StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Criminal Justice System Has Many Flaws that Need to Be Apprehended Right away - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "The Criminal Justice System Has Many Flaws that Need to Be Apprehended Right away" it is clear that although the modern era of science has facilitated the process of conviction, improper forensic science continues to haunt many innocent victims. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.5% of users find it useful
The Criminal Justice System Has Many Flaws that Need to Be Apprehended Right away
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Criminal Justice System Has Many Flaws that Need to Be Apprehended Right away"

The art of conviction in any country is no doubt complicated, time consuming, and can be improper. The possibility of wrongful convictions is quite prevalent since the nature of it is so sophisticated. The criminal justice system has many flaws that need to be apprehended right away, for the sake of innocence and justice. Wrongful conviction is also called “miscarriage of justice” is an issue that has caused even death penalties in some cases [1]. Wrongful cases can happen to anywhere and is improper since an innocent person is depriving of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, which is so precious to every human being [1]. Moreover, they take are detriment to economy since a wrong conviction of a person would obligate society to compensate a person for their wages. Hence, three causes of wrongful conviction are: eyewitness misidentification, improper forensic science, and bad lawyering [2]. Eyewitness testimonies are the primary source of evidence in cases such as his that lack forensic evidence[1]. Eyewitness misidentifications are also the single greatest cause of wrongful convictions nationwide, playing a role in more than 75% of convictions overturned through DNA testing. In 38% of the misidentification cases, several eyewitnesses misidentified the same innocent person [2]. Over 175 people have been wrongfully convicted because of misidentification but later were released due to DNA testing. Professor Gary Wells, pro-leader of the innocence project perfectly describes this issue as he states, “People tend to think of the ability to recognize a face as a natural ability [2].But a criminal situation is totally different than what people generally experience.” In order to reduce victim misidentification; it would be helpful to conduct a double-bind presentation in which the administrator is unaware of the witnesses’s description [2] . Another suggestion is to tell the person viewing the line- up is told that perpetrator may not be in the suspect line up. Furthermore, everything should be electronically recorded since it’s a strong information tool that can help the justice system reach the truth. It creates a barrier towards false confession, and at the same time is capable to forming a strong evidence to convict the guilty[2]. Another suggestion is to expand the discovery process. Discovery is an essential process in which the prosecution reveals confidential information before the trial that is associated with the investigation. This is highly critical since it builds accuracy, confidence, and reliability. In essence, the expansion of “discovery” can protect against wrongful convictions. A sequential presentation can also reform the process, which consists of lining up members one-by-one instead of side-by-side [3]. Habib Wahir Abdal, Adams Kenneth, and Gilbert Alejandro were all victims of eyewitness misidentification who were later released through DNA testing [3]. All these victims were wrongfully convicted because of eye witness misidentification. If the systematic change such as sequential presentation would have been implemented, these victims would have not been convicted [2]. Ivan Henry is another example of how eyewitness misidentifications have led to wrongful convictions. Henry was convicted of raping 8 women in Vancouver [3]. Unfortunately, the case only relied in eyewitness identification, which was highly questionable. In addition, the trail judge were bias towards convicting him as he told the jury that Henry resisted in the photo lineup. Henry had been in custody since his arrest in 1982 as he was convicted by a jury in 1983 on 10 counts. He represented himself at trial after his lawyer, Richard Peck, withdrew [2]. Sometimes the person pointing out the witness is full of emotion and pressure for justice, that they make decisions in haste. Human beings are infamous for forgetting things, and some memories are true, while others are a mixture of fantasy and deception. Taking time in a presentation and calming the witness can furthermore ease the process. Although the modern era of science has facilitated the process of conviction, improper forensic science continues to haunt many innocent victims. This is not the fault of the scientist all the time, but rather the science itself [2]. In other situations, DNA analysts fail to make a proper judgment due to lack of resources, poor training, and pressure from authorities [2].. Yet that does not diminish the fact that many analysts have behaved improperly by being involved in misconduct[3]. It is certainly not difficult to modify or taint evidence a particular case. The forensic scientist does have the pathway to fabricate results, and mask certain aspects of results that can give some leverage to a defendant [2]. Nonetheless, many analysts have practiced these unjust schemes that have resulted in plenty of wrongful convictions all across the border[2].This situation could be perfectly portrayed in the case of Alejandro Dominguez, who was convicted of a rape assault, based upon the fact that his semen matched his blood type. The semen was found in the victim’s body, which the expert “scientist” insisted upon. However, the scientist failed out to point out the fact that two-thirds of men in America could have matched that sample. If the jury understood the fact, and called out for more liable proof, than his sentence would not have lasted four years[2].. He is just one of the few examples of how even with modern forensic testimony, innocent people can be convicted. The “icing on the cake” that leads to improper convictions are false confessions. In about 25% of DNA cases, defendants made statements because of external influences. Innocent people certainly have variety of factors that influence them to confess them of something they didn’t do. These factors consist of: duress, coercion, intoxication, impairment, fear of violence, long sentences, miscomprehending the situation, and ignorance of the law[3]. In addition, age can also be a favor as children can be easily be manipulated. In addition, the incentive or the fake assurance that both children and adult “they can return home” as much as they admit guilt. Even stable, mental adults give false confession in order to reduce the length of interrogation, and falling in a false belief that they will prove their innocence later[3]. This scenario could be illustrated again in the case of Eddie Joe Royal. Mr. Royal was convicted murder of a 16-year old after he wrote to the police on how to solve crimes that plague Detroit[2]. Lloyd was also mentally unstable, and was fed lies by police that he was aiding them by giving them details of a real killer [2]. In reality however, Lloyd was manipulated to sign a confession and a recorded-statement about the crime. However, in 2002 Lloyd was proven innocent after DNA testing and was exonerated. Again these countless techniques used by officials are unjust and false.   APA [1] burden of conviction. (2010). In Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved November 29, 2010, from Encyclopædia Britannica Online:http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/84965/burden-of-conviction [2] The Innocence Project: understand causes. Retrieved November 28, 2010, from http://www.innocenceproject.org/understand/Unreliable-Limited-Science.php [3] Mary Carroll.  (2001, January). Never Too Late: The Prosecutors Story of Justice in the Medgar Evers Case [The Booklist, 97(9/10), 883.  Retrieved December 5, 2010, from ProQuest Education Journals. (Document ID: 66870130). Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Criminal Justice System Has Many Flaws that Need to Be Apprehended Research Paper, n.d.)
The Criminal Justice System Has Many Flaws that Need to Be Apprehended Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1745880-innocence-commission
(The Criminal Justice System Has Many Flaws That Need to Be Apprehended Research Paper)
The Criminal Justice System Has Many Flaws That Need to Be Apprehended Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/law/1745880-innocence-commission.
“The Criminal Justice System Has Many Flaws That Need to Be Apprehended Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1745880-innocence-commission.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Criminal Justice System Has Many Flaws that Need to Be Apprehended Right away

