StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

John Lockes Possible View of Kantian Theory and Utilitarian Theory Evaluations - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay gives detailed information about John Locke’s view of the Kantian theory evaluation and Utilitarian theory evaluation would be based on the social contract theory that explains the relationship between the state of the people and associated obligations…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
John Lockes Possible View of Kantian Theory and Utilitarian Theory Evaluations
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "John Lockes Possible View of Kantian Theory and Utilitarian Theory Evaluations"

John Locke’s Possible View of Kantanian Theory and Utilitarian Theory Evaluations John Locke’s view of the Kantanian theory evaluation and Utilitarian theory evaluation would be based on the social contract theory that explains the relationship between the state of the people and associated obligations. One of the basis for the theorist’s evaluation is sovereign power that social contract offers to a governing authority over a group of people. This ensures regulation of people’s selfish interests towards personal ambitions in the society and therefore fosters law and order.

Assumed equality among all members of the society and the need for survival under resource constraint identifies conflict between, individuals and unchecked altruism would facilitate conflicts and chaos. This established basis of social contract to ensure peace and order. Kantanian theory identifies rules as a basis to ethics. Established rules define individual’s obligations and an ethical act is one that is consistent with stipulated duty. This identifies a center of power, real as a body that establishes rules or virtual through socially or traditionally created rules.

The Kantanian theory would demand compliance with established rules that govern patents and respect for rules that established the patenting authority and would justify Grace’s operations under the existing patent (Brooks and Dunn 182- 185; Waluchow 121- 124). Utilitarian theory however focuses on consequences of actions and justifies actions that offer net benefits to a majority of members of the society. The theory justifies an act when the act offers net benefits and to more people. Even though the case identifies development of a beneficial product, patenting the product protects one entity’s rights and prohibits other people from free benefits of the neem product as an insecticide.

It also limits use among individuals who could have been using the product in its crude form, under the patent’s physical jurisdiction and would therefore be unjustified under utilitarian ethics. John Locke would therefore support the Kantanian evaluation that justifies the rule-based ethics because of the corresponding respect of power in the Kantanian theory and Locke’s theory of social contract. The theorist would however undermine utilitarian theory’s evaluation because of its susceptibility to selfish interest, based on altruism, which only leads to chaos (Brooks and Dunn 182- 185; Waluchow 121- 124).

Theory that produces the most reasonable evaluation of the case and rationaleThe social contract theory offers the most reasonable evaluation of the case. Its correspondence with the scope of the case is the first reason for the theory’s suitability. The case identifies existence of a real center of power, the government that acts through the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office that is the basis of social contract theory. Formality of involved rules in the case, legal aspects, also establishes suitability of the contract theory as the best basis for analyzing the case because Kantanian theory and Utilitarian theory lack such legal aspects.

The contemporary scope of the case, occurring in formal political set ups with political power that binds citizens, unless and until the power is changed, also means that the social contract theory that develops and governs such powers is a suitable approach to analyzing the case (Brooks and Dunn 182- 185; Waluchow 121- 124). Works citedBrooks, Leonard, and Dunn, Paul. Business and professional ethics: For directors, executives & accountants. Mason, OH: Cengage Learning, 2009. Print. Waluchow, Wilfred.

The dimensions of ethics: An introduction to ethical theory. New York, NY: Broadview Press, 2003. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“John Lockes Possible View of Kantian Theory and Utilitarian Theory Essay”, n.d.)
John Lockes Possible View of Kantian Theory and Utilitarian Theory Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1623564-philosophy-short-essay
(John Lockes Possible View of Kantian Theory and Utilitarian Theory Essay)
John Lockes Possible View of Kantian Theory and Utilitarian Theory Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1623564-philosophy-short-essay.
“John Lockes Possible View of Kantian Theory and Utilitarian Theory Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1623564-philosophy-short-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF John Lockes Possible View of Kantian Theory and Utilitarian Theory Evaluations

Political Theory of Locke and Rousseau

Navage 4/9/2012 Political Theory of Locke and Rousseau Political Theory of Locke Locke is a philosopher, who was most recognized for his political theory and unparallel thinking on political and social arena .... Finally we could analyze that Locke being an advocate of “liberalism” and Rousseau being the pioneer of the “Age of Enlightenment” has contributed invaluably for the social upgrading of human rights and freedom in West So it can be well said that Locke and Rousseau are the cornerstone in political theory and age of enlightenment movement....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

John Locke and the Tacit Consent Theory

His theory of Tacit Consent has brought about a political controversy not only among the intellectuals of his day but also among contemporary philosophers like Rawls, Nozick and Simmons.... His theory of Tacit Consent, which supposes that a person tacitly and unconsciously consents to the laws of the place where he lives, has brought about a political controversy not only among the intellectuals of his day but also among contemporary philosophers like Rawls, Nozick and Simmons....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Critically Evaluating Locke's Two Provisos

This book report "Critically Evaluating Locke's Two Provisos" discusses traces of Locke's provisos, issues related to property rights and labor, and the relevance or application of Locke's theory for explaining the consequences of global warming.... Locke focused on how labor could add to the value of a thing and Locke developed a labor theory of the difference in value.... As Locke's theory could be relevant for intellectual property rights as well which indicates fair use policy, Locke's provisos are equally relevant as a moral philosophy that could control selfish exploration of the world's resources that is solely responsible for global warming....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

SOCIAL CONTRACT THEORY OF JOHN LOCKE

Social theory and Practice, 28(3), 361-381.... However, from the point of view of Kelly, it is pointed out "Although Locke characterizes marriage as a contract, it is a contract qualitatively different from the social contract that forms the basis of government.... SOCIAL CONTRACT theory OF JOHN LOCKE During the Enlightenment, several pre ical thinkers wrote articles and books that provided society with a new way of viewing criminal activity and laws....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Kantian Ethics

Moral theory was founded on the assumption that it is the consequences of human actions that count in evaluating their merit that the kind of consequences that matter for human happiness is just the achievement of pleasure and avoidance of pain.... … Kant is known for his theory that there is a single moral obligation, which is called the categorical imperative that is derived from the concept of duty.... Moral theory was founded on the assumption that it is the consequences of human actions that count in evaluating their merit that the kind of consequences that matter for human happiness is just the achievement of pleasure and avoidance of pain....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Analysis of Mills Utilitarian Theory

Of essence, Mill's utilitarian theory is out to bring systems into place that will allow the society function not only in a just manner, but also in the fairness that it deserves (71).... In the work compiled by Arthur, Mill argues that the utilitarianism theory is based on aptness of actions if they promote happiness in the individuals.... In the work compiled by Arthur, Mill argues that the utilitarianism theory is based on aptness of actions if they promote happiness in the individuals (67)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

John Lockes and Aristotles Understanding of Moral Life

On the other hand, while Locke's notion of virtue is similar to Aristotle's view of individual excellence, Locke's idea of political power is still narrow compared to Aristotle's.... “Mixed Modes” in john lockes Moral and Political Philosophy.... Similarities and differences between John Locke and Aristotle's understanding of moral life and model of governance While both thinkers focus on extralegal action, their intention is deepen mankind's understanding of the competing to political theory....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Patients Confidential Disclosures through the Lenses of Kantian Philosophy

The paper "Patients Confidential Disclosures through the Lenses of kantian Philosophy" explores moral dilemma of whether to do a certain thing or not.... hellip; The kantian ethics propounded by the German philosopher Immanuel Kant in the eighteenth century is one of them.... Another school of thought called the Utilitarianism was advocated by john Stuart Mill in the eighteenth century....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us