StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ethics and Corruption at News International - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper 'Ethics and Corruption at News International" focuses on the fact that between 2005-2007 investigations were conducted into News International, a subsidiary of News Corporation, into alleged phone hacking practices by tabloid papers falling under their auspices. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
Ethics and Corruption at News International
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ethics and Corruption at News International"

? Ethics and Corruption at News International Between 2005-2007 investigations were conducted into News International, a subsidiary of News Corporation, into alleged phone hacking practices by tabloid papers falling under their auspices. It was later determined that phones of prominent celebrities, the British Royal Family, and even the family of murdered schoolgirl Milly Dowler were tapped -- most prominently by subsidiary tabloid News of the World -- as a means of gaining information for stories. A number of high profile resignations and arrests occurred as a direct result. The News International phone-hacking scandal would become recognized both in the United Kingdom and the United States for its sensational and spy movie-like nature. More importantly, the scandal raised important issues about privacy, as well as institutional culture and style. In considering the scandal it’s clear that the practices demonstrated large-scale institutional corruption, yet the breach of ethics outside of regular social legitimacy may not be as dramatic as they seem on the surface. The most overarching concern in terms of corruption at News International is the organizational breaching of ethical conduct. In this context of understanding it’s clear that one of the major contributing factors was organizational leadership. Stakeholder theory is a major conceptual model that investigates notions of organizational leadership. Essentially, stakeholder theory is an approach to business ethics that attempts to investigate what really counts in organizations (Phillips, 2003). While there are varying models in this area of analysis, in terms of News International, one considers the failure of leadership to emphasize ethical responsibility and journalistic integrity. I believe that greatly contributing to the pivotal breakdown that lead to the organizational corruption is the very nature of the subject matter that was covered. Tied in with notions of journalism are notions of contributing to the public good. Indeed, journalism has popularly been referred to as the fourth estate, as it can function almost as another aspect of government (Smith 2011). Following organizational stakeholder theory, ethical responsibility of the fourth estate is such that the ‘why’ of the organization is directly in-line with publically accepted means of information gathering and dissemination. This can be contrasted with many of the News International publications, most notably News of the World, which eschewed traditional journalistic content for an investigation of gossip that can only marginally be argued to constitute news. I believe, following the stakeholder approach to organizational ethics, that in this shift away from operating as the fourth estate, News International also shifted away from any coupling with ethical approaches to information gathering. In these regards, it follows that intrinsic to the very nature of gossip based journalism are organizational propensities towards corruption. One considers then that in addition to banning these forms of information gathering the government should consider banning the forms of gossip reporting that News International produces. Although it is easy and appropriate to fault News International for gross ethical misconduct, I believe the more pressing considerations are those that consider organizational elements that allowed for such practices to occur. One of the most pervasive theoretical models that one considers in relation to the events at News International is institutional theory. Institutional theory is an approach to organizations that argues despite individual backgrounds, including education and ethical tendencies, the force of the institution is such that individuals will tend towards a uniform paradigm (Scott 2004). I believe that in great part the most staggering element of the News International scandal is that it wasn’t simply an isolated incident. In these regards, the phone hacking spanned a number of years and involved a wide array of individuals employed by the organization. Consider that the first allegations of phone hacking emerged as early as 2000 as the organization, under editors Rebekah Brooks and Andy Coulson, went before Parliamentary proceedings under accusations that they had wiretapped the family of murdered child Milly Dowler and paid police officers for information (Phone-hacking scandal: Timeline, 2012). The hacking scandal continued until as late as 2005 when the story finally broke following the publication of a piece in News of the World that used tapped-telephone information from Prince William’s assistants (Phone-hacking scandal: Timeline, 2012). The longevity of these occurrences – spanning half a decade and more than one editor – indicates that they were not simply isolated aspects of immoral employees, but interweaved into the organization’s very institutional structure. One considers that in large part the criticism Rupert Murdoch received following the scandal, although no evidence has surfaced that he had any knowledge of the actions, is appropriate as it was his responsibility to establish the tone that would form the institutional paradigm. In fact, Murdoch is said to have favored Rebekah Brooks and participated in a denial after the allegations surfaced. While undoubtedly it seems that the journalists involved knew they were committing unethical acts, I believe the individuals who set the organization tone -- such as Rupert Murdoch -- must take an equal amount of responsibility. While institutional theory accounts for the organizational acceptance of such phone hacking practices, it’s necessary to also consider broader sociological aspects when responding to this organizational corruption. Notably, Knetter (1989) has argued that while institutional forces shape intra-organizational behavioral patterns, these patterns are influenced by larger-environmental notions of legitimacy that are in-turn contingent on regional economic patterns. When this contextual framework is considered in terms of corruption at News International, it