the city.  But a detailed analysis of all of Socrates’ sayings shows that this is not the case.  Moreover, there is ambiguity and contradiction within the set of Athenian law that creates sufficient doubt about the ‘guilty’ verdict:

“The Laws say that if Socrates escapes he will have both failed to obey and failed to persuade (52a3-4). Now quite a natural way of taking this charge would be to suppose that it claims that Socrates has not obeyed the law against impiety and corrupting the young, and also has not persuaded the jury that he should not be condemned on this account. If that is the correct way of taking it,  then our proposed third interpretation must certainly be rejected, since Socrates evidently did try to persuade the jury that he should not be condemned. However, it may well be  that this 'natural' way of taking the remark is mistaken, for after all our personified Laws do admit that the verdict was incorrect, and so apparently they should concede that Socrates has obeyed the Law against impiety and corrupting the young.” (Bostock, 1990, p.3)

Hence, Socrates sacrificed his life as a way of standing by the principles he endorsed to others.  Despite his tragic death in this fashion, the event has acquired him martyr status among subsequent generations of intellectuals and philosophers. And despite the official ‘guilty’ verdict, he stands acquitted of moral wrongdoing in its true spirit.  Starting with Plato - his most illustrious disciple - intellectuals have taken inspiration and strength from Socrates' choice and have contributed to positive social change.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Plato Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1425032-plato
(Plato Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1425032-plato.
“Plato Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1425032-plato.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Charges Against Socrates

The Heights of Athenian Domination

This paper holds that The Charges Against Socrates did not have strength and that they were primarily a result of the ongoing political strife amongst the varied claimants who wanted to lose no opportunity in claiming positions of authority in the newly established democracy.... The defense for Socrates will be substantiated by repeatedly referring to Plato's Republic because there is considerable circumstantial evidence in this work to steer him clear of the charges of corrupting Athenian youth (p....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Euthyphro by Socrates Assignment

EUTHYPHRO Euthyphro by socrates Word Count: 1,000 I.... However, the most notable pieces of this extrapolation will be the following: how the concept of holiness emerges and why it's important; Euthyphro's three definitions and socrates's three refutations; socrates' goal, how one knows it, and the way one can tell; and finally, what this writer's personal definition of holiness entails, including an honest Socratic response.... It is hoped that in understanding these various details, we can most definitely learn more about how socrates had trained his mind....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Apologia of Socrates and the Defense Speech of Gorgias

The paper "Apologia of socrates and the Defense Speech of Gorgias" highlights that socrates' defense and Gorgias in the defense of Palamedes have fundamental differences in that their application of logic is different, as so is their levels of philosophical thought.... socrates' defense against his case before the Athenian council is based on the principle of his curiosity and the facts that he seeks to comprehend.... socrates' defense is not perfect, as it only addresses his accusers as a crowd and not as individuals who bring their arguments and cases against him but are rather guarded by the crowd....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Platos Apology

It should be noted that one of the charges on Socrates was that he was a busybody, a humbug who inquires about the earth and sky.... The paper 'Plato's Apology' looks at socrates statement about him fulfilling a divine mission, which can be understood in light of the Oracle of Delphi.... The author states that socrates also inquires the politicians, the poets, and craftsmen to see if they were truly wise.... socrates wanted to find out and to prove that an ignorant man could be the wisest one in town, thus the questionings of the politicians, poets, and craftsmen....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Crito and Socrates, Winston Churchill Leadership

According to an article written by Megan Worley three figures were specifically important in bringing The Charges Against Socrates, these were Anytus, Meletus, and Lycon.... Ans 1)Crito is a a good friend of socrates a powerful and rich citizen of Athens, his chief purpose in coming to visit socrates is to persuade him to escape.... He has to come to give socrates eyewitness that the ship whose coming signifies socrates doom will reach in a day and to....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Philosophy questions

In addition, he tells Socrates he should leave prison to Philosophy questions Philosophy questions Read Plato, "Apology What are The Charges Against Socrates?... Socrates says that his accuser should have done what before bringing charges against him?... He cross-examined Meletus and extracted a contradiction by making Meletus to say that socrates is an Atheist who believes in demigods and spiritual beings.... In this regard, socrates argues that he caught Meletus in contradiction and the court should deduce whether Meletus has....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Ancient and Medieval Political Theory

The Charges Against Socrates were raised from the general prejudices, which surrounded him over the years he taught philosophy which is simply an approach employed by politicians across the generations and time.... The rigidity to accept new concepts that could change the society is depicted in the general prejudices against socrates.... The dialogue Crito is written by socrates in prison after the unlawful detention.... Apology on the other hand deals with trying to explain the core mandate of socrates work....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Socrates as a Threat to the Athenian Democracy

the charges were pressed by Meletus, a voluntary prosecutor, and other democratic citizens in the city.... "socrates as a Threat to the Athenian Democracy" paper examines deeper insights as to how socrates was considered by the Athenian authorities as a threat to democracy in the city.... socrates went down in history as one of the wisest philosophers ever to exist in the world.... Even in the courtroom, socrates continued to express his discontent with the democratically set institutions, including the judicial system....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us