StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Depiction of Native Americans - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Depiction of Native Americans" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the depiction of Native Americans. The depiction of Native Americans from different sources has created specific impressions about the culture and what it means to belong to a marginalized group…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Depiction of Native Americans
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Depiction of Native Americans"

Introduction The depiction of Native Americans from different sources has created specific impressions about the culture and what it means to belong to a marginalized group. The movies of the 1960s and past this time created a specific impression relating to what it meant to be a Native American and what it was to belong in the culture. The ideologies led to the audience believing that the Native American’s were foreigners in the country and had ways which did not relate to the other ways of living. In the movie, “A Man Called Horse,” produced in 1970, there is a direct correlation between living in the American lifestyle and living with the Native Americans. The ideology is one which creates divisions and contrasts that are a part of the movie and which develop a different understanding of what it means to belong to an outside culture. Summary of “A Man Called Horse” The concepts of “A Man Called Horse” are set in the Wild West when America was only beginning to develop and explore the territories that were a part of the country. The movie begins with a man, John Morgan, who is going to discover the land and which is interested in developing his own area of land in the West. However, on his journeys, he is captured by the Sioux and begins to be treated as one who is trapped in the culture. The transformation which John begins to go through after this comes from watching the culture and how each of the people live and survive on the land. This is followed by his eventual integration into the culture through gaining warrior status by killing warriors of another tribe, marrying one of the women on the land and going through initiation rights to be a part of the tribe, in which he gains the name ‘horse.’ The depictions of both cultures are then shown through the overall concept while building a sense of value that is a part of the story. Depiction of the White Man The concept which is used in “A Man Called Horse” begins with the ideology of showing the white man and the ways that were known in the Wild West and depicted by the main character, John. This is shown first through showing the character fishing by the water and performing the expected routines that are a part of the concepts used for settlement. This is followed by the viewpoint which is taken after John is captured. The film shows the Native Americans surrounding John and looking foreign and like outsiders. The perspective and the way in which it is seen through John’s eyes create a sense of threat and the belief that John may die. While he is in captive, this continues with him being treated as an animal and not receiving the proper care by being captured. These initial scenes are used to show the white man perspective of the Native Americans from this time period and to create the viewpoint of what is meant with the idea of being a foreigner as both being white and Native American. The approach which was used by showing John as an outside was used specifically to show the stereotypes that were a part of the Native American tribes. Myths about the Native Americans, beliefs in the actions which they took and the brutality which they practiced were the myths that were often associated with Native Americans. Showing the movie through the viewpoint of John was able to further define the concept of what it meant to belong as a part of the stereotype while redefining the brutality and unknown ways of the Native Americans as a part of the main ideology. This happens not only through John’s viewpoint, but also with the approach of the warrior tribe and the idea of presenting war trophies and being brutal throughout the movie. The perspective of the white man then becomes dominant in showing the stereotype of brutality from this perspective throughout the movie while building on the ethnic stereotypes that are a part of the Native American culture (Price, 1973). Native Americans as the Other The concept of creating stereotypes with the Native Americans is followed by the continuous depiction of what it means to create the Native Americans as the other. The concept of belonging to the outside and being unknown and foreign is represented throughout the movie. This continues with presenting a marginalized culture that is within society and the association which this has to the film present the idea of the culture that is unknown remaining on the outside. The concept is one which relates to the socio – cultural concepts that are a part of the culture and the association which this has to society. As this continues, there is a direct relationship to the unknown and minority culture that continues to be understood and which remains brutal in it’s ways. The concept of the warrior, the unknown culture, stereotypical costumes and the scenery which is used all add into the unknown that is presented to continue to create boundaries within the movie and the culture (Jayyusi, 2009). There are several points where this is represented in the film and where it takes over the main ideologies presented with understanding culture. An example is when the warrior tribes are going to attack the Sioux. The costume that is used includes a leather front and back with no other clothing. This is combined with children who are wearing this, carrying bows and arrows and that have long and mangled hair. This then changes to the actions in which the boy shoots the warrior with a bow and arrow then runs back to the area where the women are cutting flowers, warning them of the warriors. The following scene includes loud shouting from the boys, leading to John scalping one of the warriors with an expression of disgust from the action which he has taken. Each of these points in the scene creates a sense of the other and belonging to the outside. It is something that belongs as the identity of the Native Americans but which is understood with those who are in contemporary culture. The clothing, shouting and the brutality that is honored and recognized are all considered as a part of the other and unacceptable from the marginalized culture, as depicted from the film. The Examination of Culture from the Outside Each of the ideologies that are used with the film lead to the concept of examining a culture which one doesn’t belong to. The concept is one that is based on building a representation of culture based on the stereotypes and beliefs that are a part of the contemporary society. This helps to build a specific level of appeal to those who are watching the movie while establishing specific effects and representations which one may relate to with the movie. This creates a sense of subjectivity that is a part of the culture while developing unrealistic expectations that are a part of the culture. When the audience looks at the film, there are outside of the understanding of the culture and see the Native Americans as the subject of the film. Instead of looking at the culture as realistic, it is something to be examined and studied through the stereotypes which are created. By taking this specific perspective, the Native Americans are viewed as a subject or spectacle with the culture that is created (Casebier, 1991). The main concepts within the film and specific themes continue to add into the spectacle and the subjectivity of the Native Americans in the film. The first is at the beginning of the film and the way in which the Sioux treat John as a captive. The audience is able to view this as John being the main viewer while the Sioux are the unknown or the subjects that are to be watched. There is not only a daily set of activities that take place with the Native Americans. There are also rituals, ceremonies, warrior like responses and unknown language that is spoken throughout the film and which creates a sense of boundaries and separation. This adds into the subjectivity and the idea of the spectacle through the film. When John integrates into the tribe, there is still a sense of the subjectivity by creating him as the outsider. This is best seen with the final ceremony that John goes through. The initiation rights go through brutality, warriorship and suffering to cross over to be a Native American. This is combined with creating a spectacle out of the unknown rights that John goes through toward the end and which lead to a mystical experience before he passes through to becoming a Native American. This creates a different understanding of subjectivity about who the Native Americans are while creating a culture through the experiences that belong to the outside. The viewpoint of John remains on the outside with the final initiation rights and with the perspective which he takes in adapting to the culture and being a part of the concepts from the warrior tribe. The creation of boundaries and separation with the movie not only are noted through the actions and responses which take place. This is furthered with the actions that are taken in different events to further this perspective. For instance, creating separation through the language which is spoken creates the idea of subjectivity and furthers this initiative. The separation comes with John and the Native Americans not speaking the same language. This furthers with the costumes that remain separate until the end of the movie. The movie continues with boundaries and separation that is a part of the movie and establishes different ideologies that are associated with how one interacts in the movie. The result is a sense of separation while the audience observes boundaries and separation between the two cultures. Conclusion The depiction of Native Americans in the film “A Man Called Horse” depicts the different stereotypes, subjectivity and separation between two cultures. The white man, John, is one which holds the main perspective in the movie of what it means to look at the culture from the outside. The concepts of misunderstanding and the culture which is not understood throughout the movie continue to lead the events which continue. At the same time, the use of costumes, language, setting and the actions which take place further the boundaries between the two cultures while creating separation that are a part of both in the film. This results in the audience holding a specific description with the movie and the Native Americans while building a sense of boundaries, stereotypes and assumptions about a marginalized and misunderstood culture. References Casebier, A. (1991). Film and Phenomenology: Toward a Realist Theory of Cinematic Representation. New York: Routledge. Jayyusi, Lena. (2009). “Toward a Socio – Logic of the Film Text.” Semiotica 68 (3). Price, John. (1973). “The Stereotyping of North American Indians in Motion Pictures.” Ethnohistory 20 (2). Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Man Called Horse Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
A Man Called Horse Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1585546-native-americans
(A Man Called Horse Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
A Man Called Horse Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1585546-native-americans.
“A Man Called Horse Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1585546-native-americans.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Depiction of Native Americans

