StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Active and Passive Citizens in Society - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In this essay, the author demonstrates several problems in the movie Lions for Lambs. Also, the author describes why America's future is doomed if it will continue to avoid involvement in politics and public affairs. And discusses the issue of apathy in society…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Active and Passive Citizens in Society"

English 22 Nov Lions for Lambs Society has always had active and passive citizens or participants in its operations or regularprocedures. Active, vigilant citizens are usually more aware of their rights and are typically more acquainted with the way the government functions, and hence, are much more in sync with current political trends and issues. But what about those who are not as active or who have lesser interest in politics and public affairs? Being apathetic is synonymous to being selfish and less involved with the way society works, but there are just some individuals who prefer to be such, and it is an even more difficult feat to convince them to alter their beliefs. Despite the presence of many followers in political rallies conducted by popular political figures, there are more individuals – on the back end – who couldn’t care less, are less concerned and would just like to go on with their normal routine of getting on with their personal, family and work lives and not be bothered by other issues which are “not really their problem”. But what about the overall picture? Americas future is certainly doomed if it continues to avoid involvement in politics and public affairs, hence, it is recommended that more active participation should take place among its citizenry. This is exactly the subject that is brought forward in the movie Lions for Lambs, a 2007 movie directed by Robert Redford. From the movie’s title, you wouldn’t have the faintest idea what the movie is really about unless you get to see the film from beginning to end. Some argue that the film is preachy is more ways than one since it is a hackneyed topic (about war) and the discussions between Senator Jasper Irving (Tom Cruise) and the popular journalist Janine Roth (Meryl Streep), plus the dialogues between Professor Stephen Malley (Robert Redford) and his students Todd, Arian and Ernest seem to just go on and on in circles. Nevertheless, the film’s climax when Arian and Ernest stand up bravely to meet their end in enemy territory is the film’s saving grace, and is remarkably one of the film’s more unforgettable highlights. In spite of the film’s flaws, the issue of apathy in society is a significant concern which this movie raises and which actually requires urgent attention. In the face of the seemingly never-ending battle for supremacy in these Middle East territories, the US still continues to forge on with the arms race and assert its continuing existence in the region. The war issue has become an everyday fare with regards to the US-Middle East relations, and as such, the same issues are seen on almost all media, and it’s no wonder that the ordinary person would prefer to have a glimpse of peace in the world rather than the opposite. Notwithstanding this general yearning to have peace and harmony, it is not acceptable to be indifferent or apathetic for some varied and valid reasons: Public officials may be elected or appointed, but they owe it to their constituents to provide the service that is expected of them. After all, they get their wages from the taxpayer’s money. Too, involvement in politics and public issues is highly-expected from them since they are part and parcel of the public system. Furthermore, despite the public officials’ active “involvement” when it comes to current issues and in facing the press, they should also be more engaged in the welfare of those who are sent out to war. Just like the way Senator Irving was much concerned with the new tactic they were implementing in Afghanistan, there is also an expectation from him to also make great effort at securing the safety of the soldiers. Sadly, this was not shown in the film and from the way the character of the senator was portrayed by Tom Cruise. He seemed very complacent with the way things were going from his current standpoint – at the back of his desk in his office, comfortable, safe and content with his stature. If public officials would be less involved and less concerned with the citizens, then it would be highly-likely that they would have lesser adherents, more critics and this would spell the ultimate downfall of their political career. Lesser trust would also imply having lesser supporters. If the person were someone like Senator Irving who has more affiliation with his tactics than the soldiers, then it can also be anticipated that there would be lesser soldiers who would sign up and lesser recruits who would continue fighting for the government’s interests. Media personnel are customarily more aware and have more advanced knowledge of issues because it is a standard requirement of the trade. No media man would want to be labelled as ignorant especially when it comes to current trends and information, and of course, a background knowledge of related issues would also come in handy. Involvement in political and public affairs is made apparent in the way Janine Roth gave her reactions to the answers made by Senator Irving in the interview she conducted. “How do we know you’re going to make it right this time?”, “Yes, here we are now. And don’t you think it might be critical to examine how we got to this point?”, “We took Iraq? How did I miss that?” are just some of the sample provocative questions raised by Ms. Roth which any interviewee would somehow be challenged to answer in a more substantial way. It is fortunate that someone such as Roth exemplified someone who was morally upright by the way she declined from writing the article about her interview with the senator on the basis that it would merely be another propaganda, and not really mapping out the factual details of what was taking place in Afghanistan. It would have been easy for Roth to just fire away and write about the interview and make the article look like an exclusive story straight from a very popular senator. However, her social responsibility as a journalist took over her more practical side, hence, her real story didn’t come out, although it is not mentioned in the film how the news flash at the bottom of the TV screen on the movie’s last few scenes became possible. Then again, teachers/mentors are also commendable for being involved in social issues like the character portrayed by Robert Redford, Professor Stephen Malley. Having professors who not only teach academics but also about current problems/concerns are instrumental in giving enlightenment to their students not only about the issues, but also in seeing the potential in the students to grow into something more than how they perceive themselves. This allows the student to come out of his/her shell, express himself/herself better, and to “think out of the box” and aspire for something bigger. The connection to political and public affairs is that it enriches the minds of the students and he/she does not confine himself/herself to what can be seen physically, but that there is a bigger world out there of which he/she is also a part of. It broadens ones horizons, makes the student more aware and lets him/her realize that there is more to life than meets the eye. Without the aid of the professors/teachers, this more expansive outlook just wouldn’t be possible. Now, the previous argument is related to the students of Professor Malley – Todd, Arian and Ernest. Todd is the apathetic American student while Arian and Ernest are two of Malley’s students who because of poverty – not having enough money for graduate school – chose to enlist in the army after graduation. Arian and Ernest are deeply involved in the public issues because they have considerable knowledge about army troops, the Taliban, Bin Laden, etc. Somehow, Malley felt guilty for having talked his students into “putting themselves on the line in a meaningful way”, but Arian and Ernest could not be convinced otherwise, since they had it already planned out what they would do after becoming part of the army. “They believed the best way to change things in this country was to fight for it” is how Malley puts it. On the other end of the scale was Todd, who was the antithesis of both Arian and Ernest. Malley tried to convince Todd that he believed in him, had confidence in his capabilities and that he could be someone bigger if he really pushed himself to do it. This is seen in the confrontation scene where Malley asks Todd: “What made you like this? What changed you?”. The character of Todd represents how a great portion of the populace behaves as regards politics and public affairs these days, and which is basically the main target audience of this film. The dialogue which takes place between Malley and Todd is a deep kind of conversation where the professor made Todd realize that he wouldn’t be enjoying his freedom now if not for the involvement of political leaders and the soldiers willing to offer their services for the country over and above their own personal wants and desires. In the final analysis, the “lions” point to the characters of Arian and Ernest – brave soldiers until the end – mainly because they became sacrificial “lambs” for the betterment of the lives of people like Todd. Works Cited Lions for Lambs. Robert Redford. Perf. Tom Cruise, Meryl Streep, Robert Redford. MGM, 2007. Film. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Active and Passive Citizens in Society Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words, n.d.)
Active and Passive Citizens in Society Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/media/1573160-in-the-movie-lions-for-lambs-write-an-essay-of-argument-in-which-you-assert-your-position-on-americas-future-if-the-population-continues-to-avoid-involvement-in-politics-and-public-affairs
(Active and Passive Citizens in Society Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Active and Passive Citizens in Society Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/media/1573160-in-the-movie-lions-for-lambs-write-an-essay-of-argument-in-which-you-assert-your-position-on-americas-future-if-the-population-continues-to-avoid-involvement-in-politics-and-public-affairs.
“Active and Passive Citizens in Society Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/media/1573160-in-the-movie-lions-for-lambs-write-an-essay-of-argument-in-which-you-assert-your-position-on-americas-future-if-the-population-continues-to-avoid-involvement-in-politics-and-public-affairs.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Active and Passive Citizens in Society

