StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Giving Negative Feedback - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
According to the essay, Giving Negative Feedback, when it comes to negative feedback or criticism, no one relishes being on either the giving or the receiving side. The experience is usually considered unpleasant - something that one would rather not have. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Giving Negative Feedback
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Giving Negative Feedback"

 When it comes to negative feedback or criticism, no one relishes being on either the giving or the receiving side. The experience is usually considered unpleasant --- something that one would rather not have. This is exactly how I felt when I took on the task to provide a negative feedback to a very close friend. It was, however, a bit exciting because I will be able to apply some good practices in providing negative feedback. I remember my friend (Kat) having a somewhat heated conversation with another friend (Pao) just a few days prior. Kat criticized Pao regarding the latter’s fickleness in accepting work opportunities. I know the conversation ended badly, with Pao walking away and not speaking to Kat until today. I decided to talk to Kat to provide her a negative feedback on what she did, and at the same time to make her understand the impact of her words and actions to Pao. I wanted to apply the tips I read about giving criticisms. The result is a success because Kat accepted the criticisms constructively, and even decided to talk to Pao again using the same techniques as I did with her. Criticizing Constructively Behavior versus Person It was somewhat expected that Kat will immediately react negatively one I start with the criticism. However, I still tried to diffuse the possible initial negative reaction by making sure that Kat understand I am criticizing the action and not the person. I told her, “Kat, I felt that Pao was hurt and offended by the words he received the other day.” Kat was surprised and immediately showed interest in what I was about to say next. This is most probably because of the subtle emphasis on the fact that we are going to talk about the wrong action, and not the person who did the wrong action. She reacted positively because she felt it is not a personal attack aimed at her. I can therefore say that “focus[ing] feedback on the behavior rather than the person” (Hunsaker, 1983, p.5) will have higher chances of positive reception. Description versus Judgment The second strategy I used is “focus[ing] feedback on description rather than judgment” (Hunsaker, 1983, p.5). I feel that this is very important to avoid making Kat feel that I am judging her immediately. So, instead of telling Kat that, “You were harsh with Pao when you told him he is so fickle minded.,” I instead told Kat that, “Your voice was really higher-pitched and louder than usual, and you were pointing you finger at him on several instances.” I felt that this was an effective way to emphasize to Kat that her actions were offensive. The clear and objective description made her open to imagine her own actions and objectively evaluate if they are offensive or not. The strategy prevented Kat’s defense mechanism from acting up; especially because she knew that I was making a factual narration of my observations. There was actually no way for her to dispute facts that we both know to be true. It would have been easier for Kat to dispute my words had they been personal judgments. Specific Situation versus Abstract Characteristic The third strategy I used is “focus[ing] feedback on behavior related to a specific situation rather than an abstract characteristic” (Hunsaker, 1983, p.5). My discussion with Kat was based on a specific incident, and not based on a general observation. This proved to be effective because she seemed to be more open to listen on how that incident was wrong in many ways. This could be because focusing on a specific incident made us focus on the actions and words, rather than on the general characteristic of the person (Kat). This takes the sting out of the criticism, because I believe that it is easier to accept a criticism aimed at something you did rather than something you are. Good Intentions and Fair Process The fourth strategy I used was making Kat realize that I “[am] reliable and ha[ve] good intentions toward them” (Manzoni, 2002, p.118). Pao is a common friend, and that made Kat understand that I have only concern for our relationship as friends. I also made sure that the “feedback development and communication process is fair” (Manzoni, 2002, p.118) by allowing Kat the chance to express her reactions and ideas regarding the incident. There were times when Kat and I disagreed, particularly when I noted that there was a slight haughty tone in her voice when she talked to Pao. Still, despite our disagreement on that, I respected her opinion, and she respected my observation in return. Don’t Delay The fifth important strategy I used is the notion of not delaying the conversation. What happened between Pao and Kat was only a few days back, and when I decided to discuss it with Kat, I made sure that it would not appear too long ago. Delaying in giving feedback might make the conversation harder because it could make the receiver think negatively of the reason why it was delayed (Field, 2005, p.4). For example, had I waited for several repeat incidents before I talked to Kat, there is a big possibility that she will not take it positively. There will be a question regarding my true intention because if I really were concerned, I would have intervened earlier. No one really relishes the thought the he or she is observed doing something negative and not being called to attention about it. In this case, Kat even thanked me for bringing this observation to her attention immediately. This also makes it easier for her to correct whatever was affected by her actions and words. Reference Field, A. (2005). Block that defense! Make sure your constructive criticism works. Harvard Management Communication Letter, 3-5. Hunsaker, J. S. (1983). Taking the sting out of negative feedback: How to criticize constructively. Industrial Management, 25, 6, 5-6. Manzoni, J. F. (2002). A better way to deliver bad news. Harvard Business Review, 80, 9, 114-9. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Giving Negative Feedback Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1471622-feedback
(Giving Negative Feedback Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/management/1471622-feedback.
“Giving Negative Feedback Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1471622-feedback.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Giving Negative Feedback