indicates that in part the very ability of the organization to function on such a large-scale was related to macro-elements in the United Kingdom. In these regards, I am certainly not absolving the journalists or institutional heads, but indicating that the fact such information could be used in ways that economically benefited the publications is at least in-part indicative of a public hungry for this information. It is no secret that the United Kingdom has strong thirst for gossip and a history of dubious methods of information retrieval; one considers the Princess Diana paparazzi incident as a tragic example. While the tactics used by the publications remained largely hidden, the public was all too ready to consume whatever tawdry details could be unearthed. Such practices speak to larger notions of organizational legitimacy, as the larger sociological environment is partially attributable to the organizational corruption. In this context of understanding I believe that after the legal sanctions that were implemented, society should consider redirect its outrage internally and question the extent and type of information they choose to digest. While the privacy intrusions breached by News International are undoubtedly deplorable, perhaps, the most surprising element is that everyday citizens readily pay, albeit indirectly, to have their personal information recorded and sold to the highest bidder. Silicon Valley graphic artist Michael Ridley has explored these very notions of privacy in his work. Perhaps most prominently, Ridley’s short film ‘Network’ considers the nature of multimedia messages (MMS) that individual’s send daily over Internet and telecommunications networks (Ridley, 2011). It’s estimated that each individual sends over 736 pieces of meta-data daily, all of which are recorded by service suppliers and constitutes the individual’s digital identity (Ridley, 2011). These ‘big data’ are then analyzed and sold to interested parties as a means of advertising and tailoring product designs to the user. When one considers such practices in terms of the New International phone hacking scandal, it’s clear there are a number of prominent similarities and differences. To a large degree, the phone hacking scandal implemented what can be considered more direct forms of privacy invasion through its intrusion on actual voiced telephony. Surprisingly, a strong degree of similarity exists between the two practices once one distinguishes between these forms of communicative intrusions. In this context of understanding, multimedia message service metadata constitutes everything from SMS to email messaging to Internet searches. It’s clear then that the intrusion of privacy becomes a social concern not when personal communication is intercepted, but when the intercepting party is no longer technologically mediated and the ‘data’ takes the privileged form of voice. One can even draw a parallel between the implementation of the information, as big data analytics and media sources such as News of the World are both interested in privacy intrusion, not as a means of social progress, but as a means of achieving economic gain. Of course, there remains the thought that such privacy intrusions contribute to the social good. There is the sense that Google is using my personal information to better tailor search results, just as phone hacking, or WikiLeaks is creating a more equitable social discourse. In one instance we are giving up our own freedom, where in the other it is a celebrity’s, or the family of an abducted girl’s, that is being intruded upon. While intrusions into our digital identity are more obscure and technologically mediated, in reality such practices are not as ethically far removed from the News International scandal as we care to realize. Indeed, in terms of scale organizations store up to four years of an individual’s digital life, staggering amounts more than the News International scandal entailed. In conclusion, this essay has constituted a reflection on the News International phone hacking scandal. In this context of understanding prominent organizational theories, including stakeholder, institutional, and legitimacy theory have been presented as a means of responding to concerns of ethics and corrupt within the news publication. It’s argued that to a great degree the issues that arose are a result of the type of news being covered as well as the institutional and macro-environment in which they took place. Still, there are elements of privacy that citizens regularly discard in their daily lives. Ultimately, it’s clear that to a degree we are all being watched and recorded and sometimes, as evidenced in the phone hacking legal convictions, society decides to bite back. References Barr, R. (2008). Princess Diana Killed By Reckless Driver And Paparazzi, Rules Jury. Available from: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/04/07/princes-diana-killed- by-r_n_95426.html [Accessed: Jan 12, 2012]. Knetter, M. (1989). Price Discrimination by U.S. and German Exports. American Economic Review, vol. 79. 1, pp.198-208. Levy, G. (2011). Rebekah Brooks, the schmoozer hated by Murdoch's wife and daughter. [Online]. Available from: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article- 2015257/Rebekah-Brooks-hated-Rupert-Murdochs-wife-Wendi-daughter- Elisabeth.html [Accessed: Jan 12, 2012]. Phone-hacking scandal: Timeline (2012). [Online]. Available from: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-14124020 [Accessed: Jan 12, 2012]. Phillips, R. (2003). Stakeholder Theory and Organizational Ethics. New York: Berrett- Koehler Publishers. Rigley, M. (2011). Nonomy. [Online]. Available from: http://www.nonomy.com / [Accessed: Jan 12, 2012]. Scott, W. (2004). Encyclopedia of Social Theory. California: Sage. Smith, S. (2011). The Fourth Estate. [Online]. Available from: http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-the-fourth-estate.htm [Accessed: Jan 12, 2012]. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Ethics and Corruption at News International Essay, n.d.)
Ethics and Corruption at News International Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/media/1441190-ethics-and-corruption-at-news-international
(Ethics and Corruption at News International Essay)
Ethics and Corruption at News International Essay. https://studentshare.org/media/1441190-ethics-and-corruption-at-news-international.
“Ethics and Corruption at News International Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/media/1441190-ethics-and-corruption-at-news-international.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethics and Corruption at News International

