StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Health law Position/Analysis Paper - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Should Death Row Convicts Be Considered For Organ Donation? Name: Institution: Introduction Those who advocate for allowing death row convicts to donate their organs argue on the basis that the organs obtained from the convict will save a life. They say that it is meant to help those people suffering from long term diseases…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
Health law Position/Analysis Paper
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Health law Position/Analysis Paper"

Download file to see previous pages

This argument is in line with the legal perspective of denying death row convicts the desire to donate organs among other reasons. When one is convicted and given a death sentence, there are reasons according to the law, why he is considered to belong to such a category. There is also the issue of, allowing the death row convicts to donate their organs, is abiding by their wish. This therefore, does not accomplish the legal and moral obligations. According to perceptions from different people, allowing the convicts to donate their organs may not be a wrong thing to do, or some issue to be debated over.

The fact that the convict requests to be granted such a wish is the matter. There are two factors to consider in this debate; a) the fact that the convict requests to give his or her organs, and b) the view that focus should be on the organs which serve to help some people; even save lives. In this essay, the argument is on a legal perspective giving a recommendation on what is appropriate about the issues. Arguing Against Death Row Convicts Donating Organs There are ethical and practical barriers explaining why death row convicts are denied the chance to donate organs.

Ethical barriers involve the intention to preserve morality of capital punishment, and the fear of coercion. Moralists argue that by allowing the convicts to donate the organs, the intended purpose of capital punishment will not have been achieved. They also argue that by allowing the act, there are high chances that coercion will take place within the prison borders; that is, their rights may be violated. It is also argued that the prisoners produce poor quality organs due health and social problems, it would not be easy to procure the organs in executed prisoners, there would be low yield, and lack of support from the public (Lin, Rich, Pal & Sade, 2012).

Arguing for Death Row Convicts Donating Organs Considering the arguments presented by those advocating for organ donation by death row convicts, one would be convinced that it is the right thing to do. Lin, Rich, Pal and Sade (2012) argue that ‘one makes a differences’. This is a counter argument to a defence that says, death row inmates are just a few, and the number who would consent to organ donation could only yield a small quantity of organs. It is also argued that the qualifications for one to be an organ donor based on health and social issues should not deter prisoners from being donors.

They can be marginal donors. There is also an argument that poor quality organs are obtained because of the setting in which the organs are retrieved. Lin, Rich, Pal and Sade (2012) prove that both hospital and prison settings take almost similar time in donation after cardiac death (DCD) procedure. They also argue that even if, there was a difference in time; the organs could still be used as marginal organs. There will be no issue of coercion since the prisoners consent to the act. Even if there would be coercion, this would not apply to death row convicts since they are headed to execution.

Lin, Rich, Pal and Sade (2012) however, admits that if organ donation is considered a heroic act by the prisoner, the families seeking retribution would be offended, and the law would not have achieved its aims. Capital punishment would not have; a) Served as a determent for the crime committed, and b) Achieved retribution. In this case, they note that such donations should be carried out by

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Health law Position/Analysis Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1495604-health-law-position-analysis-paper
(Health Law Position/Analysis Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1495604-health-law-position-analysis-paper.
“Health Law Position/Analysis Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1495604-health-law-position-analysis-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Health law Position/Analysis Paper

Corporate Governance and Ethical Responsibility: An Analysis

DoRight; presented to this student as a means of providing the framework behind writing this response paper.... Although a vested interest does not necessarily correlate to an unethical action, it should nonetheless be noted by the reader that this vested interest is every bit as strong as any of those which will be or have been listed within this paper.... Name Date Course Section/# Corporate Governance and Ethical Responsibility: An analysis This brief analysis will seek to answer a series of questions concerning the case of Dr....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Job Analysis/Job Description

This paper draws a comparison between the two job positions in light of the episode of A bartender manager manages the bar, ensuring that all operations go efficiently and smoothly.... Job analysis was carried out through literature review and interviews with the bartender managers and beverage servers.... A bartender manager assumes a senior position in the bar with a lot of responsibilities....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

The Changes Their Impact on the Family Current Law

The focus of this analysis is to evaluate the changes in adoption law during the last 50 years and consider how far the 2002 Act has altered the rigidity of the previous system.... nbsp; The complex legal framework for adoption under UK law has fuelled academic and political debate, highlighting the inherent difficulty of legislating for sociological issues within a cohesive structure.... Indeed, Ball asserts that “the law can only regulate the process, but in doing so it provides the framework within which difficult decisions involving children's lives and complex personal sensitivities are taken”....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

The Minimum Wage Law

The paper "The Minimum Wage Law" states that the minimum wage law has been a work of good intentions that had severe unintended consequences.... The purpose of this paper is to examine the various issues surrounding the Minimum Wage Law and make a determination on the best approach to managing the low-end wage earners while working within the constitution and ideological constraints of capitalism.... For political conservatives, the minimum wage law violates some of the fundamental beliefs in the capitalist ideology....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Critical Analysis of Reading by Walter Miller

The" Critical Analysis of Reading by Walter Miller" paper deals with the apparent connection of ideology and criminal justice; primarily focusing our analysis on the landmark article of Walter B.... The paper intends to present the idea that “ideology and its consequences exert a powerful influence on the policies and procedures of those who conduct the enterprise of criminal justice, and that the degree and kinds of influence go largely unnoticed.... rdquo; (142) Miller has used a conceptual analysis of the various positions and theories in order to attain the purpose of the paper....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

The Most Important Benefit of Marriage

hellip; As the research paper highlights, the increase in cohabitation has also fuelled debate regarding the law's approach to determining rights on subsequent relationship breakdown, and the rising divorce rate has increased the importance of effective legal mechanisms in determining ancillary relief proceedings.... The focus of this paper is to critically discuss this argument and to this end, I shall evaluate the varying approach of the law to the financial division of assets on relationship breakdown with a comparative analysis of the rights of married couples on divorce in contrast to cohabitees....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Analysis of Organisational Behaviour

 This paper discusses organizational behavior in Imperial Tobacco Company.... The paper analyses The benchmark of ITC, which the fitness of each business systematically across the criterion of profitability, market standing, and internal vitality, ensure.... The business segments of ITC Ltd have diversified in hotels, Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG), paper & packaging, paperboards, and agribusiness.... ITC Infotech has gained a position for itself, by addressing the challenges of customers through their innovative IT solutions....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Stunning Worlds Fair EXPO 2015

The paper addresses the stated problem by considering the personality of Milan: Italian city.... This paper analyses and reports on the assurance of reliability and validity of research used.... The paper ends by recommending Milan to build on its cultural, artistic, and architectural heritage.... he paper utilizes both qualitative and quantitative research methods.... The questionnaires, web survey, focus group research and desk research will help in analysis....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us