StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Summary for Criminal Justice class chapter 7 - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In “Chapter Seven: The Irony of State Intervention” of Criminological Theory: Context and Consequences, Lilly, Cullen, and Ball (2011) explored the theory of labeling. Labeling theory asserts that state intervention, especially in the form of labeling people as criminals and…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.7% of users find it useful
Summary for Criminal Justice class chapter 7
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Summary for Criminal Justice class chapter 7"

Summary of “Chapter Seven: The Irony of Intervention” In “Chapter Seven: The Irony of Intervention” of Criminological Theory: Context and Consequences, Lilly, Cullen, and Ball (2011) explored the theory of labeling. Labeling theory asserts that state intervention, especially in the form of labeling people as criminals and ex-convicts, only reinforces criminal attitudes and behaviors. It rejects the idea that criminality is inherent to some human beings. Furthermore, labeling theorists use the statistics of imprisoned minorities to describe racial disparity, which government intervention intensifies.

Labeling theory underscores that how society reacts to and categorizes criminal actions impact the occurrence of the crime. Lilly, Cullen, and Ball (2011) explained that because crime is socially constructed, society should be wary of how the state, the predominant labeling agent, shapes criminal justice systems, which in turn, influences criminality. Labeling theory emphasizes that the criminalization of human behavior cannot be seen as always truthful, valid, and accurate, because the state, which performs the labeling, do so out of evolving (and this indicates arbitrary) interests (i.e. labeling marijuana as bad during the 1930s, when accounts for its severe negative effects on human sanity were not fully proven).

Other social groups also participate in labeling crimes and criminals (i.e. work of middle-class women against juvenile delinquency without responding to the social roots of crime). Labeling theory believes that these groups and the state are forming different conceptions of reality that affect social reactions and answers to “criminal behavior.” Lilly, Cullen, and Ball (2011) provided a number of studies that proved how labeling affects people’s reactions, including the police. The work of Heusenstamm in 1975 showed that when the police see “Black Panther” stickers on automobiles, the more that they gave these drivers traffic violations tickets.

William Chambliss (1984) showed in his study that labeling one middle-class youth group as “Saints” and another working-class teenage group as “Roughnecks” resulted to opposing reactions from society. The community, school, and law enforcers reacted more positively to the “Saints” than the “Roughnecks,” although both have almost the same level of delinquency behaviors. Labeling theory argues that labeling is criminogenic, or it results to greater criminal behaviors. The origins of labeling theory come from other thinkers.

Jeremy Bentham believed that the prison does not promote virtues. Lombroso underscored that prisons breed criminal behaviors further. Bonger noted that imprisoning the youth turns them into professional criminals. Frank Tannenbaum provided the foundation of labeling theory, where imprisonment turns evil into a dramatic event that the youth eventually imbibes because of how society treats them after their imprisonment. Edwin Lemert formalized labeling theory when he discussed the two types of deviance: Primary and secondary deviance.

Primary deviance is the phase when offenders do not yet see themselves as deviant. Secondary deviance comes from absorbing deviance because of social labeling. Labeling theory further argues that labeling results to self-prophecy. Supporters of this theory do not claim that all criminals are innocent, but that social judgment further degrades their moral identities. Due to labeling, criminals are permanently branded as criminals who cannot and will not change. Some of the criticisms against labeling theory are: 1) it does not address the deeper roots of crime and 2) it only rides on the social issues of its time.

The 1960s was a period of pessimism against the government, which strongly motivated labeling theory scholars. Many citizens distrusted the government and its actions during this time. Other theories expanded labelling theory. John Braithwaite presented his theory of shaming and crime, where shaming stigmatizes and creates social outcasts. These outcasts easily become criminals, since society disregards their existence and removes social relations and resources that could have helped them remove criminal behaviors.

