StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Death Trap in Dove and Heaneys Poems - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper "The Death Trap in Dove and Heaney’s Poems" argues in a well-organized manner that in both Rita Dove’s “Fifth Grade Autobiography” and Seamus Heaney’s “Mid-term Break” the poems the speaker or the author has lost someone close to their heart…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.8% of users find it useful
The Death Trap in Dove and Heaneys Poems
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Death Trap in Dove and Heaneys Poems"

The Death Trap in Dove and Heaney’s Poems The Death Trap in Dove and Heaney’s Poems Rita Dove’s “FifthGrade Autobiography” and Seamus Heaney’s “Mid-term Break” both talk about the same concept, death. The former talks about the death of the author’s grandfather through suddenly kindled memory while the later is a direct commentary about the funeral of the Poet’s young brother. In both the poems the speaker or the author has lost someone close to their heart. In "Fifth Grade Autobiography" the poet is reminded of a death which happened long ago while looking at a photo casually. In Haeneys "Mid-Term Break" the author talks about the grief he experiences directly on the day of his young brothers death. Both the poems leave the readers mind burdened with an unexplainable melancholy towards the end, though they do not have any direct descriptions about death in them. Dove’s poem starts by describing a photograph in past tense “I was four in this photograph fishing” The nice rhyming in the poem with ‘this’ and ‘fish’ kindles the readers to continue further. The characters in the photograph are introduced one by one, starting with Dove’s brothers. The poem proceeds to describe the boys somewhat raggedy dressing style. Any literary analyst will note alliteration here, with the emphasis on the “K” in the following lines. The cap of the brother is explained in detail creating a vivid picture of the extra furry cap and the bushy tail hanging beneath it any mind that reads it. By this time, the reader understands, the author’s childhood memories are rekindled when she is watching an old photograph. The poem continues in a swift pace in colloquial style in broken sentences. The dialectical tradition of African-American poetry actually increases the interest to finish the poem fully. The poem proceeds with the line “My grandfather sits to the far right in a folding chair,” The seating of the grandfather with his hands of the tobacco pocket is explained followed by the rhyming description of how the grandmother leans on to the brush. The sun light creates beautiful images on her dress as she stands against the ice chest. This situation is described aesthetically as “sun through the trees printing her dress with soft luminous paws.” The humble smile in the grandmother’s mind will come to the readers mind, without any mention of it. Dove suddenly mentions about her jealousy at her brother during his first horse ride. The childishness of the author makes us compare the meaning of the poem with the title automatically. Dove changes the subject again taking about her grandfather smells of lemons and suddenly out of nowhere about his death in just two words “He’s died –” The incompleteness of the sentence leave place for ample imagination. She just ends by saying she still remembers his hands. The sudden abruptness of the grandfather’s death gives the user a jerk. It makes them wonder about several things what might have caused it and when. The author leaves all the answers to be answered according to the readers will, contemplating on the dead man’s hand. She had established her connection with him fully. Dove’s main strength is the folk elements prevalent throughout the poem in several places like the brothers dressing style and grandfather smelling of lemon. There is no introspection about anything. She just writes about what happened in a simple but lively tone. She deals with truthful emotions without giving them any extra trimming or decorative words. There is no metaphor, simile or any other poetic strategy used in the poem. But, it does make the readers feel morbid and nostalgic towards the end. Seamus Heaney’s “Mid-term Break” deals with death in a more elaborate European manner. The poem starts with the poet waiting uneasily for his neighbors to pick him up from college. Instead of going home for the mid-term break happily with his parents, someone else is coming to pick him up. The reader’s interest is kindled as to what happened. The poet keeps building up the suspense by describing how he meets his macho father crying. He mentions the word funeral for the first time in the poem. Every father is a hero to his boy. Most boys dont know their fathers could actually cry. This childish shock is explained indirectly in the second stanza. He also mentions his utter surprise of seeing his father crying in the lines “In the porch I met my father crying--” In contrast to depicting his father crying, the author describes his mother sighing tearlessly in the lines “as my mother held my hand In hers and coughed out angry tearless sighs.” The mother who is expected to cry is dried of tears while the father who is expected to stay calm is weeping because of the hard blow. The poet continues to express the uneasy feeling when the strangers start respecting him suddenly by shaking his hand and expressing their condolences. Since, the father is broken with grief the poet is inclined to accept their sympathies as the eldest son of the household. The last three stanzas deal with the actual dead person. The corpse arrives dressed by nurses. The poet takes a look at his young dead brother, looking pale and sleeping in his coffin like a cot. He goes on to explain how he died hit by a car. The last line of the poem says “A four foot box, a foot for every year” The metaphor in the last stanza comparing the cot to the coffin and the size of the box to the dead boy’s age does the trick. It makes the readers feel sorry for the dead boy and his family. There are three main similarities in both the poems. Family love emphasized beautifully in both the poems. Both of them deal with the same concept death and both the poems are written in first person prospective. The three poems contrast with each other in certain terms too. Both the poems use a different style of writing. The first one uses dialectal folk type words and styles while the later uses the Standard English language used in European households. The first poem deals with memories and the second one deal with the actual happening in the present tense. The third main contrast is the descriptions. No description about the death or how it happened is mentioned in the first poem while the second one deals elaborately about the funeral scene, corpse description, reason for death etc. Conclusion Both the poems deal with the same subject and create the required nostalgic or morbid feelings in the readers mind. The former one is a simple mans view and description of life, while the later is a refined and educated persons recording of his first grief in life. Both are masterpieces in their own accord. References 1. Dove, Rita. Fifth Grade Autobiography. Poetry Foundation . 1989. 12 Sept 2012 . 2. Heaney, Seamus. Mid-term Break. Famous Poets and Poems. 1966. 12 Sept 2012 3. Alison Booth, J Paul Hunter, and Kelly J Mays. The Norton Introduction to Literature. 9th ed. New York: Norton, 2005. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Choose two poems that contain a similar subject and compare the two Essay”, n.d.)
Choose two poems that contain a similar subject and compare the two Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1602673-choose-two-poems-that-contain-a-similar-subject-and-compare-the-two-poems-explain-and-analyze-them-accordingly
(Choose Two Poems That Contain a Similar Subject and Compare the Two Essay)
Choose Two Poems That Contain a Similar Subject and Compare the Two Essay. https://studentshare.org/literature/1602673-choose-two-poems-that-contain-a-similar-subject-and-compare-the-two-poems-explain-and-analyze-them-accordingly.
“Choose Two Poems That Contain a Similar Subject and Compare the Two Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1602673-choose-two-poems-that-contain-a-similar-subject-and-compare-the-two-poems-explain-and-analyze-them-accordingly.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Death Trap in Dove and Heaneys Poems

