StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Thin Line between Project Success and Failure - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
People Express Airlines was a low cost airline with its head offices in the North Terminal of Newark International Airport that remained in operation between 1981 and 1987, when it decided to enter a merger with Continental Airlines (Ulrich, Zenger and Smallwood, 1999, p. 112)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
A Thin Line between Project Success and Failure
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Thin Line between Project Success and Failure"

A thin line between project success and failure s Submitted by s: Introduction People Express Airlines was a low costairline with its head offices in the North Terminal of Newark International Airport that remained in operation between 1981 and 1987, when it decided to enter a merger with Continental Airlines (Ulrich, Zenger and Smallwood, 1999, p. 112). The founder of the company was Don Burr and several other people who had resigned from their previous jobs (Hackman, 2002, p. 67). The launch of People Express entailed the use of 737s that flew from Newark to Buffalo, Columbus and Norfolk with other destinations being added a month after the airline was launched. The airline charged a reasonable amount for the people who wanted food or beverages during their travel with sodas being provided for fifty cents per can and honey-roasted peanuts going for the same price (Heskett, 1986, p. 93). On the other hand, the Southwest Airline company is a key company in the US airline industry and the biggest low cost carrier in the world with its head offices in Dallas (Gross and Bjelicic, 2007, p. 78). The carrier began operations in 1967 under a different title and embraced its present tag in 1971. The airline’s workforce included more than forty four thousand people by the end of 2013 while operating almost three thousand flights every day. The airline has been using Boeing 737s since inception with the exception of a few years in the seventies and eighties when it used leased 727s (Roth, 2008, p. 108). Analysis of People Express Airline using the Shenhar and Dvir model of project success People Express Airlines stakeholder analysis Low power/Low interest Low power/ High interest Investors Communities served Financial institutions Environmental issues High power/Low interest Government Oil industry Suppliers Unions High power/ High Interest Employees Customers Competitors Airports Project Efficiency The airline acquired Frontier Airline, which was based in Denver in 1985 making the combined company the fifth biggest airline in the US with main operations in most of the big cities of the country as well as transatlantic routes such as flights to Brussels (Silvia, 2011, p. 259). Throughout this time, People Express also bought out Britt Airways and Provincetown-Boston Airlines, whose operations were limited to the region and had established systems in several areas including Florida. This aggressive acquisition spree placed a huge debt burden on the airline while at the same time; the key legacy airlines improved their yield management systems that allowed them to be more competitive in comparison to People Express in terms of fares (Griffith, 1997, p. 261). Moreover, the integration of the operations associated with Frontier led to struggles in relation to labour with the newly acquired airline and changing to low-fare and no-frills approach isolated the passengers who were already associated with Frontier. Impact on the Customer The airline industry is associated with stiff competition and relatively low returns and in the early years after the industry was deregulated, discount carriers such as People Express came up but after some time they went out of business (OConnell and Williams, 2011, p. 49). When People Express was launched in the beginning of 1981, it served Newark, Buffalo, Columbus and Norfolk, and consequently experienced rapid growth, which allowed it to add flights to Florida by the end of its first year (Sheth, 2007, p. 47). Two years later, the airline started direct flights from Newark to Gatwick airport in London using a Boeing 747 that had been leased. In the beginning, the flights cost one hundred and forty nine dollars each way making the airline an instant success with flights being over subscribed for several months within twenty-four hours of making this announcement. Afterwards, the airline included Montreal-Mirabel and Brussels to its global network. The airline employed a fare system that was simplified where all the seats offered on a particular route cost the same price with very small differences between the peak and off peak fares. Except the premium class seats that were in the overseas flights only, the rest of the seats were all in economy class with the fares being paid when the passengers were already in the aircraft. Direct and Business Failures Pressure from debts forced the airline to make changes to its philosophy as People Express was determined to attract business travellers who did not mind paying relatively higher fares. The aircraft cabins were restructured and restyled to include a first class cabin and a frequent flyer initiative was also instigated. Additionally, the airline abandoned the simplified fare structure and adopted revenue management, which is a more typical pricing scheme for the airline industry. The unsuccessful integration and the huge debts associated with People Express became uncontrollable and in 1986, the company made an announcement regarding its collaboration with an investment bank in seeking buyers for part or the entire airline. A deal that was to see Frontier sold off to United Airlines was not successful since United Airlines was not able to agree to terms with the unions on the ways of integrating staff that previous worked for Frontier and this forced the board of People Express to stop operating