StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Understanding the Effects of Wrongful Imprisonment - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
When an individual has been confined without his or her consent and thus defying the will of the individual and the associated violation of freedom then it is said that false imprisonment has occurred. False imprisonment is a tort which is also presented in the common law…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
Understanding the Effects of Wrongful Imprisonment
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Understanding the Effects of Wrongful Imprisonment"

False Imprisonment: The Case of Paul Trune Introduction When an individual has been confined without his or her consent and thus defying the will of the individual and the associated violation of freedom then it is said that false imprisonment has occurred. False imprisonment is a tort which is also presented in the common law felonies and applies to both government and private detentions. This paper presents a case of Paul Trune against a farmer who allegedly falsely imprisoned him in relation to the Herbst v.

Wuennenberg case in which the plaintiff’s complain for false imprisonment was disapproved by evidence. The paper discusses Trune’s accusation with a view of illustrating the dissenting opinion that there was no false imprisonment. The accusations of Trune that the farmer intended to confine him within fixed boundaries do not sufficiently prove the crime of false imprisonment because the farmer did not lock him in the firm house. Because the farmer did not lock the farm house, it can thus be argued that there was no false imprisonment because Trune’s freedom was not limited at all.

This case can be compared with the Herbst v. Wuennenberg case in which the plaintiffs were asked by the accused to leave before the occurrence of the events which led to the legal suit. This illustrates that in the Herbst v. Wuennenberg case, the freedoms of the plaintiffs was not violated. The case led to a ruling of the appeal court that favored Wuennenberg because sufficient evidence suggested that there was no false imprisonment of the plaintiff (Supreme Court of Wisconsin 1). The actions of the farmer were motivated by the need to protect his farm from intruders and trespassers and there was no intention of leading to the confinement of the plaintiff otherwise he would have locked him in the firm yard.

In the Herbst v. Wuennenberg case, the plaintiffs admitted that they were not intimidated neither threatened by the accused (Supreme Court of Wisconsin 2). On a counter argument, Trune admits that he stayed in the firm house because he feared the possible outcome of the farmer’s actions, which does not adequately substantiate the claims that his life was in immediate danger. The actions of the farmer were inn ordinary sense harmless and the plaintiff has no real evidence to prove that the farmer put him in unbearable danger.

Trune’s arguments however differ with the Herbst v. Wuennenberg case on the trespass issue is compared between the two cases. Like in the case of Herbst and the other plaintiffs, Trune does not defend his reason for being on the farmer’s field. However, the fact that some form of trespass was involved in the two cases illustrates their similarity. The issue of forceful imprisonment however is not subsequently proved in the two cases. The lack of false imprisonment in the Herbst accusations is demonstrated by the fact that the appeal case was ruled in favor of Wuennenberg (Supreme Court of Wisconsin 3).

The accusations of Trune against the farmer are compromised by the fact that his freedom was not limited and remaining in the farm house after the farmer left was arguably on the plaintiff’s own volition.ConclusionThe claims of Trune for the alleged false imprisonment by the farmer do not provide sufficient proof because the farm house in which the plaintiff claims to have been confined was left open. The freedom of the plaintiff was not limited as illustrated by his free will that let him remain in the unlocked firm house even after the farmer had left.

The court finds that there is no false imprisonment in this case and thus rules in favor of the farmer. Work CitedSupreme Court of Wisconsin. Herbst v. Wuennenberg. 1978. Web.5 February 2012

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Studying a case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Studying a case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1588736-studying-a-case
(Studying a Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Studying a Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1588736-studying-a-case.
“Studying a Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1588736-studying-a-case.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Understanding the Effects of Wrongful Imprisonment

The Continued Implementation of the Death Penalty

This research paper "The Continued Implementation of the Death Penalty" presents some of the views both for and against capital punishment in the US, and it is seen as a barometer of a society's overall tolerance for violent crime and the clear and obvious repercussions.... ... ... ... The question of whether or not a person supports or opposes the death penalty is an issue that attracts a great deal of attention currently in the United States....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Issues Surrounding a Miscarriage of Justice

Understanding the Effects of Wrongful Imprisonment, 32 Crime & Justice.... It is important to note that currently, there are as many cases of wrongful conviction as they were fifty years ago.... Due to the alarming trend of wrongful convictions in the recent past, the legitimacy of the death penalty has constantly been reviewed.... Cases of biasness are common in the event of wrongful conviction and they include actions like unfair editing of evidence, fabrication of evidence by the police or the prosecution, issues of identification, contaminated evidence, and many other factors....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Eyewitness Evidence as a Cause of Miscarriages of Justice in the UK

There have been several cases of wrongful convictions because of untrue or distorted eyewitness evidence in the United Kingdom.... Research shows that in the United Kingdom, the sixty-two cases that involved the conviction and imprisonment of people, fifty-two of them involved mistaken eyewitness identifications.... This can have very serious implications to the person wrongfully convicted as sometimes the discovery of a wrongful conviction occurs after the innocent person has died in jail or executed....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review

Wrongfully Convicted

In instances where mistake has been identified, it is becoming more and more precise that mistaken identification is the primary reason of wrongful convictions (Simon, 2012).... Norwood was then charged of Christine's murder in 2013 and was sentenced to life imprisonment (Siegel & Bartollas, 2015).... With these important pieces of evidence undisclosed, the jury and the judge had easily made a guilty decision and sentenced Michael to life imprisonment (Davies, 2013)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Book Report/Review

Methods and Process of Capital Punishment

Another famous example of wrongful conviction was the case of Darryl Hunt.... From the critical perspective, due to the number of moral, legal and scientific reasons, capital punishment should be abolished and in the necessary cases replaced with lifetime imprisonment.... From this perspective, being an obsolete punishing policy, death penalty should be eliminated and replaced with more effective and moral policies like lifetime imprisonment. ...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Socialization and Crime in Canada

The social relationship got his friend in trouble and was sentenced a year later into life imprisonment.... The paper "Socialization and Crime in Canada" discusses that imperative to realize that crime tagging should not be concluded by the day's judgment; however, follow up activities should follow these convictions whether wrongful or not to eradicate any chances of jailing a free individual.... The same is the case with the wrongful convictions (Pearson, 2005)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Role of Consumer Protection Authorities during Crises and Disasters

In the same manner that price gougers are held guilty of benefitting mutually through exploitation, they are also guilty of wrongful actions when morals apply, as much as their actions are beneficial to the victims of the disaster (Sarat 175).... Since disaster stricken consumers are still in recovery, they require quick response to their complaints in order to facilitate their sustainability and to prevent them from experiencing further downfall as a result of fraud or any other form of wrongful opportunism....
19 Pages (4750 words) Term Paper

The Treatment and Admissibility of False Confessions as Criminal Evidence

It concludes that although such tragic mistakes in the criminal justice system are unlikely to be obliterated, more research is needed in this area, to incorporate such safeguards and remedies that aim to reduce the number of wrongful convictions, into existing criminal evidence law, regardless of jurisdictions.... Although wrongful convictions of innocent citizens based on false confessions seem like an anomaly, they are a reality within the criminal justice system....
69 Pages (17250 words) Thesis
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us