StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Legal Responsibility of an Individual - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Legal Responsibility of an Individual" states that Damien faces several counts of criminal liability. He has a primary link with the death of Michael and Cheryl. On the other hand, the death of Victoria could have been avoided if he took the responsibility to take her to the hospital…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
The Legal Responsibility of an Individual
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Legal Responsibility of an Individual"

Criminal liability case al affiliation In the context of criminal law, criminal liability constitutes the legal responsibility of an individual or a group of people to an act or omission. The act or omission in this sense implies any activity that injures another party or negatively affects the course of a particular action, subjects a corporation or individual to disrepute. The credibility of a criminal liability lawsuit depends on the ability of the complainant to effectively serve the court with sufficient information to justify negligence of duty on the part of the accused, or a proximate cause of the failure to some harm or injury1. On the other hand, criminal liability may degenerate directly from the acts that constitute a crime. For instance, a motorist who runs a street light and hits a pedestrian at a zebra crossing is liable for a lawsuit2. There are several forms of liability including tort liability, statutory, joint, or civil liabilities. This paper provides an exposition of Damien’s criminal liability relating to the death of the young Victoria, the father, and Cheryl. In any country, the supreme law acts as the standard benchmark of crime. In essence, individuals who act in contravention of the stipulation of the constitution become liable for prosecution. Only in special conditions do individuals reserve immunity of the law. Cases of commitment of crime as a result of mental illness often attract fewer punitive arbitrations. The Dicey’s theory provides a basic consideration of the supreme law. It asserts that no one should be subjected to punishment unless the law justifies it3. This assertion grants the supreme law hegemony over arbitrary power. Secondly, Dicey posits that no progressive constitution provides room for preferential treatment of individuals irrespective of their statuses. Damien faces several counts of criminal liabilities. In the onset, the act of taking away the life of anybody irrespective of their health conditions amounts to murder case. Without subjecting the mental orientation of Damien to any introspection, it is outright that he murdered Michael and Cheryl. In the case of Victoria’s death, fair reasoning never resulted in hostile treatments4. It is biased reasoning to hold him accountable for Victoria’s death. However, his case concerning Victoria’s death is complicated when he prevents Michael from reporting the matter to the police. It is legally binding on an aggrieved party and the aggressor to access justice from legal apparatus at any time of disagreement. The confrontation with Damien resulting in the death of Michael amounts to proximate liability5. In essence, it is perceivable that the confrontational approach of Michael resulted from the death of his daughter. If in case Damien too agonized the unprecedented death of the daughter, he acted irrationally to confront the aggrieved dad. He already had a stake in the death of Victoria and since he had a primary responsibility to ensure Victoria’s safety. He had failed in his assigned task and could only have acted rationally by consoling Michael6. In legal context, it is conceivable that attempts to avoid justice prove guilt. The revelation that Damien prevented Victoria’s father from legal authority casts aspersions on his was innocence of Victoria’s death. Furthermore, by accepting to take care of, even though, no legal contract was signed, Damien assumed the roles of a guardian. It is the legal responsibility of parents to ensure that those under their care are free from danger. Damien, oblivious of the implications of the injury, failed to keep constant check on the sleeping child. This act of negligence exposes Damien to the law. Damien as an adult was aware that concrete is a hard material, and Victoria could have injured the head from inside. He, therefore, had the responsibility to take her to the hospital, which he ignored. Emotions and ignorance bear no defense in law. It is acceptable that the pain of losing a loved daughter could have prompted Michael to behave unsoundly; however, Michael confronted the already grieving Michael. This is conceivably an assault which again contributed to murder when he drowned the unconscious body of Michael and the dead daughter to conceal evidence of murder. It is acceptable that psychological illnesses result in misjudgment. However, in a case of actual mental problem the perpetrator should remain unalarmed by the repercussions of their acts. It is admissible that mental tests revealed that Michael was not in a good state of mind to stand a trial for murder. Nonetheless, the fact that he got alarmed by the unconscious state of Michael and the death of Victoria implies his guilt. Damien consciously realized his possible implication in a murder probe and disposed off the bodies of the two for safety. In essence, it remains legally