StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Why Music Is Poorly Rated in the Education System - Literature review Example

Cite this document
Summary
This literature review "Why Music Is Poorly Rated in the Education System" presents a philosophy that focuses on rational and critical investigation of truths and principles of knowledge and conducts with the aim of reconstituting or improving them…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Why Music Is Poorly Rated in the Education System"

Music Philosophy Question 1: Why have a philosophy of music education? Include comment and discuss why music is so poorly rated in the Education system. Introduction As a field of study, philosophy focuses on rational and critical investigation of truths and principles of knowledge and conduct with the aim of reconstituting or improving them1. It seeks to question and search for understanding beyond what is presented at face value2. In essence philosophy helps to refine and clarify understanding3. Nonetheless, it is worth noting that philosophical practice is not confined to the academic discipline of philosophy rather it is extends beyond a subject. Philosophy can be considered as a continuous process and an attitude of exploring and probing whatever is encountered and seeking to reveal the underlying meanings, possibilities and alternatives for action. Essentially, philosophy cuts across all academic and non-academic fields or spheres of knowledge4. Music education is a key area that has been subjected to philosophical inquiry over the years. Hence the emergence of a discipline referred to as the philosophy of music education. Although philosophy of music education is a relatively old discipline, its legitimacy and importance has always been subjected to questioning and critique5. Many argue that a philosophy of music education is required mainly to due the fact that music is poorly rated in the education system. As a result, there is need to have a philosophy of music education in order to rationalise and provide insight on music education6. This paper seek to critically examine why a philosophy of music education is important or required. Firstly, it discusses why music is so poorly rated in the education system. Subsequently, it explores what philosophy of music education entails and critically discusses why a philosophy of music education is important or required. Why Music is Poorly Rated in the Education System Jorgensen (2008) suggests that perhaps one of the reasons why music is poorly rated in today’s education system lies in the fact that teachers face complex systematic problems linked to educational and artistic conflicts. In many education systems, there are endless disagreements on objectives, purposes, assumptions, expectations, methods of musical instructions, standards of testing in music education programs. As a result, there is widespread loss of faith in the quality of music education. Moreover, there is widespread skepticism about the critical purpose of musical and artistical instruction in music education programs7. Moreover, McPherson and Welch (2012) suggest that music may be poorly rated in the education system because some music educator’s pedagogical concepts, assumptions and beliefs are “reason-less” and unjustified. Some educators base their instructions on mere indoctrination, unreflective experience and poor textbooks instead of rational, careful and critical thinking. As a result, music teaching and learning is in some instances misguided, mal-practiced and unethical. They further accentuate on the importance of music education philosophy in order to provide educators with rational and justified pedagogical concepts, assumptions and beliefs on music education8. The challenges facing music education today have largely been caused by the rapid development and changes of music culture, conventions and genres. This has in turn rendered the traditional principles and methods of music education impractical and old-fashioned. Moreover, as the genres of music continue widen and change, the aesthetic backbone of the conventional music education programs continue to lose their importance. As a result, there is need for new starting points in order to replace the conventional ways of thinking. There is need for more comprehensive and wide ranging approaches to music education that will address and complement all types of music genres and styles. Although the music culture changes over time, the conventional starting point of music education has remained unchanged through centuries. Thus there is need to update the basics of music education philosophy, its aims and methods in order to be at par with the changes taking place in the music culture worldwide9. In order for teachers to responsibly and effectively provide music education, they have to determine what students should learn and why. However, many teachers tend to avoid the intensive and introspective process necessary for determining what students should be taught and why10. Bowman (1998) suggest that when teachers fail to engage in philosophical preparation for music teaching by critically and rationally examining assumptions , beliefs and questioning tradition and instead maintain status quo they inevitably contribute to poor rating of music education11. Why have a philosophy of Music Education? In order to effectively understand what philosophy of music education entails, it is perhaps crucial to examine what is philosophy of music. According to McPherson and Welch (2012), philosophy of music entails a sustained, systematic and critical investigation of beliefs regarding the nature, value or function of music. This inquiry deals with a wide range of questions, issues and problems that revolve around the nature and function of music12. According to Reimer (1989), philosophy of music encompasses a comprehensive image of the diverse values and complex nature of music. This in turn becomes relative to a philosophy of music education by providing a picture of how learning is linked to the diverse nature of music and the values that it provides13. Philosophy of music education focuses on recurrent, systematic and critical investigations of assumptions and beliefs of the basis for musical and instructional practices. Bowman and Frega (2012) argue that this practice is key to professional practice in music education. In essence, without philosophy in music education there would be no secure basis for claiming that the instructional approaches and efforts used in music education are congruent and useful. They further argue that without philosophical inquiry, the claim for professional status are rather dubious14. Nevertheless, philosophy of music education extends beyond rationalising and defending specific instructional practices. Instead, it critically examines the processes and aims of musical teaching and learning as they occur15. One of the main benefits of having a philosophy of music education is that it helps to clarify and refine understanding of