StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Proponents of Capital Punishment - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The following paper under the title 'Proponents of Capital Punishment' gives detailed information about capital punishment, also known as the Death Penalty, as a sentence punishable by death. It is a punishment for offenses that are considered vitally or fatally harmful…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
Proponents of Capital Punishment
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Proponents of Capital Punishment"

Capital Punishment In USA. Introduction Capital punishment also known as the 'Death Penalty' is a sentence punishableby death. It is a punishment for offences that are considered vitally or fatally harmful (David, R.D. & Mark, D 5). In the United States of America 38 states, the millitary and the Federal government authorize capital punishment. The mode of execution and the criteria for deciding which offenses qualify for capital punishment as well as the age limit vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction and is usually the discretion of the state judicial system. However homicide is universally punishable by death [Daly M, Wilson M. 36]. Other capital offenses include treason, aggravated rape, espionage, large scale drug trafficking and aggravated kidnapping among others. Capital punishment has been a subject of much debate in recent times. The reasons that form the basis of this debate are crosscutting and include moral, religious, practical, philosophical and emotional. Proponents of capital punishment argue that it acts as a deterrent to crime, purges dangerous criminals from the society and that it is definitely more economical to execute than to keep criminals in prison [Megivern, James J 93]. Opponents of capital punishment argue that it does not deter crime, cheapens human life and discriminates along racial and social lines [Lane, Brian and Wilfred Gregg 12]. Others have argued that killing a person for killing another is hypocritical since it brings the state to the same level as the criminal. However, previous research as well as the statistics on crime tends not to support the argument that capital punishment deters criminal activity. On the contrary studies have shown that incidences of homicide are lower in states that do not sanction capital punishment than those that do [Harries KD 22]. This paper examines the practice, the effects and whether or not capital punishment serves as a deterrent to crime. Capital punishment statistics in the US According to the SP file there have been about 15,000 capital punishment executions in the United States since 1600. Over 4,500 of these executions occurred between 1930 and 2000 with an almost 70% of these occurring between 1930 and 1955 [Gall T 15]. The military courts executed 160 errant officers between 1930 and 1961. A massive mass execution occurred on December 1862 where 38 people were killed by hanging in Mankato, Minnesota. Out of the 38 states that sanction capital punishment, Texas has had the largest number of executions - 378 since 1979 to November 2006 [Amnesty International-1997 Executions]: The Federal government has reported less activity in regard to executions and has executed only 3 people for the last 27 years. The Legal Process Once an offender is convicted of a crime that qualifies for the death penalty, the legal course involves four stages: - 1. Sentencing - involves trial like proceeding where a jury decides on the appropriate sentence though it's the judge's discretion to make the final decision [Kerr, Norbert L. and Robert M 33-75]. 2. Direct review. After the sentencing stage the case moves to the direct review level. Here the process is similar to that of an appeal. This court evaluates the decision of the sentencing court to establish the validity of the judgment. If this court does not find fault with the previous judgment from the sentencing hearing, then it ratifies the judgment. If it does find fault then it can void the judgment and/or order a repeat haring. The decision by the court is considered final. 3. The Collateral review. This is the only way that a judgment by the direct review court can be upset. Most states have this form of review. The purpose of collateral review1 is to allow the defendant to dispute the previous decisions on grounds of previously unavailable evidence. 4. Federal habeas corpus. This is the fourth level and is the only exclusive way that a state capital defendant can challenge a death penalty in a Federal court. It exists for the purpose of ensuring that the state courts have done a thorough job and the judgment does not breach the defendant's Federal constitutional rights. Does capital punishment deter crime Traditionally capital punishment has been almost universally adopted by several societies to act as a deterrent to crime. The rationale has always been that since no same person wishes to be executed then the punishment of death would serve to discourage anyone who might think of committing capital offense. The mates of execution have been different in different societies and they had their purpose in deterring criminal activity. Some more crude modes include stoning, crucifying, hangings among many others. In modern times though debate has been rife whether capital punishment still acts as a deterrent for criminals. There has been no evidence in research to relate capital punishment with reduction in crime, neither is there evidence that capital punishment encourages capital crimes. However, some2 have attempted to link crime statistics to the existence of capital punishment. For instance a recent study by Amnesty International suggested that homicide rate is higher in states that sanction capital punishment than in those that are without