StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Research Critique on: Complementary Therapy Use Among Older Rural Adults - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The title does not entirely describe the study and nor does it contain the variables. It needs to clarify what is meant by 'older', which 'rural' areas were involved and define the variables. An alternative title could be:
While the Abstract explains the purpose of the study, it is vague in parts…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
Research Critique on: Complementary Therapy Use Among Older Rural Adults
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Research Critique on: Complementary Therapy Use Among Older Rural Adults"

Download file to see previous pages

The researchers are all eminently qualified in the fields of research, nursing, education and management. Their vast combined experience and the geographical position from which they operate suggests a thorough knowledge of the topic. Both Shreffler-Grant and Weinart have researched and published in the areas of Holistic Nursing, Hospices, (Shreffler-Grant) Small Rural Hospital Care, (Shreffler- Grant), Rural Women (Weinert), and Chronic Health Conditions (Weinert). Bette Ide has developed a Farm/Ranch Stress Scale, published on Ethical issues in the quality of care and health related hardiness and service use of rural older adults, while Elizabet Nichols has vast managerial and educational experience.

Their qualifications include PhD., R.N., and professorial positions, all quality attributes which give confidence in the study and report. The article, as published in Public Health Nursing Vol 22 No.4 in July 2005, does not give a clear statement of when exactly the work was carried out. Page 326, para 3 has a reference (Shreffler 1999) and p325 mentions a paper published by an undergraduate as a result of involvement in this work, dated 2003. While the Abstract directs us to the Objective and hypothesis, there is no clear framework or map as such.

However, from the Methods through to the Discussion, all requirements connected to the purpose are present, some more than others. While Measures are identified and described, there is not enough information regarding the descriptive design interview. The questionnaire should have been included, as should more specifics as to when interviews took place (e.e. time of day, numbers per week and so on). Had the questionnaire and more details been provided, this would allow for replication of the study elsewhere.

I would contend that overall, despite these omissions, the design meets the needs of the research adequately.THIS IS WHERE YOU NEED THAT CONCEPT MAP, IF ONE EXISTS, I AM NOT SUREWithin the study, human rights are fully protected, at no time could any individual be identified, nor was anyone coerced. Approval was given by the Human Subjects Institutional Review Boards at both universities. The Problem is introduced on p 324, para 3, and from there on, the issues are elucidated, with connections made between their significance and the work of nursing and health professionals.

The need for the research is well presented, with good references and information on earlier research findings in support. This study is thus highlighted as unique in its goals, which are made clear. The study also shows an adherence to a holistic approach, not dismissing the use of complementary therapies as negative, but perceiving this health choice to have value. Variables used characterized the use of any form of complementary therapy, as it was found that some people used therapists, some self-directed therapies and some used both.

Table 2 presents these in a simple and easy to comprehend format. As mentioned earlier, the research questions are defined, the results well explained and expanded on, I would also contend

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Research Critique on: Complementary Therapy Use Among Older Rural Essay”, n.d.)
Research Critique on: Complementary Therapy Use Among Older Rural Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1518099-research-critique-on-complementary-therapy-use-among-older-rural-adults
(Research Critique On: Complementary Therapy Use Among Older Rural Essay)
Research Critique On: Complementary Therapy Use Among Older Rural Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1518099-research-critique-on-complementary-therapy-use-among-older-rural-adults.
“Research Critique On: Complementary Therapy Use Among Older Rural Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1518099-research-critique-on-complementary-therapy-use-among-older-rural-adults.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Research Critique on: Complementary Therapy Use Among Older Rural Adults

What are the suicidal risk factors for older adults

One of the main causes of suicide among the aged is depression, and it accounts to a large percentage of the suicide deaths among older people in United States of America (Zweig, 1993).... hellip; What are the suicidal risk factors for older adults?... Suicide, among the older adults is a worrying trend.... There older population, are more likely to commit suicide than younger people, and this is because of their vulnerability to depression and other chronic illness....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Healthcare Inequality among Older Adults

