StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Business Implications of Land Law - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The purpose of the following assignment "Business Implications of Land Law" is to analyze several legal cases that feature elements of property and land law. The issues risen in this assignment are the disposal of waste and the process of reclaiming organizational property…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
Business Implications of Land Law
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Business Implications of Land Law"

Land Law – Advice One of the first things to consider in this instance is who is to clean the rubbish. The Council will not, because this is private land and public health and safety is not critically affected. The Environmental Protection Act of 1990 states that “it shall be the duty of any person who imports, produces, carries, keeps, treats or disposes of controlled waste…………. to prevent the escape of the waste from his control.”1 This is a duty imposed upon all businesses and the Act holds organizations responsible if they fail to properly dispose of waste. Where contracts for transfer of a business property are concerned, one of the elements that may need to be specially negotiated includes removal of rubbish It may be necessary to include a special provision in the contract requiring the seller to remove all rubbish from the property prior to the completion of the sale.2 In general, a buyer also has the right to inspect the property thoroughly before the sale and if the Company had carried out such an inspection of the property, they would have been able to find the rubbish and require that it be disposed of before the sale was concluded. It is the buyer’s duty to carry out such an inspection and since the Company has chosen to purchase the property without carrying out such a thorough inspection of the premises before the sale was concluded, it may not have much legal recourse to file for any breach of contractual conditions, since the condition for removing of waste and transfer of the property sans rubbish was never set out among the contractual terms. The Company’s legal options are not so good once the sale has been concluded and the property has passed into its hands. Since it has not included any provision for clearing up of the rubbish in the contract and the sale has already been concluded, the disposal of the rubbish may be held to be the responsibility of the Company, because it is the new owner of the property. Although the Company will have to incur a cost of 5000 pounds for removal of the wastes, it appears likely that if the matter is taken to the Courts, the principle of caveat emptor or Buyer Beware will apply. As a result, the stage at which the Company stands is one where it may be held to be the owner of the property and therefore responsible for clearing the rubbish according to the guidelines laid out in the Environmental Act of 1990. The sliding doors could possibly be recovered if it can be proved that they were fixtures to the property rather than chattel. Fixtures will accede to the property when it is conveyed, but chattel will not and can be removed. The decision rendered in the case of Holland v Hodgson3 supported the legal maxim that what is annexed to the land becomes part of the land. It was also held that in determining if something is a fixture, it is necessary to examine (a) the degree of annexation of the object to the land and (b) the object of the annexation.4 An article resting on the land by its own weight may not be a fixture5, as also held in the case of Hulme v Bingham6, where heavy machinery was not held to be a part of the property. When an article has been attached loosely rather than fixed to the walls and can be removed easily, this may classify it as chattel rather than a fixture. This was the case in Leigh v Taylor7 where valuable tapestries had been attached to the wall and were removed, but this was done in such a way that no damage was caused. Gray and Gray have however argued that recent case law has suggested that the Courts have moved away from this earlier position8 of looking only at the extent to which the article is fixed to the property and its purpose. In the case of Elitestone Ltd v Morris9, the House of Lords refined the principle of annexation further in determining whether an article is a fixture or chattel. In this case, it was held that what is to be determined is whether the article has been set up for the purpose of enjoying it better as a chattel or whether it has been attached in order to bring about a permanent improvement to the property. On this basis, the House of Lords held that it must be determined whether an article can be said to be a part and parcel of the property, in which case it will qualify as a fixture that cannot be removed, even if it is removable without damage. Two of the additional factors taken into consideration by the House of Lords in this case were how easily the article could be restored using its constituent parts and how permanent was its attachment to the property10. In this instance, the object at dispute is the sliding doors at the factory, which have been replaced by a cheaper hinged door. In the case of D’Eyncourt v Gregory11 the article in dispute was again tapestries attached to the wall. But the manner of fixing in this case was such that it was deemed to be permanent and therefore, the Court held that the fixtures were intended to become a part and parcel of the property. In TSB v Botham12, the Court of Appeal held that bathroom fittings, fitted cupboards in the kitchen, fitted sink and work surfaces were all fixtures, but fitted carpets, blinds and curtains could be removed because they had been attached in an insubstantial way. White goods were held to be chattel because the degree of annexation was slight and they could be removed without damage to the fabric of the building and without any difficulty. Applying the precedents in the above cases to the sliding doors, where the question of annexation is concerned, the sliding doors are removable without damage to the fabric of the building. The object of annexation is to function as protection for the items placed inside the warehouse and the removal of the sliding door has not