StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Market-Based Instruments of Environmental Policy in Practice: The European Emissions Trading Scheme - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay talks that the environmental pollution and gradual depletion of the natural resources in the global economy could be attributed to one of the major factors, namely inappropriate pricing of goods and services. The market based instruments influences the cost of production…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Market-Based Instruments of Environmental Policy in Practice: The European Emissions Trading Scheme
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Market-Based Instruments of Environmental Policy in Practice: The European Emissions Trading Scheme"

? Market-Based Instruments of Environmental Policy in Practice: The European Emissions Trading Scheme Contents Contents 2 Introduction: Market based instruments for environmental policy 3 European Emissions Trading Scheme 4 Application of economic theories and concepts for explaining European Emissions Trading 5 Economic analysis: Market Based Instruments in European Emissions Trading Scheme 7 9 10 Incorporation of aviations industry in the European Emissions Trading Scheme 12 Conclusion 12 References 14 Bibliography 16 Introduction: Market based instruments for environmental policy The environmental pollution and gradual depletion of the natural resources in the global economy could be attributed to one of the major factors, namely inappropriate pricing of goods and services. The hidden costs due to the damages incurred by environmental pollution, loss of soil and species, climate change, heat waves, storms and floods are borne by the people who have not even enjoyed the benefits of the products and services offered in the markets. The utilization of market-based instruments such as taxes, subsidies, charges, permits, helps in the realization of the social, environmental and economic objective of the nations and continents like Europe. The market based instruments influences the cost of production and at the same time protects the health and environment of the consumers and the society respectively by effective management of the resources and the wastes cue to production and consumption. The various ways in which market based instruments prevents the sources of environmental pollution and health degradation includes the following. Due to the implementation of the market based instruments, the producers have shown more responsible behaviour towards switching over to the eco-friendly systems of production, efficient use of natural resources and reduction of wastes. The consumers have also received more transparency on the values of products and services consumed and this resulted in the reduction of excessive consumption with the sense of value for money. The market based instruments like tradable emission permits, fuel taxes have resulted in the reduction of emissions from the transports and aviation industry. The waste disposal taxes, incentives for recycling and taxes on packaging have resulted in changes of behaviour of the households and the business. The incentives for energy efficient heating systems and improved insulation have controlled the heat wave emissions in Europe. The taxes on the pesticides and the fertilizers have also been able to control the pollution due to agricultural activities. European Emissions Trading Scheme The European Emissions Trading Scheme is a policy measure adopted in Europe where the regulatory measure has been taken to fix the level of emission of parameters that emerge from the sources of environmental pollution and degradation of health issues in Europe. The upper limit of the emission level of harmful gases, disposal of wastes has been fixed as compared to certain benchmark or relative to a standard value of the parameter. The European Emissions Trading Scheme works in the following manner. In the initial stages, the emission allowances are first permitted to the sources of emission that causes environmental pollution, depletion of natural resources and other health problems. After initial allocation of the resources, the sources of emission are required to bring down the emission level to the prescribed standard as per the prescribed standard with the help of allowances or permits granted to them within the designated time period of one year (Ellerman, Buchner and Barbara, 2007, p.72). After the designated period of one year, a market for the European Emissions trading would come into action where the sources covered under the scheme would be able to sell or buy the allowances available with them through the process of exchange. The cost or purchase or sell of the allowances for controlling the emissions would be determined by the cost of control of emissions of the seller and the market prices of the allowances. This trading emissions scheme provides flexibility to the emitters in finding ways to reduce the level of pollution from their own operations. Through the emissions trading scheme, the emitters would be able to buy allowances necessary for controlling the pollution level from the other sources who do not consider the ways of controlling emissions to be very expensive (Coase, 1960, p.41). The emitters who buy