StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Nursing Leadership in Healthcare Reform - Scholarship Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This scholarship essay "Nursing Leadership in Healthcare Reform" reviews the concept of nursing leadership in the context of healthcare reforms. It is felt that developing leadership among nurses is important since they play an important role in healthcare…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
Nursing Leadership in Healthcare Reform
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Nursing Leadership in Healthcare Reform"

? NURSING LEADERSHIP IN HEALTHCARE REFORM Introduction: The word reform, according to the Oxford Dictionary, means bringing about change in a set of practices or in an organization for improvement. It could mean reform or change in a particular area or department or a major one that could affect the system as a whole. Most management experts and practitioners agree on one thing – that reform or change is not an easy process in most instances, one of the major obstacles being resistance to change. Reforms, especially strong ones also need capable and efficient leadership to manage and implement the change process. These factors hold good whether the reform takes place in the public or private sector, and whether it takes place in a service or manufacturing industry/area. As can be seen from the above section, the change process requires leadership from all levels of the organization including physicians, top management, nursing staff, and other sections of service providers in the healthcare sector. This paper reviews the concept of nursing leadership in the context of healthcare reforms. It is felt that developing leadership among nurses is important since they play an important role in healthcare. It is these employees who have the closest association with patients and are responsible for implementing any reforms that are implemented for their (patient’s) benefit. In the process, the paper will review the concepts of leadership (in nursing) reform/ change management, and how it can be applied to the nursing sector. The area of study (through review of literature) will be the healthcare reforms in the United States. Leadership in the nursing industry – a brief review: The problem within an organization is to identify and develop leadership qualities among its employees at different levels. The problem with the nursing sector was that they are seen as submissive to the demands put forward by their hierarchical superiors and the demands of the patients (Ivanov & Blue, 2008, 19). With such behviours engrained into the profession, it would be a challenge to develop competent nurse leaders even in a status quo situation. It becomes more challenging when reforms are involved. Secondly, the nursing profession has been plagued by a command and control style according to Moss (2005, 80). In effect, an autocratic style of leadership is exhibited by nursing managers towards their subordinates. The author is of the opinion that this creates an atmosphere that is not conducive to development of leadership within the profession. What is required is a participative or transformational approach by the leader who is attuned to the sensitivities of their subordinates and patients. They should also be receptive to new ideas whether it is provided by superiors or subordinates. The advantage here is that subordinates will have a sense of fulfillment and will become willing participants in the reform process. More on leadership styles and its impact on the nursing leadership concept will be given in later sections of this paper. The third major challenge, especially in the United States is severe shortage of qualified nurses. According to some studies, a shortage of forty thousand to one million nurses will be experienced in the healthcare sector in the country by 2020. It can be said that these are the main challenges to developing effective nursing leadership. Healthcare reform in nursing: Nursing is all about caring and the profession should develop a humanistic approach with regard to patients, other staff members, the organization and the community (Marshall & Coughlin, 2011, 185). Healthcare reforms usually focus on streamlining the affordability of healthcare, insurance issues, and solving the problems associated with Medicare and Medicaid (through reduced government spending), these does not directly affect the nursing profession at the grassroots level. These are basically administrative, social, and financial issues and nursing professionals have to implement the statutes and guidelines that are brought about by healthcare associations and government. While these are important reforms that could be brought about in the US healthcare sector, those reforms that directly affects the nursing profession will only be discussed here. Marshall & Coughlin provides several guidelines for reform that is specific to providing basic healthcare. The 1st one is to develop a relationship (continuous if needed) with the patient. Unlike standardized manufacturing, health care should take into consideration specific physical, emotional and cultural factors into account. The US population is culturally and religiously diverse. For example, a Muslim patient should not be provided with medication (as far as possible) that is prohibited by their religion. Communication with the patient is extremely important so that he or she feels reassured regarding the care provided. Inter-staff communication and sharing of knowledge and information is essential. Safety and transparency of treatment should be ensured. Nurses should be trained to anticipate the needs of the patient. Communication among all levels of service providers (doctors, nurses, administrative staff etc) is essential. So nursing leadership should be equipped to implement these reforms as well as have the ability to nurture leadership talent among their subordinates. Leadership and nursing – a theoretical perspective: Nursing leaders should have the ability to “plan and manage both predictable and unpredictable changes” (Daly, Speedy & Jackson, 2007, 192). The three critical components required in this instance are basic leadership skills, effective communication, inter-personal skills, management of groups, and the ability to identify and solve problems. The ability to motivate others and to communicate the need for reform is also essential. A lot of change management theories and the specific steps on overcoming resistance to change have evolved over the years. Combined with an effective leadership style, reforms can be implemented effectively within the nursing healthcare sector. Several leadership styles that seem appropriate (and inappropriate) can be seen in the nursing sector. They include autocratic, transformational, transactional, situational, and participative approaches (Forman, 2011, 84). As can be seen from the above sections, nursing profession in general is dominated by an autocratic approach. Transformational leaders are usually charismatic and have the ability to inspire, challenge, enthuse and provide an environment of team spirit. Transactional leaders are more inclined towards anticipating and satisfying the materialistic needs of subordinates. There would be no