Frontier and file for bankruptcy (Fridson, 1996, p. 17). Preparing the Future Ultimately, People Express had no other option but to sell the entire company to Texas Air Corporation for approximately one hundred and twenty five million dollars in cash, notes as well as assumed debts (Hanlon, 2007, p. 82). As a result of the concerns regarding regulatory approval for the buyout, Texas Air bought Frontier’s assets from People Express in a different transaction that was worth one hundred and seventy six million dollars. Consequently, the airline stopped existing as a carrier in February 1987 when all its operations were integrated into the operations of Continental Airlines which was a subsidiary of Texas air under a joint marketing contract. Challenges faced by People Express Airline Inability to achieve cost parity with the other players in the industry resulting from high costs of aviation and infrastructural bottlenecks Imbalance between the demand and supply Lack of a proper differentiation strategy that led to intense competition Price wars in the industry with various airlines including Southwest Airlines Increased levels of leverage costs for the airline Analysis of Southwest Airlines using the Shenhar and Dvir model of project success Southwest Airlines stakeholder analysis Low power/Low interest Low power/ High interest Investors Communities served High power/Low interest Government Oil industry Boeing Suppliers High power/ High Interest Employees Customers Competitors Airports Board of directors Project Efficiency The wide-ranging expansion methodology associated with Southwest Airlines has remained of an organic nature and in 2011, the airline bought out AirTran Holdings, which is the parent company of AirTran Airways, which was among the biggest low-cost planned carriers in the US (Ireland, Hoskisson and Hitt, 2012, p. 123). The acquisition was worth around one and a half billion dollars and it provided Southwest Airlines with a chance to increase its presence in core markets were it had not expanded its operations to yet. The increase in its operations also entailed including newer destinations to its route and providing access to the international leisure markets that were not far from the United States such as the Caribbean and Mexico. A unique feature of Southwest Airlines is the fact that its pilots are not unionized like other pilots in most of the airlines and this does not limit the flying hours of the pilot so a specific period (Pride, Hughes and Kapoor, 2012, p. 308). Impact on the Customer Southwest Airlines is a carrier whose focus is on the provision of point-to-point services, instead of the hub and spoke approach that is associated with the main airlines in the United States (Havel, 2009, p. 333). Point-to-point services provide direct routings through decreasing the number of connections, delays and the overall time of an entire trip. Consequently, almost seventy-one percent of the customers associated with Southwest Airlines took nonstop flights in 2011. During this time, the average trip length for each of the company’s aircrafts was six hundred and sixty four miles in an average time of 1.8 hours. This form of services have also allowed the airline to offer its market regular and appropriately arranged flights with relatively low charges (Verweire and Berghe, 2004). The management of the airline is perceived as the most vibrant in history and numerous analysts in the airline industry consider the policies that are created by the top management in the company as being instinctive and efficient. Direct and Business Success Numerous other unique characteristics are associated with Southwest Airlines that make it stand out from most of the other airlines in the industry. To start with, the airline operates one type of aircraft, the Boeing 737, and this decreases the cost of maintaining its fleet, training as well as costs associated with the inventory to a considerable degree. The company also hedged aggressively on fuel, which enabled it to maximize on profits when other airlines were experiencing losses with the company maintaining a cost per seat mile of 0.12 dollars that is almost twenty-five percent cheaper than what is charged by its competitors. The benefits the airline’s workers are entitled to include profit sharing as well as employee-empowerment that give them a chance to take part in the company’s decision-making (Hill and Jones, 2013, p. 156). The work set-up at the airline is fun and casual and carrier has become famous for asking its candidates at one time to change for wearing suits to Bermuda shorts and those who did so quick enough were hired. Additionally, the company does not enforce a formal hierarchy and it is commonplace to find the pilots helping the flight stewards in checking the passengers in to the plane of cleaning the planes. This form of structure has assisted the airline to achieve the fastest turnaround while being the only airline that does not charge nominal fees if a customer changes the date of their flight. The management of Southwest Airlines at one point emphasized on maintaining the lower cost structure through having a standardized fleet and decreasing the inflight meals as well as entertainment amenities. Nevertheless, the management equally focused on winning the satisfaction of customers, which was demonstrated by its remarkable retention of customers. Preparing the Future Each Southwest aircraft has an average of ninety-four workers at its disposal as compared to the number of workers per aircraft in most of its competitors cases which approximately one hundred and thirty. Regardless of this relatively low number of workers per aircraft, the Southwest staffs serve more than two thousand five hundred passengers every year as compared to the one thousand for its competitors. In maintaining a lean workforce, the company has been able to eliminate a huge percentage of the costs of labour that are incurred by other airlines, while