those allowances would able to reduce the cost of compliance to the standard level of emission which otherwise would be very high for them under the traditional regulatory methods of individual emission control and monitoring. Application of economic theories and concepts for explaining European Emissions Trading The European Emissions Trading Scheme includes the market where the sources of environment pollution and the health problems in Europe participate to buy and sell allowances for controlling the emissions that exceed beyond the prescribed standard level of emission. The fluctuation of the prices in which the allowances are sold and bought by the sources could be explained by the economic theories and concepts. In order to explain the role played by the market based instruments for controlling the emission levels, cost of emission control and the purchase and sell of allowances in the emissions trading scheme in Europe at market based prices, the economic theories of price elasticity of demand, marginal rate of substitution and the indifference curve concepts could be applied in this field (Mankiw, 2011, p.62). In case of the European Emissions Trading Scheme, the emission limits prescribed by the regulatory agencies and the allowances allocated to the suppliers are the quantity instruments. These quantity instruments are referred by the emitters in order to meet the prescribed norms of emission. The prices of these quantities or the allowances provided to the emitters vary in the European Emissions Trading Scheme based on the supply and demand of the allowances after the designated period of operation of the emitters in the industry. The volatility of the prices of the allowances which is borne by the industry and not by the regulators could be explained by the economic theory of price elasticity of demand (Marshall, 2006, p.58). The economic theory of price elasticity of demand explains the response of the demand of the quantity due to change in unit price of the quantity. This could be explained by the following curve as shown below. A rise in the level of demand for the quantity or the emissions would lead to the change in the price level of the quantity which in this case is the allowance sold in the European Emission Trade Scheme. The emitters who have higher demand for the allowances would be able to obtain it at a relatively lower price from the emitters who are not so much in need of those allowances as a result of meeting with the prescribed norms of the regulatory agencies. This is resembled by the price demand curve as given below (Stonier, 1984, p.25). Figure 1: Price versus Demand Curve In the transfer of the allowances at a price in the European Emissions Trading Scheme, the exchange of allowance for controlling the emissions at a comparatively lower cost, the economic theory of marginal rate of substitution could be applied. The theory of marginal rate of substitution explains that the emitters would be ready to sell the allowances to other players while maintaining the same level of utility or the emission control level. The neo-classical theory of economics support the fact that the consumption of the good and services which are the allowances in this case is continuously divisible and the marginal rate of substitution of the allowances would continue till the point of indifference in the utility of the allowances are restored in the market (Schotter, 2008, p.57). The market based instruments enforced by the regulatory agencies are the taxes, charges, permits which are price based instruments. These price instruments have led to the variation of the emission control by emitters due to which the cost of control of the emission has varied which in turn has decided the prices of the allowance sold in the emission trading scheme (Hepburn, 2006, p.239). Economic analysis: Market Based Instruments in European Emissions Trading Scheme The signing of the Kyoto Protocol was the platform where the proposal of the Emission Trading Scheme in the market was first mentioned as a market based instrument which could be use the policy makers in order to control the level of environmental pollution and health problems by controlling the production and consumption of goods which gives rise to the emission of harmful gases, disposal of wastes and causes depletion of the natural resources. The European Emission Trading Scheme highlights the use of market based instruments like allowances, permits, etc. that have played a significant role in controlling the level of emission and the related pollution of the environment and health problems. There are several evidences that support the implementation of market based instruments as a part of the European Emissions Trading Scheme (Ellerman and Buchner, 2008, p.276). The tradable renewable energy certificates have been implemented by the European countries like UK, Italy, Netherlands and Sweden. The tradable renewable energy certificate is a market based instrument that poses obligation on the emitter to produce renewable energy as a certain percentage of the total energy production (Lu, Zhu and Cui, 2012, p.262). The tradable energy certificates have not only allowed the European countries to develop renewable energy reserves but also provide the way of producing the renewable energy in