interfered with this object of annexation, because the items in the warehouse are still protected through the use of the other door. The most important factor is that the sliding doors are a trade fixture and trade fixtures are removable. In Mancetter Developments v Garmanson Ltd13 tenants were allowed to remove an extractor fan because even when applying the rules set out above, an object may be deemed a fixture, the law allows tenants of business premises to remove them. In Young v Dalgety plc14 tenants were allowed to remove light fittings. The sliding doors may also fall under the category of decorative or ornamental fixtures, which can always be removed by the tenant while vacating, subject to how they have been attached. If an item can be removed without substantial damage to the building, it will be viewed as chattel. For example, in the case of Spyer v Phillipson15 valuable antique wood paneling was held to be chattel, and therefore removable. Applying the case precedents listed above, it appears likely that the sliding doors may be held to be chattel and therefore removable. Where a sale of land has taken place, it has been held in the case of Taylor v Hamer16 that a fixture passes with the land unless the seller tells the purchaser that the things are going to be removed. Where the sliding doors are concerned, there are two factors working against the company in recovering the sliding doors. Despite the fact that all items on the property pass with the sale, the sliding doors are not fixed to the warehouse in such a manner that removing them would cause destruction to the property. Secondly, they are trade fixtures, which can always be removed. Where the fire alarm is concerned however, the Courts may find it to be a fixture rather than chattel. Applying the criterion set out in the case of Elitestone v Morris17, the purpose of the article needs to be considered. Has it been affixed for enjoyment as a chattel or to bring about a permanent improvement to the property? In the case of Re Whaley18, tapestries and portraits were held to be a part of the general architectural design of the property and therefore held to be fixtures. But in the case of Berkeley v Poulett19 where a sale of the property had taken place and seller had removed several objects, the Court held such objects to be chattel rather than fixtures because they were not intended to be enjoyed as objects and not intended to form part of the architectural design of the property. The objects removed by the Seller included statutes, a sundial and some pictures fitted into abscesses into the wall. While the sliding doors may be held to be chattel as detailed earlier, the fire alarm may be held to be a fixture. At the outset, applying the annexation test, it is wired and built into the warehouse. Secondly, its purpose is one of utility, i.e., to detect and broadcast any presence of fire. As specified by Lord Scarman in the case of Berkeley v Poulett20 the object and purpose of annexation is more important than the degree of annexation to the property. Even assuming the fire alarm is removable without causing damage to the property, the purpose served by the object is one integral to the property. If it was installed in the warehouse, the purpose of the alarm was obviously to serve as a protective device ensuring the safety of the warehouse. Removing the object thus deprives the structure of a vital element. It is also possible that dismantling the fire alarm may have involved some structural damage to the ceiling or wiring of the property. On this basis, the alarm would qualify as a fixture rather than chattel. It appears likely that the Company may be able to successfully argue to have it replaced by the Seller, on the grounds that the alarm constitutes part and parcel of the property. The alarm could be considered part of the architectural design of the property as set put in Re Whaley21 or determined to be installed for improvement of the property, as in D’ynCourt v Gregory.22 The conclusions on the issues raised would thus be as follows: (a) Rubbish left on land: The Company’s legal options for any recovery from the Seller are limited. It may be necessary for the Company to arrange for proper disposal of the waste through appropriate sources and pay the necessary fee for the same. (b) expensive sliding doors – the Company’s chances to reclaim these doors through legal action appears limited, because it may not be held to be a fixture. (c) fire alarm – there is a good chance for the Company to receive this back from the Seller, on the grounds that it is part and parcel of the property. Bibliography * Cragg, Braye, 2008. “Buying a residential property”, http://www.brayecragg.com.au/templates/brayecragg_content.aspx?pageID=4905; * Gray, Kevin and Gray, Susan Francis, 2006. “Land Law”, Oxford University Press. * Kirtlan, Yvonne, 1997. “Land, fixture or chattel?” Estates Gazette, 14 July at pp 121 * Section 34(1)(b) of the Act. http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1990/ukpga_19900043_en_5#pt2-pb3-l1g34; Cases cited: * Berkeley v Poulett (1976) 241 EG 911 * D’eyncourt v Gregory (1866) LR 3 Eq 382 * Elitestone Ltd v Morris (1997) 1 WLR 687, HL * Holland v Hodgson (1872) LR 7 CP 328 * Holland v Hodgson, Op. Cit. * Hamp v Bygrave (1983) 266 EG 720 * Hulme v Bingham (1943) KB 152 * Leigh v Taylor (1902) AC 157 at 162 * Mancetter Developments v Garmanson Ltd (1986) QB 1212 * Re Whaley (1908) 1 Ch 615 * Spyer v Phillipson (1929) 2 Ch 183 * Taylor v Hamer (2002) EWCA Civ 1130 * TSB v Botham (1996) EGCS 149 * Young v Dalgety plc (1987) 1 EGLR 116 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Business Implications of Land Law Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words, n.d.)
Business Implications of Land Law Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words. https://studentshare.org/law/1719453-land-law
(Business Implications of Land Law Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words)
Business Implications of Land Law Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1719453-land-law.
“Business Implications of Land Law Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words”. https://studentshare.org/law/1719453-land-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Business Implications of Land Law