My Sisters Keeper by Jodi Picoult

In discussing the natures of family, death, and love, Picault explores the focus of a family that is in the wake of a devastating illness that is ravaging the life of the older child.... In the protagonist's life, death was a presence that had hovered over her from the time she was born....
14 Pages (3500 words) Book Report/Review

Comparative Analysis of the Nature of God in the Book of Job and the Nature of God in Beowulf

For the sake of Job, God has made his real presence felt as He talks and rebukes his friends -- Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar and deals with Satan in a casual manner instead of considering to vanish all the evil schemes which Satan negotiates with Him, confident that the enemy will later fall into his own trap....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Oedipus - Blinded by Overconfidence and Enlightened through Sightlessness

He cherishes it throughout the life as his own accomplishment without understanding it was yet another trap prepared for him to make him marry his biological mother Jacosta.... Oedipus – Blinded By Overconfidence and Enlightened Through Sightlessness Oedipus was born and bought up in royalty....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Othello by William Shakespeare

Othello is a great play written by William Shakespeare, who is accredited for many other works, especially during the Elizabethan era.... The play revolves around the themes of wealth, racial discrimination, love, and hate among many other themes.... .... ... ... Verbal positive depiction of Othello is illustrated through the many speeches of different characters in the play....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Prosody of Dickinson and Whitman

Emily Dickenson used rhyming patterns in her poetry such as "To Make a Prairie (1755)" and Poem 632 In the poem "I Cannot Live With You" rhyme is used in the fourth section: And were You lost, I would be-Though My NameRang loudestOn the Heavenly fame-And were You-saved-And I-condemned to beWhere You were not-That self-were Hell to Me-Not only did Dickenson use the traditional form of rhyme in her poems she used what.... Many poems are stories put to rhyme or verse....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Geographical References Used In Abraham Lincolns Gettysburg Address

The essay "The Geographical References Used In Abraham Lincoln's Gettysburg Address" presents the following things: on this continent; that nation or any nation; a great battle-field of that war; a portion of that field; this ground; the world; this nation; and the earth.... ... ... ... Their deep insights about life are most valuable that without them, the study of American Literature would be incomplete....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Presentation of Power and Social Status within Women in Literature

The author of the paper "The Presentation of Power and Social Status within Women in Literature" argues in a well-organized manner that the self-discovery of Lady Chatterley places her in a more powerful role and enables her to challenge the conventions of society.... ... ... ... D.... .... Lawrence has presented the themes of power and social status within women in his novel 'Lady Chatterley's Lover' to portray the struggle between the individual and society....
15 Pages (3750 words) Coursework

Incidents in the life of a slave girl

In the case of Linda who was a beautiful female slave fell into an additional trap since her master fell in love with her (Harriet, Jacob 11).... The incident in the life of a slave girl is a narrative telling the life of a slave girl Harriet Ann Jacobs featuring in the story by the name Linda Brent (Harriet, Jacob 11)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us