Native Americans in the Early American Republic

native americans in the Early American Republic Name Institution native americans in the Early American Republic Berkhofer (1978) notes that, historically, the white settlers and the native americans have had negative attitudes towards each other.... In this regard, the white settlers, in particular, have had negative attitudes towards the native americans considering them as being uncultured dangerous barbarians.... This bad blood between the native americans and the white settlers arose because the native americans of the late 18th century and early 19th century used to commit various atrocities including murder on their fellow white settlers, with the aim of defending their land from being grabbed by the white inhabitants under the ‘Manifest Destiny' (Berkhofer, 1978)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Stereotypes in Cartoons: African American Representation

During World War II, the artistic expressions of African americans influenced the development of cartoons.... He argues that the interpretation of African americans' social and cultural expression was distinctive.... hite animators used cartoons to depict the cultural characteristics of black americans.... These depictions of African americans were observed frequently in the early 20th century in America.... Additionally, the caricature features, which depicted black americans, were present in the first cartoons made by Looney Tunes and Disney....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Native American Iconography and depictions in Art of 18th and early 19th century

Catlin expounds at length on the methods that the native americans used to soften the leather that... Since the time of the earliest European colonists in North America, the native American peoples have been endlessly stereotyped, misrepresented, and misunderstood.... As the Europeans have quickly become the dominant racial and cultural group in what is now known as the United States, the native culture has been subjugated.... The true native American has become mixed with the stereotype, a process that began While not all such depictions were blatantly racist or derogatory (though of course some were), almost all contributed in some way to the dissolution of the native American culture that is seen today....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Images of Asian-Americans

A significant amount of evidence attests to the occurrence of a major problem in relation to the depiction of Asian Americans in the media.... In conclusion, this research has argued that a bamboo ceiling regarding the depiction of Asian Americans in the media exists and that this bamboo ceiling must be overcome through pro-active measures that counter-act such depictions.... The present research argues that the portrayal of Asian-americans in the media has reached a bamboo ceiling and that because of this pro-active measures are necessary to counter-act these limited and negative depictions....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Identity in Thunder Heart

Thunder Heart (1992) provides a fresh departure from other films that discuss the identity of native americans.... The following discourse argues that the author and director rely on many Hollywood props in giving the identity of native americans.... Throughout the film, various depictions of native americans take place.... All the characters show substance in revealing the identity of native americans (Indians) in American society....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Theodore De Bry and John White

In many of De Bry's engravings, the facial structure of most of the characters were altered where they ended up looking more like Europeans rather than native americans.... The important aspect that De Bry failed to capture in his engravings was the difference between Europeans and native americans, which was a distinctive feature that should have come out clearly as White intended....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Marginalization of Native Americans Before and After the 1930s

This literature review "The Marginalization of native americans Before and After the 1930s" discusses the marginalization of native americans that intensified during the nineteenth century through the systematic eradication of their tribes as land ownership issues arose.... Apparently, Manifest Destiny lived on until the 1980s through cultural and legislative changes that signified that native americans, including their history and future development, were still less important than whites to the government and the media....
10 Pages (2500 words) Literature review

Y Goddodin from the Book of Aneirin as a Scottish Equivalent of Homers Iliad

Poets have always created the right depiction of the scenario around them and if the depiction is that of war and strife amongst people of two states, with an adequate description of the state of common people during the time of war, then it becomes a historical landmark of the times that it was created in, giving readers a complete picture of the powers that ruled society at a certain point in history....
40 Pages (10000 words) Thesis
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us