StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Ethical Aspects of Cloning - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay “The Ethical Aspects of Cloning” appeals to the fact that even if the child, tragically deceased, could be cloned, his copy would be a clone only biologically, because a new environment and circumstances would form a new personality that is not identical to his predecessor. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
The Ethical Aspects of Cloning
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Ethical Aspects of Cloning"

Cloning The debate regarding cloning has been raging for over a decade, and the core issue of the debate is ethics. The argument is largely between science and religion, and the possibilities of cloning strike a strong emotion in many who consider it. The very idea of cloning human embryos has initiated new laws in nations where no provisions were made for such an advanced scientific achievement, and even the bible has no reference to it; the Ten Commandments say “Thou shalt not kill,” but nowhere does it say, “Thou shalt not create.” Margaret Talbot (New York Times magazine, 2001) embarked on a bold and delicate journey to explore the issues behind human cloning for the purposes of recreating lost loved ones. Beginning with an example of the death of a 10-month-old baby boy caused by something going wrong during a minor operation. The parents of the infant want to clone him, giving the reason that he should have a chance of life. Although they are a healthy, fertile couple with the ability to produce another child, they do not want another child. They want that child. Talbot goes on to wonder if people realize that creating a genetically identical copy of a human does not mean that the clone will be the same person, only a replica. The idea of cloning a human being for the purposes of replacing what was lost is ludicrous in my opinion. First of all, as Talbot’s article states, the clone would not have the same memories or necessarily the same personality as the original. A good case in point to demonstrate a difference in personality between an original human and a clone would be identical twins; they are genetically alike, yet they have different preferences, different personalities and sometimes are so different that they may as well have come from different families. It is easy to become so familiar with a person, a pet or a friend that to associate anyone or anything that looks like them is associated with the original, with expectations of sameness. This is a very basic human reaction and the desire for continuity. Religious or spiritual beliefs aside, everyone and everything is unique, even if similar. I believe that the exclusively human abhorrence of death is the core of the desire to clone a child or person from the original. Yet simple analysis shows that the reality of the idea is inharmonious with the expectations of the people who want a clone. In exploring a fringe science group called the Raëlians, Talbot explores the rationale behind cloning “replacement children.” The Raëlians believe that humans are genetically altered clones of extraterrestrials, and they have a membership of over 55,000 people worldwide. They also have enormous resources and a team of brilliant scientists, which lends them some amount of credibility. The statement of this group is, if someone wants a clone, why shouldn’t they have one? Although the raw logic of the Raëlians is not really flawed, the thinking of the many hopeful customers is. Talbot points out that a cloned child would be raised by its parents with unprecedented expectations, whether conscious or not, and the child would have no memories of previous experience with the family. Talbot wonders if people really realize the brevity of that. Still, grieving does alter one’s sense of reason, and cloning seems to be offering hope to many who have lost children in unfortunate and sudden circumstances such as accidents. The research done by Talbot lead her to a 77 year old woman who wishes to clone her son Matthew, who at age 37 died after falling out of a tree. The woman acknowledged that someone else would raise Matthew because of her age (she calls the hypothetical clone Matthew), an idea she doesn’t really like. So what, Talbot asks, will she be getting if she could have Matthew successfully cloned? The answer is, “his mind.” He had an I.Q. of 165 and the world needs a mind like that. Again, here is a flawed pattern of thinking: even if the original could be cloned, there is no guarantee that the clone would have the same mind. Raised in a different environment, under completely different circumstances and with even a different set of neurological pathways and as yet undiscovered differences in neurological construction, it does not seem likely that the same mind could be replicated. At this point it might be wise to consider the philosophers of old such as Descartes, who delved into the ability of the mind alone to perceive truth. Descartes’ journey into the distinction between mind and body is in harmony with the Eastern philosophies which state that it is the mind that returns into a different body at some point in the future (reincarnation), yet that very mind is separate from the brain, which is simply the organ that organizes and processes information perceived. Using this argument, there is no guarantee that the same mind (or “soul”) would animate the body of the clone. Granted, this is stretching reason, but it is a point to consider. We cannot use hypothetical or theoretical arguments for or against cloning, because the truth is, we simply do not know enough about the nature of the mind or even the secrets of the brain to form an absolutely factual opinion. Yet in exploring the human condition, Talbot does a good job approaching the illogical desire for humans to reproduce a copy of an original with hopes that it will be the same, as is the case of the parents who lost the infant in surgery. Philosophy did not conceive of cloning, yet it still can address it in terms of what is ethical and what is not. This really rests with the individual, on a psychological basis. What is one hoping to reproduce? For whom? The answer is completely egocentric in that people who wish to clone a lost child want what they want are do not wish to take chances. Yet it is obviously not realized that the clone itself is a chance. The clone would be a completely different and unique person; in the case of the 10-month-old, let us say that a successful clone is achieved. Raised by the same parents, the parents would obviously wish to shape the personality of the clone to be as close as possible to the original. They very well could mistake gestures and imitations on the part of the infant as the original having returned, when it is simply a matter of normal infant behavior and development of cognitive and motor skills. Even looking into the future, the life path of the infant would not be the same as the original. A body can possibly be cloned, but not a mind or a set of decisions, preferences, or even attraction to the same things. While there is nothing inherently wrong with cloning an individual, great care needs to be taken in examining the motives for creating the clone, and it is likely that we are not yet ready for such an enormous undertaking of soul-searching and reflection as to what the true purpose of the clone would be. Reference Talbot, Margaret. “A Desire to Duplicate.” The New York Times Magazine. February 4, 2001, p. 40. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Cloning College Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Cloning College Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/science/1503262-cloning-college-essay
(Cloning College Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Cloning College Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/science/1503262-cloning-college-essay.
“Cloning College Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/science/1503262-cloning-college-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Ethical Aspects of Cloning