Public Enemies by Johnny Depp

The events that took place show that it is possible to achieve the criminal justice irrespective of the duration it take.... Just as it is reflected in the movie, the criminal gang tagged as public enemy could not live longer than they had expected.... the criminal group organized several robberies with violence and all manner of actions, which left people just guessing on their next move.... In addition, it makes it easy to understand the roles that the federal body played in preventing the criminal activities of the gang and its members....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Development of Professional Policing In Nineteenth Century England

Sometimes victims were unable to pay for the services of the constable and the criminal would not be apprehended.... In the protracted battle that was to follow the detractors initially gained the upper hand and were able to stall many parliamentary measures that were proposed to establish more professional and effective policing.... The reasons were many for the charges against the old police.... John Wade in response to this practice said, "The office has fallen into the hands of the lowest class of retailers and costardmongers, who make up the deficient allowance of their principals by indirect sources of emolument" (cited by Rawlings, 2002, p....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Criminal Court Visit

The public may perceive that the ends justify the means and that the criminal procedure as it is written today may violate or deprive an individual of the constitutional rights.... the criminal procedures must balance the defendant's right and the state's interest in a speedy and efficient trial with the desire for justice.... Many times juries will not be informed that their decision will pass down an extremely harsh sentence for fear that they will not find guilt because they do not like the sentencing guidelines for the criminal activity....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Honesty versus Justice

Prepare a 1000 to 1500 word paper on "Honesty versus Justice and Due Process versus Crime Control" by explaining some of the ethical dimensions of key issues confronting the criminal justice system and private security. According to the 'Random House Dictionary of the English Langauge' 'Honesty' means the quality of being honest, uprightness, probity, or integrity, freedom from deceit and fraud.... The whole lot from Police to Judiciary and legislature that enacts the laws play a part in the legal system; in fact all have their roles defined in the criminal justice system....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Compare with crime control theory vs due process

The essay compares crime control theory with due process and explains the difference between these approaches and how they affect the criminal justice system.... Both these models are important to the system of criminal justice and they play a key role in identifying offences and also in the interpretation of the criminal justice system.... His article is said to have influenced every person who works on the criminal justice system.... In the said article, the author has further proposed the criminal justice model and the due process model....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Police Brutality in New York and New Jersey

In as much as the law allows the use of reasonable force by the police in apprehending suspects, the governments of New York and New Jersey should install the relevant surveillance systems to reduce the many incidences of police brutality Despite the fact that the law on procedures of apprehension is very clear, some police officers still prefer to use excessive and more often unreasonable force in dealing with suspects or innocent citizens (Holmes and Smith 87)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us