Healthcare Inequality among older adults Name Tutor Collage Date Introduction Health care generally tends to get worse as age advances.... The society at the moment has changed, and older people are more in number due to improved medical care offered.... This has led to a need to research on the social economic disparities among the older people.... hellip; This implies the direct relation between economic disparities among the old and their health status....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Substance Abuse Among Aging Adults

The current study, conducted by personnel from 'US Department of Health and Human Services' and 'Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration' evaluates the grave nature of rising number of aging adults suffering from SUD (Substance Use Disorder).... ational Survey of Drug Use and Mental Health's data for the year 2000-2006 was used to calculate the current SUD suffering adults.... The results were then logistically regressed to project the expected number of adults suffering from SUD in the year 2020....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Placement of Older Adults

rosacks as he has to use a walker while climbing down the stairs or up the stairs and he may assistance of someone.... In the interdisciplinary team there will be the therapist who would administer therapy into Mr.... Trosacks will be able make him understand his specific needs as a patient and offer him hopeful solutions for change throughout the therapy formality....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Holistic Care of Older Adults

In the current health care setting, nurses are caring for more adults, aged 65 and above, more than any other age group.... cant events Relationships Work and home Summary statements Organization/quality (Total 10 points) older adult identified with initials only (2 points) Key information present (7 points) Well-organized/brief (maximum 1 page) (1 point) Sketchy, missing some information (5 points) older adult's name used (0 points) Missing critical information (2 points) Lacks continuity or is too wordy/long (0 points) Analysis of Life Review Goal and benefits of Life Review Similarity to remembering Difference from remembering Erikson Developmental Stage Description of client Ego integrity rating (1-10) Rationale for rating Citations regarding Erikson's theory (Total 45 points) 4+ benefits (10 points) Comparison with 2+ examples (10 points) Contrast with 2+ examples (6 points) Theory with 2 specific examples (10 points) Rating present and plausible (3 points) Rationale clear from example (3 points) 1+ reference in text (3 points) 2-3 benefits (7 points) Comparison with 1 example (5 points) Contrast with 1 example (3 points) Theory with 1 specific example (8 points) 0-1 benefits (0-2 points) Comparison without examples (3 points) No comparison (0 points) Contrast without examples or no contrast (0 points) Loose connection between theory and client (3 points); Missing description of theory or no connection (0 points) Rating missing or implausible (0 points) Rationale unclear or example missing (0 points) No references in text (0 points) Reflections Value and reason Most significant point of interview Difficult/anguishing part Impact on clinical practice Personal legacy (Total 14 points) Statement(s) with 1+ reason(s) (3 points) Example(s) with 1+ reason(s) (3 points) Example(s) with 1+ reason(s) or statement of none (3 points) Example(s) with 1+ reason(s) (3 points) Definition,....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Criminal Convictions Among Children and Young Adults

Statistics reveal 51,800 male young adults and 7,100 female young adults 19 years of age and under were convicted for various criminal offenses in England and Wales in 1998.... hellip; This discussion talks that the drop in figures is in a large measure due to changes in laws and rules governing incarceration of children and young adults.... Community sentences have replaced jail terms and the approach to the conviction of children and young adults is tied up with their rehabilitation and welfare in the long run....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Empowering with Older Adults in the Community

The current investigation “Empowering with Older adults in the Community” offers the opinion of a social worker at referring the client to the proper rehabilitation facilities, coordinating social services to ensure that aged clients would have an independent capability to independent living.... nbsp; The Centre for Policy on Ageing through the Care Quality Commission specifies that its concerns related to older adult care, specifically: the shape of care provision; access to care and services; choice and control; and quality and safety....
17 Pages (4250 words) Research Paper

Treatment And Care For Older Adults

The goal of the study "Treatment And Care For Older adults" is to evaluate a community-based fitness and healthy diet program for older adults with the intentions of improving their physical activities, healthy eating, and improve the entire health among all the participants of the study.... he goal of this study is to evaluate a community-based fitness and healthy diet program for older adults with the intentions of improving their physical activities, healthy eating, and improve the entire health among all the participants of the study....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us