it. Opponents of capital punishment argue that it does not deter crime in any way [Freedman, M. E. 23]. One of the arguments for this point of view emanates from the fact that the incidences of capital offenses are not higher in states without capital punishment. They argue that this would have been natural outcome if capital punishment served to discourage offenders. Capital punishment is supposed to warn those who would engage in capital crimes. This is the underlying reason why several nations still retain capital punishment. However this opinion is refuted by a counter argument that offenders at the time they are contemplating a capital crime rarely concern themselves with what would happen when they are caught but rather just consider the risk of being caught. Thirdly opponents argue that capital punishment takes away the value of human dignity [Megivern, James J 76]. Executing a person for the offense of killing another does not add value to the victims' dignity. The argument that capital punishment does not deter crime is strengthened by the fact that of recent research that shows that there is no reduction in capital crime or homicide in countries with death penalty as opposed to those without. On the contrary research has revealed that crime incidences are significantly lower in countries without that abolished capital punishment than in those countries that retain it. Other studies have suggested that human beings derive some pleasure from enacting punishment on wrong doers [Everitt, David 16]. This pleasure is not related to whether or not there are any benefits received. Ken Follet reflects this revelation in the novel pillars of the earth where a community has formed a tradition of savoring public executive. Pertinent issues arising from Capital Punishment There has been growing concerns by proponents of the due process in the administration of justice about the issue of people who might inadvertently be sentenced to due for offenses they are innocent of. This concern stems from the fact that more than 70 people previously sentenced to death have been found innocent by higher courts since 1972 and subsequently acquitted [Helen, P. (1993]. This means that there are or have been those who have not been as lucky and died for crimes they never committed. Another issue has been the use of more humane ways of execution. This has been the trend in modern times with the most modern democracies moving towards less painful and less painful ways that are considered more dignified than some of the methods than have traditionally been used. Discrimination along racial, economic lines has also been issues that have elicited much debate in regard to capital punishments in America. Mitigating circumstances. This is an argument that people who end up committing vitally harmful crimes are people with very poor social background like living through domestic violence in childhood, neglect and lack of parental love. These backgrounds produce a lack of aspects of humanity and thus they are not wholly to blame for their crimes. Other pertinent issues pertaining to the death penalty include the length of the legal process, the length of stay on the death row as a condemned prisoner the absence remedial consolation for victims of vicious crimes. Conclusion Despite the fact that there is no evidence that capital punishment deters crime, opinion polls continually reveal that it enjoys support from the majority of the American population. The opponents of the age old kind of punishment have raised important points to support their opinions while proponents seem to cling to an un-provable notion that the retention of capital punishment deters crime. The debate rages on about the penalty with no end in sight with different cases arising that move the American people on either side of the spectrum. References. Daly M, Wilson M. Homicide. New York, NY: Aldine De Gruyter; 1988. David, R.D. Mark, D. (2002). Machinery of Death. The Reality of America's Death Penalty Regime. Routledge, New York. Everitt, David. Human Monsters. Chicago: Contemporary Books, 1993. 7-19 Freedman, M. E. (2006) Giarratano is a Scarecrow: The Right to Counsel in State Post Conviction Proceedings, 91 Cornell L. Rev. 1079, 1097 Gall T. Statistics on weapons and violence: a selection of statistical charts, graphs, and tables about weapons and violence from a variety of published sources. Detroit, MI: Gale Research; 1996. 12-17 Geberth, Vernon. Sex-related Homicides and Death Investigation. CRC Press, 2005. 12 27 Harries KD. Serious violence: patterns of homicide and assault in America. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas Publisher, Ltd.; 1996. 18-25 Helen, P. (1993). Dead Man Walking. Random House. ISBN 0-679-75131-9. Kerr, Norbert L. and Robert M. Bray, eds. The Psychology of the Courtroom. San Diego, CA: Academic Press, 1982. 33-75 Lane, Brian and Wilfred Gregg. The Encyclopedia of Serial Killers. NY: Berkley, 1992. 8-14 Megivern, James J. The Death Penalty: A Historical and Theological Survey. Paulist Press, New York. Stuart, Banner (2002). The Death Penalty: An American History. Harvard University Press. Pp 3-7 Amnesty International-1997 Executions Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Capital punishment the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Capital punishment the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1531762-capital-punishment-the-united-states
(Capital Punishment the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Capital Punishment the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1531762-capital-punishment-the-united-states.
“Capital Punishment the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1531762-capital-punishment-the-united-states.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Proponents of Capital Punishment

