StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent crimes be Tried and Jailed as Adults - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Institution Course Instructor Date Does Adult Crime Translate to Adult Trial and Punishment? There has been a salient controversy surrounding juvenile justice. Young people below the legal adult age of 18 years have faced the consequences of crime when found guilty by the courts…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent crimes be Tried and Jailed as Adults
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent crimes be Tried and Jailed as Adults"

Download file to see previous pages

The cause of the dilemma was whether adolescents were to be tried in the existing adult courts and face punitive measures as applied to adult criminals. The issue of whether they would face trial in adult courts led to a critical question of whether they were 100% responsible for the crime they committed. Even when the assumption was that the adolescents were culpable of the crimes committed, an ardent concern would arise on whether they the competence required to handle the trial process. This paper will highlight that trying juvenile delinquents in adult courts is inappropriate.

The onset of the 20th century saw the emergence of the initial literature on the means of resolving juvenile crimes. The institution of juvenile courts would soon follow, a factor shaped by the assumption that adolescents were more likely to adopt new attitudes because of their assumed malleability in comparison to adults. Such assumed malleability evident in adolescents motivated the adoption of rehabilitation as the most effective strategy in juvenile courts. However, the approach of rehabilitation changed, getting more inclined to the punitive approach that was evident in the adult courts (Ash 146).

In the 1960s, the rehabilitative approach was classified as unsuccessful in addressing juvenile crime, and with most of the courts proving highly punitive to juvenile offenders. In the 1970s, increased prophecies of a potential surge of juvenile crimes emerged. This perception served to alter the approach towards juvenile justice. In the following years, many juvenile delinquents received transfer to adult crimes to undergo trial. Many people believed that the prophecies would come true, and that an increase in hardened juvenile criminals would require stringent punitive measures.

The perception that determined justice ideologies at that time were shaped by the thinking that adolescents who committed crimes needed to face similar consequences with adults committing similar offenses. However, contrary to the predictions, juvenile was only higher in the late 1980s and early 1990s, but subsided immensely in the years that followed. Although the predictions were falsified by the passage of time reduction of crime, they initiated the issue of adolescent culpability to crime, in the punitive system.

This issue had been neglected because juvenile courts had adopted a rehabilitative approach. In the punitive system, it was critical for prosecutors to prove that the adolescent had made an informed choice to commit crime (Ash 145). Many people believed that youths above 15 years are able to make informed choice cognitively. However, in cases where evidence indicating the incapacity of an adolescent to carry out mature judgment, then that translated to a minimized culpability. According to Ash, it is critical for courts to realize that adolescence is a period where an individual is subject to increased peer influence, a factor that makes many of them perpetrate group crime.

Evidently, this period of growth is defined by many mistakes in many individuals, before the young adolescents can discern individual goals and pursue them. Most of the adolescents only exhibit a crime record during this period of rigorous growth and confusion, but transform into responsible citizens after adolescence. Therefore, trying adolescents in adult courts and labeling them as hardened criminals was unfair, as this was an aspect limited to the adolescence stage, and they

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent crimes be Tried and Jailed as Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1493941-should-jouveniles-accused-of-violent-crimes-be
(Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent Crimes Be Tried and Jailed As Essay)
https://studentshare.org/english/1493941-should-jouveniles-accused-of-violent-crimes-be.
“Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent Crimes Be Tried and Jailed As Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1493941-should-jouveniles-accused-of-violent-crimes-be.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent crimes be Tried and Jailed as Adults

Corrections and Juvenile Justice

Unfortunately, these inclinations are destroying youth and forcing the courts to punish them as adults for their participation in crimes and maladaptive behaviors (Van Velsen, 2001; Griffin, 2005).... Unfortunately, due to neglect, demographic and pathological concerns, the number of adolescents present in juvenile detention institutions is almost equivalent to the number of young adults enrolled in college and technical preparatory schools (Puzzanchera & Sickmund, 2008)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Proposal

The Historical Development of the Juvenile Court

Statistics show that the facilities are likely to have a complex mixture of people with children who might have been accused of something to proven delinquents.... The main role of these courts was to rehabilitate and reform neglected children, children who committed offences not deemed appropriate for their age and who committed offences that would be considered crimes if carried out by adults.... In this case, the child was initially institutionalized for six years, the punishment for the similar offence for adults was a mere 50$ or a few months detention....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Criminal Justice System: The Root Causes of Criminal Behavior in the Society's Youth

Youths caught in the system are a portrayal of that which comes from parents and peers, or outside related or non-related other adults.... This paper takes a look at the root causes of criminal behavior in our society's youth and the legal policies that affect it.... It is noted in this work that the purpose of enacting legal policies is to deter crime and reduce the rates of recidivism that peter through the criminal justice system....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Federal Crime Prevention Programs in the United States

It is found that under-age binge drinking is more among teenagers below the age of 21 than adults.... nbsp;… It is really quite essential to state that criminals can be punished after they commit crimes, but it is better to prevent it from happening rather than punish them.... The rate of daily crimes shows that a person living in America cannot sure if he will live the next moment.... The gravity of the situation has forced the government to make maximum efforts in the direction of controlling crimes of all kinds in the country....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

The Effectiveness of the Juvenile Incarceration

13), he establishes that a program which is focused more on identifying youth offenders who are at risk of being repeat offenders should be implemented to the juveniles while they are incarcerated.... nbsp; There is a degree of detachment on the part of offenders when the rehabilitation programs work to manage and dictate on what these youth should or should not do....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Evolution of the Rights of Juveniles

Kent was accused of housebreakings and a couple of purse snatching cases.... Nevertheless, the juveniles do not still have the privilege to enjoy as many rights as the adults do.... nbsp;Juveniles across the world to make the mistake of committing some serious crimes and hence the world can witness a great number of such juveniles charged for their delinquency....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Should Minors Be Charged as Adults in Court

The author argues that all states in America should adopt the policy of charging young offenders or minors as adults, as it seems to be very effective in helping America stop crime.... nbsp;… Most of the time, people tend to argue that young offenders should not be charged as adults and consider it as a radical and traditional way of thinking.... It is due to this fact that there is an argument that they ought to be charged as adults in courts....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Delinquency in Military Teenagers

The stress often leads them to commit various kinds of non-violent crimes such as underage drinking etc.... This result in them going into stress and committing non-violent crimes.... These crimes are called delinquency.... Juveniles who have been enlisted in the military can additionally be influenced by serious anxiety and that can come about into crimes being carried out by them.... If the child does not get a proper parenting, then they can start disrespecting them and later on become violent....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us