the cheapest method (Caney and Hepburn, 2011, p.225). Thus, it could be observed that the cost of compliance to control of environmental pollution is reduced by the role of market based instrument (Stavins, 1995, p.144). In order to control the damages to the environment by complying with the prescribed limits of emission, the allocation of allowances to various countries of Europe is given below in Table 1. The allowances have been expressed in terms of million tons of carbon-di-oxide per year (European Environment Agency, 2005, p.32). Table 1: Allocation of allowances to European nations in June, 2005 The prices of the allowance sold and purchased by the emitters in the European Emissions Trading Scheme are determined by the supply and demand for the allowances and the market prices of those allowances. The fluctuation of the price of these allowances is borne by the industry and not by the regulators. The fluctuation of price of the allowances from 2003 to 2005 has been shown below in Figure 2 (European Environment Agency, 2005, p.33). Figure 2: Price of allowance (July, 2003 to Sep, 2005) The contributions of the European Emission Trading Scheme have helped to address the problems of acid rain precursor in Slovakia and Netherlands. The international obligations have been imposed on Slovakia in the emission of sulphur -dioxide into the atmosphere while the Netherlands faces obligation of reducing the emissions of nitrogen oxides in the environment that causes acid rain precursors in the environment (Stavins, 1998, p.75). The allocations provided to Slovakia and the Netherlands for controlling the environmental pollution have been given above in Table 1. The packaging recovery notes issues in UK is another example of market based instrument that is used in the European Emission Trading Scheme. The packaging recovery notes are issued to the companies which in turn put an obligation on the businesses of the amount of amount of amount of package recycling to be done in order to prevent the disposal of the wastes. The packaging recovery notes are traded in the emissions trading scheme as an evidence of meeting the packaging and recycling obligations (Montgomery, 1972, p.417). The allowances under the European Emissions Trading Scheme also stated that under article 5 of the landfill directives, any member country that is conducting the activities of land-filling more than 75% of the biodegradable wastes or municipal wastes as compared to the 1995 levels are able to take up derogation for a period of four years. UK which has been land-filling its bio-degradable wastes at the rates of 80% as compared to the levels of 1995 are likely to take up the derogation provided in the allowance of the European Emission scheme (Burton and Sanjour, 1970, p.148). The exchange of the allowances between the members in the European Emissions Trading Scheme is largely possible due to the features of the European Emission Trading Scheme that have been analyzed and explained as follows. The members of the European Emission Trading Scheme maintain a computerized registry with a dedicated website where the allowances allocated to the members are maintained. The trading and exchange of allowances between the members occurs through the computerized mode which could be explained by the economic theories of price elasticity of demand, marginal rate of substitution. The price of the allowances fluctuates in response to the level of supply and demand of the allowance, the cost of controlling the emissions (Hepburn, 2006, p.235). The change of unit price of the allowances determine the level of the demand or in other words the market forces adjusts the price level on the basis of demand of the members who could reduce their cost of compliance by the process of transfer from another member for whom the cost of compliance is less. The seller justifies the sale of the allowances through the economic theory of marginal rate of substitution which allows the seller to sell the allowances by maintaining the same level of control over the environmental pollution and hazards created due to economic activities, wastes disposals and others. Incorporation of aviations industry in the European Emissions Trading Scheme Looking at the increasing level of emission from the aviation sector, the European Commission has decided to include the activities and the potential damages of the aviation industry under the purview of the European Emissions Trading Scheme. The incorporation of the aviation industry under the European Emission Trading Scheme is a complicated task as the emissions of the aviation industry not only includes the emission of carbon-dioxide but also includes a comprehensive emission of several radiations from the aircrafts. Looking at the growing priority over controlling the environmental impacts due to aviation, several changes on the use of market based instruments have been considered. The taxation on kerosene as a fuel for aviation is reconsidered as the previous taxation on aviation fuels rarely taxed kerosene as an aviation fuel (Ekins and Barker, 2001, p.338). Thus the lost opportunities for controlling the damages to the environment have been recovered by the incorporation of aviation industry under the purview of the European Emissions Trading Scheme. Conclusion