Death penalty

Arguments in support and in opposition of capital punishment or death sentence have been on academic discourse and moral as well as religious circles for quite sometime.... For those who support capital punishment, the likelihood of tangible results not being felt, they argue, is as a result of lack of swiftness in executing the convicted culprits.... Marzili reckons that death penalty has been used over the years by different societies across the world as a punishment methodology aimed at deterring possible or would-be-criminals from committing unlawful actions....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Effects of Capital Punishment

Proponents of Capital Punishment argue that the death sentence is a fair and ethically acceptable punishment for offenders who commit intentional murder (McClellan, 231).... Other Proponents of Capital Punishment claim that homicide is evil by executing victims who consciously murder.... For instance, states in the European Union prohibit the exercise of capital punishment.... Application of capital punishment Violent crime according to police information and injured party surveys refers to any offense in which the wrongdoer has some corporal contact with the injured party....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Issues of Capital Punishment

It has been argued by Proponents of Capital Punishment that the approach helps society reduce crime.... Eliminating future dangerousness It has been argued by Proponents of Capital Punishment that executing an individual who has committed serious crimes such as killing, others, stealing, raping, treason among others will eliminate that individual and the society will live with no fear of being raped, killed among others.... "The Issues of capital punishment" paper presents arguments for and against capital punishment and make a judgment on whether the approach is good in deterring people from committing a crime or not....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The Causes of Crime with Special Emphasis on Social and Psychological Factors

This report presents an overview of the causes of crime with special emphasis on social and psychological factors which lead to criminal tendencies.... Further the report discusses the magnitude of crime, patterns, as well as how different crimes are manifested.... ... ... ... The effects of crime are also described although not in depth....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Against Death penalty

Proponents of Capital Punishment argue that instead of giving capital punishment, keeping the hardcore criminals in prison for a lifelong period is highly expensive and meaningless.... ?? (10 Pros and Cons of capital punishment).... He also pointed out that a record number of 56 murderers were executed in 1995 alone, and many of the people in America and the Supreme Court believe that executions are appropriate punishment capital punishment is a controversial topic all over the world because of the immense value associated with human life....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Issues in the criminal justice system: capital punishment

Consequently, there exists a controversy in the adoption and execution of capital punishment.... onsequently, according to the UN website there have been increased calls for the abolition of capital punishment.... However, according to Amnesty International, majority of the world's population is still under the influence of capital punishment.... Thus, most of these nations have been vehemently involved in the propagation of capital punishment....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Capital Punishment as Non-Effective Form of Punishment

The Proponents of Capital Punishment contend that, by killing criminals through capital punishment, we deny the criminals any other opportunity to commit a crime, hence reducing crime in the society; also, the Proponents of Capital Punishment argue that through subjecting criminals guilty of grave crimes to capital punishment, we scare other potential criminals from committing such crimes in future.... he second argument advanced by the Proponents of Capital Punishment is the argument that a death penalty is an effective form of punishment because it ensures that justice is done to both the offended party and the offender....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Do Criminals Deserve to be Treated with Dignity

The same applies to those who have committed serious crimes that warrant death penalties or capital punishment such as murder, defilement, and treason.... In some countries and some states in the United States [such as Alabama, Arizona, Florida, Kansas, Oregon, Texas, and Virginia], the right to life may be legally forfeited if the person had indulged in, or committed a capital crime....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us