StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Investigation of Two Pieces of Evidence of the Climate Conditions - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper 'Investigation of Two Pieces of Evidence of the Climate Conditions' tells us that through changes in climatic conditions, the process of deglaciation occurs. The ice melts into the oceans, forming certain geological features, which are distinctive enough to attract divergent debate on their formation…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.5% of users find it useful
Investigation of Two Pieces of Evidence of the Climate Conditions
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Investigation of Two Pieces of Evidence of the Climate Conditions"

? Investigation of 2 Evidences of the Climate Conditions of the Last Deglaciation of Learning Introduction Through changes in climatic conditions, the process of deglaciation occurs. Under such process, the ice melts and drains into the oceans, forming certain geological features, which are distinctive enough to attract divergent debate on their formation (Anderson & Anderson, 2010). In fact, most geologists could not explain the unique and mysteriously shaped landform. Their formation is believed to have lasted for many yeas, possibly millions. As the huge ice sheets moved and curved the landscape, it left the sides of the mountains hanging, making many people to believe that the features in that region resulted from glaciations (Baker, 2001). Therefore, the paper presents an investigation of evidences and uses them to make inferences about the impacts of the last deglaciation away from the margin of the ice sheets, especially the formation of Scablands. Arguments from the Documentary In the documentary, the author attributes their formation to gradual soil erosion through the actions of rivers (NOVA, 2005). It is also assumed that it was formed by the action of glaciers during the ice age. Under the assumption, enormous sheets of gradual-moving ice that originated from Canada curved new landscape as it moved down-hill (NOVA, 2005). According to Harlen Bretz’s theory that reflected the scientific convention, Channeled Scablands resulted from an overnight enormous catastrophe, which is more Bible-inspired, but not gradual geological evolution, which is more scientific, oriented (Anderson & Anderson, 2010). He seemed to be discrediting the geological or scientific beliefs that the formation of such landscape might have resulted from a gradual process that would last for a long time. The Use of Scientific Evidence to Reconstruct Conditions of the Last Deglaciation According to Edmiston, Scablands are some of the prehistoric features (Edmiston, 2005). He argues that Pardee was among the early geologists to offer explanation regarding the formation of Scablands (Edmiston, 2005). He was of the opinion that the features might have resulted from the actions of ice-age glaciers. Particularly, glacial erosion could be responsible for the formation of such features (Soennichsen, 2008). In fact, he argued that normal erosion could not explain the formation of Scablands. He categorically explained that the deep gorge, large portholes resembling small lakes and sharp hanging dry falls are scientific evidences of glacial erosion (Bretz, Smith & Neff, 2006). Another scientific evidence to reconstruct Bretz’s theory was the enormous discharge from glacial lakes such as Missoula could yield such great volume of water, which might be responsible for the formation of channeled Scablands (Geological Survey, 2010). Later, scientists, through the analysis and application of hydrological principles, discovered that open-channel hydraulics was consistent with Bretz’s qualitative observations. Therefore, Bretz got support from the scientific evidence (Bretz, 2003). The other scientific evidence was the Columbia gorge that the scientists believed had significant discharge attributable to channeled Scablands (Summerfield, 2001). Yet, in different and convincing evidence, the geologists found another large lake believed to have been formed from glacial activities (Young & Stearley, 2008). The lake is situated in the West of Montana. Evidently, it empties catastrophically due to glacial actions (Burr, Carling & Baker, 2009). Subsequently, its waters spill over into the Scablands through the channels. The Relevance of Scientific Studies Due to the nature of the Channeled Scablands, thus being deep and containing many other physical features (Young & Stearley, 2008). Therefore, the gradualist explanation offered better account of the events, which might have led to the formation of the feature (Furtwangler, 1999). The Violent and rapid assumption theory of Bretz could not have scientific evidence and justification, thereby prompting more scientific investigation (Bretz, 2003). Indeed, the