StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Arbitration of Jesse Stansky - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Arbitration of Jesse Stansky" states that generally, Jesse has proved himself as unprofessional several times. If it would not have happened then for this particular case there was a chance to take some other decision regarding punishment…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.1% of users find it useful
The Arbitration of Jesse Stansky
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Arbitration of Jesse Stansky"

The Arbitration Case of Jesse Stansky Which argument should be given more weight: Those based on company policy, the employee handbook, and the labor agreement or mitigating factors given by the grievant and his witness? Explain in detail. Answer: In case of any company especially if the concern is involved with production or manufacturing department, there a chance of conflict is always constant. This though happens in other sectors also where production is not related with the company’s wok. But the reason why it happens especially in these type of organization is, in case of production unit basically workers come from lower middle class of any society. Now it has often being seen that within this class to be involved with a conflict in normal life is quite a usual and regular job. So when people are coming from this level to any work place a little bit of behavioral effect will be reflected in the work environment also. As all these can affect the output of the company so the Human Resource department has to be very consciously and with lots of patience have to handle the situation. Each and every company has its own policy of how they want to set the rules and regulations regarding the performance assessment of any employee. But still it can happen that in some critical situation employees are to be judge on the basic of situational evidence and witnesses. Like in the situation of Jesse Stansky given in the case study. The complaint against him was he has been found as hitting one of his colleagues. Now this is a serious offence and this situation implies that he was trying to influence any other worked by force and fear. This kind of behavior is a serious offence for any organization. Though Jesse Stansky was working in that organization for many years and has contributed although not very remarkable but as an average employee. While judging this particular situation of Jesse Stansky along with the company policy, the employee handbook, and the labor agreement, the Human Resource department has to give emphasis about what other witness are saying about the situation. This is so because it is important to identify the reality of the situation and this can only be known if the description of the situation is been heard from other employee who was also present in that particular situation. In this particular case Jesse Stansky has been found in a situation with another technician named Gary Lindekin where Jesse was hitting Gary. And this has been observed by another technician who was present there. So for the Human Resource department it has become more important to create a lesson for other employees that any kind of disorder will not be tolerate by the authority. It can be said that rules of company policy, employee handbook etc all are important but should not go beyond the safety, security, and prestige of a human being. Here may be Jesse can be left with a prior warning but then it influence other worker for doing the same offence again. But a termination of Jesse will give a lesson to all other employee along with it will create a good impression in the mind of the employees that the employers are doing justices with the victims. 2. How might unprofessional conduct be defined? Explain in detail. Answer: An unprofessional conduct relates to the disability of performing of any employee. When a work done by any employee does not satisfy the standard of service what is required, then that work is termed as unprofessional conduct. This generally happens when the employees are either not having the required skill what is want for the job or is not ethically concerned about the work (Casey, 2010). Like in case of Health Professions Act (HPA) the unprofessional conduct relates the following points A disability of lack of knowledge or skill in case of professional services. Disobey of Code of Conduct, Standard of Practice etc. Failure to perform the work assigned to the employee. Performing in such an order that can bring harmful affect on the integrity of the organization. Possessing a mentality of not following the rules lied under the HPA rule (Papadakis, 2004). In the given case study also we can see the reflection of the unprofessional conduct. Jesse Stansky is an employee who has disobeys the rules of company policy. By creating violence in the work place with his own coworker he has shown enough unprofessionalism towards his work. In any kind of mismatch in the idea about how to work or anything else with his calege Jesse should have consult the problem with his supervisor instead of breaking company rules. This is very important for any organization to observe that whether any of unprofessional activity is going around internally in an organization and if it is happening then firm steps must be taken so that other employees also get a lesson from it. 3. If you were the arbitrator, how would you rule in this case? Explain fully the reasons for your decision. Answer: the meaning of arbitration is outside the court taking any decision about any conflict. It generally involves a participation of two or more people. The judgment is done by the third party about how and what exactly has happened and what will be the justice for the situation. If I had been the arbitrator then I would have also taken the same decision what has been taken in the given case. Nancy Huang, the H.R. manager of the company has exactly taken the correct decision regarding the conflict happened between Jesse Stansky and Gary Lindekin (Bediei, 1994). Below the reason why this decision is being supported by me is being discussed. Jesse has done an unprofessional work inside the organization. Before this incident he was also being suspended for his other fault in performance. Due to his negligence a system control error took place in the production system of the company. Three days of suspension was punished to him for this from the side of the company. He is also an average performer with a problem of irregularity. Particularly for this reason Jesse Stansky got warning for several times also. So in general Jesse Stansky was performing in an inefficient manner and before this incident he has not created a very good impression as a worker in the mind of the employer. A habit of disobey of rules and regulations has always been noticed in the nature of Jesse Stansky. The particular situation what for Jesse was terminated actually crossed all the limits of unprofessional activity. He has tried to terrorize one of his own coworker while taking a decision in a critical matter relating to production. This was really a very big offence done by Jesse Stansky and he deserves the termination in true sense. The judgment could not have done so confidently if there would have been only two employees among which conflict took place. But another employee saw the incident and he also reported the same thing what Gary has reported. So there is no confusion to understand the real situation. Jesse has proved himself as an unprofessional for several times. If it would not had happened then for this particular case there was a chance to take some other decision regarding punishment. But after doing so many unethical and irresponsible work there is no question of giving him any other chance to be rectified. This type of judgment is important for other employees also. As it gives the message that the employer are with you always but only when you are following the rules of the company and performing your duty in a correct manner (Berg, 1958). References: Berg , A. (1958). The New York Convention of 1958: An Overview . Retrieved From: http://www.arbitration-icca.org/media/0/12125884227980/new_york_convention_of_1958_overview.pdf. Bediei, F. (1994). Online Arbitration Definition and Its Distinctive Features . Retrieved From: http://ceur-ws.org/Vol-684/paper8.pdf. Papadakis. A, M (2004). Unprofessional Behavior in Medical School Is Associated with Subsequent Disciplinary Action by a State Medical Board. Retrieved From: http://www.udel.edu/PT/current/PHYT600/2013/Lecture1handouts/Papadakis,%20Hodgson,%20Teherani.%20Unprofessional%20Behavior.pdf. Casey ,J. 2010. The Top Ten Causes of Unprofessional Conduct. Retrieved From: http://www.fieldlaw.com/articles/JTC_Top10Causes.pdf. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Human resources Case study analyze Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Human resources Case study analyze Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1637138-human-resources-case-study-analyze
(Human Resources Case Study Analyze Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Human Resources Case Study Analyze Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/management/1637138-human-resources-case-study-analyze.
“Human Resources Case Study Analyze Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1637138-human-resources-case-study-analyze.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Arbitration of Jesse Stansky