dissatisfaction, but the elements that are seen in transformational leadership would be low or missing in this instance. This style is more suited to an environment where reform or change is not necessary. A participative approach, as the name suggests, involve subordinate input and participation. This would make them (subordinates) that their views are important in implement the reform process. As a result, they will be more enthusiastic in becoming a part of it. Situational leadership is a combination of the above styles. The leader will execute a particular style depending on the situation at hand. The nurse leader will be strict when the need arises, but will also use other styles in order to effectively implement the reform process. In modern day management practices, the situational leadership is seen as the most effective. Since nursing is a noble service oriented profession, the nursing leader can also exhibit qualities of servant leadership. In this approach, the leader only attempts to serve and does not expect any service (for the leader) from the subordinates. Reform/change management: Nursing leaders should be educated as to how reforms and resistance to change can be managed. Several theories about reform and change management have evolved over the years, prominent among them being the eight step process (Sare & Ogilvie, 2010, 217) developed by John Kotter. The first step is to create a sense of urgency with regard to reforms. The second step is to form a team or coalition. This could be an informal team without taking recourse to hierarchy. The team could include influential staff, whether they hold official positions or power or not. The third step is to create a vision for reform followed by effective communication of the same among subordinates. The fifth step involves empowering employees to implement the change process without bureaucratic or other hurdles coming in the way. The sixth step involves developing short term visions and targets. This is important since achievement of these short term targets will motivate subordinates to higher challenges and ultimately achieve the ultimate aim of the reform process. If possible, any individual who actively resists the change process should be removed from the system. The final step is to anchor the change or reform process. Recommendations and suggestions: Klainberg & Dirschel (2010,43) feels that the current qualification to obtain employment as a nurse only provides clinical training. For those aspiring for managerial and leadership positions should have a bachelor’s degree and a license from the state in which he or she is employed. But according to the authors, aspects like sociology, psychology, and management studies (which are components of leadership) are not adequately provided under such bachelor programs. There are high level doctoral degrees like Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) which do provide education is social and behavioral sciences. But these are primarily aimed at individuals who can obtain top management and even board positions in healthcare organizations. In effect, tailor made training that will help to develop leadership among the lower levels of the hierarchy, especially those involved in direct care with the patients is still lacking. Those holding doctoral degrees usually may not have direct contact with the day to day activities of healthcare and would be more involved in policy making and strategic planning. The DNP program has to some extent aims to correct the problem. According to a statement made by the American Nurses Association (ANA), their purpose of this doctoral degree is to “ensure that all patients have access to affordable healthcare benefits and services, and the ability of all health professions and organizations to innovate and improve quality of care” (Klainberg & Dirschel,2010,48). While this is commendable, there is no specific mention as to how leadership training can be implemented lower down the hierarchy. What could be done to rectify the problem is to develop leadership courses (probably diplomas in nursing leadership) to equip the lower level hierarchical staff to develop the required qualities. Another suggestion would be to utilize DNP qualified personnel to develop and provide training classes within an organization or region so that their skills and knowledge can be imparted. Another important aspect is to eliminate the submissive role along with autocratic management on the part of nursing managers and supervisors that is inherent in this profession. Instead of being autocratic, a participative, transformational, situational, and even a servant leadership approach is best recommended. It is felt that only then will a second rung of leadership will evolve. Such aspirants should be identified and trained to become future leaders especially among those working at the bottom of the healthcare hierarchy. With regard to reform management, nursing leaders can make use of several change management theories that have evolved over the years. The one recommended here is the eight step process developed by John Kotter. Conclusion: Reforms involve a change process aimed at improving organizational performance or a set of practices. The paper discussed healthcare reforms and leadership in the context of the nursing profession. Any reform process requires effective leadership and management of change. This is also true for the nursing profession. Challenges like autocratic leadership and submissive attitudes are obstacles in this regard. The reform process focused on patient care, team building, communication, and management of change. It can be concluded that leadership is an essential component of the reform process. Proper training at all levels of nursing practice especially at the lower levels of hierarchy is essential. A training program that involves theories of leadership and change management is seen essential in order to bring about the necessary healthcare reforms in the nursing profession. References Daly, J., Speedy, S. & Jackson, D (2007). Nursing leadership, Elsevier. Forman, H (2011). Nursing Leadership for Patient-centered Care, Springer. Ivanov, L.L. & Blue, C.L. (2008). Public health nursing: leadership, policy, & practice, Cengage Learning. Klainberg, M.B. & Dirschel, K.M. (2010).Today's nursing leader: managing, succeeding, excelling, Jones & Bartlett Learning Marshall, E. & Coughlin, J.F. ((2011). Transformational Leadership in Nursing, Springer. Moss, M.T. (2005). The emotionally intelligent nurse leader, Wiley. Sare, M.V. & Ogilvie, L (2010). Strategic planning for nurses: change management in health care, Jones & Bartlett Learning Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The value of nursing leadership to healthcare reform Scholarship Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1424914-the-value-of-nursing-leadership-to-healthcare
(The Value of Nursing Leadership to Healthcare Reform Scholarship Essay)
https://studentshare.org/other/1424914-the-value-of-nursing-leadership-to-healthcare.
“The Value of Nursing Leadership to Healthcare Reform Scholarship Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1424914-the-value-of-nursing-leadership-to-healthcare.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Nursing Leadership in Healthcare Reform