Ethics and Ethical Behavior

The "ethics and Ethical Behavior" paper discusses ethics and ethical behavior in police integrity and the impacts of these factors on the police force, the citizenry, and the justice system of a country.... Ethics can be described as notions that individuals harbor with regard to what is right or wrong… Corruption by police officers is mostly precipitated by a disregard for ethics and moral values as guiding principles in the dispensation of their duty....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Political Corruption in Bulgaria after 1989

It is the corruption at the political level that is most dangerous in the country.... To add oil to the fire, the Bulgarian government had to battle with uncontrolled corruption at all levels of administration.... This essay "Political corruption in Bulgaria after 1989" is about post-communist Bulgaria which strived hard to emerge as an economic power in Europe.... But the corruption, a chronic problem since the collapse of communism, underlines the destiny of the nation....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Philosophy Ethics: Ethical Relativism

I came across the moral corruption of some people belonging to the Middle East, where they secretly practice same sex relationships without displaying slightest tolerance for it publicly.... They criticize the western societies for practicing adultery and fornication at massive scale, and thus have completely ignored the moral values and ethics from their very life....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

News of the World

The news that shocked the world though is that in the mid-2011, it was announced that news international, the new owner of the tabloid will stop publishing News of the World.... “News of the World axed by news international”.... At the peak of its history in 1950, news of the World had eight million readers (Addley; Sparks & news of the World news of the World is one of the longest running national newspapers in the United Kingdom....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

How Did News International Violate Ethical Standard of the Society of Professional Journalists

This study "How Did news international Violate Ethical Standard of the Society of Professional Journalists?... hellip; Perhaps the recent controversy that rocked the News of the World and other tabloid newspapers published by news international in Britain is the greatest scandal in modern British media history.... nbsp; The Metropolitan Police also estimated that there may be 4,000 possible targets from the documents they seized from News of the World Today (BBC News 2011a)  Further investigation revealed that money was paid to police between £20,000 to £30,000 in exchange for information that news international would publish as confirmed by a former Scotland Yard chief  (Chapman 2011)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Ethics and Diversity in Policing

Various codes of ethics and conduct are employed by the Department of Justice in each state/ municipality in order to… Department of Justice 2000, p.... Among the rules including in the police codes of conduct there are certain that are quite difficult, either because of the conditions of work, such as those focusing on the behavior of police officers working within prisons, or because of the police sub-culture, such as those regulating the duties of police officers working in departments controlling police corruption....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Corruption and Integrity in Business

According to Transparency international, "corruption is operationally defined as the misuse of entrusted power for private gain" (Transparency international, n.... This paper "corruption and Integrity in Business" discusses corruption and integrity in business that is difficult because it is based on what someone perceives as "corrupt" versus how they perceive "integrity".... So, it is unclear as to what "standards" this writer should take to give meaning to corruption and integrity....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

National Security, Fight Against Terror And The Police Ethics

hellip; The significance of understanding the fundamental ethical standards, which can enable the country to inhibit the invasions of the international terrorism, have also been considered in the discussion of this report.... he international terrorism has long been witnessed as one of the major threats for the US citizens.... The continuous threats from the international terrorist groups have become a major and critical concerning factor, which provided drastic effects to the national economy....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us