StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Compare and contrast skinner and moore's different views - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Skinner and Moore’s different views Concerning their views on determinism, below are elemental points that compare and contrast Skinner and Moore’s different perspectives. Skinner’s hard determinism According to Skinner, human behavior cannot be determined if we just only rely on internal psychological state, but things around us must be understood in a Scientific way, then we should learn to understand how things are and what exists…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Compare and contrast skinner and moores different views
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Compare and contrast skinner and moore's different views"

Download file to see previous pages

So experiment and observation, highly empirical they are, but would therefore make sense. It is only through doing these based on Skinner’s point that we could understand when a certain thing happens, another thing should follow. This means things we see now are results of something happen, so there must something happening before we see things as they are. This means further that an internal psychological state exists only then that we could exactly determine it, but based on Skinner’s claim we could be certain it certainly does exist.

Thus, Skinner is compelled to believe we have no free will, because there is “technology” of human behavior that controls us, and there are forces around us that cause us to create our choice or determine our behavior. Based on these, Skinner has two conflicting views: we have no control over our actions; we ought to behave in a certain way, which only implies we have choices to make, so at some point we are given the chance to control our actions. Determinism at this case seems to become incompatible with ethics, as Skinner believes forces around could either shape people as good or something else.

Moore’s soft determinism According to Moore’s point of view influenced by soft determinism, hard determinism of Skinner seems to be incompatible with ethics as it could be claimed people may not be held responsible for their actions. Moore believes that a person without free will has no moral obligations. So in Moore’s point of view, Skinner must be denying something intuitive. As Moore would want to point out, the word “could” only implies we really have choices to take. That is, an able person seeing somebody drowning could either save that person or not under certain circumstance.

For Moore it is morally right to save life, as this is what the moral society dictates. However, a person could also choose not to save someone else’s life and accept what the moral society will have to say as a result of such action. Here where Moore clearly wants to point out people have free will. Everyone “could” choose to do things, so we are left with choices. Analysis It is clear on the point of Skinner that external forces are the ones creating our choices. So Skinner is convinced there is no way we could have free will because forces around us have already predetermined our actions.

At this point, Moore’s claim that we have free will cannot be compatible with the idea that we could choose for ourselves choices to take as they are already predetermined. If Skinner’s point is right, much better than Moore’s, then the two of them might be arguing something that did not exist at all and significantly undetermined. We have therefore to note that Skinner and Moore are trying to believe in the premise that “everything always being caused,” which is the very idea of determinism.

This means everything we do is predetermined. Moore’s claim could therefore create a point if free will, based on Skinner’s point of view is something that exists and a strong influential force that could determine choices or actions of people. However, if free will is something that is also predetermined, then it could create certain actions, which according to Skinner must be predetermined as well. In this case, it is relevant and valid when Skinner would claim external forces

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Compare and contrast skinner and moore's different views Essay”, n.d.)
Compare and contrast skinner and moore's different views Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1457924-compare-and-contrast-skinner-and-moore-s-different
(Compare and Contrast Skinner and moore'S Different Views Essay)
Compare and Contrast Skinner and moore'S Different Views Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1457924-compare-and-contrast-skinner-and-moore-s-different.
“Compare and Contrast Skinner and moore'S Different Views Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1457924-compare-and-contrast-skinner-and-moore-s-different.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Compare and contrast skinner and moore's different views

Comparison of Freud and Skinner Theories

This paper will attempt to compare and contrast Freud and Skinner's approaches to understanding behavior.... Freud and skinner Abstract Psychologists who deal with personalities are often faced with several questions like what factors influence the changing patterns of behavior and what differentiates one individual with the other.... hellip; Both Freud and skinner attempted to provide explanations to all such questions, but their concepts and perceptions of human behavior had contrasting elements....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

The Concept of Operant Conditioning

skinner's operant conditioning Introduction B.... skinner, American psychologist who was also an author and an inventor, is regarded as one of the most eminent psychologist of the 20th century by many of his peers.... hellip; skinner came up with his theory of operant conditioning inspired by the work of Edward Thorndike, particularly Thorndike's work regarding the learning behavior of animals with the aid of the puzzle box and resultant theory of 'Law of Effect'....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Issues Faced by Purely Online Retail Fashion Companies in Marketing Their Products

Being an essential part of life of the modern society, business in the new XXI century faces enormous changes.... The Internet as a business, social, technological and information phenomenon has already become one of the core concept of life, and its significance for the future generations will grow....
61 Pages (15250 words) Coursework

Virtual Tour Technology

different kinds of visions have elevated the status of virtual environment to the level of pop iconography.... The paper “Virtual Tour Technology” will discuss numerous developments in virtual technologies in modern world that create for people more and more possibilities....
22 Pages (5500 words) Essay

Othello - Character Analysis

Everyone considered Iago as honest, and would be out of character for Othello to believe any different.... In Shakespeare's play Othello, the character of Othello has certain traits which portray him as naive and unsophisticated compared to many other people.... This is why Iago, the antagonist uses him as a scapegoat to get his rewards....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Ethics at the Top Two Auction Houses

At a glance, auctions of fine arts and other high-valued merchandize allow ordinary people to glimpse at the mystifying, ostentatious world of the rich.... Prized personal possessions such as rare fine arts, antique furniture, collectibles, memorabilia and other effects that only the 'rich and famous' typically can own are among the items being offered at auctions....
23 Pages (5750 words) Essay

Skinner and Behavior Analysis

The coursework "skinner and Behavior Analysis" describes the concept of personality.... But, still, another different focus in personality psychology concerns the connection of behaviors/thoughts/emotions which functions to build the dynamic appearance of personality in different situations (Haggbloom, 2002).... Skinner's personality theory (Skinner, 2011), personal variations in behavior are basically the outcome of various types of learning experiences met by different individuals....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Freud and Skinner's Approaches to Understanding Behavior

This paper will attempt to compare and contrast Freud and Skinner's approaches to understanding behavior.... nbsp;… Although both skinner and Freud focused their research work on human behavior and personality, their perspectives apparently seem to be wholly incompatible.... "Freud and skinner's Approaches to Understanding Behavior" paper states that While Freud stresses the unconscious mind and theorizes his concepts on its influence on the human behavioral patterns, skinner on the other hand emphasizes the environmental responses to human stimuli....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us