StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Job Design Scoring Matrix - Report Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper 'Job Design Scoring Matrix' tells that The rank order is very apt and appropriate. The first case has been ranked as the lowest on the MPS score chart, and the second case has been ranked as the highest on the MPS score chart. Point one is the AJ and the Housing Authority case…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
Job Design Scoring Matrix
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Job Design Scoring Matrix"

Job Design Scoring Matrix Case # Skill Variety Task Identity Task Significance Autonomy Feedback from the job MPS score Rank Order 1 3 6 3 90 42. 5 3 4 6 1 196 1 3. 1 1 5 4 4 112 3 4. 2 1 3 5 4 120 2 Appropriateness of the rank order: The rank order is very apt and appropriate. The first case has been ranked as the lowest on the MPS score chart and the second case has been the ranked as the highest on the MPS score chart. Case one is the AJ and the Housing Authority case. This case is low on skill variety and task identity. The task allocated is monotonous with little or no variation. There are no working units under AJ hence he low rating on task identity. Case 2 is f Mike’s computer services. This case is high on motivational score. This is because of the immense skill variety that Mike gets to exercise on his job. There is a lot of autonomy provided to him and his work is divided into units. This job is high on motivation and Mike is more likely to be satisfied when on job. Enriching Jobs: Case 1: AJ works for the Housing Authority of a large city. His job is to screen applicants and send them on to either a Section Office that controls placement in a region of the city or to another agency which provides additional services that the client may need. AJ interviews people and takes their financial and other data. He then decides what to do with the potential client—to place them in housing and/or to provide them with some other service such as drug and alcohol rehab, etc. AJ sees a large number of clients each day. He rarely finds out what happened to any of his clients. Were they were placed in appropriate housing; did they received the services he recommended? He does get a report on a monthly basis that basically tells him how many people he saw, how many went here or there, how many finished which programs, etc. He never knows, though, what happened to any specific individuals AJ’s case ranked lowest on the MPS score. This job is very high on autonomy but very low on skill variety and task identity. It is not challenging enough and there is a certain amount of stagnancy when it comes to this job. Skill variety brings about high intrinsic motivation. Managers can implement it by combining job tasks. The Housing authority needs to give AJ a bigger conglomerate of tasks to be performed. This will improve both skill variety and task identity for AJ and he will be able to derive more meaningful experience from his work. Case 2: Mike is a computer services specialist in one school within a university. He handles many of the “general” needs of the faculty and staff within that school. People call him for any problem they might have with their computer. If it is a specialty problem such as with a server, the problem or the client will be referred to the specialist who handles that problem. He also helps with installing equipment in classrooms and offices. Additionally, he serves as the technical advisor to the School’s Technology Committee. Normally, Mike gets 20 to 30 calls a day. Some require just a short conversation to figure out the problem and solve it, and a few are more complex or unique and call for careful problem solving, sometimes involving the other technical services specialists and occasionally the information systems manager. Occasionally, Mike must work overtime to get everything done. Mike has several tasks that he considers “beneath him” such as servicing printers, installing software packages, and solving simple “how to” software problems that “faculty ought to be smart enough to figure out for themselves.” Mike’s case was the best case of the four cases. It is high on motivation score and has high scores on almost all job dimensions except for feedback. Mike’s university should open feedback channels for Mike to excel in his job. He should be provided with regular performance appraisal and feedback to be able to excel in his job and grow beyond what he has already grown thus far. As a result not only will he refrain from abstaining from work but will also ensure that he keeps improving in his performance. Case 3: Missie works for the Commercial Capital division of one of the largest appliance companies in the world. She calls on clients—who are typically retail stores that sell the company’s appliances and borrow from the company to pay for their large shipments—to collect payments. The computer automatically calls up the names and phone numbers of clients who need to be called each morning. Missie spends her whole day in front of the computer calling clients, handling client complaints and questions, and recording comments the clients make about their payments into the data base. When something out of the ordinary occurs, such as when a client says some material was damaged and they are not going to pay for it, Missie must go to her supervisor. Actually, Missie has been doing this for so long, she knows how to handle almost every situation that comes up; but the supervisor requires that Missie bring the problems to her. The problem is that each situation takes much longer to process, and Missie has to hang up, talk to the supervisor, and then call the client back. Doing this causes her to often get behind; and the supervisor puts a lot of pressure on her to finish the work that the computer assigned in the morning. Missi’s job is the second lowest on diagnosing motivating potential score. She works for a company that sells its equipment to retail store clients. Her job is low on skill variety and task significance. Job autonomy is significantly less as there is constant reporting to the boss. It is not challenging enough and there is a certain amount of stagnancy when it comes to this job. Skill variety brings about high intrinsic motivation. Managers can implement it by combining job tasks. The medium of communication needs to be changed to a more formalized reporting system. Case 4: PollyAnna works as a receptionist at Dewey, Cheatem, & Howe, a big law firm. One of the founding partners, Mr. Cheatem, didn’t like the new telephone answering system that was installed last year, and he insisted that the firm have a real person for clients to talk to when they called in. So PollyAnna was hired to answer the telephone and to forward calls to the appropriate person. She also acts as receptionist in the lobby. When people walk in and ask for a specific lawyer, she calls the office, and the lawyer’s assistant who comes to the reception area and meet or speak with the person. The good thing about Anna’s job is the level of autonomy offered to her. The bad thing is the negiligible amount of skill variety in her job. This makes Anna’s work monotonous. There is single channelized way that she is compelled to follow every time. Her managing department needs to add more color and variety to her job. Analysis of findings: Case 1 ranked lowest on MPS score and case 2 ranked highest on MPS score. The results showed that most jobs were low on MPS score because they were low on skill variety and task significance, thus highliting the importance of both these dimensions of job to job enrichment. Works Cited Diana Cordova, Mark Lepper. Intrinsic Motivation and the Process of Learning:Beneficial Effects of Contextualization, Personalization, and Choice. 1995. Harter, Susan. A New Self-Report Scale of Intrinsic versus Extrinsic Orientation in the Classroom: Motivational and Informational Components. 1981. Whyte, Cassandra B. Effective Counseling Methods for High-Risk College Freshmen. Measurement and Evaluation in Counseling. 1979. Lauridsen, K. (editor) and Whyte, C.B. An Integrated counseling and Learning Assistance Center.New Directions Sourcebook. Jossey-Bass, Inc. 1980. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Job Design Scoring Matrix Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Job Design Scoring Matrix Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/professional/1746737-diagnosing-motivating-potential
(Job Design Scoring Matrix Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Job Design Scoring Matrix Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/professional/1746737-diagnosing-motivating-potential.
“Job Design Scoring Matrix Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/professional/1746737-diagnosing-motivating-potential.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Job Design Scoring Matrix