catastrophic explanation cannot be replicable, while the gradual process could be replicated. The implication is that the catastrophic explanation is based on the Biblical teaching that relies on supernatural forces without proper evidence (Young & Stearley, 2008). Geologists would therefore, disapprove such claims on the basis of no evidence and lack of replicable and convincing evidence. In essence, gradualism would offer meaningful explanation to the formation of such features and add meaning to the glacial perception of Bretz (Tate, 2007). In fact, Mansfield’s argument could have some scientific evidence. For example, in the work of C. Tate, he points out Mansfield’s argument that, as a result of persistent pounding and subsequent flooding of glacial waters, there was similar consistency in shaping the landscape as the water channeled its direction to form the Scablands (Tate, 2007). This, he postulated, might have taken a longer period and could not be abrupt as Bretz thought of it (Tate, 2007). Therefore, the general scientific evidence of protracted glacial erosion is believed to be behind the features. To add strength to the scientific findings, Meinzer agreed that the features in the area are bizarre and so large that someone examining them for the first time would role out the possibility of an instantaneous phenomenon (Burr, Carling & Baker, 2009). Precisely, the scientific evidence could be relevance because as a result of climatic changes, the ice sheets could melt to form a large amount of glacial water that might cause significant erosion. However, for the explanation to be considered true, the proponents have to give substantial evidence that the assumed climatic changes occurred in the region and actually caused the giant floods. The gorging of landscape due to the availability of large volume of water might have occurred systematically and over a period. Indeed, that would give it relevance in explaining the formation of Channeled Scablands, because even climatic changes are gradual and have slow impacts on the environment (Allen, Marjorie & Sargent, 1996). The hanging valleys are a good evidence of a gradual process. Apparently, a rapid force might have scrapped the hanging valleys and possibly flattened them. Empirically, a process is slow, but steady meaning that the features are formed from cumulative effects of the process (Weis & Newman, 1999). Furthermore, the cumulative effects adhere to the laws of uniformity. Actually, this makes scientific evidence more explicit than the theoretical assumption of the occurrence, because the results are channeled in a uniform shape (Dawson, 2008). More scientific explanations to the formation of channeled Scablands have been put forward by geologists, trying to oppose Bretz theory (Roth, 2008). For example, geologists attribute the formation of Scablands to continental drifts, using the plate tectonic theory. Perhaps, this could be more convincing because the drifts could actually lead to the high hanging valleys (Slaymaker & Kelly, 2007). Sometimes, it could be related to catastrophic explanations since the drift might occur in an instant, not the flooding conception. Problems/Difficulties/Potential Pitfalls in Using Such Evidence The assumption that the rivers resulted to the formation of such features had some potential pitfalls. First, it is difficult to associate mere river erosion with large potholes, which are found in Scablands (Edmiston, 2005). There was a problem in the assumption of glacier activities. According to documentary, the ice sheets purported to have moved down hill from Canada, during the most recent ice age, did not actually reach the area called Scablands. In addition, they could not be responsible for the hanging valleys (Isaak, 2007). The reason for this argument is that in places, which have experienced the action of moving ice sheets, their rapid and erosive nature could have washed the hanging valleys. Perhaps, other natural occurrences with slow, but consistent erosive impact would have played a role in the formation of such landscape (Tate, 2007). Despite the fact that certain features could only exist through catastrophe, catastrophic situations are not very common (Allen, Marjorie & Sargent, 1996). Therefore, such explanations inclined to catastrophe might not be scientifically accepted in explaining the formation of some mysterious physical features such as Scablands. Also, the stream of water could have lasted for long, however, Edmiston argued the violent nature of such activity was evidence that the process did not last for a long time (Edmiston, 2005). Apparently, this complicated the matter. Bretz’s theory of sudden giant floods, which led to the formation of Scablands, attracted a lot of controversial argument, because he could not explain its source and the reasons for its