The Cross Cultural Implications for a UK Manager Undertaking an International Business

The author states that national culture in a different country greatly influences the way in which a manager performs and hence the need to assess the cross-cultural implications of a UK manager who is undertaking an international business assignment in another country.... It is important that he learns the implications of cultural diversity.... Hofstede four cross-cultural implications that may aid business managers on international businesses to competently perform despite the change in culture....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Peer to Peer Networking In Business

This is because the technology can be used for both beneficial and destructive practices depending on which end of the technology one is at, as well as ethical and legal implications.... This is because the technology can be used for both beneficial and destructive practices depending on which end of the technology one is at, as well as ethical and legal implications.... Business ethics and legal action indicates implications that are equivalent to theft due to infringement of copyright laws and theft of intellectual property....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Peer to Peer Networking In Business

Legally, the issue of copyright infringement has been the debate concerning P2P, application that is viewed by some law enforcers to be copyright infringement.... The increased application of P2P technology has seen many business firms on the wrong side of the law and thus the aim of research is to establish whether businesses are comfortable with P2P technology.... Peer to Peer Networking in business Professor Date Abstract Technology is being applied in business to ease most of the processes and to maximize profits in the end, Peer to peer services allow users to network resources to several users at the same time....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Income Taxation Law Issues

Also, the house should not be rented or be on more than two hectares of land, and must have a dwelling in it4.... [INCOME TAXATION law] (Name) (Instructor/Tutor) (Course/Subject) (Institution/ University) (City, State) (Date) Part 1- Problem Question Capital Gains Tax Implications on Sale of the Shoe Manufacturing Factory Premises A capital gain is the difference between the cost of asset acquisition and the proceeds realised from disposing the same asset1.... Capital Gain Tax implications on PKY Pty Ltd An expense was incurred in acquiring the company, PKY Pty....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Various Legal Implications and Legislative Concerns of Electronic-Commerce

E- Commerce draws from technological devices such as mobile technology, online marketing, supply chain… This essay critically evaluates various legal implications and legislative concerns of e-commerce which deserve a greater attention from business regulators and law 77), E- Commerce can be considered to be a transactions feature of e- commerce.... E- Commerce is a business where companies take part in selling their products through electronic services like computer networks or the internet services (Agnew, 2001, p....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Legal Implications of Electronic-Commerce

Regardless of the type of signatures chosen, certain legal implications still exist.... E-commerce has challenged legal assumptions about the location and meaning… It has also redefined business competitors' locations.... It is critical for legal stakeholders to familiarise themselves with these legal concerns in order to guard against loss of business due to these issues.... In traditional business settings, handwritten signatures authenticate contracts by providing a unique form of identification for the signee (Chaudhury and Jean-Pierre, 2002)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Business submission

espite the fact that the above business practices aim at compliance with the two principles I mentioned earlier, they also come with little side effects which we must agree to take charge of.... Secondly, innovations pertaining to technology create a new whole world of more superior business opportunities which in turn helps the business to remain or win competitive advantage over others in the same industry....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Buyer and Consumer Behaviour: Weet-Bix

On the other hand, Ehrenberg (1969) used the concept “Double Jeopardy” as marketing law that brands having lower market share tends to have low brand loyalty and limited purchase frequency within a specific time period.... (2008) defined brand performance as the brand value that is able to provide definitive as well as a measurable contribution towards sustainable success for the business as a whole....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us