StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Structure and Agency in Revolutionary Theory - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Structural theorists postulate that elements responsible for defining human culture should be perceived more in the context of their relationship with a larger all-encompassing structure and system. The theory behind this thinking is referred to as structuralism that seeks to…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Structure and Agency in Revolutionary Theory
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Structure and Agency in Revolutionary Theory"

Structure and Agency in Revolutionary Theory Structural theorists postulate that elements responsible for defining human culture should be perceived more in the context of their relationship with a larger all-encompassing structure and system. The theory behind this thinking is referred to as structuralism that seeks to reveal by uncovering the structures upon which the foundation of human thinking, emotions and perception are grounded. Structural theorists believe that human life cannot be defined through the intelligible except of their interaction, but through a variant structure characterized by constant laws of abstract culture.

The school of culture and agency is based on the premise that repeated conditioning of individuals through their culture patterns human behaviour. Agency forwards the notion that human behaviour is determined by free will that charts the way for independent action and free will in making choices. Revolutions are occurrences in governance that result to a change in leadership, which is achieved through various means. Numerous schools of thought have been forwarded in an attempt to explain and the understanding of the making and the instigators of revolutions.

This paper seeks to highlight the debate between structural theorists and the culture and agency school to the 1906 constitutional revolution in Iran. The 1906 constitutional revolution in Iran was instigated by the Shah’s extravagance, which led to the exploitation and destruction of the nation’s economy (Poulson 104). Teheran was the seat of Persian power and majority of the population was composed of merchants, noble classes, religious authorities and the educated elite who felt and understood the consequences of the Shah’s extravagance (Poulson 106).

They were the main instigators of the revolution that called for the removal of the chancellor who was to blame for the dire economic situation. After the removal of the chancellor the Shah did not change his extravagant ways and the same group campaigned and advocated for the establishment of an institution would rule by law instead of royal and foreign influence. In the context of this discussion, the 1906 revolution in Iran can be viewed from both perspectives that are presented by structural theorists and the culture and agency school of thought.

This is because according to Skocpol, there are always structural forces that underlie the uprising of a revolution. Persia was facing an economic meltdown under the leadership of the Shah, which means the societal structure was under threat (Geels 32). This is in the sense that factors that influence and impact the socioeconomic well-being of people threaten the integrity of the societal structure. In an effort to maintain and sustain their socioeconomic structure, the Persians sought for a variant structure characterized by constant laws of abstract culture through the establishment of a parliamentary system of governance (Geels 40).

The adage by Wendell Phillips that “revolutions are not made, they come” can be interpreted to echo Marxist theory on revolution (Lux 258). This theory postulates that under the forces of agency and structure, people will always be inclined to desire systems and structures that pose as collective bargaining chips for their interests. This can explain the overwhelming influence that the British and the Russians had in Iran during that period. The country was polarised between the two forces determinant theory with regard to revolutionary thinking and perception.

Agency theory postulates that people are driven to exercise their free in decision-making processes and at the same time, structuralism plays a key role (Burton 538). This is because free will cannot be sustained if it does not reflect the well-being of the society as a whole.Work CitedBurton, John, Lisa Walters, and Suzanne Trill. "VIIIThe Earlier Seventeenth Century: General." The Years Work in English Studies 88.1 (2009): 530-552.Geels, F. W. "The multi-level perspective on sustainability transitions: responses to seven criticisms.

" Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 1.1 (2011): 24-40.Lux, R. Revolution and the Will to Change: Cosmology, Cognition and the Mechanics of Transformation in the Thinking. Utah: University of Utah. 2007. Print.Poulson, S. C. Social Movements in Twentieth-century Iran: Culture, Ideology, and Mobilizing Frameworks. Illustrated Edition. New York: Lexington Books. 2006. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Structure and Agency in Revolutionary Theory Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/history/1623305-structure-and-agency-in-revolutionary-theory
(Structure and Agency in Revolutionary Theory Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1623305-structure-and-agency-in-revolutionary-theory.
“Structure and Agency in Revolutionary Theory Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1623305-structure-and-agency-in-revolutionary-theory.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Structure and Agency in Revolutionary Theory

Success of the Communist Movement of the 1960's in Cuba and Not Bolivia

hellip; The political spheres, structure and organization of the communist parties in various countries, and the support of anticommunist nations contributed to the success or failure of the revolutions.... The political spheres, structure and organization of the communist parties in various countries, and the support of anticommunist nations contributed to the success or failure of the revolutions.... The paper will disapprove the theory that economic reasons cause communist uprisings....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

What extent does neo-realism provide a satisfactory account of world politics

Foreign policy is led by the structure, and the nation officials are thus prisoners of the revolutionary system' structure and its determinist's reasoning commands what they must carry out in the behavior of overseas rule (Jacques 2007, p.... In conclusion, neorealism is a concept of international relations, which was formerly defined by Waltz Kenneth as a response to the eminent realism theory.... It was also an effort to renovate and adjust the theory of realism to international politics....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Structure and Agency in Media and Culture

The researcher of this essay aims to study the relationships between structure and agency to better understand the environments of the society, and how humans living in that structure should exercise their agency for the benefit of society.... The paper tells that a debate, ongoing for decades is persistent in determining the relationship between structure and agency.... Whether considering the voluntary or planned actions of subjects, or micro/macro analysis of a society or individual, the debate on structure and agency relationship keeps recurring....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Language Game and the Problem of Free Will

hellip; These manuscripts will be used to explore important elements of complex social phenomenon that Habermas deemed relevant to demystify the linkages between social structure and human agency in everyday life.... 1 By integrating structure and action through communication and other factors in the public and private realm, the current paper will illustrate significant elements of Habermas's works in order to demonstrate its' profound impact on social theory that continues to this very day....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Understanding Social Change

Herbert Spencer offered the theory of change that was based on population growth and structural differences, Karl Marx examined change in revolutionary terms and that change is brought about by struggle for supremacy between economic classes. … Augusta Comte in his theory on social dynamics said that change in society progresses through a series of predictable stages based on development of human knowledge....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Transaction Cost Economics and Evolutionary Theories

Evolutionary theory also referred to as the old institutional economics as Foss (1994) defined it, this theory tends to investigate the possibility of transforming the already existing structures of organisations, therefore the evolutionary theory observes organisation forms as having emerged from the already existing...
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Global Justice and Planetary Health

Furthermore, Emerson's infusion of Transcendental ideas of the all-consuming essence of nature was also viewed as revolutionary, as well as cult-like among 19th century New Englanders.... Greta Gaard and Lori Gruens Ecofeminism: Towards Global Justice and Planetary Health begins by discussing the historical ramifications of the connection between ecology and feminism, linking them to a 1974 academic conference in Berkeley, California, and claiming the movement… The authors identify four questions that they argue guides ecofeminist investigations: “what are the problems that ecofeminism has addressed; how did these problems arise; why should these problems concern feminist; and why might ecofeminism 276)?...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Phenomenological Mind

ccording to Gallagher and Zahavi (2008: p6), one concept underlying phenomenology is that preoccupation with functionalism, identity theory, materialism, dualism, and other metaphysical issues may lead to highly abstract and technical discussions, which fail to connect to the experience.... In this case, phenomenology mainly deals with gaining a proper description and understanding of our mental experiential structure....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us