StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Defence, Pride and Prejudice - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Socrates and Augustus were in their seventies at the time of Apology and Res Gestae respectively. Both had a desire to be remembered by posterity. Apology as well as Res Gestae were sort of public relations moves. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
Defence, Pride and Prejudice
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Defence, Pride and Prejudice"

Ramakrishna Surampudi 17 May Defence, Pride and Prejudice Socrates and Augustus were in their seventies at the time of Apology and Res Gestaerespectively. Both had a desire to be remembered by posterity. Apology as well as Res Gestae were sort of public relations moves. While the former readily deserves to be labeled propaganda, applying the same word for Apology may cause a bit of uneasiness especially because of the respect we have for Socrates and his wisdom. Nonetheless, it is no sin to see propaganda in Apology since its chief motive was to impress and influence the listeners.

As for objectivity, there is no way we can verify the claims made by Augustus in Res Gestae. But common sense tells us that some facts could have been suppressed or exaggerated. In the trial of Socrates, we believe it was motivated by spite and prejudice (of those to whom Socrates’ teachings caused embarrassment) and, therefore, our sympathies are with the great philosopher. Still, the fact remains that Apology is in first person narrative which means it is one-sided and so there is an equal possibility for lack of objectivity, though the degree may differ.

However, there is little scope for suppression of facts or exaggeration in Socrates’ statement because it is primarily based on reasoning unlike Res Gestae which is a self-satisfied account of ‘facts’ or things done. Res Gestae states that Augustus, after the civil wars, transferred the republic ‘from his power to the power of the senate and the people’. It sounds great to hear about a ruler who let the spirit of democracy flourish thousands of years ago. But history tells us that, contrary to modern day republics, the senate and the people, as such, were never allowed to be binding on the king and his decisions.

Res Gestae does not tell us that tribunes could veto laws passed by the senate and Augustus was ‘tribune-for-life’. It was therefore a masqueraded republic. The hypocrisy of the so-called ‘principate’ is evident in Augustus, in 27 B.C., being voted a large military command for a period of ten years and in the institution of ‘impeium maius’. Res Gestae informs us that Augustus was known for his ‘courage, clemency, justice and piety’. It is conveniently ignored that thousands of people were crucified during his reign.

Augustus claims having brought peace to Spain and Gaul by conquering them, but we know that this peace must have been preceded by a lot of bloodshed. Nor would have Augustus rid the sea of pirates without the use of violence. But it is too much to expect the second half of the fact to be recorded. He was proud of the gladiatorial shows and beast hunts that he had patronized. In what looks like an accomplishment, certainly, there should have been at least a few, even in those days, who saw the ugliness and the inhuman side of those activities.

Res Gestae lists achievements in which Augustus took great pride. The pride sometimes, as in the insertion of his name in the hymn of Salii seems to border on megalomania and narcissism. In Apology, what we see apparently is Socrates’ humility when he states that he knows nothing. But this statement was preceded by a mention of a prophecy by the oracle at Delphi that he was the wisest of all men. Thus, in a very subtle manner, Socrates implies that his interlocutors were more ignorant than he.

The flavor of Augustus’ self-assessment may be very different from that of Socrates, but a sense of pride was a common factor. Socrates’ assertion that he had no particular wisdom or special knowledge makes it hard to perceive the underlying pride. Strictly speaking, Augustus was admittedly a great ruler even without Res Gestae. It was less out of a need and more out of anxiety that his achievements might be surpassed by those of later rulers. For Socrates, the defence was a matter of life and death, though he was not very much worried about it.

It is an irony that a man like Socrates had to face charges of impiety and that his logical argument did not find favor with the judges. It is understandable that Socrates’ questioning further irritated the judges instead of persuading them. What stands out is that Socrates never seemed to make an attempt to come round to the viewpoint of the judges and to understand their apprehensions. His argument that no one does evil knowingly and willingly is difficult to buy. His analogy of horse-trainer also looks like begging the question, because grooming horses and training humans cannot be equated.