International Commercial Arbitration: Pros and Cons

ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES1 OF INTERNATIONAL arbitration LITIGATION: In simple words, litigation is defined as a process through which an argument between two or more parties is taken to a court.... arbitration: In litigation, the case is taken to the court of law.... It is known as ‘arbitration'.... Thus, arbitration is defined as a technique which involves...
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Arbitration Law paper

The parties have latitude to elect the law governing arbitration,2 language of the arbitration, rules that govern the arbitration3, language applicable to them and the seat of arbitration4.... hellip; Courts must support and supervise the arbitration process so as to ensure the integrity of the arbitral process and protect the public interest.... Nevertheless, this should not sacrifice or prejudice confidence of the users of the arbitration process....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Arbitration in the United Kingdom

n the United Kingdom, the first law on arbitration was the arbitration Act 1697 although arbitration had been common in England prior to its passing as by 1610, there already was a recorded judicial decision on arbitration, specifically the Vynior's Case3.... Today, UK arbitration policies are guided by the arbitration Act 1996 founded on the principles that: ... arbitration today is commonly used to resolve commercial disputes most specifically in the context of international commercial transactions although labour, consumer, investors, family and even states disputes are encompassed....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Human Resource in Success of a Business

The notion that human resource management is vital to the underlying success of a business is one that has been explored in a wide variety of businesses and in various contexts.... This exploration dates back to the late 1980s to the early 1990s and has been embodied in a change… In the past, the department which managed employees was referred to as the personnel department....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Arbitration as an Alternative Form of Dispute Resolution

The confidentiality of the existence of the process as well as any other disclosure made during the arbitration process is protected.... The arbitrators award in arbitration cases is often final and courts rarely reexamine arbitration arbitration is an alternative form of dispute resolution.... The arbitrators award in arbitration cases is often final and courts rarely reexamine such awards.... Additionally, other characteristics of arbitration are that it is a confidential process....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Arbitration: Alternative Dispute Resolution

Amica Mutual Insurance Company, 2004 the use of “party arbitrator” system resulted in procedural impropriety where the court vacated the arbitration award.... Recently, the arbitration clause enforceability, especially in the consumer agreements context (such as credit card agreements), draws scrutiny from many courts.... In the end, it is upon the arbitration users to develop draft arbitration agreements that are effective and to establish effective arbitration procedures (National Paralegal....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Camp David Accord 1978

This assignment "The Camp David Accord 1978" focuses on the political agreement between Israel and Egypt signed in September 1978.... Some analysts think that the Camp David Accord was not signed on the basis of justice and Israel was the major gainer out of the Accord.... hellip; By this Accord, Israel affirmed its willingness to restore to Egypt the exercise of its sovereignty throughout the Sinai....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Communication of Intelligence: The Kennedy Assassination

This report does integrate investigative dealings by the Secret Service to accredit or to help in accrediting the establishment of the President Kennedy's assassin or his motives.... The report reveals various elements of the Secret Service's operations, which are not cumulative public understanding....
12 Pages (3000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us