How to Improve Management Performance of Your Organization

This essay "How to Improve Management Performance of Your Organization" outlines that managing performance is the procedure of assessment of progress, of an organization.... It is the measurement, analysis, and optimization of resources to provide a service to a level that has been agreed upon....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Research Methods used in Educational Psychology

he findings of the study revealed that, on a whole, the teachers at the two Title I schools "spent more time engaged in non-instructional talk, in transition, Giving Negative Feedback, and incurred more students exiting their classrooms during literacy classes than did their counterparts in the non-Titled schools" (Stichter, Stormont, and Lewis 179).... Among the 4 Levels included in the SFAT, Levels 2-4 were used to verify factors such as the context of instruction; prompt, feedback, and instructional characteristics; non-instructional talk; and behaviors exhibited across the students....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Interpersonal Skills in Organizations

de Janasz, who works with the Institute for Management Development, Karen O.... Dowd of Daniels College of Business, University of Denver, and Beth… Schneider of Winston - Salem State University.... The book is an impressive read with nineteen chapters each coming with a set of questions to test ones understanding based on the text....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Behaviors in Nursing Management Professional

The paper “Behaviors in Nursing Management Professional” will begin with an introduction that outlines the critical responsibilities of managers in the nursing profession.... Some of the identified roles include communicators, creating relationships with internal stakeholders.... hellip; The author will discuss the value of effective leadership in nursing....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

CanGo's Performance Appraisal System

Managers are well aware that reactions to negative feedback are hard to predict.... It can be especially difficult to provide direct feedback to an under-performing subordinate in a face-to-face meeting.... Effectively managing the "people side" of an organization is as important to its success as is the effective management of traditional business areas such as finance and marketing....
19 Pages (4750 words) Essay

The Place of Feedback

Errors indicate that the student did not completely grasp, or probably misunderstood the thought of what is being taught and instead of Giving Negative Feedback to the student, this provides an opportunity for the student to assess himself/herself in terms of what they did not understand, and find a way to correct this mistake.... Studies have shown that there is minimal effect on the students when the teacher gives them feedbacks, especially when the feedback is given to the class as a whole....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Deaf Professors Challenges

The senior faculty then decides to put her down by ignoring her and Giving Negative Feedback during review.... ulia continues to achieve more and working hard and even after her reward with the grant she had She then receives negative comments the following year on issues of being unfriendly and absenteeism in some faculty meetings....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Cross Culture Management

According to Hofstede, there is a difference of human inequalities that underlie the functioning of a society.... Germany and United Kingdom have a low PDI score of 35… U.... has a score of 40, showing unequal distribution of wealth compared to Germany (Raj, Colm & Brian, 2009).... Japan has the highest PDI score of 54....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us