Hence, in spite of the rationality of his ideas, Socrates’ argument fails to beget the desired result because of the derogatory scorn that dominates his expression. Defence is a self-centered activity and it is bound to be clouded by prejudice. Neither an emperor nor a philosopher can be an exception to it.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Defence, Pride and Prejudice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1421735-defence-pride-and-prejudice
(Defence, Pride and Prejudice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1421735-defence-pride-and-prejudice.
“Defence, Pride and Prejudice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1421735-defence-pride-and-prejudice.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Defence, Pride and Prejudice

Masculinity in Pride and Prejudice and Great Expectations

Masculinity in pride and prejudice and Great Expectations Introduction In Dickens' Great Expectations, the masculine is treated in ways that are different from society at large.... This is a little of what the function of Elizabeth is in pride and prejudice, and represents a classless and governmentless “natural” society – where class doesn't matter, only the inner person does.... On the other hand, Darcy, in Austen's pride and prejudice, represents masculinity in that class does matter in society, which is a view that is more in keeping with governments and class structures, therefore is more representative of masculinity as a whole in society....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

English Arbitration Act 1996

The roots of the English arbitration acts have been in existence for centuries.... The first one was in 1698 followed by several acts that had organized and developed arbitration according to the requirements of each era.... hellip; The roots of the English arbitration acts have been in existence for centuries....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

The Struggle for Civil Liberties and Social Justice

Malcolm X's commitment to black pride and social justice had its origins in the racial harassment that he and his family had to bear with in his growing up years.... Gross generalizations about an entire race or group of people are the foundations on which stand the acts of social injustice and gross prejudice.... Racial and ethnic biases stand to be the most potent forms of prejudice....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

To Kill a Mockingbird: The Influences on Harper Lees Life

Written from 1955 to 1958 and published in July 11, 1960, To Kill a Mockingbird garnered a Piltzer Prize and stayed on top of the Bestseller list for 88 weeks in the same year (The Big Read 2008). Set in the 1930s in Maycomb, Alabama, and written in the point of view of a little girl named Scout Finch, To Kill a Mockingbird talks about life in the south and its struggles with racism, sterotype, discrimination, and prejudice.... Racial prejudice makes white men unreasonable in their judgement and ultimately deprives African-American men of the right to a just trial, and even a comfortable, worry-free life (Dorr 712)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Book Report/Review

Jane Austens Lessons on Dating and Marriage in Pride and Prejudice

The paper "Jane Austen's Lessons on Dating and Marriage in pride and prejudice" states that there are several elements of Austen's work, pride and prejudice, which can be seen through a modern-day scope, and some of the advice is good and still relevant.... This sets the scene for the attitudes and storylines of pride and prejudice.... This quote also emphasizes the very nature of matrimony in Pride & prejudice; that it is something that a man needs to complete his collection of good luck....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

The Perception of God in Both the Buddhist and Christian

The absence of any significant Condition and Religion interactions strongly suggests that religious priming increases prejudice toward certain out groups in Buddhists and Christians alike.... Religious primes were found to increase prejudice toward the perception of God in both the… This finding is important for two reasons.... First, these results suggest that members of religions with dissimilar value systems respond in the same way to priming of their Although some researchers have speculated that Buddhisms less proscribed teachings might engender greater tolerance, these results indicate that in group religious priming affects Christians and Buddhists in the same way, suggesting that defense of wider cultural values, rather than religious values per se, underpins religious prejudice....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Disgust as an Indicator for Threshold of Society for Intolerable Conduct

"Disgust as an Indicator for Threshold of Society For Intolerable Conduct" paper deals basically four dimensions of the issue such as the liberty of the individual to act as per his desire.... he reaction of society to what it considers disgusting, and the law in relation to the issue.... nbsp;… Firstly, the public at large must be allowed to decide what induces mild surprise and what excites their base passions such as disgust....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Recount the Catholic Churchs Responses to Nazi Anti-Semitism

For centuries, the Catholic Church has openly taught Anti-Jewish beliefs and attitudes that, although it did not advocate the persecution of Jews, it had unwittingly condoned the prejudice, the hatred, the degradation and, sometimes, the demonization of Jews (Valois).... he Catholic Church, however, contended that its prejudice against Jews involved “attitudinal anti-Judaism rather than doctrinal anti-Semitism” (Valois)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us