Sherman provided defiance theory, which argues that people show defiance to the court and/or police who disrespect or shame them. Rose and Clear’s Coerced Mobility Theory underscores that massive imprisonment of minorities increases crime rates within these groups. These labeling theories continue to argue that individuals have inner and external conditions that make them more vulnerable to criminality because of stigmatizing criminal labels and processes.ReferenceLilly, J.R., Cullen, F.T., & Ball, R.A. (2011).

Criminological theory: Context and consequences (5th ed.). SAGE. ISBN-13: 978-1-4129-8145-3.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Summary for Criminal Justice class chapter 7 Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1617430-summary-for-criminal-justice-class-chapter-7
(Summary for Criminal Justice Class Chapter 7 Essay)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1617430-summary-for-criminal-justice-class-chapter-7.
“Summary for Criminal Justice Class Chapter 7 Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1617430-summary-for-criminal-justice-class-chapter-7.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Summary for Criminal Justice class chapter 7

Competition Is Better than Cooperation

COMPETITION IS BETTER THAN COOPERATION IN THE RELATIONS BETWEEN criminal justice AGENCIES Name of Institution Date: Competition Is Better Than Cooperation in the Relations between criminal justice Agencies The criminal justice system has been defined as the set of processes and agencies that have been established by governments in order to control crime, as well as impose sanctions and penalties on individuals who have been found guilty of committing crime (Nash, 2010, p....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Legal Limits to Press Freedom

In fact, these citizen's rights are lumped together as primary concerns of the European Convention on Human Rights, which exhorts member states to adopt measures that would balance the right of the public to be informed and the right to privacy and to fair and unimpeded administration of justice (5).... A significant portion of the paper will illumine the outcomes of the relevant cases after they were brought to court as a tort or criminal complaint....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Implementing the Responsibility to Protect

This research explores the issues relating to sovereignty, as contained in The UN Secretary-General Report “Implementing the Responsibility to Protect”.... nbsp;… The conclusion from this study states that sovereignty of the state and international relations that it builds with other states is a very important consideration in evaluating the extent of economic development....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Chapter summary Criminal Justice class

Cesare de Beccaria used democratic liberal ideas and applied them to the field of criminal justice.... These early theories have affected the criminal justice policies and practices of their times.... Some of them, including their biases, continue to affect present people and criminal justice principles and behaviors.... Furthermore, Summary of “chapter 2” Summary of “chapter 2: The Search for the ‘Criminal Man'” “chapter 2” explores the early theories of crime,and it covers spiritualism, classical thinking, and positivism....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Summary for Criminal Justice class chapter 6

Lilly, Cullen, and Ball (2011) reviewed two of Travis Hirschi's theories, social bond theory and self-control theory in “chapter Six: The Complexity of Control” of the book Criminological Theory: Context and Consequences (2011).... Hirschi's social bond theory asserts that in the absence of social bonds or the Summary: chapter 6 of Criminological Theory Lilly, Cullen, and Ball reviewed two of Travis Hirschi's theories, social bond theory and self-control theory in “chapter Six: The Complexity of Control” of the book Criminological Theory: Context and Consequences (2011)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Philosophy Case Comment: Varieties of Liberalism

Recent trends in globalization have resulted in the development of international law, which is still a relatively new phenomenon, but its existence may be seen in the International Court of justice for the resolution of inter-state conflicts and the International Criminal Court3....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Criminal Law Discussions

This act of S would qualify as an Assault as well as a Battery, although the separate existence of these two offences has been confirmed by s-39 of the criminal justice Act 1988 which are both summary trial offences.... This coursework "criminal Law" requires a discussion of the Non-fatal offenses against the person in the context of the acts committed by Stan and Oliver while they were on their way back from a football match.... Allen, criminal Law....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

The Social Life of Smokes by Dwyer

Dwyer's work chapter 1: The social life of smokes: Processes of exchange in a heroin marketplace' in Fraser and Moore (eds), 2011.... Summary of the work by Dwyer (2011) chapter 1: The social life of smokes: Processes of exchange in a heroin marketplace' in Fraser and Moore (eds), 2011....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us