The market based instruments play a significant role in controlling the damages to the environment as it controls the behaviour of producers in the process of production and the volume of consumption by the consumers. The European Emission Trading Scheme was implemented due to the proposals that emerged in the conference of Kyoto Protocol on climate changes and environmental protection. The European Emission Trading Scheme aims to put the burden of environmental protection on the market based factors and releases the pressure from the regulatory changes. The market based instruments are the allowances, permits, incentives and the taxes that are allocated to the member countries for control of the emission within the period of one year. The allowances and the market based instruments are traded among the member countries of Europe in order to reduce the cost of compliance of the regulatory limits for controlling the damages to the environment. The transfer of allowances between the member countries could be explained by the economic theories and concepts of price elasticity of demand, marginal rate of substitution, etc. References European Environment Agency. 2005. Market-based instruments for environmental policy in Europe. [Pdf]. Available at: http://www.cbd.int/doc/case-studies/inc/cs-inc-envpolicyeur-en.pdf. [Accessed on 8 November, 2013]. Stonier. 1984. A Textbook Of Economic Theory, 5/E. New Delhi: Pearson Education India. Mankiw, G. 2011. Principles of Economics. Stamford: Cengage Learning. Marshall, A. 2006. Principles of Economics. Washington: Osprey Learning. Schotter, A. 2008. Microeconomics: A Modern Approach. Stamford: Cengage Learning. Ellerman, A., Buchner, D. and Barbara, K. 2007. The European Union Emissions Trading Scheme: Origins, Allocation, and Early Results. Review of Environmental Economics and Policy. 1(1): pp. 66–87. Hepburn, C. 2006. Regulating by prices, quantities or both: an update and an overview. Oxford Review of Economic Policy. 22 (2): pp. 226–247. Ellerman, D. and Buchner, B. 2008. Over-Allocation or Abatement? A Preliminary Analysis of the EU ETS Based on the 2005-06 Emissions Data. Environmental and Resource Economics. 41(1): pp. 267–287. Caney, S. and Hepburn, C. 2011. Carbon Trading: Unethical, Unjust and Ineffective?. Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement. 69(1): pp. 201–234. Montgomery, W. D. 1972. Markets in Licenses and Efficient Pollution Control Programs. Journal of Economic Theory. 5(1): pp. 395–418. Stavins, R. N. 1998. What Can We Learn from the Grand Policy Experiment? Lessons from SO2 Allowance Trading. The Journal of Economic Perspectives. 12 (3): pp. 69–88. Burton, E. S. and Sanjour, W. 1970. A Simulation Approach to Air Pollution Abatement Program Planning. Socio-Economic Planning Science. 4(1): pp. 147–150. Coase, R. H. 1960. The Problem of Social Cost. Journal of Law and Economics. 3(1): pp. 1–44. Lu, Y., Zhu, X. and Cui, Q. 2012. Effectiveness and equity implications of carbon policies in the United States construction industry. Building and Environment. 49(1): pp. 259–269. Hepburn, C. 2006. Regulating by prices, quantities or both: an update and an overview. Oxford Review of Economic Policy. 22 (2): pp. 226–247. Stavins, R. N. 1995. Transaction costs and tradable permits. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management. 29(1), pp. 133-148. Ekins, P. and Barker, T. 2001. Carbon taxes and carbon emissions trading. Journal of Economic Surveys. 15(1), pp. 325–376. Bibliography Coase, R. 1960. The problem of social cost. Journal of Law and Economics. 3(1), pp. 1-44. Hahn, R. W. 1989. Economic prescriptions for environmental problems: How the patient followed the doctor's orders. Journal of Economic Perspectives. 3(2), pp. 95–114. Weitzman, M. L. 1974. Prices vs quantities. Review of Economic Studies. 41(1), pp. 225-234. Baumol, W. J. 1972. On taxation and the control of externalities. American Economic Review. 62(3), p.45. Baumol, W. J. and Oates, W. E. 1971. The use of standards and prices for the protection of the Environment. Swedish Journal of Economics. 73(1), pp. 42–54. Bruvoll, A. and Lasen, B. M. 2004. Greenhouse gas emission in Norway: Do carbon taxes work?. Energy Policy. 32(1), pp. 493–505. Ekins, P. and Speck, S. 1999. Competitiveness and exemptions from environmental taxes in Europe. Environmental and Resource Economics. 13(1), pp. 369–396. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Market-Based Instruments of Environmental Policy in Practice: The Essay - 2”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1490438-market-based-instruments-of-environmental-policy-in-practice-the-european-emissions-trading-scheme
(Market-Based Instruments of Environmental Policy in Practice: The Essay - 2)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1490438-market-based-instruments-of-environmental-policy-in-practice-the-european-emissions-trading-scheme.
“Market-Based Instruments of Environmental Policy in Practice: The Essay - 2”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1490438-market-based-instruments-of-environmental-policy-in-practice-the-european-emissions-trading-scheme.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Market-Based Instruments of Environmental Policy in Practice: The European Emissions Trading Scheme

