StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ludwig van Beethovens Third Symphony - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Ludwig van Beethoven’s Third Symphony" focuses on offering one reasonable analysis, the spotlight is mainly on the organization of thematic aspects of the two recordings in the third symphony that gives the work a “symphonic” or cyclical quality…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
Ludwig van Beethovens Third Symphony
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ludwig van Beethovens Third Symphony"

Beethoven Introduction Broadly accredited for being one of the most essential symphonic compositions in western songs, Ludwig van Beethoven’s third symphony is simply a masterpiece. Beethoven’s semi-programmatic name, “Eroica,” the intense size, exceptional formal organization, as well as developmental history of the composition, all together, opened up too many variables to permit a remarkable analytical approach to the composition, which is mutually settled upon by the musical community reasonable, as supported by over 200 years of serious attempts to do precisely that. This essay will specifically look at Movement 1 that was done by two orchestras. The two orchestras are the Baltimore Chamber Orchestra and the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra. This paper seeks to offer one reasonable analysis, the spotlight being mainly on the organization of thematic aspects of the two recordings in the third symphony that give the work a “symphonic” or cyclical quality. Compare. The orchestras are performed in mini-sonata form. This is because the oboe and flute in both played the main melody. There is no playing of countermelody Also the orchestras end with recapitulation where fugue is maintained by all strings. The two recordings start ambitiously with one of the greatest opening movement of any symphony composed to date. The orchestras also dispense the movement with an unhurried section. The total performing time of each recording is approximately 15 to 18 minutes. The Baltimore Chamber Orchestra performance is analyzable as a prolonged symphonic form with some rondo elements. Instead of the tidiest, foursquare assortment of first time, which frequently packs it up at the selected stand and time aside for the next event; Beethoven’s symphony utilizes a thematic group wherein the same material takes on numerous distinct personalities. The development of the recordings, similar to the rest of the pieces, is characterized by remarkable rhythmic and harmonic tension owing to dissonant chords, as well as long passages of syncopated tempos. Most amazingly, the Baltimore Chamber Orchestra initiates a novel melody in the development part, breaking the classical tradition, which the development section simply works with present materials. The development sections of the recordings lead back into the recapitulation; particularly, the horns seem to come in early with the tonic melody whereas the strings are still playing the leading chord. The Eroica symphony is a funeral hymn in C minor accompanied by a trio in C major. It carries multiple forgets, and its somberness has led to its being utilized in public funerals. The tempos of the two recordings were slightly different with the Baltimore Chamber Orchestra is slightly faster than the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra. The first passage of the Eroica symphony is a series much similar to the second phase of the Baltimore Chamber Orchestra, in that they utilize a melodic sequence, which unfolds all through the violins and winds. This begets a second and more energetic passage at the closing stages of the Baltimore Chamber Orchestra. Consider the rhythmic aspect of the melody in the Baltimore Chamber Orchestra, the team shifts this into the accompaniment and prolongs it because it interpolates three-quarter rests. The phrasing also appears to change from a beat-two orientation, witnessed through his organization to a beat-one orientation to the eighth note functions as a precursor. The curve of the Eroica symphony is actually similar, even though it is much more disjunct. In both orchestras, the finishing is a set length of variations and fugue on a subject Beethoven had formerly composed for The Creatures of Prometheus – his ballet music. Contrast. Oboe of Vienna Orchestra has a sharp sounding than Baltimore’s which penetrated through staccato. The flute that played the melody in Vienna had a varied volume and its tempo was fast. In Baltimore, the flute had equal volume and its tempo was slow. Vienna’s violins were faster and louder compared to Baltimore’s. The characteristics and mood between Baltimore and Vienna orchestras were slightly different. The Baltimore Orchestra took into account more than just an instrumental playability and range compared to the Vienna Orchestra. The Baltimore Orchestra took into account what the instrument is mainly good at doing and changed the fundamental musical ideas accordingly. This is why their solos were clearer. For instance, when using the woodwinds, the Baltimore Orchestra decided to add trills and grace notes in order to enhance the melody. The Vienna Orchestra, on the other hand, had more dynamics than the Baltimore Orchestra. Their dynamics were extremely powerful and it offered more gave them more strength. They incorporated extremely loud moments, extremely soft moments plus everything in between. The sound quality of the Baltimore Orchestra was full of bass unlike the Vienna Orchestra. The Vienna Orchestra attacked their sound more with a piano as compared to the Baltimore Orchestra, which used the bass guitar more. The Vienna Philharmoniker and the Baltimore Chamber Orchestra composition have an allegretto and allegro kind of tempo respectively. Baltimore is at a vivacissimamente while Vienna is at vivacissimo. The Vienna Philharmoniker orchestra starts on a vivacissimo tempo. This means that it starts very quickly and lively then followed by a series of rallentando (progressive slow pace) and Accelerando (increase in pace). The increase in tempo by the conductor in vienna is sharper, quick and vigorous. The Baltimore Chamber Orchestra starts on a vivacissimamente tempo. Meaning it starts very faster and more lively. Its progressive series of rallentando and Accelerando is slow and less vigorous. It tends to have a ritenuto tempo which means that it works in a slowing manner and lean towards a more “held back” feel. The dynamic contrast between the two orchestras mostly lies in the technique of switching abruptly between very soft to very loud and very loud to very soft. The Vienna Philharmoniker switches very abruptly between soft and loud tempo. This brings about a sharper sound and what makes it pronouncing is the crescendo that gets the whole orchestra like a freight train. On the other hand, the Baltimore Chamber Orchestra is not that abrupt in switching between soft and loud tempo which brings out a “held back” like feeling. It gives out a mood that can be translated to; if someone sets the volume too low, he might miss out on the quiet and peaceful composition that comprises a healthy portion of the song. The recordings are a landmark in the history of the classical symphony for numerous grounds. The pieces are almost twice as long as symphonies by Mozart or Haydn. The Baltimore Chamber Orchestra performance has only been roughly as long as all Classical symphonies, taking into account that the exposition repeat is considered. The recordings cover more emotional and expressive grounds when compared to earlier works, and they are often cited as the start of the Romantic age in music, hence their tender, emotional and affectionate mood. The Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra, in essence, displays a prominent array of emotion, from the depression of the major funeral March theme, in the relative comfort of happier, main episodes. The closing of the recordings show a similar diversity, and is of significance in the overall scheme that was practically unheard of in the past. The opening subject of the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra is not similar to the overture to the Baltimore Chamber Orchestra. In Baltimore Chamber Orchestra, the horn-solo enters with the main subject four bars prior to the "actual" recapitulation. Conclusion. I would prefer Baltimore Chamber Orchestra. This is because it has some enhanced element that outshines Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra. Baltimore has a first tempo that gave the performance that hype that moved the audience. Additionally, Baltimore was energetic and also the character’s mood was appealing. This is not to say that the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra was not good, but the Baltimore Chamber Orchestra was better (Tippett & Harper 54). The musician, in the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra, has only offered the audience a glimpse of his melodic thought. It does not grant itself in its full effect only after the inclusion of some bars.” Vienna lacked any warning: the texture moved to the next theme without giving the audience to digest and acknowledge. Therefore Baltimore Chamber Orchestra was better than Vienna. Reference Brahms, Johannes. Symphony No. 3. S.l.: LSO, 2005. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Beethoven Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Beethoven Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/music/1482964-beethoven
(Beethoven Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Beethoven Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/music/1482964-beethoven.
“Beethoven Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/music/1482964-beethoven.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ludwig van Beethovens Third Symphony

