StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Fingerprinting Technologies in Forensics - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Fingerprinting Technologies in Forensics" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues on the use of fingerprinting technologies in the sphere of forensics. The scientific evidence that would be considered in this study would be that of DNA testing or fingerprinting…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
Fingerprinting Technologies in Forensics
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Fingerprinting Technologies in Forensics"

Forensics Introduction: The scientific evidence that would be considered in this study would be that of Ddeoxyribonucleic Acid or simply DNA testing, or DNA profiling, or fingerprinting. In real terms the presence of DNA clues in a crime location could make all the difference between return of a guilty verdict, or the exoneration of a suspect. Crime fighters and forensic experts make good use of DNA profiling by matching DNA profiles found at the site of crimes with the DNA records stored in the database of law enforcement authorities. Over the years of its useful application for major tests, and successful accomplishment as a major crime detector, DNA has, perhaps through trials and errors, evolved as a complete science in itself, earning itself a permanent position in the annals of criminal justice procedures. From a humble beginning during the 19th Century without much data support to prove its credibility and usefulness, it has now evolved as an empirical and objective science on its own merits and rights. History and development of scientific evidence: Over the years, it was discovered, perhaps by accident, way back in 1868, by a Swiss biologist called Friedrich Meischer when he was differentiating nucleus properties in pus cells. Since then, DNA profiling has come a long way and has been used to provide due judicial process of justice in many criminal and non criminal cases. The theory that underpins DNA is that it is virtually impossible for the DNA profiles of any two given persons (except biological twins) to be the same. During the mid eighties, Alec Jeffreys and colleagues researching DNA fingerprinting at the University of Leicester arrived at certain startling facts (at that period of history) regarding the fact that “individual differences in based on repeat sequences in DNA.” Do occur that could help in criminal investigation. (Johnson & Williams, 2006). Further it was also seen that “The possibility of deriving DNA from the ‘abandoned property’ of criminal suspects left at crime scene generated huge interest amongst police investigators.” and could even assist result in cracking major criminal cases, where the perpetrators could remain at large due to lack of incriminating evidence against them. (Johnson & Williams, 2006, para.18). Since then, there have been many improvements in determining the speed, efficacy and conclusiveness of DNA profiling and its impact upon society as a composite and complete science. Over time dedicated DNA Scientific Research Centers have also been operationalised to aid and abet solving of social and criminal issues through the deployment of DNA profiling. These efforts have also met with a reasonable degree of success such that DNA fingerprinting has now come to represent a major scientific and anti-criminal breakthrough in recent times. DNA tests have also proved conclusive evidence in absolving innocent suspects who were languishing in jail accused on false and misled charges, while, conversely, setting out punishment to actual criminals who were moving scot free due to lack of circumstantial evidence and material witness to substantiate their crimes. However, DNA profiling was used conclusively to solve a criminal case during 1985 which involved a double murder case in Lancashire. DNA tests proved that the man who had confessed was not the actual killer and finally “Within a year, despite an attempt to evade screening, local baker Colin Pitchfork became the first person convicted of murder in Britain using DNA evidence, and was sentenced to life imprisonment.” (Steinhauer, 2010). DNA technology has gained tremendous boost of technological advancement including latest state-of –the art technology for apprehending criminals and murderers, while at the same time, making sure that the innocent suspects need to be exonerated on the basis of solid evidence. Further the use of DNA as a forward crime fighting strategy has also been ratified by the International Police. According to Interpol, “DNA profiles can be stored and searched across international borders using the Interpol Standard Set of Loci (ISSOL).” (DNA profiling, 2010). How the evidence is generally collected and preserved for trial: The evidence is collected and retained in a manner that could truly evidence its identity and integrity and whenever required allow the evidence to be available for testing and retesting procedures. Further, it is necessary that evidence should be properly and securely packed and stored, not necessarily in plastic containers since plastic retain moisture and this could leave scope for contamination of DNA evidence