StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Do native peoples today invent their traditions - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Do Native Peoples Today Invent Their Traditions Cultural anthropology is the science of the beliefs, ideas, practices and the history of human settlements, of the peoples of our world. The renowned anthropologist, Roger Keesing describes anthropology as “an exploration, an excavation of the cumulated, embodied symbols, of other peoples, a search for meanings, for hidden connections, for deeper saliences than those presented by the surface evidence of ethnography.” (Keesing, R) A variety of methods are used by anthropologists today, to study in depth, the various cultures of the world…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Do native peoples today invent their traditions
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Do native peoples today invent their traditions"

Download file to see previous pages

Almost always there are valid arguments on both sides of the controversy. This, I believe is also the case in the arguments put forth by Keesing and Trask, in their difference of opinions, about whether native peoples today invent their traditions. However, I do think the arguments put forth by Trask more valid. Cultural anthropologist Roger M Keesing maintains, that the traditional culture accepted by the native people of the pacific is an invented version of their past, and that they do not really know what life was really like before the invasion of the white man.

On the other hand, Haunani-Kay Trask, a Hawaiian scholar argues that Keesing relies only on western documentation, while the native people have sources like oral traditions and genealogies that western documentation does not take into account. I believe that this is a valid point because I think that there is a difference in perception between people of different cultures, and many native customs and nuances in dialects, may not be correctly understood by someone who is alien to that culture.

There are subtle changes in the pronunciations of certain words in some dialects and these could convey a very different meaning. Trask herself is critical of the westerner’s understanding of native culture and the institutions therein, while Keesing too argues that “interpretation itself is fraught with difficulties, some perhaps ultimately intractable.” (Keesing, R) In the present debate, Keesing’s arguments are based on a collection of essays of Hobsbawm and Ranger, that conclude that cultures and traditions change over time due to a variety of factors.

Most anthropologists agree that customs and traditions change over time. However to say that these have been invented to cater to the tourism industry, and the native people do not really know what life was like before western invasion; also is difficult to accept. It is a well documented fact, that in many cultures, knowledge and traditions were handed down orally from father to son spanning generations. For example in India the Vedic texts are said to have been orally passed on for generations.

Although it may be argued that it may not have been handed down in its purest form, allowing for some changes as a result of verbal communication, to say that these traditions have been invented by native people in the recent past cannot be accepted. It must also be accepted that documentation of these traditions were mostly carried out by the western invaders, as the local people relied on verbal communication and not on the written word that was alien to their culture. As Trask argues, it is perhaps the native scholar rather than the western one who would be the better judge of whether the present traditions are those that have come down the ages or invented in the recent past.

Having the advantage of being a native, the local anthropologist would be in a better position to understand the nuances of words, and their various meanings, as they were once used in bygone times, and the sum total of what has been handed down through the ages. Keesing accepts the fact that it is important to question

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Do native peoples today invent their traditions Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/anthropology/1460783-do-native-peoples-today-invent-their-traditions
(Do Native Peoples Today Invent Their Traditions Essay)
https://studentshare.org/anthropology/1460783-do-native-peoples-today-invent-their-traditions.
“Do Native Peoples Today Invent Their Traditions Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/anthropology/1460783-do-native-peoples-today-invent-their-traditions.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Do native peoples today invent their traditions

Do native peoples today invent their tradition

Appreciating Human Diversity Name Professor Anthropology Date do native peoples today invent their tradition?... This paper attempts to discuss whether the natives today invent their traditions.... their traditions are not directly similar to the archaic eras.... Consequently, it is inappropriate to assume that these natives invent their cultures.... These immigrants come with new values and social structures that either absorb or consume the existing traditions....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Early American Military Tactics: A Contrast in Fighting

The Colonist Struggles with Native Americans The Colonists took their military traditions from their mother country.... History North America in the 1600s was quite a different place from the one we know today.... Discussion today we seldom think about American involvement in warfare on American soil.... As mentioned much of conflicts in America were fought during eras of founding, development, and expansive growth into the North America that we know today....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Three major aspects of colonial takeover of American lands based on Foreigners in Their Native Land

… In this chapter, the writer considers three major aspects of colonial takeover of American lands that was captioned under the heading of “Foreigners in Their native Land”.... Three major aspects of colonial takeover of American lands based on “Foreigners in Their native Land” The first component of the chapter looked at the war against Mexico where foreigners taking over the land of Mexico turned around to be lords of the land and battled the original natives of the land....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Rolling Over the Native Culture

nbsp;… As the paper, Rolling Over the native Culture, declares the Spanish introduced the horse to North America in the 16th century.... The horse was a superior tool for the native Americans as it provided them with much greater mobility, allowing the Indians to travel greater distances and expand their territory.... However, native American music was offered at tribal ceremonies and was a part of their traditional activities.... The horse was a superior tool for the native Americans as it provided them with much greater mobility, allowing the Indians to travel greater distances and expand their territory....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Topic: Evaluate the proposition that a global monoculture will destroy diversity and difference

Goulet, states, “traditional peoples must be shocked into the realization that they are living in abnormal, inhuman conditions as psychological preparation for modernization” (Rockwell, 1994, p.... In this essay, I will analyse the immediate impact of the colonial imperialism; first by considering the methodical distribution… Then, I will comment on the philosophical and economical evolution of the Troadjas tribes....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

MUSIC in Britain

Although traditionally used in the dawn of the 17th century, the full impact of Baroque music was not felt until mid 17th century; the effects were delayed due to native reluctance in incorporating the music, wars between the Great Nations, as well as cultural and religious differences....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Indigenous Population in the USA

Kirch (2008), states that the longevity of indigenous peoples in North America is lesser than that of the national population.... The paper "The Indigenous Population in the USA" describes that coordination and cooperation among public and private agencies within American health care scenario plays an important role in the success of its health systems/ services for the native Americans.... The native Americans include a number of tribal groups in the USA with similarity in cultural values....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Proposal

Cultural Photographs by Martn Chambi

The movement was dedicated to the affirmation of the rich traditions of the indigenous culture and it constantly tried to create a way through which the tension between the ex post facto and modern culture that characterized his society at the dawn of the 20th century most of which was caused by western incursion.... This paper "Cultural Photographs by Martín Chambi" focuses on the fact that Martin Chambi was born in Puno located along the shores of Lake Titicaca, to a family of native Quechua peasants, he is celebrated world over in the artistic circle for his commercial photography....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us