StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Values and Reality - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The question `Is value a part of the world?’ is completely redundant and it is in

the nature of subjectivity which needs to be altered in perspective…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
Values and Reality
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Values and Reality"

VALUES The question Is value a part of the world' is completely redundant and it is in the nature of ivity which needs to be altered in perspective. Values change from individual to individual, community to community. Values that are cherished by one individual may not be a guideline for another individual at all. Indeed the values which underline the character of one community may not be accepted at all by another community. The concept of values is entire subjective in nature. Values are not there in the world for any observer, one without our human interest in morality.

The test for an objectivity of a property is whether it used in judgements for which there are developed standards of rational argument and whether they are needed to explain aspects of our experience that are otherwise inexplicable. John McDowell thinks that both these test moral properties are in a sense "subjective" but not in a way that undermines their reality. The connection between McDowell's general metaphysics and this particular claim about moral properties is that all claims about objectivity are to be made from the internal perspective of our actual practices.

Characterising the place of values in our worldview is not, in McDowell's view, to downgrade them as less real than talk of quarks or the Higgs boson.Mackie, In Ethics: Inventing Right and Wrong Part I, acknowledges that subjectivism is often thought of as a kind of skepticism. However, he claims that "subjectivism" is also used to refer to a first order normative view. It is the view that each individual ought to do whatever that individual happens to think he should. The term "subjectivism" has also been used to convey different second order views as well.

There are second order linguistic claims about the nature of moral language, of moral terms and moral judgments. Mackie feels the type of second order subjectivism is really a report or expression of the subject's feelings or attitudes. He differentiates his own moral skepticism from this view on two grounds - one that his is a negative claim, and two, that his thesis is ontological, not linguistic. Mackie observes that there is a connection between these differing forms of skepticism; Many people get attracted towards the linguistic type of second order moral skepticism because they already embrace the negative ontological attitude towards objective value.

Mackie's skeptical claim that there are no objective values is consistent with the idea that values are subjective in the sense that they are agreed upon or shared. It may also be that such values can be made universal without being objective. He also distinguishes between objectivism about values and descriptivism. Descriptivism is a view about moral language, according to which, the meanings of moral terms are purely descriptive. It does not involve evaluative or prescriptive component.The descriptivist about moral meaning holds that someone can judge an act cruel without condemning it.

Mackie points out that the mainstream European tradition of moral philosophy since Plato holds that values are objective and also that moral judgments refer to these values and are essentially motivating or action-guiding. This mainstream view of moral discourse implies that descriptivism is false because it implies motivational externalism, whereas the mainstream tradition embraces motivational internalism. Mackie observes the objectivity of moral judgments in the sense that they can employ intersubjectively valid standards.

Since those standards themselves are not valid because they reflect in turn objective values, he maintains his fundamental moral skepticism about the objectivity of values. Value is part of the world and subjectivity is not distinct from it in the traditional understanding. Sources - 1. Mind Value and Reality - John Mc Dowell (Harvard 1998)2. Needs, Values Truth - D. Wiggin's (OUP 1998)3. Ethics : Inventiing Right and Wrong Part I

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Values and Reality Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507865-values-and-reality
(Values and Reality Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507865-values-and-reality.
“Values and Reality Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507865-values-and-reality.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Values and Reality

Quality Management in Green Valley Bakers

In the paper “Quality Management in Green Valley Bakers” the author discusses the quality of their pieces of bread, cakes, and confectionaries for Green Valley Bakers in San Francisco, which will most likely be ratified by the Bread Bakers Guild of America.... hellip; The author states that Green Valley Bakers can not only take full advantage of increased business but also try to reach out to more customers in this season....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Aristotles Criteria and Apology by Socrates

It is therefore the Apology criticizes all forms of art, either performing or verbal or written, by declaring them as strictly against moral Values and Reality.... Consequently, he discards the claim made by Plato in his Apology that human imagination serves as a copy of real natural phenomena, and poetry is the copy of that imagination; consequently, poetic work is mere the copy of the copy of reality, which should not be accepted altogether.... Tragedy and epic, according to him, are the serious, complete and adequate imitation of reality existing in society, and present the true picture of the social traits and characteristics in a serious tone and refined manner....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Reality Television: A Silent Epidemic Contorting Human Values

They are the ones who absorb much more than information, jokes, language, music, sexual preference and lifestyle but, most often, they are exposed to wrong values and virtues that they often deem right, cool and practical.... An author of this paper shall investigate the psychological impact of the reality TV on its audience.... The writer claims that reality shows have a tremendous effect on the way most people value their physical bodies over their mental, social and spiritual disposition....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Philosophy: Real or True Reality

The judgment of reality is subjective in… It is necessarily grounded in the personal experience of pleasure, not in concepts.... Despite the mpts of philosophers to provide universal principles for the classification and judgment of works of art, to find objective criteria for reality in art, Kant is firm that there are no objective rules of taste (King 1997).... The communicability of the mental state of the reality experience is fundamental....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The size of a company is not important for global trade nowadays

But the increased awareness about the western culture because of global trade activities resulted in exchange of cultural Values and Reality shows like television programs are nowadays popular in India, Pakistan and Middle Eastern countries.... For example, reality shows were earlier popular in America and UK like countries....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Teen oriented dating reality shows are undermining the values of our youth

Since the inception of reality television shows, many young people have been flickering through channels on their television sets to look for new dating reality shows.... The result of the explosion of cable programming channels was the mergence of various genres of programming all… Among the most successful programming type has been the reality television programming, especially the teen-oriented dating reality shows....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

A Local Authority Home for the Elderly

The initiative by the Local Authority (LA) to develop a home for them is a value generating initiative that will help promote the quality of life for them while… In addition, it is morally acceptable in the society to have a concern for those with one body weakness or another such as the elderly....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Benefits and Drawback of Fair Value Accounting Measurement

The values of most of such assets are documented at their purchasing price with adjustments for depreciation (for building, plant and machineries etc.... Fair Value Accounting is the valuation guideline introduced by Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) for standardizing the fair value calculations of financial instruments....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us