speculative whether the mental disorder diagnosed in Damien resulted in his murderous acts or otherwise the murderous acts resulted in the mental disorder7. If the former is true, Damien is liable for the murder of Michael. Furthermore, an attempt to conceal evidence of the crime exposes Damien as a rational criminal who is aware of the impacts of the law and its due process. In a case example of R.v Pritchard (1836), the defendant was deaf and dumb. The presiding judge Alderson set out mechanisms to determine the inability of the defendant to plead due to his condition. The jury was directed to interrogate three conditions of the defendant to allow effective proceedings. In the case of Damien, psychiatric tests revealed his mental sickness but this alone could justify lack of criminal liability. Insanity claims do not free murderers from a second-degree murder liability. In criminal jurisprudence, it is assumable that even when criminals are not in the right state of mind, they are aware of crime. This awareness of crime in illness results to plea of guilty but mentally ill. Guilty but mentally ill criminals are liable for second-degree murder lawsuit. However, mental illness that meets insanity threshold is permissible for leniency. A court session by the European court sitting on 13th May 2003 in arbitration of a murder probe involving an allegedly insane assailant is a case example of a court process involving mentally ill defendants. In this case, the criminal was held in custody awaiting psychiatric report. The reports revealed he was suffering from paranoid schizophrenia8. After elaborate court sessions, the court ruled that the criminal was unfit to plead for murder9. It was decided that he be detained in hospital for treatment since he could not be held liable for murder. In the case of Michael and Damien, by virtue of having left the kid under Damien’s care on several other occasions and found her safe, it is speculative to believe that he was ill as at the time of the murder. This implies that Damien is liable for a second-degree murder case unless repeated psychiatric tests prove otherwise. Sustenance of a criminal liability depends on the available information about the mental illness of accused and its relevance to the offense in question. Responsibility for criminal offense results from a conscious engagement of an individual in crime. Section 1(1) mental health act amended section 1(2) mental Health Act 1983 of the English constitution define mental disorder as any disorder or disability of the mind that result in irrational or unconscious actions10. Section 1(3) mental health act restricts the exploitation of mental illness to protect promiscuity or other immoral acts. According to the legal provisions every individual with the age of discretion, is, presumed by law to be sane accountable for his actions. The onus is on the resistance to establishing insanity at the time of the offense on the balance of probabilities. Therefore, unless there is contrary statutory authority, the prosecution has to establish beyond all reasonable doubt, when particular issues arise no forces are involved that affect sanity11. The paranoia that besets Damien after the death of Michael gives an evidential link between his stability of mind before the occurrence of the deaths.in this sense, unless the mental diagnosis gives the undisputable timeline in which the diagnosed mental problem began, Damien is liable for the death of Cheryl and Michael12. Mental illnesses undeniably disrupt a persons thinking, feeling, mood, ability to relate to others and daily functioning. Serious mental illnesses include major depression, schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), and panic disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder and borderline personality disorder. It is legally admissible that some mentally ill individuals experience cognitive inability to make rational decisions to prevent criminal offenses. It is important to balance between criminal justice and public security. The American judicial system practice sentences of guilty but mentally ill. This facilitates the achievement of justice for both the complainant and the defendant13. Liability of ‘guilty but mentally ill’ subjects the accused to mental rehabilitation as part of the detention for the criminal act. This form of liability achieves congruence between public security and the criminal’s state of mind. Taking such verdict into consideration, even though Damien was later diagnosed with mental illness, granting amnesty would imply collaboration with crime on the side of the law enforcement agency. The neutrality of any law provides for justice to all the parties estranged in a lawsuit14. The subjection of criminals to punishment ought to be overly deterrent. It could be possible that other mentally ill but conscious individuals would exploit their situations to commit more criminal acts. The case of Damien involvement in the death of Michael and Cheryl predisposes him to the due process of the law. The death of Victoria degenerated purely from the accident; Damien bears no legal responsibility since anyone is predisposed to accidents15. “Mental illness” bears varying connotations in a legal and psychological sense. In a psychological sense, a person must meet the criteria for a disorder listed in Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders to qualify for mental disability. In a legal