abrupt flow (Bretz, 2005). In addition, the development of the channels within a limited time cannot be rationalized, owing to the nature and shapes of the Channeled Scablands (Eic & Busacca, 2002). Conclusion In summary, the formation of Channeled Scablands is an issue that is controversial in nature, owing to the explanations from two different perspectives. For example, there are theoretical explanations, which are Biblically inspired and geological explanations, which have scientific base. The two modes of explanations do not agree on a universal explanation, nevertheless the geological seems to develop their explanations from the theoretical perspectives. The position that Harlen Bretz took in his explanation of the matter could have been the one that triggered the works of geologists and other explorers to offer better explanation for the physical features found in that region. In the documentary, the formation of Scablands is attributed to gradual soil erosion through the actions of rivers. It is also assumed that it was formed by the action of glaciers during the ice age. It is also assumed that large sheets of gradual-moving ice that originated from Canada curved new landscape to form the unique features. However, scientists have refuted the actions of rivers, arguing that mere river erosion could not be associated with large potholes. Generally, the gradualist explanation offered better account of the events, which might have led to the formation of the features. Therefore, the process leading to the formation of the Channeled Scablands might have taken more time than anticipated and the theorists who claim rapid occurrences missed the point. References Anderson, R. S. & Anderson, S. P. (2010). Geomorphology: The Mechanics and Chemistry of Landscapes . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Allen, J. E., Marjorie, B. & Sargent, S. C. (1996) Cataclysms on the Columbia. Portland, Oregon: Timber Press. Baker, V. R. (2001). Catastrophic Flooding: The Origin of the Channeled Scabland. Benchmark Papers in Geology. Vol. 55. Bretz, J. H. (2003). "The Channeled Scabland of the Columbia Plateau." Journal of Geology, Vol.31, p.617-649. Bretz, J. H. (2005). "The Spokane flood beyond the Channeled Scablands." Journal of Geology, Vol.33, p.97-115, 236-259. Bretz, J. H., Smith, H.T. & Neff, G.E. (2006) "Channeled Scabland of Washington — New Data and Interpretations." Geological Society of America Bulletin, v.67, p.957-1049. Burr, D. M., Carling, P. A. & Baker, V. R. (2009). Megaflooding on Earth and Mars. Cambridge University Press. Dawson, A. G. (2008). Ice Age Earth: Late Quaternary Geology and Climate. London: Routledge. Edmiston, R. (2005). The Joy of High Tech: Science is a Process. Retrieved from Eic, V. & Busacca, A. J. (2002). Late Quaternary Stratigraphy of Loess in the Channeled Scabland and Palouse Regions of Washington State. Furtwangler, A. (1999). Acts of Discovery: Visions of America in the Lewis and Clark Journals. Chicago: University of Illinois Press. Geological Survey (U.S.) (2010). The Channeled Scablands of Eastern Washington: The Geologic Story of the Spokane Flood. Isaak, M. (2007).The Counter-Creationism Handbook. New York: University of California Press. NOVA. (2005). Mystery of the World. [Documentary]. Retrieved from Roth, A. A. (2008). Science Discovers God: Seven Convincing Lines of Evidence for His Existence. New York: Autumn House Publishing. Slaymaker, O. & Kelly, R. (2007). The Cryosphere and Global Environmental Change. New York: Wiley-Blackwell. Soennichsen, J. (2008). Bretz's Flood: The Remarkable Story of a Rebel Geologist and the World's Greatest Flood. Washington: Sasquatch Books. Summerfield, M. A. (2001). Global Geomorphology. New York: Prentice Hall. Tate, C. (2007). Bretz, J Harlen (1882-1981), Geologist. Retrieved from Weis, P. & Newman, W. L. (1999). “The Channeled Scablands of Eastern Washington”: The Geologic Story of the Spokane Flood. Young, D. A. & Stearley, R. (2008). The Bible, Rocks and Time: Geological Evidence for the Age of the Earth New York: IVP Academic. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Investigation of 2 evidences of the climate conditions of the last Research Paper”, n.d.)
Investigation of 2 evidences of the climate conditions of the last Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1438401-investigation-of
(Investigation of 2 Evidences of the Climate Conditions of the Last Research Paper)
Investigation of 2 Evidences of the Climate Conditions of the Last Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1438401-investigation-of.
“Investigation of 2 Evidences of the Climate Conditions of the Last Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1438401-investigation-of.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Investigation of Two Pieces of Evidence of the Climate Conditions

