StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Normative vs Positive Accounting Theories - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Normative vs Positive Accounting Theories" focuses on the major differences between normative and positive accounting theories. Accounting theories are those methodologies, assumptions as well as frameworks that are applied when studying the application of financial principles…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
Normative vs Positive Accounting Theories
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Normative vs Positive Accounting Theories"

Normative and Positive Accounting Theories Normative and Positive Accounting Theories Introduction Accounting theoriesare those methodologies, assumptions as well as frameworks that are applied when studying the application of financial principles. To study accounting theories, there is requirement to review both historical foundations and of accounting practices and the verification of accounting practices. In this essay, the aim will be to discuss the differences between normative and positive accounting theories. The essay will, then go on and critically discuss the role and application of the theories in improving accounting practice. Differences between Positive and Normative Accounting Theories Positive Accounting Theory (PAT) is an objective theory aiming at predicting accounting practices and policies that are chosen applied by firms as well as the effects of such, on the firms after the implementation. Under this theory, available data and statistics in the firm are analyzed to enable the firm to derive applicable conclusions based on the results. The main purpose of the results of the analysis is to create an understanding when predicting accounting policies across differing firms. On the other hand, Normative Accounting Theory (NAT) is a subjective kind of theory with an aim to describe the economic future of a given firm or investor. This is the theory that usually attempts to tell economists what they should do. This theory does not solely use predictive values to make evaluations, but it also considers the logical consistency of the rationality of individuals. Therefore, as positive accounting theories tend to make predictions of the events of the real world, normative accounting theories tend to inform people about what they should do (Coetsee, 2010). Main Elements of PAT PAT has two different perspectives that include the efficiency perspective and the opportunistic perspective. Under the opportunistic perspective of PAT, there are three elements including the bonus plan hypothesis, debt covenant hypothesis as well as the political cost hypothesis. The bonus plan hypothesis of PAT has the assumption that the manager with the bonus plan has a high likelihood of using accounting methods intended to increase the current period reported income. As such, this makes a prediction that a manager will be rewarded on the basis of their performance. Debt covenant hypothesis, on the other hand, tries to put a limit on the managers ability to transfer assets to new creditors, themselves or new shareholders. Political cost hypothesis, on the other hand, refers to how a firm would react to the possibility of regulation of other regulators as well as other interest groups and how these might affect the wealth of the firm. Elements of NAT Some of the elements of NAT include the current cost accounting (CCA), historical cost accounting in times of rising prices, exit-price accounting, and the current purchasing power accounting. Under the latter, the theory focuses on the purchasing power and capital maintenance and performing current purchase power adjustments. Strengths of NAT and PAT To begin with, positive accounting theory practices can best be applied in explaining past financial events. They also help in offering an explanation about the current financial standings of either a business or an individual. For a company to determine the reason it is operating at a net loss, the positive accounting theory practices help to compare its actual revenue to the actual expenses over the course a year. The accounting practices used under PAT enable the construction of financial documents like cash flow statements and balance sheets. On the other hand, NAT practices become very useful in trying to set future policies of economics which are theory based. Normative statements can be viewed in the form of the mission statement of a company or the market strategies that are included in the companys business plan. Such statements are a reflection of the business ideals to be accomplished by a company. Limitations of PAT One limitation of PAT is that it fails to provide accountants with a prescription of how to account, which is a critical issue for practicing accountants. The theory is also very slow and limited for development. It is flawed scientifically with hypotheses that are frequently not supported. The theory is also not as value free as it asserts. Limitations of NAT NAT, through the exit price theory, does not consider the assets value in use. It supposes that the value in use of an asset that is retained rather than sold is greater than its current exit price. During asset valuation at their perceived sales value, it usually implies that the firm has an intention of liquidating its assets. Another limitation through its historical cost accounting theory is that there is a justification for the historical cost utilization through the going concern assumption. It becomes difficult to build an evidential case for a continuity projection. There is no business capable of continuing indefinitely. Therefore, assuming continuity is rather less reasonable than cessation. Application ad use of PAT and NAT and their Role in Improving Accounting Practice PAT is usually applied by these managers for the benefits of the company. Given the fact that PAT theories promote the fact that a manager is compensated depending on the performance, the theory makes managers work harder as they want more compensation. This has an influence in improving accounting practice as it enhances the relationship between the agents and the shareholders as in the agency theory. On the other hand, NAT theories affect accounting practice in such a way that, their influence has some effects in the historical costs that may change the values in the financial statement, with time. The application of different accounting policies by firms due to the normative evaluations make it possible for the firms to change their accounting practice due to the subjective influences. Conclusion Positive and normative accounting theories are theories that either guide people or firms on the accounting policies to apply, or predicting the policies and practices that are applied by various forms. In as much as various firms apply both the PAT and NAT, the two has their limitations. At the same time, these theories have the potential to change accounting practice as they predict and provide an application of the best or most appropriate policies and accounting practices by firms. Bibliography Coetsee, D., 2010. The role of accounting theory in the development of accounting principles. Meditari Accountancy Research, 18(1), pp. 1-16. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“NAT and PAT Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
NAT and PAT Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1695788-nat-and-pat
(NAT and PAT Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
NAT and PAT Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1695788-nat-and-pat.
“NAT and PAT Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1695788-nat-and-pat.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Normative vs Positive Accounting Theories