Visual Analysis Art

Confirmable from, A University of Tradition: The Spirit of Purdue, while in terms of aesthetic value, the structure achieves great scoring in terms of points; however, the president of the Purdue and the university architect had to absorb certain amount of pressure and complaints directed to them due the hindrance notable in the project.... Name: Professor: Course: Date: Introduction Art analysis attempts to evaluate the artistic sanding of the art or design and its effectiveness in communication of the anticipated message....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Keyboard Is the Primary Input Device

The paper "Computer Keyboard" tells us about one of the primary input devices that most modern computers use for the input of data/instruction.... There are a series of changes that a keyboard has gone through within around 130 years that a keyboard was first invented.... hellip; The keyboard has seen various formats including the one that had the letters arranged sequentially and the others most of which were designed in such a manner to increase the typing speed and reduce the movement of fingers as far as possible....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The Internet and its business capabilities

Entrepreneurship is the creation of new enterprise (Low & MacMillan 1988) and in most cases these are often small businesses employing fewer than 500 people (Bartol & Martin 1998), which would include CepatPrint as it employes fourteen people.... CepatPrint is targeted at small and medium sized businesses (SMEs) and this in itself reflects the contributory aspects of entrepreneurship, as small businesses are known to contribute to: economic growth by fuelling business start ups (Bartol & Martin 1998); contribute to innovation (Aldrich & Auster 1986); create employment opportunities; offer an alternative avenue into business for women and ethnic minorities (Bartol & Martin 1998) and generate hom… e businesses (Zimmer & Scarborough 1996)....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Project Management Methods

This research works on the existing literature and tries to identify the various reasons behind the failure of IS projects.... The methodologies adopted by the teams for project execution leads to a number of issues during the course of the project.... This has been analysed and a survey conducted to identify the major causes for project failures....
28 Pages (7000 words) Essay

Ship Propulsion Systems: the Options

The design of the propulsion system to be used on any ship is dependent on the requirements of the vessel (Harvey, 2007 pg 55).... This system was the first propulsion design created, and thus was used in almost all ships in the earlier days.... In determining the options that are there in the ordering process of the four… This will aid in weighing out the technology that will be efficient and with minimal controversies....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Entrepreneurship: CepatPrints Entrpereneurial Challenge

The author of the paper titled "Entrepreneurship: CepatPrints Entrepreneurial Challenge" analyzes and looks at how CepatPrint can capitalize on the opportunities offered by the Internet for its distribution channel, order fulfillment and market presence.... nbsp;… -commerce has enabled businesses to conduct transactions over the internet as it enables instant communication and interaction, as well as providing real-time access to information, products, and services....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Value Chain Management

The strategy of differentiation needs to be developed regarding price, image, support, quality, and design....  This paper "Value Chain Management" discusses developing and making the organization achieve its objectives in a systematic way by cost advantage with maximum benefit....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Defending in and around the Penalty Area

The author of the following paper states that UEFA Champions' league remains to be one of the most coveted soccer tournament of all times, and each team that qualifies to participate in this tournament does anything within their ability to win each game.... hellip; This paper is aimed at analyzing the match between Liverpool and Real Madrid that took place on 22nd October 2014 at Anfield....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us