critical, problematic and controversial issues in music education. Generally, music education philosophy encompasses an open-ended process that focuses on identifying critical practical problems and frames them in such a way that gradually contributes to their resolution16. McPherson and Welch (2012) note that, being a professional and effective music educator demands more than mere formal or informal musical understandings and skills, experience and practical savviness. Although these qualities and abilities are essential, they are not sufficient for effective, ethical, wise and compassionate teaching of music. Effective teaching of music requires educators to develop, update and sustain a professional philosophy guidance system. Therefore, a philosophy in music education is required in order to promote effective, ethical, wise and compassionate teaching of music17. They further note that, given the challenging practical, intellectual and moral issues surrounding music education, it is not surprising that music education has caught the attention of philosophers. For instance, in the “Politics” Aristotle observed that, “It is not easy to determine the nature of music or why anyone should have a knowledge of it.” Drawing on these sentiments, McPherson and Welch (2012) assert that through music education philosophy, scholars, teachers and students can find strategies, concepts and resources that can enable them to clarify key concepts and develop an effective philosophy practice guidance system18. In support of philosophy of music education, McPherson and Welch (2012) argue that an unexamined professional is not worth pursuing. Failure to critically examine the instructional approach used in music education can be dangerous and damaging because what educators do can significantly affect the well-being of learners. Music education philosophy assesses and informs educator’s habits of teaching effectively, ethical, compassionately and wisely. Therefore, philosophy of music education should not be optional, instead it should be central and highly prioritised. Reimer (1989) notes that; “The purpose of the philosophy … is to provide a system of principles for guidance in creating and implementing useful and meaningful music education programs.19” These sentiments accentuate the importance of having a philosophy of music education. As earlier observed in this paper, one of the main reasons why music education is poorly rated in the education system is because there are conflicting pedagogical concepts, assumptions and beliefs on what effective music education instruction should encompass20. As a result, music teaching and learning is in some instances misguided and lacks efficacy21. Philosophy of music education provides an avenue for examining what is working and what is not working as far as music education is concerned. Through continuous, rational and systematic inquiry of assumptions and beliefs of musical and instructional practices suitable approaches creating and implementing useful and meaningful music education programs can be identified22,23. In his article, “What is philosophy of music education and do we really need it? “ Panaiotidi (2002) argues that philosophy of music education is a field of knowledge that helps in clarifying key concepts, fundamental premises and principles of music education. It involves theory building and developing proposition on the right approaches of music education. The article further suggest that there is a close link between philosophy of music education and music pedagogy. On one hand, philosophy of music education continuously scrutinizes the efficacy of music pedagogy. On the other hand, it informs and guides music pedagogies. Over the years, music education programs have benefited from the insight generated from music education philosophy24. Essentially, Panaiotidi (2002) supports the sentiments of Reimer (1989) that philosophy of music education provides a system of principles for guidance in creating and implementing useful and meaningful music education programs25. Conclusion This paper has examined why a philosophy of music education is important or required. It has foremost discussed why music is so poorly rated in the education system and subsequently explored what philosophy of music education entails and why it is important or required. The findings of this paper show that music is poorly rated in today’s education system because in many education systems, there are endless disagreements on objectives, purposes, assumptions, expectations, methods of musical instructions, standards of testing or examination in music education programs. Moreover, many music education programs are based on the traditional principles and methods of music learning, thus they do not meet the needs of a continually changing music culture. In order to address these challenges, this paper accentuates on the need for philosophy of music education. This paper illustrates that a philosophy of music education is needed so as to provide a system of principles for guidance in creating and implementing useful and meaningful music education programs. Furthermore, having a philosophy of music education helps to clarify and refine understanding of critical, problematic and controversial issues in music education. Bibliography Broomhead, P., 2004, “The Problem of Music Education Philosophy for Undergraduates”, Journal of Music Teacher Education vol 14, pp. 20-26. Bowman, W.D., 1998, Philosophical Perspectives in Music, Oxford University Press, New York. Bowman, W.D. & Frega, A.L. 2012, The Oxford Handbook of Philosophy in Music Education, Oxford University Press, Oxford. Dictionary.com, Philosophy Definition, viewed January 27 2015 Jorgensen, E.R., 2008, Transforming Music Education, Indiana University Press, Bloomington, Indiana. Jovunen, M. Ruismaki, H. & Lehtonen, K., 2012, “Music Education Facing New Challenges”, Social and Behavioural Sciences vol 45, pp. 197-205. McPherson, G. & Welch, G.F, 2012, The Oxford Handbook of Music Education, Volume 1, Oxford University Press, Oxford. Panaiotidi, E., 2002, “What Is Philosophy of Music Education and Do We Really Need It? Studies in Philosophy and Education vol 21, pp. 229–252. Navia, L.E. 1999, The Adventure of Philosophy, Greenwood Publishing, New York. Reimer, B. 1989, A Philosophy of Music Education:Advancing the Vision, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Why Music Is Poorly Rated in the Education System Literature review, n.d.)
Why Music Is Poorly Rated in the Education System Literature review. https://studentshare.org/music/2065006-music-philosophy
(Why Music Is Poorly Rated in the Education System Literature Review)
Why Music Is Poorly Rated in the Education System Literature Review. https://studentshare.org/music/2065006-music-philosophy.
“Why Music Is Poorly Rated in the Education System Literature Review”. https://studentshare.org/music/2065006-music-philosophy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Why Music Is Poorly Rated in the Education System

