StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This research paper “Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College” examines the abolition of the Electoral College system of voting. This system also advocates for the two-party system. This closes up democratic space, while dividing the country along red and blue lines…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College"

Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College The Electoral College system of voting was established in the Constitution of the United States to vote for the President and the Vice President. This was later amended in 1804. It is a system of voting where, according to Article 2, Section 1 Clause 2, each state is given electors equivalent to the members it has in the House of Representatives in addition to one elector for each of the two Senators (Burg 18). When voters elect Presidential candidates they are, by extension, instructing the electors from their state to vote in favor of the same candidate (Hewson 41).

This system has, however, been criticized due to weighty reasons.The abolition of the Electoral College system of voting would be better for the electoral landscape. The first reason is that this system leads to gross inequality in the issuance of campaign resources (LeVert 74). Larger states receive more funding for campaigns. Secondly, it is also on record that smaller states are accorded more electoral votes. This gives the notion that some states are more politically important than others.

The minority are given a louder electoral voice than the majority. Wyoming has 3 votes with a population of 532,668 citizens against 32 votes for Texas which has approximately 25 million people. Wyoming has an elector for every 177,556 people, while Texas has one for every 715449. This shows unequal representation. It is clear that a majority of the population may endorse a candidate, but the Electoral College system deprives the larger population of the ability to decide their leadership (Burg 155).

This system also advocates for the two-party system. This closes up democratic space, while dividing the country along red and blue lines (Burg 109). It is important to note that other political parties exist in the US, but are not given the support given to the Republican and Democratic parties, despite having positive ideals for the American people. Advocates for the electoral system have argued that this system spreads votes, preventing candidates from concentrating their campaigns in places with high population density.

Another defense has been that the system allows the different states to determine and design their own voting regulations, and the freehand to change them whenever they see it necessary to do so. Another argument is that the system maintains political stability by supporting the two-party system (Hewson 88). However, these arguments do not address the main issues that touch on the voters, like their freedom to vote for their choice for President and economic issues. For instance, the four decades of the embargo between the US and Cuba has denied farmers in the western states from selling their produce in Cuba.

If the votes of the people in these states, where the embargo is unpopular, were considered by use of the popular vote, the embargo may not have lasted as long, meaning less economic losses for these states and the country at large. The Electoral College system of voting has been seen to award victory to candidates who have lost the popular vote, like George W. Bush in the 2000 elections. This system goes contrary to democracy as stipulated in the constitution. Therefore it would be more beneficial to use the popular vote method over the Electoral College system.

This is because every voter would have one vote (LeVert 34). In addition, candidates would have to visit all states, big or small, to get votes as every vote would count.Works CitedBugh, Gary. Electoral College reform challenges and possibilities. Farnham, Surrey, England: Ashgate Pub., 2010. Print.Hewson, Martha S.. The Electoral College. Philadelphia: Chelsea House Publishers, 2002. Print.LeVert, Suzanne. The Electoral college. New York: Franklin Watts, 2004. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College Essay”, n.d.)
Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1634753-how-would-eliminating-the-electoral-college-impact-presidential-politics
(Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College Essay)
Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College Essay. https://studentshare.org/politics/1634753-how-would-eliminating-the-electoral-college-impact-presidential-politics.
“Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1634753-how-would-eliminating-the-electoral-college-impact-presidential-politics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Impact of the Elimination of the Electoral College

Crime Mapping

The purpose of this analysis is to get the comprehension of the crime incidents so that an attention of police may be put in place which efficiently targets a definite attention of crime.... A report derived from this analysis will bring to light opportunities for police administrators to assign policing assets, possibly for a precise intervention plan....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Proposal

Direct Democracy in California

The people had developed social unrest causing political mayhem due to the injustice carried out by the governments.... The main reason of… Moreover, during this era, women were not allowed to vote and thus there they were not allowed to make public decisions.... In addition, the progressive era aimed at Moreover, this era advocated for scientific approaches to decision making as well as medical and engineering solutions....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Voter ID: The Social, Economic, Legal and Political Aspects of Voter ID Laws

It is evident that the state also accepted personal care home identifications, or college identifications provided the documents were current with the expiration dates indicated.... The author argues that despite the voter identification laws being advantageous and disadvantageous, it is essential that the laws are implemented to enhance a successful electoral process.... The laws should be implemented in Ohio to ensure that all voters intending to participate in an electoral process provide an election proof, which is the voter identification to an election official at the polling station, in order to, be allowed to vote....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Analysis of Electoral College Process

The US presidential election is always determined by the 538 members of the electoral college.... The US presidential election is always determined by the 538 members of the electoral college.... the electoral college really favours the states, since it ensures there is more attention to the less populous states which would otherwise be at the risk of being sidelined and ignored by the presidential candidates.... All in all the electoral college has always helped magnify the scope of the incoming candidate's victory and for someone entrusted with the most high-profile job in the world, an additional boost of legitimacy cannot be underestimated....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Policy brief on Poverty and Development in Argentina

This paper talks about Argentina which despite being a relatively rich nation still remains a country having a relatively high rate of poverty.... here are various strategies that the Argentina government can adopt in order to reduce poverty levels in the country.... … According to the report the growth process of Argentina has further been slowed down due to the recurrence of the financial economic crisis that happened in the year 1995 and 1998....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Czech Republic and Belgiums Participation and Representation in the European Parliament

Proportional representation is applied in the electoral system.... In this election (European parliament), Belgium comprises of three electoral districts.... It began as a simple assembly of national parliaments that were appointed to the European Parliament.... The direct election began in 1979 and since then, it has become the only… This parliament has progressively been transformed from being a purely consultative body into a legislative one....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

The Impact of Increasing Oil Prices on Selected Sector/S of International Business or Travel

The proposal shows the background information about the impact of high oil prices all over the world.... While the purposes of various studies conducted were varied, one specific concern was to analyze the impact of oil consumption resulting from the fact that there is an increased fuel energy scarcity compared to the increasing demand....
14 Pages (3500 words) Coursework

Political Programs and Methods

By far the most used, and commensurately the most powerful, is to band together with other like-minded interest groups as a means of pooling resources and seeking to create a maximal impact on the way in which public policy is crafted.... The paper "Political Programs and Methods" highlights that issues relating to equal rights, equal pay, and other issues relating to equality were also approached from the standpoint of ensuring that a truly free and equal society would fulfill the tenets of equal representation under the rule of law set out to establish....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us