context, a person must be insane based on four pre-determined tests of insanity. Notably, volition and responsibility determine whether and how much punishment an offender should receive.in the case of Damien, unless evidence pointed to the mental disorder diagnosed in previous tests. He has legal liability for the murder of Michael and Cheryl16. In a case example; Rv Henesy (1989) court appeal, the appellant, had been arrested driving a stolen car but pleaded to be diabetic and that the wife had just left him17. However, the jury determined that the appropriate prayer for leniency would have been insanity and not diabetes. This implies that if sufficient evidence supported the fact that Damien was surely insane as at the time of the murder, he bears no criminal liability18. In conclusion, Damien faces several counts of criminal liability. He has a primary link with the death of Michael and Cheryl. On the other hand, the death of Victoria could have been avoided if he took the responsibility to take her to hospital or otherwise notified the father19. This non-responsiveness to the plight of Victoria implicates Damien on a negligent of responsibility case. Leniency is granted by any constitution on criminals diagnosed with mental sickness that affect their quality of judgment however, such provisions must be consistent with available evidence on the mental disorder and the implications of such leniency n the security of the public. A more neutral approach to Damien’s criminal liability should take into account his mental condition without compromising the security of the public20. This implies that Damien is liable on the basis of “guilty mentally ill.” The first guidelines for a test of insanity in English courts were based on the 1843 trial of Daniel M’Naghten in England. The M’Nagthen rules created during this trial established that every person is of “sound” mind unless they can prove otherwise. To prove an insanity defense “If only at the time of committing the act, Damien was acting under such a defect of reason, as not to know the nature of the act he was involved in. In this light, if he did know what he was doing hence he reserves non-criminal liability. Bibliography Aneshensel, Phelan, Bierman. Handbook of the sociology of mental Health. (Dordrecht: Springer, 2012). Bailis, Darley, Waxman, Robinson. Community standards of criminal liability and the insanity defense. Law and Human Behavior. (425-446, 1995). Boston, Manville. Prisoners’ self-help litigation manual. (Oxford: Oceana, 2010) Chen, Ke. Criminal law and criminal procedure law in the People’s Republic of China: Commentary and legislation (2013) Elliot. The rules of insanity: Moral Responsibility and The Mentally ill offender. Albany, NY: state Unv. of New York Press).Criminal Justice in action: The core. (Belmont, C.A: Thomas Wardsworth Inc, 2013). Gardner, Anderson. Criminal law, (Belmont, CA: Wordsworth Learning Inc 2012). Great Britain. Mental Health Act 2007: Chapter 12. (London: Stationery Office 2007) Reed, Bohlander, Wake. General defenses in criminal law: Domestic and comparative perspectives (2014). Loughnan. Manifest Madness: Mental Incapacity in the Criminal Law. (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2012). Moore. Current trends in policing and the mentally ill in Europe: a review of the literature. Police Practice and Research. doi:10.1080/15614261003701756 (2010) Probation and mental illness. Journal of Forensic Psychiatry & Psychology. doi:10.1080/14789949.2012.704640 (2012). Purpura, Criminal justice: An introduction. (Boston: Butterworth-Heinemann 1996) Parry, American Bar Association,Criminal mental health and disability law, evidence and testimony: A comprehensive reference Manual for lawyers judges and criminal justice professionals, (Chicago: Commission on mental and physical Disability law 2009) Pallock, Ethical Dilemmas and decision in criminal justice, Australia: (Wordsworth Cengage Learning 2009). Rodensky, The Crime in Mind: Criminal Responsibility and the Victorian Novel. (New York: Oxford University Press, 2003).  Robinson. Law without justice: Why Criminal Law Doesn’t Give people what they deserve. (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005). Torrey, E.F. National Alliance for the mentally ill (US) & public citizen health research group. Criminalizing the seriously mentally ill: The abuse of jails as mental hospitals, a joint report of the national alliance for the mentally and pubic citizen health (2002) Levy and Nachshon, D & Carmi, A. Psychiatry and the law. Tel Aviv, Israel: Yozmot Pub. (2002) Zechmeister, Kilian, McDaid. Is it worth investing in mental health promotion and prevention of mental illness? A systematic review of the evidence from economic evaluations. BMC Public Health. (2008). Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Criminal law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words - 3, n.d.)
Criminal law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words - 3. https://studentshare.org/law/1862051-criminal-law
(Criminal Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words - 3)
Criminal Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words - 3. https://studentshare.org/law/1862051-criminal-law.
“Criminal Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words - 3”. https://studentshare.org/law/1862051-criminal-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Legal Responsibility of an Individual