International Trade Innovations

In the light of this effect, reductions in the cost of trading tasks can generate shared gains for all domestic factors, in contrast to the distributional conflict that typically results from reductions in the cost of trading goods. Engine of long-run economic growth.... Hence, it would be desirable from a public policy perspective to identify and promote sectors displaying both a high innovation rate and, in an increasingly competitive international economy, a high degree of international competitiveness (Henisz, 2000)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Car Industry Development in Europe

Introduction: the european is at the forefront of international efforts to combat climate change and must deliver the reductions in greenhouse gas emissions to which it has committed under the Kyoto protocol.... the european commission proposed in January 2007 "The EU pursues in context of international negotiations, the objective of a 30% reduction of GHG emission by developed countries by 2020 (compared to 1990 levels)".... the european parliament called for "a policy of strong measures to reduce emission from transport, including mandatory limits for CO2 emissions from new vehicles in order of 80-100g CO2/km for new vehicles in the medium term to be achieved through emission trading between car manufacturers....
23 Pages (5750 words) Essay

Technology as an Aide to Developing Cleaner Solutions in Environment

New technology is the medium that will help address the issue of environmental issues.... hellip; Scientists, policymakers, and laypeople are beginning to evaluate and understand the gravity of the situation and interpret data about environmental change in a new light: progressive, incremental degradation of environmental systems is not as tolerable as it once was, and to combat that, small time measures can only achieve so much.... New technology is the medium that will help address the issue of environmental issues from a "prevention" perspective rather than a "solution"....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

The European Union Emission Trading Scheme

The paper "The European Union Emission trading scheme" describes that even although the EU ETS scheme has not been able to fully achieve its intended goals, it has to some extent managed to promote and encourage companies to realize the need for including environmental greening strategies.... eing the first global emission trading scheme of it is kind, the EU ETS has experienced significant changes some of which are threatening the achievement of its goals while others are lessons for follow-up phases....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Corporate Social Responsibility at Sainsbury PLC

In the critical discussion, the social, ethical and environmental contribution of the company will be analysed and also the concept of ‘greenwashing' will be explored and examined in perspective of Sainsbury.... Wood (1991) has explained that CSR framework has been developed on the notion that business and society are not distinct entities; instead, they are… Business has been considered as an inseparable and important member of a society as it is the main source of employment, investment and wealth....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Integrated Approach to Environmental Conservation

The author of the current paper claims that an integrated approach to environmental conservation involves protection of both biodiversity and the ecosystem.... As such in rural development, the UK government is working on actively involving rural communities in the planning and implementing of policies that will enhance their social, economic and environmental standings....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

The EU Environmental Policy and Why It Is a Success to Both the Environment and the Economy

The author of"The EU Environmental Policy and Why It Is a Success to Both the Environment and the Economy" paper assesses the degree to which he/she feels the european environmental policy has been a success.... the european Union commenced its environmental policy with a program that was ambitious… The Natura 2000 was formed through the european Union legislation on habitats and birds, and currently, throughout Europe, more than 30 thousand sites are boasted by it....
17 Pages (4250 words) Case Study

Global Contributions to CO2 Reduction

nbsp; In the European Union, the country has developed its EU emissions trading scheme, a cap and trade policy instrument that serves as legislation to assist in business activity-related greenhouse gas emissions (Burney, 2010).... The author of this paper focuses on India, conducting a case study research methodology regarding the economic reality of this developing country that could potentially conflict being a significant contributor to the curbing greenhouse gas emissions....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us