StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Can Values and Morality have Different Meanings - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Can values and morality have different meanings? It is not necessary that values and morality may travel in parallel directions always. John Steinbeck reminds people about this fact with the help of his famous novel Cannery Row published in 1945. This paper analyses the relationships between the characters Mack, Doc and Henry in the novel Cannery Row to prove that values and morality can often been travel in opposite directions…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
Can Values and Morality have Different Meanings
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Can Values and Morality have Different Meanings"

Download file to see previous pages

Even though Henri claimed to be French he was not so in reality. In other words, Henri is described as cunning character in this novel. Steinbeck tells us that Mack and the boys can be viewed as antisocial elements by a society; but in reality these antisocial elements also hold some positive elements. Society may consider them as "sons of bitches", but Steinbeck likes to labels them as "the Virtues, the Graces, and the Beauties of the hurried mangled craziness of Monterey" (Steinbeck p.18). Steinbeck tries to judge them based on what they truly are rather than what they do.

In his opinion, what they do cannot be taken as a measure to label them as antisocial elements since they are not doing any immoral activities intentionally. Steinbeck blames society for the making of Mack and the boys as antisocial elements. In his opinion, when people are deprived of freedom and virtue, they may engage in antisocial behaviors. Doc is portrayed as a loveable character in this novel. Even aggressive people like Mack and his company were very much attracted by the personal behaviors of Doc.

In the novel, Cannery Row, Mack and his friends are trying to do something nice to their loyal friend Doc, who actually demanded nothing from them. The intentions of Mack and his friends were positive; but the Thank you party organized by Mack and his allies ended up in a disaster because of their own fault. In other words, Mack and his friends tried to demonstrate the value of friendship; however, they failed to demonstrate in an ethical manner. Steinbeck reminds us that even successful people in this world may have both bad health and bad souls because they "tear themselves to pieces with ambition, nervousness, and covetousness"(Steinbeck, 133).

In his opinion, it is better to live naturally rather than artificially. In other words, keeping something in the mind and doing something exactly opposite to that cannot be labeled as a moral activity. Of course by doing so, a person can uphold the integrity of values publicly, but it should be remembered that he is doing something opposite to his instincts. For example, in our society we can see so many people who admire celebrities publicly and criticize them privately. Such activities cannot be labeled as moral activities even though it can be perceived as valuable activities.

According to Steinbeck, the essence of humanity is living naturally based on instincts. In that sense, Mack and the boys can be considered as successful men, since they tried to live naturally. “Henri loves boats, but he is afraid of the oceans"(Steinbeck, p.37). Steinbeck tries to ridicule the attitudes of the public through these words. A boat is intended to use in oceans. If it stays on land, it may become useless. The utility of the boat can be exploited only if it is used in water or ocean.

Steinbeck compares people who are living unnaturally to a boat staying on land. There are many people who try to live in accordance with the social norms even though their instincts are against it. For example, there are many people who like to have more than one wife at the same time. But the social norm is to have only one wife at a time. Even though, people like to have more than one wife, they forced to live with one wife alone. Such things are upholding social values, but it cannot be

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Can Values and Morality have Different Meanings Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1440946-john-steinbeck-cannery-row-the-relationship-of-mac
(Can Values and Morality Have Different Meanings Essay)
https://studentshare.org/english/1440946-john-steinbeck-cannery-row-the-relationship-of-mac.
“Can Values and Morality Have Different Meanings Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1440946-john-steinbeck-cannery-row-the-relationship-of-mac.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Can Values and Morality have Different Meanings

The accidental investment and Mans search for meaning compared

The author who was also in that business but later due to the lack of ethics and morality of the colleagues left explains how those bankers are self-centered thinking only about their future and not of those clients.... The ethics and morality by bankers in the investment business has simply evolved from being that based on truth and deep care for the client to that of making money and generating revenue regardless of how they will do it.... The theme of the first part of the book is about ethics and morality and how the guards in the concentration camp just like the bankers in the above book think about only themselves and hence step down harder on the rest of the people to achieve their goals and objectives at the end of the day....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Morality and Rights

Sometimes it looks as though there is no distinction between law and morality, because a moral person/society has to be good, law-abiding and ancient Greek writers vouch for that.... What was moral 2000 years ago need not be moral today1 because then individuality was powerless. 148908 Sometimes it looks as though there is no distinction between law and morality, because a moral person/society has to be good, law-abiding and ancient Greek writers vouch for that....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Nietzsche's Preface (no.7)

ecause they can have contradictory and different meanings in the course of their long life span, Nietzsche still does not believe that concepts are the fundamental stuff making up reality.... He instead looks beneath all the things in an attempt to confirm what seems to be driving the different meanings that these things adopt over time.... In contrast to such assumptions "good," "evil" or "bad," have had the same meanings as always, Nietzsches genealogical method illustrates how such terms have had to evolve while shattering any illusion for the continuity or the absolute truth for the present moral concept....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Necessity of Crime in Society

The evolution of law and morality due to crime is not towards a more objective truth.... Developing societies have crimes suited to their surroundings like property crimes, while developed societies experience more contemporary and advanced types of crime like embezzlement and identity theft.... Crime as deviance can be argued to have a functional and normative effect (Arrigo & Williams, 2012: p98).... From the relativist view, it is possible to contend that morality and law differ according to society, while modification of conditions may result in changes within the same society (Webber, 2010: p42)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Meaning of Life and Morality

The author of "The Meaning of Life and morality" paper looks at some of the most popular moral schemas and then describes his/her own view on this vast and important subject.... There are as many theories as there are grains of sand on the beach, but some ideas over the years have been more popular than others.... Still, others have no real faith and try to build a moral foundation out of their personal experience adding rules and content to it as the years go by....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Comparison Between Negotiation Style in China and USA

The application of Hofstede's four Dimensions of negotiation is helpful to have a deeper understanding of American style/way of negotiation.... The main components of Chinese Culture that influenced negotiation are agrarianism, hierarchy, morality, pictographic language and suspicion of foreigners.... The diversity in beliefs and values in American society is helpful to be dominant and aggressive in international negotiations.... For instance, the history of USA as a colony of the Europeans, its struggle for independence, the formation of the union of states, diversity in population etc helps it to be an amalgam of cultural characteristics that can be seen in other cultures....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

The Meaning of the Word Morality

Notably, within the common implication and application, many people usually have the tendency of defining and emphasizing certain parts of the word thereby emphasizing different things with very different meanings.... In most cases, the practical and observed agnostic or religious goals and values usually have different applications of the word and its related principles.... However, open-mindedness should note that morality has different implications and applications since the word can be used in different aspects of life to relent to different situations and meanings....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review

Ethics, Metaphysics, Pragmatism, and Their Individual Value

Meta-ethics examines the origin of human's ethical principles and their meanings.... nbsp;    In regards to values in ethics, morality comprises the actions, decisions, and opinions that people express what they regard as right or good.... Ethics consists of superlatively significant critical reflection on the values by which humans live.... hellip; Ethics is concerned with the study of theories regarding moral values, as well as the concepts used for their identification and assertion....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us