Music in People's Life

music remains an important part of a person's life.... Day in and day out, we all listen to music, whether intentionally or unintentionally.... This brings about two major groups of people, who are active followers of music and passive followers of music (Howell & Costley 2006).... CASE STUDY Name: Institution: Professor: Course: Date: HUMAN RESOURCE CASE STUDY Overview music remains an important part of a person's life....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Comparative Business Systems

Comparative Business Systems: Brazil and Germany Name: Tutor: Institution: Date: Comparative Business Systems: Brazil and Germany Overview of Brazil and Germany National system In 2011, Brazil was identified to be the seventh wealthiest economy with a GDP of 2.... trillion dollars, since it is the largest country with a population of Latin Americans and Caribbean....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

1-2 page critique/summary of an article

The study made use of data collected by the California Department of Education (CDE), found in their website, the California Basic Educational Data system (CBEDS), and the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) Data Explorer (p.... The NAEP Data Explorer allows one to analyze the data they have collected by creating tables, charts and maps of national and state results in 10 subject areas (National Center for education Statistics, n.... A measurement and comparison of the estimated participation in special education, the English Language Learner Reading results of both non-disabled and disabled students, and the estimated participation in alternate assessment were presented by the author (pp....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Challenges of Teaching and Learning Languages

Unless the primary education system is strengthened we will not be able to achieve the right benefits of education and it will merely remain only as a solution to global problems rather than as a means to realize the true potential of an individual (Carroll, 2006).... All these factors together with local conflicts have resulted in a poorer educational system in countries such as Africa and South Asia and in countries with a high population the situation is even worse (Crawford, 1995)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Moderation in Intervention

Also if growth is too rapid it can risk a shock to the system by bursting an economic bubble, like the tech bubble of the nineteen-nineties or the recent housing bubble.... hellip; The author will explain dangers to an economy that inflation, deflation and unemployment present, then why intervention must be calibrated properly....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

The Benefits of Computerizing Employees Records

In each case, I have produced the following information to enable the selected system programmer to design and build the appropriate system.... lient information will only need to be put into the system when they engage our service and updated as and when client details change....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Educational Issues in the Global South

This paper tells that many players in the education arena have claimed for a long that empowering girls could only be made possible through education.... irstly, there are claims that by taking girls to school it helps in ensuring equality in other areas as well besides in education system.... A myriad of challenges by these girls mostly in the global south are evident, and claims are made often that many would greatly benefit if education were given pre-eminence....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

A Critique of In Freemont High School, an Article by Jonathan Kozol

The literary work by Kozol was an eye-opener, and he acted in time to announce the mismanagement in the education system.... It will instigate numerous reforms in the education system with the objective of introducing reforms that will prove helpful to the provision of a bright future.... By pointing out the failures of the education system in California, Kozol gives the readers a clear approach to the problem and supports his arguments with illustrations....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us