StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Justice Antonin Scalia and the Doctrine of Original Intent - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name: Course: Institution: Date: Justice Antonin Scalia and the Doctrine of Original Intent Application of facts to a case and law that govern that particular case is what all justices would say they do, when they are working on a case. They will say theirs is not to make the law, but rather, interpreting and applying it, since, the work of making laws is for the authors, legislators and constitution ratifiers…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
Justice Antonin Scalia and the Doctrine of Original Intent
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Justice Antonin Scalia and the Doctrine of Original Intent"

Download file to see previous pages

What originalism is and the advantages of originalism as compared to other methods of constitution and statutes interpretation. He has also given reasons as to why he chooses to use the method of originalism over other methods which still prove to be efficient. Original intent is used in law as a theory that defines how the constitution and statutes should be interpreted. Original intent implies that when interpreting any text, the authors intent on that particular text, should first be determined so as to accomplish the purpose of that statute.

Original intent assumes that a particular text has only one intended meaning (Scalia 23). Theoretical debates on the adjudication of the constitution have been there for a long time. There are all types of advocates who give different methods of interpreting statutes as well as the constitution and how the courts ought to do and what they ought not to do. Originalism is a method that has proved quite dominant in America (Levy 342). This method has been well embraced by Justice Antonin Scalia.

Who is seen to fully embrace this method and further gives long justifications to help support the originalism belief. Justice Scalia Antonin insists that Original intent determines the meaning of the constitution. . Scalia advocates for textualism with exceptional rigidity. Textualism refers to having statutes interpreted based on its normal meaning. Other critics say that textualism is more of political. All the same Justice Scalia Antonin appears to be more conservative as is evident in his service at the Supreme Court.

Scalia agrees that text that is statutory is not necessarily inherent liberally neither inherently conservative as that depends on who wrote it. Originalists say that reading strictly of any text can only be found by giving an interpretation of the constitution by using the original intent of that particular constitution. Justice Scalia opts to use an originalism theory that is softer, that is to say, interpretation should be made based on the time of constitution adaptation. Scalia feels this is much stricter as compared to allowing attempts by Justices to decipher author’s intent.

Textualism is what Justice Scalia advocates for since he believes that Intent ruling is as ambiguous as a living constitution. He believes this allows greater discretion as compare to other methods of interpretation. According to the conservative originalists, rights are those made via the democratic process and written constitutionally together with its amendments. Justice Antonin Scalia does not quite agree with the living constitution idea or even agree to give power to the judiciary to even modify the constitutional.

This means that Scalia’s originalist method is more of statutory interpretation of the text than the living interpretation of the constitution. Believing that the normal meaning of the statute should facilitate for

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Justice Antonin Scalia and the Doctrine of Original Intent Research Paper”, n.d.)
Justice Antonin Scalia and the Doctrine of Original Intent Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1464317-justice-antonin-scalia-and-the-doctrine-of
(Justice Antonin Scalia and the Doctrine of Original Intent Research Paper)
Justice Antonin Scalia and the Doctrine of Original Intent Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/history/1464317-justice-antonin-scalia-and-the-doctrine-of.
“Justice Antonin Scalia and the Doctrine of Original Intent Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1464317-justice-antonin-scalia-and-the-doctrine-of.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Justice Antonin Scalia and the Doctrine of Original Intent

Exploring Original Intent versus a Living Constitution

This is how the significance of original intent is determined in the present times, despite the far reaching changes that have taken place in society and value systems since the Constitution was written.... Exploring original intent versus Living Constitution (20.... 1) original intent is a legal and constitutional process by which the constitution is legally interpreted in seeking to ascertain the original meanings of specific provisions of the federal or state constitution by determining the ways in which the given provisions were perceived when the constitution was drafted and ratified....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Justice Scalia's Fundamental Rights

Constitution was passed with the intent to keep illegal immigrants and aliens from accessing and using the benefits provided by U.... [Author's Name] [Class] 06 June 2012 Justice scalia's Fundamental Rights In one of his recent interviews, Justice scalia expressed his opinion on the relevance and effectiveness of the 14th Amendment to the U.... hellip; Justice scalia's opinion resulted in a storm of disagreement and violent opposition....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Justice Scalia's Supreme Court Rulings

Since 1986, justice antonin scalia has delivered different rulings on various high profile cases in the United States Supreme Court.... hellip; In his 26 years of service on the highest court in the land, Scalia has significantly promoted conservatism ideology in his verdicts, rooting for textualism in constitutional analysis and originalism in the interpretation of laws of the country (scalia and Ring 8).... According to scalia and Ring, the justice enthusiastically rejects the notion of an evolving society guided by an “adjusting” set of laws (9-11)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Justices Breyer & Scalia on Judicial Interpretation

Justices antonin scalia and Stephen Breyer, each being highly respected members of the Supreme Court, have their own distinct views in regards to judicial responsibility and the overall role of the Supreme Court itself.... In an interview conducted at The Federalist Society, Justices' Breyer and Scalia are provided with an environment to engage in healthy discussion having to do with their individual interpretations of both laws, as well as the intent behind them....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

How much of Yogasara's teachings close to original Buddhist doctrine

Currently, there exist three main branches of Buddhism tradition; The Theravada -doctrine of the Elders, the Mahayana -Great Vehicle and the Vajrayana -Diamond Vehicle simply known as Tibetan Buddhism, (Olson 56).... Now his name has changed to Buddha meaning “awakened one," after going through a great realization of the nature of life, death and existence and Buddha… The paper will show how much of Yogasaras teachings close to original Buddhist doctrine. Buddhism is said to be non-theistic owing to the fact that Buddha taught that believing in gods was not useful for those seeking to gain knowledge....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Criminal Procedure Issues

DiscussionIn accordance with justice antonin scalia, each and every constitutional law should be interpreted depending on the actual context and should not be subjected with the addition of multiple other associative meanings4;5.... On the contrary, the commentators appeared to have criticized justice antonin scalia stating him to be highly concentrative on the understandable meaning of the constitutional laws6.... justice antonin scalia also proved the fourth comment regarding the attainment of associated meaning from the constitutional interpretation as vague by stating that the legislation only possesses the authority of structuring the rules and it should remain confined to a specific meaning9....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

U.S. Supreme Court Justices and Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals

The current configuration of eight justices and one chief justice was formed in 1869.... nbsp;The current Chief justice, John G.... Following graduation from Harvard Law School, Roberts clerked for Henry Friendly, Second Circuit Court of Appeals, then-justice William Rehnquist, Supreme Court.... From 1982-86, he served in the Department of justice (Reagan Administration)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Coursework

Debate between Scalia & Dworkin

This paper “Debate between Scalia & Dworkin” sets out to discuss the concept that debate between scalia and Dworkin did more of confusing the people rather than clarifying the constitutional jurisprudence.... The determination of the original meaning is left to the people to whom the statute is addressed.... The people's defined original meaning regards the people's understanding of a given statute and uniquely distinguishes itself from the contradictory will of the legislatures....
25 Pages (6250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us