Accounting Theory - Comparison between Positive and Normative Approach

On the other hand, positive accounting theories explain observed phenomena.... This paper will take into consideration the positive and negative approach of accounting theories; their advantages and disadvantages, comparison and relationships between the two and evidence supporting that where each of the approaches might be appropriate in the current economic and business environment.... It takes into consideration why accounting theories have developed in the manner in which they have in order to predict accounting events....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Understanding Accounting Theories

There are different hypothesis that are found in the positive accounting theories.... These are the positive accounting theories and the normative accounting theories.... The positive accounting theories try to explain what is happening at the moment.... This essay "Understanding accounting theories" focuses on developing an understanding of what accounting is in the first place.... This picture is best painted by looking at the history of accounting which will also provide insight into the various accounting theories....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Accounting Theory and Methodology Are a Waste of Time

here are two types of accounting theories; the proposal or the normative type and the descriptive or the positive type.... evelopment of accounting theories began in the early 1900.... These are just a few; there are many theorists such as Littleton, Sweeney, Hatfield, Ijiri and others who have contributed to the development of accounting theories.... The normative accounting theories are based on the assumptions of their proponents and they are acceptable to those who support the assumptions (Cathey, Clark and Schroeder 123)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Change From Normative Accounting Theory to Positive Accounting Theory

asic Definitions – Normative and positive accounting theories ... asic Definitions – Normative and positive accounting theories ... omparison and Contrasting of the Change between the Two accounting theories ... “Normative accounting theories.... This essay "The Change From Normative Accounting Theory to positive accounting Theory" compares the change from normative to positive theory of accounting and from geocentric to heliocentric model of the solar system....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Varied Theories of Accounting

accounting theories ... This forms the basis of this study which is to analyze how varied accounting theories can be evaluated and how one can prove the theories since none of them is universally accepted.... In addition, analyze how one can demonstrate that one accounting theory is superior to others, what impact internationalization of accounting regulation has or will have and suggest the most superior theory of all accounting theories. ...
16 Pages (4000 words) Literature review

Positive Theories of Accounting

Therefore positive accounting theories (PAT) is of the opinion that the selection of accounting policies by a particular firm is with the aim of reducing contracting costs while at the same time enhancing the firm's efficiency (Markus 2002). ... Ali & Hwang (2000) argue that positive accounting theories make an assumption that managers of different firms are rational.... It is through the use of these accounting theories that financial policies are chosen and its application made on the basis of either efficiency or the available opportunity....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review

To What Extent Is Accounting Conceptual Framework Positive or Normative Theory

The methodology defined in this study is continuous research especially based on accounting theories, concepts, principles standards and values.... Types of accounting theories 7 ... Conceptual framework began being worked upon in 1979, whereby its main idea was to come up with accounting standards which were believed to be principled based and also one which was in connection to the various existing accounting theories (Bullen, 2005). ... Types of accounting theories ...
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Normative Ethical System

mportance of Evaluating accounting theories ... The accounting theories are closely related to accounting practices and cannot be handled separately.... To accommodate these changes, accounting theories are regularly evaluated.... This makes it necessary to evaluate frequently accounting theories (Santos, 2012). ... valuation of accounting theories is necessary to eliminate unnecessary diversities in accounting treatment of similar items....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us