StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Instructions to Authors - Case Study Example

Summary
The paper "Instructions to Authors" analyzes that several journals publish their own ethical guidelines. Surprisingly, many journals say little or nothing in their “Instructions to Authors” about which types of data manipulations and data presentation conducts are acceptable and which are not…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Instructions to Authors
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Instructions to Authors"

Essay Case Studies of scientific misconduct Introduction To protect the integrity of research, the scientific community takes strong action against perceived scientific misconduct. In the current definition provided by the U.S. government: “Research misconduct is defined as fabrication, falsification, or plagiarism in proposing, performing, or reviewing research, or in reporting research results.” (The National Endowment for the Humanities, 2001). Several journals publish their own ethical guidelines (Coats, 2008). However, it is surprising that many journals say little or nothing in their “Instructions to Authors” about which types of data manipulations and data presentation conducts are acceptable and which are not. A particularly delicate issue is that of digital image manipulation. In the days before imaging software became so widely available, making adjustments to image data in the darkroom required considerable effort and/or expertise. It is now very simple, and thus tempting, to adjust or modify digital image files. Many such manipulations have been recently discussed and stigmatized in biology top journals (Rossner, 2004). For what concerns handling of scientific misconduct, several institutions have issued guidelines, even though determining appropriate sanctions is often very difficult and may vary in any specific case. As remarked in the NIH guidelines, sanctions imposed on a particular individual may have consequences that are much broader, i.e. members of the laboratory may be indirectly or directly affected as well. There should be a logical correspondence between the nature and severity of the proven allegations and the sanctions imposed. (NIH Committee on Scientific Conduct and Ethics, 2004). The sanctions may include, but are not limited to, the following: removal from a particular project; letter of reprimand to be included in the individuals NIH personnel file; special monitoring of work; decrease in laboratory support probation; suspension with or without pay; denial of a raise in salary or a salary/rank reduction; termination of employment (NIH Committee on Scientific Conduct and Ethics, 2004). Questions and answers CASE ONE a) Do you agree with the committee’s finding? Why or why not? I do agree, since the student behavior in case report clearly corresponds to the current definition(s) of scientific misconduct issued by several independent institutions and committees (see Introduction for such a definition). b) Dr. Potter was a co-author of the submitted manuscript. Should he also be found guilty of scientific misconduct? He should not be directly guilty of scientific misconduct. Nonetheless, he is likely the last author of the paper since he is the mentor of the student. Last authors, and corresponding authors, have several clearly stated responsibilities, such as controlling that the co-authors of their work are mentioned and agree to terms and conditions of publications etc. Last authors and corresponding authors have also implicit responsibilities, such as mentoring and controlling students behavior and skills. As a part of the education program underlying a laboratory experience, there is teaching scientific behavior. The latter consists of not only making experiments following the scientific method but it also includes ethical behavior, since science is based on the assumption that experiments are true and reliable. Dr. Potter will likely have severe consequences from his lack of attention; for instance, he will need to publish a corrigendum or to retreat his paper from the journal. This act negatively affects ones credibility with negative fallout on future publications. c) Should the university revoke George’s degree? Revoking a students degree is one of the sanctions hypothesized by several american universities in the case of scientific misconducts. For instance, Case western Reserve University, in his Graduate School guidelines on handling scientific misconducts states: “ In the event that a suspected violation of academic integrity standards is reported after graduation, the Dean for Graduate Studies will make a determination as to the feasibility of investigation and adjudication. Graduation will not preempt investigation or adjudication of a suspected violation when those processes are feasible. If a student is found responsible for a violation and the sanction imposed makes the student ineligible to earn her or his degree, the degree may be revoked.” (Case Western Reserve University, school of graduate studies, 2006) In this specific case a final answer is not possible in the absence of the detailed results by the faculty investigating committee. Only their report would allow to clearly assess the severity of the scientific misconduct. However, on the basis of the available data, I do not think that the degree should be revoked. The basis of this reasoning is the fact that the alteration of image(s) proofing part of the student’s scientific work was not compromising the whole course of the studies. A thesis comes following a whole period of higher education during which the candidate is evaluated by several exams; the thesis itself is a significant and complex period of time spent in the laboratory where the student learns in practice how to make research. It is unlikely that a specific set of data is essential to conceive and write a thesis. Therefore, the thesis and the previous career should maintain their validity. This being said, it is obvious that the student should be sanctioned in some way. CASE 2 a) Should these experiments be allowed to continue? The experiments should be subjected to a deep examination by the institutional IACUC (see below, part b). Its seems from the case description that not all the countermeasure to avoid stress and pain were undertaken (see below, part b). If that is the case, the experiments could continue under novel and more rigorous procedures for a limited period of time and then resubmitted to judgement by the IACUC for definitive stop or approval. b)What kind of arguments or considerations should be considered in reaching judgment on this question? Experiments on animal are regulated in the USA, specifically for what concerns the possibility of inducing pain (“Laboratory Animal Welfare Act”, 1966, P.L. 89-544). In the US, the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals defines in practice the parameters for animal testing regulations (“Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals”, ILAR, National Research Council, 1996 , pg 64). Pain and stress has to be avoided to an extent comparable to what one would do with humans. Therefore, analgesia and sedation must be used to avoid pain in all cases this would be not a negligible issue for humans. All this is particularly true because the animal used in the experiments are mammals, which are anatomically and physiologically similar to humans. In our case it seems clear that the animals are stressed and suffer. However, from the available data the countermeasures taken to avoid or diminish to a bearable level the negative effects of the experimentation are not clear. The whole case report appear to be rather inconsistent and thus difficult to judge. For instance, from the sentence “the rats become so aggressive that they literally tear each other apart in fits of rage” it seems that the rats are hosted in common cages. While sharing cages (withing certain limits) is the routine practice in all animal facilities, it is apparent that it is not reasonable in this specific case, where the animals should be individually hosted in separate cages to avoid fights – it seems unlikely from the text and the current knowledge of testosterone effects on hostility (Archer, 1991) that the animals are prone to attack themselves. c) Who should have the final say in this ethical decision the investigators, the university’s IACUC, the university’s dean, or the funding agency? The Institutional Animal Care and Use Committees (IACUCs) play a central role in regulating ethically sensitive research and in applying federal and state laws. For grant applications and sceintific publications involving animal experimentation, it is often mandatory to have and cite the approval by the local ICACUC. Therefore, the latter should have the final say on the issue. SOURCES Archer, Jhon. “The influence of testosterone on human aggression.” British Journal of Psychology, 82 (1991) 1-28. Print. Case Western Reserve University, school of graduate studies. “Academic Integrity Procedures and Rules.” (2006). Published online at http://sourcebook.od.nih.gov/resethicscases/sm-booklet.htm Coats, Andrew J.S. . “Ethical authorship and publishing.” International Journal of Cardiology, 131 (2009) 149–150. National Endowment for the Humanities “Research Misconduct Policy.” (2001). Published online at http://www.neh.gov/grants/guidelines/researchmisconduct.html. NIH Committee on Scientific Conduct and Ethics. “A Guide to the Handling of Scientific Misconduct Allegations in the Intramural Research Program at the NIH.” (2004). Published online at http://sourcebook.od.nih.gov/resethicscases/sm-booklet.htm Rossner, Mike; Yamada, Kenneth M. “What’s in a picture? The temptation of image manipulation.” The Journal of Cell Biology, 166 (2004) 11–15 . Print. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Instructions to Authors