for production in Court. The following aspects need to be clearly informed in the accompanying documents and /or package in which the evidence is stored: 1. Place and location from where the said evidence has been collected 2. Person from whom the evidenced has been collected – date and time of collection, the identity of the person who had collected the said evidence, with designation, and the method in which it was collected 3. it is to be recorded whether the person’s informed consent was obtained before gaining said evidence and no force or coercion was resorted to obtain the said evidence. If it was gained through Order of the Court, this fact also needs to be acknowledged in the documents. Further it is important that best practices and police guidelines are followed in the retention of the said evidence and it needs to be preserved in its state till such time the due judicial processes are complete. Even after these procedures are exhausted, the formal procedures and rules governing destruction of evidence needs to be observed. The legal issues involved in admission of DNA evidence into trial: Perhaps one of the main issues is the ready and absolute admissibility of DNA evidence- since it cannot be accepted as 100% absolute to testify against a suspect. At best, it could narrow down suspects in criminal cases and list probability but in all likelihood it cannot be accepted as most certain evidence. This could be due to a plethora of reasons, the contamination of evidence being one such fact. Due to handling and storage inaccuracies, it is quite possible that DNA evidence could be contaminated which could vitiate its prospects as a genuine piece of evidence in court admission, for both prosecution and defense. Besides laboratory errors and statistical mistakes could also happen that could render incorrect verdicts if applied. “However, some courts have excluded it from evidence because of problems with the possible contamination of samples, questions surrounding the significance of its statistical probabilities, and laboratory errors.” (DNA evidence-legal history of Dna evidence, 2010). However, it is believed that DNA evidence may serve more appropriately as exclusion evidence, viz. exclude a suspect’s incrimination in a crime, since DNA evidence collected at the scene of crime may not match that collected from an innocent suspect, rather than an inclusion or incriminating one, viz. there is sufficient evidence, beyond reasonable doubt, to prove that both the samples do match. Another risk could be in terms of the fact that if the DNA samples of ordinary people are in police database records, the risk of their being fully or partially matched in future crimes or being linked with DNA samples found in present or future crime scenes cannot be disregarded. This could put even innocent people to risk and embarrassment. Often DNA samples could reveal sensitive, private and confidential data like family links, relationships and propensity to diseases, and often researchers who use such database could gain access to DNA of ordinary citizens without their permission or consent. This is often seen as a flagrant violation of privacy and civil liberty rights of citizens in a free country, like the United States of America. Conclusions: While the question of DNA profiling does seen to have earned its own share of bouquets and brickbats, there is enough evidence to prove that, in itself, DNA is indeed a useful collaborator of investigative fact finding and needs to be put at the positive disposal of such agencies who are actively engaged in pursuing the truth behind social and criminal doings. However, more than blame DNA technology, it is necessary to modify and upgrade the use and enforcement of such technology and use it for common good. The technology, like every other one, is only as good (or bad) as its utilization and therefore, it is intrinsic that legislation predicates it and the legal machinery supports and enforces the due and legitimate enforcement of DNA for human safety and welfare and it needs to serve much more than just as an crime solving device. Reference List DNA evidence-legal history of Dna evidence. (2010). Retrieved September 1, 2010, from http://law.jrank.org/pages/6228/DNA-Evidence-Legal-History-DNA-Evidence.html#ixzz0yER7c6Ir DNA profiling. (2010). Interpol. Retrieved September 1, 2010, from http://www.interpol.int/public/forensic/dna/default.asp Johnson, P., & Williams, R. (2006). Genetic and forensics: Making the national DNA database. UKPMC Funders Group. Retrieved September 1, 2010, from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1351151/ Steinhauer, J. (2010). ‘Grim sleeper’ arrest fans debate on DNA use. The New York Times. Retrieved September 1, 2010, from http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/09/us/09sleeper.html Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Forensics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1569678-forensics
(Forensics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1569678-forensics.
“Forensics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1569678-forensics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Fingerprinting Technologies in Forensics