Symphony of Ludwig Van Beethoven

The final and complete symphony that was composed by Ludwig was completed in 1824.... This symphony is the best known of the entire Western classical repertoire's works.... This symphony has been adopted in the European anthem.... The sketchbook of Beethoven shows that some musical materials that were used in the symphony were written in 1811 (Nicholas 231).... The symphony also came from other Beethoven's pieces, while completion of the work on its own right shows some sense for future sketches for the symphony....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Creation and Reception of Ludwig van Beethovens Fifth Symphony

This essay deals with ludwig van Beethoven's Fifth Symphony.... One of the most famous performer/composer that ever lived was of course ludwig van Beethoven.... Born December 16, 1770, ludwig van Beethoven came from something of a musical family.... One can argue that one of the most formative experiences that ludwig van Beethoven had was with regard to his times and studying under the tutelage of Joseph Haydn.... As a means of not only understanding the mechanics and theory of the music but also the mechanics playing these instruments, Beethoven was able to integrate on a more personal level with his symphony orchestra as well as the individual musicians who were responsible for relating his concepts and ideas into the mood of the music Once Ludwig began composing and publishing his compositions, Beethoven experienced an astounding level of initial success....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Beethoven Interpretations

It was during this time that Beethoven wrote the symphony ‘Eroica,' heralding what could have possibly been the Originally a dedication to Napoleon Bonaparte Eroica was changed once Napoleon declared himself Emperor.... I chose Eroica for the symbolism, beliefs and ideas that are represented with the symphony.... Because the Eroica was longer than most pieces it was generally performed towards the start of most concerts and was also known as symphony No....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Beethovens Symphony No 6

The paper "Beethoven's symphony No 6" highlights that in the midst of his turbulent life, this symphony emerged as Beethoven's spiritual center, a place from which the rest of his work began to draw a new and profound kind of quality of longing and joy.... The roles given to solo woodwinds in the symphony distinguish Beethoven as the composer who vastly expanded their role in symphonic music.... Beethoven himself said in the program notes for the first performance of this symphony that it was more an expression of feelings than a painting, (Newmarch, p....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Beethovens Ninth Symphony: The Genesis

The following research "Beethoven's Ninth symphony: The Genesis" would investigate the origin of the Beethoven musical talent and briefly describe his personal background.... Furthermore, the writer will discuss the creation of the worlds famous Ninth symphony.... ...
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Ludwig van Beethoven - Drama in Life and Work

Bonaparte was seen by Beethoven and his people as the Liberator and hence he dedicated his music to him, particularly his third symphony (Prevot).... The purpose of this essay 'ludwig van Beethoven - Drama in Life and Work' is to illustrate how dramatic events in the great composer's life influenced his oeuvres: optimistic in his youth, when he was healthy, and in his maturity, when he lost his hearing and was often on the verge of despair.... Beethoven is said to have occasionally misspelled his name form 'van as 'Von' denoting aristocratic birth, to gain the favor of the nobility in Vienna (Monaco)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Aesthetics Meaning in Terms of Music and Early Years and Works of Beethoven

During this period, ludwig van Beethoven (1770 - 1827) brought the Classical period to a climax and ultimate.... In the first phase, ludwig created his First and Second Symphonies, Opus 18 in addition to fifteen thirty-two piano sonatas.... "Aesthetics Meaning in Terms of Music and Early Years and Works of Beethoven" paper examines states that the aesthetics of Beethoven's music gave the music a new meaning in the society that set the course of the beauty of music to date....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us