not allowing any inadequacies to affect the smooth operating of its business activities. Pilot unions prescribe limited working hours for specific periods, which affect the pilots of other airlines who affiliated to these unions. This does not affect the pilots who work for Southwest Airlines as they are not affiliated to any Union and this allows them to work without any hindrances. In the application of its point-to-point system, it is commendable how Southwest Airlines has circumvented the airports which are congested therefore not requiring the numerous gates or thousands workers to deal with the myriad of flights that come in and disperse and this has resulted in a decreased proportion in terms of the costs operation of the company. Southwest Airline Strategy analysis Arenas Short-haul, point-to-point service Midsize cities and secondary airports in large cities Frequent departures on these routes Price and convenience sensitive travellers Boeing exclusivity Vehicles Internal development to maintain the airlines culture Differentiators Extremely low ticket prices Convenience Reliability Fun, friendly experiences Economic logic Low cost through high aircraft utilization Limited use of travel agents Lean and highly productive staff Limited passenger service Staging Incremental origin-destination pair expansion from original stronghold in Southwest US Build out existing airports instead of spreading too thin and too fast Risk analysis of Southwest Airline and People Express Both airlines are affected by the same risks as they main operation and strategy is almost the same. Strategy Anticipated benefit Downside Reducing fares and yields Increased demand Price reduction might result in a disproportional increase in the total demand creating an elastic demand Increasing fares and yields More revenue Increase in prices results in positive revenues if demand remains inelastic Increasing number of flights Increased demand Escalates the costs of operation Decreasing number of flights Reduction in operational costs Less frequencies may result in markets losses and lost demand Enhance passenger service quality Increased demand Increases costs of operation Decrease quality of passenger service Decrease in the cost of operation Excess cuts reduce market share and demand Conclusion Critical chain project management provides a chance to initiate the planning of projects well for the first time and companies should make sure they break with their typical traditions of have they have been doing things previously and re-design their projects from the beginning. However, planning is merely half of the story as the real power of Critical Chain Project Management can be demonstrated from the controls that are afforded in the process of the execution in the manner in which Southwest Airlines did it. Very few carriers were better placed to operate in the 80s than People Express which had a cheerful customer service and devoted customers in a period when the Southwest Airlines could not pose significant competition in the industry. A number of the veterans of this airline have the belief that passengers who have fond memories of flight travel during the period when the airline was in operation will return to using the airline in the event that it is re-launched. Initially, the airline had be embraced by travellers as it was charging fares that were inexpensive while at the same time having exceptional customer service which had developed a passion and respect for the people who used the services of the airline. At the time when the airline was still in operation, it only got a chance to expand its services to other destinations where its competitors had been in operation for decades and had already had found newer ways of cutting costs and the customers had already realized that air travel could be inexpensive. Bibliography Fridson, M. 1996, Investment illusions, Wiley, Chichester. Griffith, K. 1997, Industrial forecast, 1998-2000, Fairmont Press, Liburn, GA. Gross, S. and Bjelicic, B. 2007, Handbook of low cost airlines, Erich Schmidt, Berlin. Hackman, J. 2002, Leading teams, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, Mass. Hanlon, J. 2007, Global airlines, Butterworth-Heinemann, Amsterdam. Havel, B. 2009, Beyond open skies, Wolters Kluwer Law & Business, Austin. Heskett, J. 1986, Managing in the service economy, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, Mass. Hill, C. and Jones, G. 2013, Strategic management, South-Western, Cengage Learning, Mason, OH. Ireland, R., Hoskisson, R. and Hitt, M. 2012, Understanding business strategy, South- Western Cengage Learning, Mason, OH. OConnell, J. and Williams, G. 2011, Air transport in the 21st century, Ashgate, Farnham, Surrey, England. Pride, W., Hughes, R. and Kapoor, J. 2012, Business, South-Western Cengage Learning, Mason, OH. Roth, B. 2008, Aircraft family design using enhanced collaborative optimization. Sheth, J. 2007, Deregulation and competition, Response Books, New Delhi. Silvia, J. 2011, Dynamic economic decision making, Wiley, Hoboken, N.J. Ulrich, D., Zenger, J. and Smallwood, W. 1999, Results-based leadership, Harvard Business School Press, Boston. Verweire, K. and Berghe, L. 2004, Integrated performance management, Sage, London. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(A thin line between project success and failure Essay, n.d.)
A thin line between project success and failure Essay. https://studentshare.org/management/1850583-a-thin-line-between-project-success-and-failure
(A Thin Line Between Project Success and Failure Essay)
A Thin Line Between Project Success and Failure Essay. https://studentshare.org/management/1850583-a-thin-line-between-project-success-and-failure.
“A Thin Line Between Project Success and Failure Essay”. https://studentshare.org/management/1850583-a-thin-line-between-project-success-and-failure.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Thin Line between Project Success and Failure