Does the Internet Represent a More Democratic Medium of Information

Given the non-competitive nature of media markets, the assertion that the media in contemporary society “gives people what they want” is unconvincing, to the exception of one media-the internet.... With regard to structure, democratic media is essentially organized and overseen by ordinary citizens or their grassroots organizations; in terms of functions, democratic media, as a matter of priority, pursue serving the informational, cultural, and other communication needs of members of the public from which the media constitute or represent (Gaur 2006, p....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Nussbaums The New Religious Intolerance

University Nussbaum's The New Religious Intolerance A Paper Submitted to (Name of Professor) In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Course (Course) Nussbaum's The New Religious Intolerance Introduction The society is sometimes affected by vices such as inequality based on sex stereotypes, ethnic, originality, economic and social status.... Inequality degrades understanding in various societal aspects including interpersonal, of intra- and interactions among members of society and the established institutions....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review

The relation between domestic terrorism and armed forces in the U.S. in mid-90s

Various recent events, most particularly the bombing of the Federal Building in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma in April, 1995, and the racially motivated murders of two civilians by active-duty United States Army personnel in Fayetteville, North Carolina in December, 1995, have focused the attention and suspicion of both military and civilian authorities on the possibility that extremist and potentially terroristic elements have established themselves within the Armed Forces of our country....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Morality of Shared Responsibility

The issue is of critical and relevant importance in that it addresses the tension and conflicts that arise when responsibility is rightfully assumed for the plight of a group, individual responsibility is inappropriately diluted, and the public good goes down the slippery slope of a nanny society.... It is often characterized by individuals that are held blameless, while their problems are attributed to the government or the society they live in....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

The Effect of Web Supporting

Over the years, the monarchies have been overcome by the need for active and democratic governance.... Political change has been instigated through social media activism which is practiced by the when governments do not support the people or infringe on the rights of the citizens (Benioff).... he involvement of citizens on issues of democracy is evident in various governments.... citizens engage in politics in order to open opportunities that are deemed to be infringed by the government....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

No Smoking Legislation

There has been an evident change in terms of health as a result of the ban; cases related to both active and passive smoking drastically reduced.... Children are the most victims of passive smoking in society, hence, a ban in public smoking will be an initiative to safeguard children's and passive smoker's health.... hellip; As a result of the ban legislation, different premises or places are supposed to flaunt a no smoking display, to inform citizens that smoking is prohibited in that locality or the premises....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Impact That Web 2.0 Has on Political Participation

The main hypothesis here is that there is no correspondence between the political parties' websites that allow citizens and what the citizens expect.... adding value to political participation, the relevant websites are categorized into ones that are built and owned by political actors such as governments and parliament or the ones owned by citizens....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Active Citizenship and Development

It is an extremely essential concept for both the rejuvenation of civil society as well as for public governance.... It is an extremely essential concept for both the rejuvenation of civil society as well as for public governance.... At various levels, the initiatives taken range from implementation of training modules on this concept of active civic participation aimed at local agencies and civil society institutions.... A host of surveys, best practice exchanges, conferences, seminars and public awareness campaigns have aided the progress of citizens' participation at micro level....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us