Discuss and analyze DNA and fingerprinting technologies used in law enforcement today

DNA and fingerprinting technologies used in law enforcement today DNA and fingerprinting technologies used in law enforcement today Current criminals are smarter than the criminals in the past and they have the ability to conduct crimes without leaving any evidences at the crime site.... DNA and fingerprinting technologies used in law enforcement today DNA and fingerprinting technologies used in law enforcement today Current criminals are smarter than the criminals in the past and they have the ability to conduct crimes without leaving any evidences at the crime site....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Digital fingerprinting

This research deals with the improvements in the technological aspects of digital fingerprinting and focuses on its application and contexts as also its uses and processes.... The two techniques show differences in fingerprinting methods as the first patent deals with identification of fingerprints and its applications and the second technique deals with transmission and storage of fingerprints through a mobile device.... This study is based on research questions that will aim to examine the use of digital fingerprinting and such other techniques in crime control and crime investigation and how the methods of storage of digital fingerprints in databases could have an impact on the information accessibility in general....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

DNA Fingerprinting in Molecular Biology

The paper 'DNA Fingerprinting in Molecular Biology' seeks to evaluate DNA fingerprinting, which became one of the fastest known and adapted genetic technologies in the world.... This was the time when scientific technologies were still in their beginner stages, and it was until 20 or so years later that any real inventions and revolutions were to take place in DNA technologies.... These two discoveries were going to affect the entire future of genetic technologies....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Abridged Literature Review

Several studies revealed significant progress in the development of fingerprinting in forensic science, such as the development of an enhanced minutiae-extraction algorithm for an automatic identity-authentication system and a scalable multimedia fingerprinting forensics (Jain, Lin, Pankanti and Bolle, 1997; Lin, Zhao and Ray Liu, 2006).... Relevant literature is presented under the sections: controlled substance examination, fingerprinting, firearm.... inzburg (in Joseph, 2001) maintained that fingerprinting is the best available system of identifying people in the late nineteenth century....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Technologies Used by Police Forces

Later in the years, this is what emerged to be the core of forensics (McElreath et al.... The driving force for the introduction of forensics was to foresee justice prevail because before, the judicial proceedings were just based on evidence coming from victim statements and coerced confessions.... forensics was the better option after jurists and criminologists were convinced that it had standards of neutrality and objectivity.... In addition, forensics could add fairness and precision to investigations as a result scientists and doctors had a partnership with the police so that they could integrate solving crimes and science (McElreath et al....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

The Development of DNA Fingerprinting and Computer Forensics

This paper under the headline "The Development of DNA Fingerprinting and Computer forensics" focuses on the fact that forensic scientists use all the tools and technologies at their disposal to gather and analyze the evidence from criminal investigations.... The question of civil liberties violations is long-standing, and both DNA profiling and computer forensics occupy a decidedly fuzzy area of investigation and require the utmost of care when scientists are gathering evidence....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Magnetic Fingerprinting and Automated Fingerprint Identification

The paper "Magnetic fingerprinting and Automated Fingerprint Identification" states that most forensic investigators are using magnetic resonance fingerprinting as well as IAFAS due to their speed, accuracy, image quality, and success rate, along with the level of conviction.... Even though fingerprint powders are used in dusting for fingerprints at the crime scene, in the recent past the method has been improved with most criminal investigators using computers and magnetic fingerprint powders for fingerprinting....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Forensic Science and Security

This paper ''Forensic Science and Security'' tells that For most people, forensics science is an interesting but confusing field of study which is full of intrigue and mystery.... Individuals should investigate the field of forensics either to learn more about how criminal evidence is gathered.... Furthermore, research has also indicated that different implementations of technologies have assisted in influencing the values of a community....
11 Pages (2750 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us