Ground invetigation in South Florida and Hong Kong

The paper outlines a comparison of ground investigations on the two countries Hong Kong and the South Florida state in USA.... This research is the best example of comparison between the two processes of ground investigations in the two countries Hong Kong and the South Florida state in USA.... In the process of ground investigation, sampling is an essential part; it involves using sampling, random and sparse techniques to obtain sound samples for testing....
47 Pages (11750 words) Dissertation

Diseases in Grapevines that are Prevalent in Colder Climates

However, these diseases are prevalent elsewhere also where the climate tends to be damp and extremely cold during winters.... hellip; Grapevines are highly sensitive to climatic conditions and some varieties are especially prone to higher risks of diseases in colder climates.... Some are more susceptible than others and it appears sensible to attempt and plant those which have better resistance to diseases and climatic conditions.... Botrytis and Mildews are two of the major diseases that affect grapevine cultivation in the UK, especially in Sussex and Kent, due to cold and moist conditions....
32 Pages (8000 words) Dissertation

Psychology in Relation to Crime

The evidence of a dead body that is half-naked reveals high chances of the occurrence of rape.... This was an attempt to prevent recovery of evidence by any person searching for her.... The various pieces of vests can be explained in two ways.... There are a number of events that happen in relation to crime which requires an adequate analysis in order to arrive at effective conclusive results regarding the investigation (Erickson, 2013)....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

(ZPICS), (RAC) and Healthcare Fraud Waste and Abuse

The practice of auditing has experienced numerous stages of evolution.... The Medicare and Medicaid programs were developed in 1965 in which legislation provided framework for Medicare and Medicaid services in the country through strong administrative and regulatory authority; … CMS has been authorized to protect Medicare Trust Funds by detecting and preventing fraud, abuse and waste....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Forensic Odontology: Forensic Dentistry as an Aid to the Pathologist

However, it is also important that a lot of research be done in this field before the judiciary takes decisions based on these pieces of evidence.... Also, the fact that the teeth can withstand severe damages (Vale, 1996) when compared to the body makes this an important piece of evidence in many cases.... The rookie tasks of saving a life by curing, giving medicines are now replaced with ultimate pro tasks that not only help physicians track the patient's state better but in many cases helps in a criminal investigation....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

Homicide Investigation

This research paper is about the major sources of evidence required for a homicide investigation and ultimately a conviction for the crime of homicide.... nything present at the scene of homicide gets enough attention and hence used as source of evidence in court.... For homicide investigation to be successful, the investigators must get some evidence and access the scene of crime the victim used.... Patrol officers have to respond in a rapid way to the scene of homicide crime to protect materials that they will use as evidence against the suspect before they are lost, destroyed or altered (Chan, 2000)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

The Effects of Global Warming

The following paper under the title 'The Effects of Global Warming' discusses the climate that has constantly been changing over the past decades.... Much exploration has been done to find out exactly why the climate has been behaving indifferently of late.... hrough the eyes of two authors, this essay will delve into the effects of global warming.... The authors are Matt Rosenberg, the author of the article “Negative Effects of Global Warming,” and Matt Ridley, the author of the article “why climate change is good for the world....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Glass Examination

In addition, the surfaces of glass fragments can be microscopically examined for evidence of the method of manufacture and the type of object from which they came.... ased on studies, since glass evidence is most often encountered in offenses and crimes, the glass fragments recovered from the burglary tools, clothing(s) of the suspect, hair, shoes and others may be compared to known glass from the scene....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us