StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Dishonoring a Persons Moral Rights - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The "Dishonoring a Person’s Moral Rights" paper states that dishonoring the human rights of a clinically alive or functionally dead patient should not be a choice. It should not create further moral dilemmas in our society. There should be a law to finally lead us to address the current issue. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
Dishonoring a Persons Moral Rights
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Dishonoring a Persons Moral Rights"

Download file to see previous pages

The question of moral rights is a long-debated issue. Many have argued about the extent of moral rights but the issue still remains a moral and ethical dilemma in the present society. When a dying person’s chance to live is almost gone and hospital bills keep running without assurance that the patient can be revived. Dishonoring the right to live in lieu of practical reasons, the situation presents both moral and ethical dilemmas.

 In his book, Gazzaniga (20) points out that since there is no consensus on when consciousness actually begins, there is likewise no definite time as to when consciousness ends. Following this, he raises the view that determining the end of consciousness should then serve as an indication that a person has no chance to live, hence giving others the right to dishonor the patient’s moral rights.

Many neuroscientists agree that there is a certain state when a person loses consciousness. In particular, brain trauma or severe dementia could lead a person to be entirely unconscious of what is happening around him. The meaning of consciousness could lead to a better view of the issue. By consciousness, we mean, “attentiveness,” or “a state of arousal.” A person who is unable to attentively do mental processes is therefore considered unconscious. Gazzaniga further explains that a person who is unable to process cognition is considered “incapable of morally or ethically being engaged in anything” (27-28).

The patient loses his human characteristics owing to the inability to use the brain. This leads to the impossibility of exercising moral rights, leading them to be considered irrelevant and useless. A person’s moral rights should then be revoked because they are useless in the given situation. To elucidate, if a plant seizes to grow and has withering leaves, it will soon decay, even if one waters it every day and exposes it to sunlight. If it dries up and all its leaves fall, leaving the branches, it will have no use so it would be better to unroot it and plant another tree in its place.

If the owner wishes to retain it, with all its dryness and sullen appearance, he is not keeping it for its purpose as a tree but for sentimentality, which could be both impractical and unreasonable. Similarly, if a person ceases to function normally, the person will eventually die, thus prolonging hospitalization or clinical treatment will not matter or have an effect on him. Moreover, if the family decides to keep the patient with severe dementia in bed without the latter living a normal life, they are only behaving like the tree owner who wishes to keep the person for sentimentality or moral decency.

In this case, the purpose of life is gone, and morality can be all the more questioned. Further to the issue of when a person loses the ability to control brain processes, Gazzaniga elaborates that this happens when “the nervous system can no longer sustain the cardiovascular function on its own” (28). Although some may contest that consciousness ends before the nervous systems reach such a point, it is rational to believe that the chance to live is similarly gone. The person will die no matter what, and the only incentive is that relatives can see him longer. In such a situation, it will also be unfair to the patient because he is kept for a different purpose. To make it worse, the family will have to pull up resources in order to afford clinical services. 

Relevantly, if the patient is in a charity ward, he will be wasting resources that should be spent on other patients. Such a situation may be more immoral and unethical to bear for both family members and physicians.

 Another issue that needs to be addressed is, “Up to what point should society honor the will of a person?” This is applicable when a person has given will before the severity happened. In this regard, it should be emphasized that the will of a normal-thinking and behaving person is different from that of a severely demented person. Those of the latter are only brought about by stimulus-response processes. Meaning, they are not products of rationality or human brain processes. Such can be compared to the brain processes of animals. Therefore, they should neither warrant consideration nor should they affect moral and ethical standards. 

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Moral Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Moral Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1496426-moral-dilemma
(Moral Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Moral Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1496426-moral-dilemma.
“Moral Dilemma Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1496426-moral-dilemma.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Dishonoring a Persons Moral Rights

Analyzing Cause and Effect: Antigone by Sophocles

"Causes and Effects of moral Conflict in Antigone" paper argues that Antigone asserts that the causes of moral conflict in the play are the complex differences in what morality is and who should define and control it.... The main causes of moral conflicts are differences in duties and laws.... Another cause of moral conflict in the play is the conflict between duties to the gods and duties to the state.... he main causes of moral conflicts are differences in duties and laws....
22 Pages (5500 words) Essay

Major Issues in the Professional Code

The reports indicating that the patient was uncooperative depicted that the moral rights of the nurse were not followed.... With reference to the case, there are two types of deontological ethical theories, duty theories and rights theories.... went to seek treatment, she could have respected the patient bill of rights.... This clearly shows that her rights are being violated with respect to the rights theories....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Dental Aspects of Oral Cancer

This research paper "Dental Aspects of Oral Cancer" highlights fundamental concerns pertaining to dental processes and oral cancer.... The phenomenon of oral cancer is quite extensive as it destroys the entire oral setup of an individual.... These include the mouth, tongue, cheek, and teeth.... ... ...
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Mans Laws vs Gods Laws in Antigone by Sophocles

Antigone stands upon her rights saying: "Isn't a man's right to burial decreed by divine justice I don't consider your pronouncements so important that they can just.... The play Antigone is based on the conflict between two laws, and forces the audience to decide whose law is greater: God's or man's Thesis Facing the characters with a moral choice, Sophocles depicts that God's laws are more important for people because they reflect eternal truth and morality while man's laws are based on power and authority of the ruler only....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

Secret Master Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite

Simply, what has transpired so far for this Master Mason is of less importance than the great step he now seeks to take.... The preparation, symbolism, ceremony, and indeed the power of this ritual encompasses a whole life-changing experience.... The neophyte stands on the threshold of knowledge and a great depth of understanding, as Pike states: ...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Woman at Point Zero by Saadawi and Chronicle of a Death Foretold by Marquez

The paper "Woman at Point Zero by Saadawi and Chronicle of a Death Foretold by Marquez" explores the extent fate is a part of the protagonist in 'Woman at Point Zero' by Saadawi and 'Chronicle of a death foretold' by Marquez dictated by the moral values of the culture in which they live.... In Chronicle of a Death Foretold the moral value in question is honor whereas in Woman at Point Zero it is the attainment of power.... imilarly, honor as a moral value affects the lives of all the major characters in Chronicle of a Death Foretold as they exist in relation to a single major event....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Lens and Artifact from Letter from Birmingham Jail and Antigone

These two characters argue that they are fighting for human rights which they feel have been denied to them.... The paper discusses the incidence of civil disobedience in the dialogue presented by MLK and Antigone.... MLK expresses civil disobedience in the form of a letter while Antigone gets the chance to express her disobedience to the King in person....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Education and Law

Students should return the favor for moral and legal reasons.... The paper "Education and Law" highlights that teachers have a legal responsibility towards their students.... Teachers are supposed to keep student information confidential and increase their contact on a daily basis to boost performance....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us