StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

'civilization and its discontent, Sigmund Freud - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In Freud’s terms it is impossible tom escape the view that people often use false principles of measure because of their quest for power, success and prosperity for themselves and esteems the qualities in other people while underestimating true value of life…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
civilization and its discontent, Sigmund Freud
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "'civilization and its discontent, Sigmund Freud"

Download file to see previous pages

Freud was controversial and influential and in “civilization and its discontent”, Freud explicitly argues that humankind is violent and cites different terrible instances that suggest part of humankind is violent and he refers to it as “the inclination toward aggression”. Freud suggests that humans were never meant to be happy because what is often referred to as happiness comes from satisfaction of needs, which are currently complex therefore from this nature is possible as episodes.

However, in “Civilization and its Discontents” Freud emphasized the social role of superego in preserving social order by preventing and turning individual aggression against the society which result in increased discontent with civilization. Though Freud has less to say regarding the common defense against guilt; he manages to show that instead of being victims of sadistic superego people become its agent in the name of ideals, laws and ethics. According to Freud (p.66), conscience is one of the three functions of superego; however, Thrasymachus, the sophist, promotes doing away with justice as well as all moral standards when he breaks into the discussion angrily claiming to offer better definition of justice.

Thrasymachus considers justice to be merely an advantage for the strong even though he considers his definition to be not the real definition of justice because it is de-legitimization of justice since he believes that it is not rewarding to be just. Thrasymachus believes that just behavior works for the benefit of other individuals and not the individual who behaves justly; therefore, he considers justice to be the unnatural restraint on people’s desire to have more. Hence, to Thrasymachus justice is a principle forced on people and does not benefit them to adhere to it so the rational thing is to ignore it entirely.

Nevertheless, this view of Thrasymachus promotes injustice as a virtue because the perception of life from this view is that life is a continuous competition for more money, power among others and individuals who possess much in the struggle have the greatest virtue. As the discussion progresses, its burden shifts from the challenge of defining justice to defining justice in a way that is proven and worthwhile. In “The Republic” Socrates tackles the challenge of describing justice and injustice throughout the discussion (Lear 186).

Nevertheless, Thrasymachus manages to show that justice is never universally presumed to be valuable because there are individuals who this it better to look out for their interests instead of following rules. Thrasymachus claim points down to general sophistic moral concept that norms and mores considered just are mere conventions that hinder individuals who adhere to them while benefitting those who flout them. Thrasymachus does not only make assertions that norms of justice are conventions but also claims that the norms are conventions promoted by rulers for their interests and keeping the subjects in oppression.

In countering Thrasymachus claim, Socrates has various arguments against Thrasymachus claim the first argument involves making Thrasymachus admit that he advanced injustice as a virtue where life is a competition. Socrates also launches another long and complex chain of reasoning that results in him concluding that injustice can never be a virtue since it remains contrary to the virtue of wisdom. Injustice goes against wisdom since wise men like men skilled in some art do not seek to thrash out those that possess similar skills in the same art; as well, mathematicians are never in constant competition with each other.

Socrates moves to another argument from the understanding that justice involves adherence to certain rules that enable similar

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“'civilization and its discontent, Sigmund Freud Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1486599-civilization-and-its-discontent-sigmund-freud
('Civilization and Its Discontent, Sigmund Freud Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1486599-civilization-and-its-discontent-sigmund-freud.
“'Civilization and Its Discontent, Sigmund Freud Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1486599-civilization-and-its-discontent-sigmund-freud.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF 'civilization and its discontent, Sigmund Freud

Civilization and Its Discontents

In the paper “Civilization and its Discontents” the author gives Freud's introduction of civilization and its discontents' texts as the irremediable antagonism that exists between various demands of instinct and the restrictions surrounding civilization.... This shows that Civilization and its Discontents is a great contributor to the Western culture's literature.... hellip; freud explains that his book does not just barely touch on civilization and instincts, but covers the whole concept and theory of human behaviors, explaining why people behave as they do, with reasons explaining why even the best-intended of people's actions give the impression of having hindered human beings in their life....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Civilization and Its Discontents

This essay talks about the central thesis of sigmund freud's "Civilization and its Discontents" which is the assertion that the conflict between sexual needs and the societies restrictions is a big factor to human “dissatisfaction, aggression, hostility and ultimately, violence”.... Civilization and its Discontents & Bury Me Standing: The central thesis of sigmund freud's Civilization and its Discontents is the assertion that the conflict between sexual needs and the societies restrictions is a big factor to human “dissatisfaction, aggression, hostility and ultimately, violence”....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Freuds Assumption of Individual Grievance to Civilization

But essentially their journey symbolically turns into one In the jungle, the Id, being liberated from the restrictions of freud's Ego and Superego that modern civilization sets for the individuals to prevent both individual and collective social unhappiness, appears before the characters with all its monstrous and raw natures.... Dickey's characters' implicit and underlying grudging against the monotony of civil life has its basis in freud's assumption of man's relationship with his surroundings....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Analyzing Between a Film and Freudian Theory

Civilization and its discontents largely dwell on the superego, ego, and the id nature of humankind that mainly aims at benefiting one's desires but fails to protect the surrounding environment (Heffner).... According to Freud in his analysis of Civilization and its discontents, civilization is built upon human instincts.... Scientists and psychoanalysts regard freud as an important person shedding lots of information regarding human behavior....
7 Pages (1750 words) Movie Review

Civilization by Sigmund Freud

This is a commentary of his Civilization and its Discontents, which creates the context about his unenthusiastic aspect of non-resolvable… Part 1 of his book presents his sociological appliance of psychoanalysis.... In Civilization and its Contents, he describes (I) the conflicts that occur between individuals' social rules and sexual argues that helps them to endure, and (ii) Thanatos, which is a key self-destructive instinct of death, which has overwhelming social consequences when directed outwards....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Civilization and Its Discontents by Sigmund Freud

The paper "Civilization and Its Discontents by sigmund freud" states that an aspect of the book that needs further clarification has to do with the state of human freedom before civilization.... hellip; Dwelling more on the individual, freud holds the opinion that the laws that came with civilization have come to suppress human innate satisfaction to a very large extent.... Until now, I still hold the opinion that it is culture rather than a civilization that makes the individual discontent....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review

Frankenstein by James Whale and Freud

hellip; According to sigmund freud, human beings are under control of the id, the ego, and the superego that controls the desires and satisfaction.... Civilization and its discontents (Freud) largely dwells on the superego, ego, and the id nature of humankind that mainly aims at benefiting one's desires but fails to protect the surrounding environment (Heffner).... This paper tells that freud defines the id as the set of the uncoordinated instinctual trend....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Nietzsches and Freuds Views on Sexual Identity

n turn, the sigmund freud also regards the issue of sexuality and sexual identity.... From the paper "Nietzsche's and freud's Views on Sexual Identity" it is clear that Nietzsche serves primarily as a moralist.... Here freud refers to a certain Nietzschean theme: the subordination of powerful people to morality.... If Nietzsche considers sexuality in general as one of the most important spheres of human life worthy of self-expression, freud examines sexual identity within the framework of his theory of libido (sexual energy)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us