Positive Impact of Nursing Leadership

The paper "Positive Impact of nursing leadership" discusses that most of the general nursing communities are well aware of these findings because in this modern world most of the hospitals are mainly patient-oriented and they strive hard to provide the best service to the patients.... This paper will analyze the article, nursing leadership Style and Psychosocial Work Environment written by Terry Malloy and Barbara Penprase.... ne such research article would be, nursing leadership Style and Psychosocial Work Environment....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Clinical Practices

In this discussion, the significance, effectiveness as well as the applicability of nursing leadership on patient and staff outcomes in contemporary clinical practice contexts will be taken into concern.... The aspect of nursing leadership is defined as those activities which are usually performed by a nurse practitioner for enhancing the health as well as the safety of the individuals or the patients.... The significance, applicability as well as the effectiveness of nursing leadership on patient and staff outcomes in contemporary clinical practice context relates to the important fact that a ‘clinical nurse leader' plays an imperative part in enhancing the hea...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Leadership in The Healthcare Sector

It is expected from all members of the organization to a show commitment towards these codes with the conduct of a professional particularly in the field of healthcare management.... It can be stated that the purpose of the Professional Platform for Ethics and leadership is to initiate and facilitate a well-articulated foundation for leadership and ethics in practice. ... he major aspect of Ethics and leadership is its ethical codes....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Nursing and Healthcare

The paper "Nursing and healthcare" presents that trends in UK general healthcare and nursing reveal a shift towards 'whole systems' thinking.... As Scull notes, psychiatry dominance was linked to the profession's successful leadership and management in the advancement of claims to possess knowledge of lunacy as a disease with biophysical origins.... This development is driven by an explicit focus on improving both service efficiencies and how the needs of service users are met using effective nursing....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Leadership Theories In Nursing

In the field of healthcare particularly, situations are hardly set and fixed.... healthcare leaders deal with varied situations on a daily basis and must be prepared to deal with contingencies at all times.... This research paper describes various leadership theories in nursing field of study.... The researcher mostly focuses on the description of Situational leadership Theories, Style Theories and their comparison as well as different models of each theories....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Leadership Roles in Nursing

In addition, leadership in nursing entails innovation and visionary administration from junior to senior nurse officials.... Moreover, leadership in nursing tends to promote a good practice environment and safe health facilities (Rigolosi 2013).... nursing leadership, therefore, is about being competent and engage the practices of nurses to provide better care around the legal scope and boundaries of their ethics (Malloch 2013).... The author of the paper under the title "leadership Roles in Nursing " will begin with the statement that leadership integrates different thoughts and reflections in many contexts....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Contribution of Leadership to Quality Care

The author of the paper "Contribution of Leadership to Quality Care" tells how s\he was being appointed as a trainee in the healthcare center from where s\he gained practical experience regarding the leadership qualities possessed by the nursing professionals working in the healthcare center.... She was prominent and experienced in every aspect of decision-making that is required for providing good quality healthcare in the organization.... Therefore, a nurse should possess effective leadership skills as well as styles that would help in leading, controlling, organizing, and planning their activities, which would serve beneficial in delivering effective healthcare services to the patients (National Academy of Sciences, 2011; CNA, 2010)....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Nursing - Critically Reflective Account of a Leadership Issue Pertinent to Your Own Work Role

this research paper describes nursing and leadership as an important issue in healthcare organizations.... Rather, the leader of a healthcare organization should understand and identify with employees and tailor his or her approach accordingly.... ecent reforms have required healthcare organizations to implement new ways of operating and to redefine their purposes, the nature of their work and the relationships between employees.... he changing requirements and concerns of patients demand that healthcare is delivered in integrated care patterns spreading across some clinical disciplines....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us