Product or brand success

Product or brand failure In contrary to product success, product or brand failure means that the product in the market cannot meet the customer needs in the market (Hlavacek, Maxwell, and Williams 33).... Basically, product success can be defined as the capability of a specific product to meet the requirements of a consumer in the market.... When defining product success, it is important to consider portfolio management.... In determining product success, portfolio management incorporates or ignores a number of decision making approaches in the business....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Causes of Failures of Construction

This essay presents failure of construction projects whihc is one of the most dreadful consequences that can occur as a result of executing the project as it not only brings a bad name to the parties involved in the execution of the project, but also incurs them a lot of cost and waste of time.... According to the report failure of a construction project can be defined as, the act of falling short, being deficient, or lacking; nonattainment or nonsuccess; nonperformance, neglect, omission; bankruptcy; and loss of vigor or strength'....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Key Factors that Determine Success of any Project

project success is perceived differently by the parties involved which makes it difficult to understand whether a project has met with success.... Belassi and Tukel (1996) contend that a combination of many factors at different stages of the project life cycle results in project success or failure.... ooke-Davies further clarifies that project success is more difficult than project management success because the goals and methods are liable to change....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Iconic Projects Are Virtually Certain to Fail

The above description of a project's success refers only to the general aspects of project success; there is no reference to the benefits that a project may offer to the parties involved – i.... The paper "Iconic Projects Are Virtually Certain to Fail" states that the evaluation of the success/ failure of iconic projects should be based on appropriately supported arguments; the initial requirements of the projects would be taken into consideration.... In the specific iconic project, the failure of the contractor to handle disputes during the development of the project led to failures regarding specific aspects of the project (as already explained)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Causes of IT Failure

However, while IT has become an essential part of the business world, it also carries massive risks for those businesses that use it especially in case of failure.... The failure of IT projects in companies tends to lead to massive losses which are brought about because of the loss of data as well as the inability of the business to receive and carry out orders from its customers (O'Callaghan, 2007).... IT failure is among the most devastating events for companies, many of which invest large amounts of money in it to ensure that they work smoothly....
12 Pages (3000 words) Literature review

Engineering Contribution in Project Failure

The paper "Engineering Contribution in Project failure" describes that the rates of failure for typical machines from industries, 'bathtub' curve and exponential distribution have been essential when explaining the aspect of reliability thus helping engineers to minimize chances of project failures.... The application of the reliability engineering was made effective regarding project Bombardier Q400 aircraft operating QF1466 where its failure was minimized by a group of engineers by applying the 'bathtub' curve which they used to reflect the possibility of the machine failing versus time it is likely to take for the project to fail....
29 Pages (7250 words) Case Study

Common Reasons for IT Projects Failure

The paper "Common Reasons for IT Projects failure" is a great example of information technology coursework.... However, recent research indicates that many of these projects culminate with failure, right from their start.... The paper "Common Reasons for IT Projects failure" is a great example of information technology coursework.... However, recent research indicates that many of these projects culminate with failure, right from their start....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Causes of Failures in Large Construction Projects

Project failure is the inability to meet the objectives and goals of a project.... If a project fails to meet the set time, budget, and quality work, the project has associated with the failure of many issues.... There are various causes of project failure, and each failed project has different failure issues.... It will also identify potential points of construction failure.... It is, therefore, important to meet the estimated time, budget, and quality to construction projects for its success....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us