Scientific misconduct

However, it is surprising that many journals say little or nothing in their “Instructions to Authors” about which types of data manipulations and data presentation conducts are acceptable and which are not.... Last authors, and corresponding authors, have several clearly stated responsibilities, such as controlling that the co-authors of their work are mentioned and agree to terms and conditions of publications etc.... Last authors and corresponding authors have also implicit responsibilities, such as mentoring and controlling students' behavior and skills....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Qualitative Study Evaluation

So this analysis explains that teachers use their prior knowledge like authors uses her prior knowledge of philosophy in mathematics and drama.... As author was a practicing teacher, the steps to gain assess to the site and students were not listed but would expected be the same steps which are necessary to make qualified in the required field of instructions....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Unpositives of the Dick and Carey Model

The authors tend to attain most of their ideas from Robert Gagne's conditions employed in learning.... The authors view a system as, in principle, a combination of parts that rely on each other to facilitate the intended goal.... Develop and select the materials that are applied in instruction delivery; the instructions materials include instructors' manuals, students' modules, and web pages for distance students.... Designing and conducting formative instruction evaluation enhances instructions....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

The study of curriculum and instruction

Baker's (2009) study focuses multimedia instructions to develop a pre-service skill of student observation among the teachers as the trainers have admitted that this skill is very challenging to be taught and Baker's study may help in this connection.... he curricula and teaching instructions that are required to meet the needs of diversified learners are being examined in the book written by Coyne et al....
13 Pages (3250 words) Annotated Bibliography

Structures for Adult English Language Learners

The authors research study investigates the impact of explicit grammar instruction on grammatical knowledge and writing proficiency in First-year students of French at a UK University.... The authors use a dual process approach by examining the interaction between explicit and implicit learning in skills learning.... The authors assert that implicit systems are robust during disasters and serious deficits of conscious such as cases of amnesia and blind sight since the cognitive processes are a function of evolutionary older and thus have greater resistance to conscious deficits than explicit processes....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Professional Rounds in Education

n this book, the three authors seek to explain how teachers from different levels, including district-level and school administrators, can apply certain frameworks so that they attain better expertise in their fields of work.... Additionally, the authors state that it is not these instructional rounds, which better the expertise of teachers, or raise student performance.... In a nutshell, these authors focus on how instructional rounds of education can be used in coming up with atmospheres which are collegial, thus offering environments in which the administrators and leaders can come up with effective strategies, implement, and share them amongst themselves....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Manuscript Submission Instructions to Authors

It is described as long-leaf stature of up to six feet in a ton of the early mixed bags.... Outside is a leg that which is encompassed by clears out.... The upper part is the critical piece of the plant in light of the fact that it has a.... ... ... Wheat is an aggregate of macronutrient sugars biggest rate of which constitute around 75%....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Professional Rounds in Education

This essay gives a review of books written by various authors in the field of instructional rounds.... The authors of this book drew their inspiration from the models used by physicists in developing this book.... This book will make you change your old methods of instructions and adopt them.... ee skillfully articulates hitches that educators in the field of instructional rounds undergo and relates his case studies well with principles of instructions providing this invaluable resource to educators. ...
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us