Movie Piracy: Stealing and Irresponsibility

Movie piracy is bad, because it is another form of stealing and showcases the lack of responsibility of people for their movie-sharing actions, and so it should be stopped by the government and film industry through a carrot-and-stick approach.... Movie piracy also erases the responsibility of people for what they did not even pay for.... This includes educating students and communities about the legal and ethical implications of piracy (Read)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Cons of Underage Drinking

With respect to the actual age of being able to buy and imbibe alcoholic beverages, this too should be a function of similar laws which define when an individual can vote, can engage in sexual relations, and can join the military in service of their country.... It will be the purpose of this analysis to measure and consider many of the current issues surrounding underage drinking while at the same time offering a simple rubric and solution to an issue that is costing the legal system hundreds of millions of dollars in expense and countless hours of needless and wasted man hours to enforce....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

The value of Life

The appreciation of the harmony and tranquility witnessed in the past indicated the level of personal ethics and social responsibility of the society.... hellip; The challenge of the value of life has been partly handled by the legal structure through the setting of the penalty helped developed the understanding of the value of life.... The difference between the non-legal manner and the legal approach is handling the matter creates a minimal difference in the society....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Four Suspects: One Legal Stop

hen the flight is 'unprovoked' and can be shown to have taken place in a 'high crime area,'" an officer is justified in stopping and frisking the individual (Williams, 2000, p.... With that power comes the responsibility to act lawfully and reasonably.... Their pursuit of the individuals was proper and legal.... Having encountered the suspects loitering in a high-crime area, then seeing them attempt to evade, the officers made a legal stop....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Federal Law of the United States

A classic example of such an instance can be cited in the case of Schiavo1 in which all the academics, scholars, journalists, columnists and whoever can write or say something irrespective of their depth of knowledge vehemently debated the changes made by the Federal Laws only to affect the life of an individual in Schiavo.... ith this background I intend to present this paper on the ability of a country like United States to handle the Bills of Attainder or the legal framework made to control the acts or deeds, commissions or omissions of an individual....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

U06d2 Legal Reporting

The government has allowed for the health care personnel to participate and help the society by reporting any kind of suspicious behavior, however if this right and responsibility is dishonored and misused to falsely report, then the individual can also be faced with serious consequences like civil and even criminal obligations (Pozgar, Santucci, & Pinnella, 2009).... In order to ensure that the general public is provided with the best levels of safety and highest levels of quality in terms of health care, the government and the American Medical… together have developed numerous laws that are mainly to protect the general public and ensure that all the processes and events are legal and in the best interest of all....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Describe legal system incentives for social responsibility

They present to the world a picture of their contribution to the society in form of a good deed named –Corporate Social… In order to develop a CSR program, Economies of scale also have to be considered, for such efforts can never be demonstrated to improve social welfare, which are not favourable for the organization fiscally. Getting people to do a responsible act can be a task Describe legal system incentives for social responsibility ID Lecturer Corporations across the globe seek to present an image to the world of what and how they are contributing to the society apart from churning up revenues....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Viable Morality and the Legal Component

"Viable Morality and the legal Component" paper has an insight into the various areas in which human morality issues have raised mixed reactions (abortion and the possible alternatives as enumerated by Honore) so that we can have a clear understanding of the relationship between morality and law.... nbsp; … I agree with Honore that individual obligation to others is determinable individually with or without the generalized obligation determination....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us