The Concept of Human Cloning

Their Advocates of cloning practices say that it may, among other things, serve society as an effective alternative treatment for infertility.... The cloning of animals has stirred the debate about the ethical, legal and social aspects regarding human cloning.... The concept of human cloning is a controversial subject that is problematical to comprehend as the physical and psychological needs, present and future, of someone produced by this method are unknown....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Ethical Dilemma of Plagiarism

The similarities of the two ethical approaches toward custom essay websites are that both indicate the action is unethical.... The differences are the End Based ethical approach is focused on the impact on the student, whereas the Rule Based ethical approach is unethical because of the college's rules.... Most rules are based on end results, so these two ethical approaches can be used in real life....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

To what extent does the fashion industry take part in unethical behaviour to increase retail sales

By referring to the available rules and regulations as well as ethical standards, it is ethically and legally inappropriate to offer misleading, false, and deceptive information regarding the quality and nature of products to potential customers.... With the advent of globalisation, clothing industry has turned out to be one of the most favourable manufacturing sectors in international market....
22 Pages (5500 words) Essay

New Technologies and Perhaps Globalization

In a world where the environment is totally polluted, the advent of cloning can be a remedy to some of the diseases and conditions (Kass & Wilson 4).... cloning is no doubt one these most controversial issues in the modern… Those who support cloning are very passionate about what they believe is a major break- through in reproducing like-cells.... The example of Dolly the sheep being cloned has brought in tensions among the antagonists, who belief that when it eventually comes to cloning of human beings, the world will be at the verge of existence....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Ethical Duties as an Entrepreneur

This paper will analyze the ethical duties of an entrepreneur, arguing that one's good does not necessarily harm others.... One of the most significant aspects that are crucial for understanding this duty is the difference between morals and ethics.... From the paper "ethical Duties as an Entrepreneur" it is clear that an entrepreneur should be able to maintain a perfect balance between professional and personal life.... he next important duty which should be analyzed in great detail is connected with the necessity to implement an ethical decision-making process....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Ethical duties as an Entrepreneur (Is your good harm to others)

This may be true; however, in the end the positive aspects of closing it will overweigh the negative consequences in the short run.... This means that it is an ethical duty of a person to make a clear distinction between two aspects of one's life so that none of them would suffer from interference from the other (“The Unavoidable Ethical Dilemmas That Entrepreneurs Face”, n.... This paper will analyze the ethical duties of entrepreneur, arguing that one's good does not necessarily harm others....
2 Pages (500 words) PowerPoint Presentation

The Possibility of Cloning Human Beings

The paper "The Possibility of cloning Human Beings" describes that the benefits of cloning technologies have been achieved at a very high cost, which is not justifiable.... cloning technologies serve no meaningful purposes in human society, and they can never be wholly accepted by all people.... hellip; In therapeutic cloning, a person would be able to clone an identical copy of himself, which would enable him to obtain acceptable organ and tissue matches with reduced risk of transplant rejection by the host (Harris, 1992)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Should Human Cloning Be Allowed

hellip; But the first instance of cloning which marked the existence and invention of cloning in our present world refers to the startling announcement made by The Roslin Institute, a biological research institution near Edinburgh, Scotland, on 22nd February 1997, that they have succeeded in cloning a biological identical copy from cells taken from an adult sheep.... This method of cloning serves as the basics of modern medicinal research.... This work called "Should Human cloning Be Allowed?...
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us